You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Shaker shocker
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Shaker shocker


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 30 Oct 15 1.23pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 1.15pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 1.04pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.54pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.

Lol, you do make me laugh. There is a high probability that he is a terrorist and could well engage in terrorist activities here, but you don't really care about that do you because he is an anti-Western 'victim'. As for detention without trial, I don't hear you going on about the numerous people imprisoned without trial in areas of Cuba outside of G Bay - you know opponents of that model of socialist freedom that many on the left here so admire.

Not at all. Firstly, given that he was arrested supposedly for fighting for the Taliban in 2001 its highly unlikely he was a terrorist at all, given that they were the government of Afghanistan. Technically of course the Northern Alliance, were a terrorist group.

I care very much about the dangers of crime and terrorism, but I also care very much about the legal rights of citizens and the duty of the state to abide by its own laws far more.

Also the US never arrested him as a terrorist, or on grounds of being a terrorist, but that he was an 'unlawful combatant'.

Secondly, you seem to suggest that high probability is grounds for arrest and imprisonment - what do you set that criteria being as probable?

F**k knows what Cuba has to do with it. I would say the difference probably is that a) he's British b) That I have higher expectations of the UK and US than Cuba
.

Guantanamo Bay is in Cuba. He is not British, he is a Saudi citizen. Why do you have higher expectation of the UK and USA - the new left despise these countries as wicked capitalists.


You do know that Guantanomo is leased to the US and that Cuba has nothing to do with goes on there, right? In fact, on the Malcon in Havana they have huge billboards drawing attention to it.

Cuba has a known problem with the way it treats descent. As does e.g. North Korea. Should we be held to the same standards? Or should we consider ourselves to be a little bit fairer? I would argue the latter.

 

stevegood Flag 30 Oct 15 1.23pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 30 Oct 2015 1.15pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.54pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.

Lol, you do make me laugh. There is a high probability that he is a terrorist and could well engage in terrorist activities here, but you don't really care about that do you because he is an anti-Western 'victim'. As for detention without trial, I don't hear you going on about the numerous people imprisoned without trial in areas of Cuba outside of G Bay - you know opponents of that model of socialist freedom that many on the left here so admire.

Depends how you look at it. If you do not have a burning desire to destroy the US and the western world one day, 14 years locked up, without trial, in worse conditions than any western nation allows, with no knowledge of when you'll be released and undergoing torture... Well by the end of all that, by hell, you may be an enemy of the west.

Not saying he's a terrorist or not. But I would suggest that if he is, the most sophisticated security intelligence machine in the world, might have found some evidence during the last 14 years, that he is.

You could have said that about Jamal al Harith, who after pocketing £1 million of our money is now off to engage in a bit of beheading and burning people alive with ISIS. I guess the wicked West has driven him to that? Probably because we only gave him a measly £1 million?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Oct 15 1.37pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 1.23pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 30 Oct 2015 1.15pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.54pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.

Lol, you do make me laugh. There is a high probability that he is a terrorist and could well engage in terrorist activities here, but you don't really care about that do you because he is an anti-Western 'victim'. As for detention without trial, I don't hear you going on about the numerous people imprisoned without trial in areas of Cuba outside of G Bay - you know opponents of that model of socialist freedom that many on the left here so admire.

Depends how you look at it. If you do not have a burning desire to destroy the US and the western world one day, 14 years locked up, without trial, in worse conditions than any western nation allows, with no knowledge of when you'll be released and undergoing torture... Well by the end of all that, by hell, you may be an enemy of the west.

Not saying he's a terrorist or not. But I would suggest that if he is, the most sophisticated security intelligence machine in the world, might have found some evidence during the last 14 years, that he is.

You could have said that about Jamal al Harith, who after pocketing £1 million of our money is now off to engage in a bit of beheading and burning people alive with ISIS. I guess the wicked West has driven him to that? Probably because we only gave him a measly £1 million?

Actually, if we'd tried him, he'd probably be spending the rest of his life in prison, without the possibility of parole, or after 14 years, executed even.

The problem was not trying him, breaking our own laws and so on. If I remember rightly when he was arrested IS didn't even exist (and Al-Queda was a very minor threat to a few nations national interests).

How well our war goes, those tactics have paid off so well.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 30 Oct 15 1.39pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 1.23pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 30 Oct 2015 1.15pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.54pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.

Lol, you do make me laugh. There is a high probability that he is a terrorist and could well engage in terrorist activities here, but you don't really care about that do you because he is an anti-Western 'victim'. As for detention without trial, I don't hear you going on about the numerous people imprisoned without trial in areas of Cuba outside of G Bay - you know opponents of that model of socialist freedom that many on the left here so admire.

Depends how you look at it. If you do not have a burning desire to destroy the US and the western world one day, 14 years locked up, without trial, in worse conditions than any western nation allows, with no knowledge of when you'll be released and undergoing torture... Well by the end of all that, by hell, you may be an enemy of the west.

Not saying he's a terrorist or not. But I would suggest that if he is, the most sophisticated security intelligence machine in the world, might have found some evidence during the last 14 years, that he is.

You could have said that about Jamal al Harith, who after pocketing £1 million of our money is now off to engage in a bit of beheading and burning people alive with ISIS. I guess the wicked West has driven him to that? Probably because we only gave him a measly £1 million?

Who's to say? Seriously 14 years of that. Doubt he cares about the £1m. It's not like he's going to have much opportunity to spend it in some middle eastern quasi-wasteland.

Maybe he was, maybe he wasn't. Probably was. No proof either way. But if he wasn't before, he is now.

But if I think of my situation, would I rather have £1m and 14 years locked up like that (without knowing it was 14 years), not seeing my kids grow up etc. 14 years of the best years of my life, I would never get back.

They may as well shove their £1m up their arse. And I mean that with 100% honesty and sincerity.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Oct 15 1.42pm

Why on earth did those idiotic yanks let Jamal go? In California some guy got 20 years for stealing a pizza a while back yet this extremist was let out in half that time.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 Oct 15 2.06pm

You could quite easily commit a string of murders and end up serving 14 years - put this into some context. Also the quasi-fascist comments about the left are completely off the mark and have nothing to do with most of these threads.
If you are such a true blue Tory that you need to slate the 'left' at every turn, even when it has nothing whatsoever to do with it, then I hope you are happy in your mansion and visiting the kids in Gordonstone once a year.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Oct 15 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Oct 15 2.28pm

Quote Stuk at 30 Oct 2015 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

He's a British national, married to a British Woman. It has everything to do with our law (as he's a citizen of the UK) and US law, as they're the country that took him to Guantanemo bay and Camp-XRAY which is a US base (and thus US nationality).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Oct 15 2.32pm

Quote ASCPFC at 30 Oct 2015 2.06pm

You could quite easily commit a string of murders and end up serving 14 years - put this into some context. Also the quasi-fascist comments about the left are completely off the mark and have nothing to do with most of these threads.
If you are such a true blue Tory that you need to slate the 'left' at every turn, even when it has nothing whatsoever to do with it, then I hope you are happy in your mansion and visiting the kids in Gordonstone once a year.

You'd serve 14 years, but you'd be on a life tariff, which means you need Home Office approval to leave the UK usually (in all likelihood if you commited a string of murders in the UK, you'd get a minimum of 20 to whole life tariff).

Arguably even that is better than letting someone go that you 'were certain was a terrorist for 14 years' and then decided wasn't worth putting on trial.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

stevegood Flag 30 Oct 15 2.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 2.28pm

Quote Stuk at 30 Oct 2015 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

He's a British national, married to a British Woman. It has everything to do with our law (as he's a citizen of the UK) and US law, as they're the country that took him to Guantanemo bay and Camp-XRAY which is a US base (and thus US nationality).

He is not a British citizen, he is a Saudi Arabian citizen - I wonder how they would treat someone returning to the country strongly suspected of meaning it harm?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Oct 15 2.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 2.28pm

Quote Stuk at 30 Oct 2015 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

He's a British national, married to a British Woman. It has everything to do with our law (as he's a citizen of the UK) and US law, as they're the country that took him to Guantanemo bay and Camp-XRAY which is a US base (and thus US nationality).



He's not, he just has the right to live here.

As I said, nothing to do with us until today.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Oct 15 2.44pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 2.28pm

Quote Stuk at 30 Oct 2015 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

He's a British national, married to a British Woman. It has everything to do with our law (as he's a citizen of the UK) and US law, as they're the country that took him to Guantanemo bay and Camp-XRAY which is a US base (and thus US nationality).



And your last word should be territory not nationality.

 


Optimistic as ever

stevegood Flag 31 Oct 15 12.19pm

I see Shaker is 'undergoing medical tests' - looking for weapons of mass destruction I expect. Love the picture of ernest chap holding 'welcome home shaker' poster, he could have added 'please don't blow us up if you are in fact a terrorist'. Mind you, he might be just trying to curry favour in the hope of a contribution to his organistation from the millions that Shaker will no doubt be awarded by tax-payers.

[Link]

 

oldcodger Flag 31 Oct 15 1.00pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 2.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 2.28pm

Quote Stuk at 30 Oct 2015 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

He's a British national, married to a British Woman. It has everything to do with our law (as he's a citizen of the UK) and US law, as they're the country that took him to Guantanemo bay and Camp-XRAY which is a US base (and thus US nationality).

He is not a British citizen, he is a Saudi Arabian citizen - I wonder how they would treat someone returning to the country strongly suspected of meaning it harm?

Only he isn't strongly suspected of trying to harm the country.

I know with the way you come across you feel that you're doing the right thing, but you clearly have little idea of the push at the time to fill GBay and how embarrassing it now is for them to admit that there are no grounds at all for the presence of many there. Hence innocent people remained for a long, long time. There was effectively a bounty system, all kinds of people got caught up in it.

Edited by oldcodger (31 Oct 2015 1.01pm)

 

stevegood Flag 31 Oct 15 8.03pm

Quote oldcodger at 31 Oct 2015 1.00pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 2.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 2.28pm

Quote Stuk at 30 Oct 2015 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

He's a British national, married to a British Woman. It has everything to do with our law (as he's a citizen of the UK) and US law, as they're the country that took him to Guantanemo bay and Camp-XRAY which is a US base (and thus US nationality).

He is not a British citizen, he is a Saudi Arabian citizen - I wonder how they would treat someone returning to the country strongly suspected of meaning it harm?

Only he isn't strongly suspected of trying to harm the country.

I know with the way you come across you feel that you're doing the right thing, but you clearly have little idea of the push at the time to fill GBay and how embarrassing it now is for them to admit that there are no grounds at all for the presence of many there. Hence innocent people remained for a long, long time. There was effectively a bounty system, all kinds of people got caught up in it.

Edited by oldcodger (31 Oct 2015 1.01pm)

Check this out:

[Link]

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 31 Oct 15 8.20pm

Quote stevegood at 31 Oct 2015 8.03pm

Quote oldcodger at 31 Oct 2015 1.00pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 2.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 2.28pm

Quote Stuk at 30 Oct 2015 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

He's a British national, married to a British Woman. It has everything to do with our law (as he's a citizen of the UK) and US law, as they're the country that took him to Guantanemo bay and Camp-XRAY which is a US base (and thus US nationality).

He is not a British citizen, he is a Saudi Arabian citizen - I wonder how they would treat someone returning to the country strongly suspected of meaning it harm?

Only he isn't strongly suspected of trying to harm the country.

I know with the way you come across you feel that you're doing the right thing, but you clearly have little idea of the push at the time to fill GBay and how embarrassing it now is for them to admit that there are no grounds at all for the presence of many there. Hence innocent people remained for a long, long time. There was effectively a bounty system, all kinds of people got caught up in it.

Edited by oldcodger (31 Oct 2015 1.01pm)

Check this out:

[Link]


I used to have one of The Guildford four enjoy an occasional drink in the bar I worked at and to paraphrase an Irish friend of mine I worked with 'I think he was innocent of the Guilford bombing, but got away with other stuff so kind of evens it self out"

 


Pro USA & Israel

oldcodger Flag 31 Oct 15 10.33pm

Quote stevegood at 31 Oct 2015 8.03pm

Quote oldcodger at 31 Oct 2015 1.00pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 2.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 2.28pm

Quote Stuk at 30 Oct 2015 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote stevegood at 30 Oct 2015 12.26pm


Similar cries and hand-wringing from the left centered around another Q Bay detainee, Jamal al Harith. He was released back into the UK and received £1 million from the tax-payers to compensate him for the dreadful wrongs done to him. Subsequently, he went of to fight for ISIS.

Its actually irrelivent whether he is guilty or not, its about the fact that he's never been tried. The right to a trial, in the UK, dates back to the very first ever real documentation of law in the UK.

Right or Left wing, I'd generally assume that the right of the state to imprison people without trial is illegal.

Luckily the circumstance of his arrest, were solid. He was captured by bounty hunters, paid by the Northern Alliance (who were basically glorified smack runners with an army) fighting for Al-Qaeda / The Taliban (Dependent on who you ask). The Northern Alliance paid for foreign fighters, as it could pass them onto the US.


How is it anything to do with the UK or UK law? He's Saudi, was in Afghanistan and was taken by Americans to Cuba. Nothing to do with us until today.

I hope his coffee lived up to expectation.

He's a British national, married to a British Woman. It has everything to do with our law (as he's a citizen of the UK) and US law, as they're the country that took him to Guantanemo bay and Camp-XRAY which is a US base (and thus US nationality).

He is not a British citizen, he is a Saudi Arabian citizen - I wonder how they would treat someone returning to the country strongly suspected of meaning it harm?

Only he isn't strongly suspected of trying to harm the country.

I know with the way you come across you feel that you're doing the right thing, but you clearly have little idea of the push at the time to fill GBay and how embarrassing it now is for them to admit that there are no grounds at all for the presence of many there. Hence innocent people remained for a long, long time. There was effectively a bounty system, all kinds of people got caught up in it.

Edited by oldcodger (31 Oct 2015 1.01pm)

Check this out:

[Link]


The fact remains that if there was anything remotely close to evidence connecting him to plotting or carrying out terrorist acts he would not be seeing the light of day.

The fact also remains that the US itself believed that countless numbers of those in Gitmo were completely innocent, so let's not get too excited about the prospect of people being locked up without trial.

[Link]

 

Hoof Hearted 01 Nov 15 10.47am

This guy has terrorist written all over him and is biding his time to strike at some point in the future.

Funnily enough Shaker Aamer is an old friend of Moazzam Begg. Which is interesting not least because at Gitmo, Begg himself identified Aamer as a ‘recruiter for al-Qaeda’. He said that Aamer had fought in Bosnia and had been a member of the jihadist group run by Abu Zubair al-Haili (a senior al-Qaeda operative from Saudi Arabia) and had among other things spent ’30 days training on the AK-47 and rocket propelled grenades’. Seven separate sources at Guantanamo also described Aamer’s connections to al-Qaeda.


The naivety or bull headed denial by his sympathisers sickens ne in the same way that we see convicted rapists/murderers let out of prison early to re-offend by the same liberal minded morons that think more about the offender's human rights than trying to protect the innocent.

 

oldcodger Flag 01 Nov 15 1.19pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 Nov 2015 10.47am

This guy has terrorist written all over him and is biding his time to strike at some point in the future.

Funnily enough Shaker Aamer is an old friend of Moazzam Begg. Which is interesting not least because at Gitmo, Begg himself identified Aamer as a ‘recruiter for al-Qaeda’. He said that Aamer had fought in Bosnia and had been a member of the jihadist group run by Abu Zubair al-Haili (a senior al-Qaeda operative from Saudi Arabia) and had among other things spent ’30 days training on the AK-47 and rocket propelled grenades’. Seven separate sources at Guantanamo also described Aamer’s connections to al-Qaeda.


The naivety or bull headed denial by his sympathisers sickens ne in the same way that we see convicted rapists/murderers let out of prison early to re-offend by the same liberal minded morons that think more about the offender's human rights than trying to protect the innocent.


It's nothing like your 'convicted' example since he hasn't been convicted of anything. If I was tortured I'm sure I'd start saying what I needed to too. A court should decide rather than a note scrawled up by the 'we don't torture', 'iraq has wmds' crew. They're hardly going to publicly say he's innocent even if they now think he is are they. If he genuinely was a danger he'll be watched very closely now.

Our allies shouldn't seek to bypass the need for trial and just abduct and lock people up, many of whom the US themselves acknowledge in leaked documents are very likely completely innocent. It seems in your quest to 'protect the innocent' you don't mind if innocent people are kidnapped, tortured and fed through their arseholes via 'rectal feeding' as an enhanced interrogation technique, so sexually abused too.

Gitmo is a lawless hell hole. Even a soldier posing as a prisoner as part of a training exercise there was beaten so badly he received a significant brain injury. Guilt didn't determine the treatment that people received. Be sickened by that.

It's a similar situation to Abu Ghraib, where it was retrospectively viewed that vast numbers of prisoners were not Taliban or al-Qaeda or in fact guilty of anything, just unfortunates caught up in the incredibly flawed bounty system that was throwing money at people. Many tortured there died or killed themselves. The treatment of those innocents doesn't 'sicken you' then? I wonder why.

Edited by oldcodger (01 Nov 2015 1.28pm)

 

stevegood Flag 01 Nov 15 1.29pm

Quote oldcodger at 01 Nov 2015 1.19pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 Nov 2015 10.47am

This guy has terrorist written all over him and is biding his time to strike at some point in the future.

Funnily enough Shaker Aamer is an old friend of Moazzam Begg. Which is interesting not least because at Gitmo, Begg himself identified Aamer as a ‘recruiter for al-Qaeda’. He said that Aamer had fought in Bosnia and had been a member of the jihadist group run by Abu Zubair al-Haili (a senior al-Qaeda operative from Saudi Arabia) and had among other things spent ’30 days training on the AK-47 and rocket propelled grenades’. Seven separate sources at Guantanamo also described Aamer’s connections to al-Qaeda.


The naivety or bull headed denial by his sympathisers sickens ne in the same way that we see convicted rapists/murderers let out of prison early to re-offend by the same liberal minded morons that think more about the offender's human rights than trying to protect the innocent.


It's nothing like your 'convicted' example since he hasn't been convicted of anything. If I was tortured I'm sure I'd start saying what I needed to too. A court should decide rather than a note scrawled up by the 'we don't torture', 'iraq has wmds' crew. They're hardly going to publicly say he's innocent even if they now think he is are they. If he genuinely was a danger he'll be watched very closely now.

Our allies shouldn't seek to bypass the need for trial and just abduct and lock people up, many of whom the US themselves acknowledge in leaked documents are very likely completely innocent. It seems in your quest to 'protect the innocent' you don't mind if innocent people are kidnapped, tortured and fed through their arseholes via 'rectal feeding' as an enhanced interrogation technique, so sexually abused too.

Gitmo is a lawless hell hole. Even a solider posing as a prisoner as part of a training exercise there was beaten so badly he received a significant brain injury. Guilt didn't determine the treatment that people received. Be sickened by that.

It's a similar situation to Abu Ghraib, where it was retrospectively viewed that vast numbers of prisoners were not Taliban or al-Qaeda or in fact guilty of anything, just unfortunates caught up in the incredibly flawed bounty system that was throwing money at people. Many tortured there died or killed themselves. The treatment of those innocents doesn't 'sicken you' then? I wonder why.

Edited by oldcodger (01 Nov 2015 1.22pm)

very likely completely innocent
LOL

Did the wicked Westerners chop any of their heads off or burn them alive in a cage.


Edited by stevegood (01 Nov 2015 1.32pm)

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Shaker shocker