You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Stone Roses
November 22 2026 1.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Stone Roses


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Only 10 a year!! Flag 04 Nov 15 5.58pm

Quote EagleEyedAlbert at 04 Nov 2015 12.06pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 03 Nov 2015 6.04pm

The can't sing accusation is a bit ridiculous.

You can argue alot of band's front men cannot sing. Liam Gallagher is a notable example. They are not polished crooners who would do a duet with Aretha Franklin. But they do have distinctive iconic voices which compliment the bands style and sets them apart. You wouldn't swap him for anyone else - it wouldn't work, if you put Michael Buble in it would sound awful


...it really isn't. He's the singer- and he can't sing. Not a question of the tone, quality, style of his voice.
The fact is he can't sing in tune with the music that the rest of the band is playing.

A good band that did one solid album & a decent b-sides album.


There is more to being a front man of a proper band that holding a note otherwise music is just full of boy bands and Xfactor.

The group as a whole were/are amazing and were transformed by Mani's arrival on bass who altered their sound (Reni has to be the coolest drummer of modern times) and for a couple of years they were untouchable until court cases and substance abuse. They didn't even bother putting Sally Cinnamon, Elephant Stone or Fools Gold (all singles) on the debut LP.

Brown as a frontman is the embodiment of cool and is a great lyricist (Pearl b****** always gives me goosebumps), he may not be a great singer but neither were John Lydon, Pete Doherty, Kurt Cobain or even Bob Dylan.

I usually don't say anything but whenever there is a Stone Roses thread the hack comment about not being able to sing always grates.

 

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 06 Nov 15 9.22am

Quote Only 10 a year!! at 04 Nov 2015 5.58pm

Quote EagleEyedAlbert at 04 Nov 2015 12.06pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 03 Nov 2015 6.04pm

The can't sing accusation is a bit ridiculous.

You can argue alot of band's front men cannot sing. Liam Gallagher is a notable example. They are not polished crooners who would do a duet with Aretha Franklin. But they do have distinctive iconic voices which compliment the bands style and sets them apart. You wouldn't swap him for anyone else - it wouldn't work, if you put Michael Buble in it would sound awful


...it really isn't. He's the singer- and he can't sing. Not a question of the tone, quality, style of his voice.
The fact is he can't sing in tune with the music that the rest of the band is playing.

A good band that did one solid album & a decent b-sides album.


There is more to being a front man of a proper band that holding a note otherwise music is just full of boy bands and Xfactor.

The group as a whole were/are amazing and were transformed by Mani's arrival on bass who altered their sound (Reni has to be the coolest drummer of modern times) and for a couple of years they were untouchable until court cases and substance abuse. They didn't even bother putting Sally Cinnamon, Elephant Stone or Fools Gold (all singles) on the debut LP.

Brown as a frontman is the embodiment of cool and is a great lyricist (Pearl b****** always gives me goosebumps), he may not be a great singer but neither were John Lydon, Pete Doherty, Kurt Cobain or even Bob Dylan.

I usually don't say anything but whenever there is a Stone Roses thread the hack comment about not being able to sing always grates.


...so did his voice the times I saw him live.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

Beastie Flag 06 Nov 15 9.40am

Quote Only 10 a year!! at 04 Nov 2015 5.58pm

There is more to being a front man of a proper band that holding a note otherwise music is just full of boy bands and Xfactor.

The group as a whole were/are amazing and were transformed by Mani's arrival on bass who altered their sound (Reni has to be the coolest drummer of modern times) and for a couple of years they were untouchable until court cases and substance abuse. They didn't even bother putting Sally Cinnamon, Elephant Stone or Fools Gold (all singles) on the debut LP.

Brown as a frontman is the embodiment of cool and is a great lyricist (Pearl b****** always gives me goosebumps), he may not be a great singer but neither were John Lydon, Pete Doherty, Kurt Cobain or even Bob Dylan.

I usually don't say anything but whenever there is a Stone Roses thread the hack comment about not being able to sing always grates.


Nah come on, I love the Roses and I’m not too worried about polished vocals either, as you say plenty of music legends were never great singers but Ian Brown can be so out of tune, it’s unlistenable at times.

Still one of the great frontmen though!

 

Stuart Shave Flag Hampshire 06 Nov 15 5.17pm

Worth going for this one song alone

[Link]

 

bilbo Flag 06 Nov 15 7.27pm

They only ever had a couple of songs that I liked. I couldn't stand to watch a whole concert.

 

bilbo Flag 06 Nov 15 7.36pm

... and of his solo stuff Corpses In Their Mouths was a tune. Loved the harmonica bit.

 

OllieMaidstoneEagle Flag Maidstone, Kent 06 Nov 15 10.42pm

Quote Stuart Shave at 06 Nov 2015 5.17pm

Worth going for this one song alone

[Link]


That clip epitomises Stone Roses, the backbeat of Reni's perfectly timed drumming,coupled with Mani's driving bass,over layed with Squire's licks and intricate guitar work and then Browny's vocal, albeit not the most powerful, but altogether amazing! Thank you Mr. Shave. My fav [Link] Ollie's Dad,Ash

 


Red and Blue Army!
LONDON BORN PALACE BRED LIVE AND DIE FOR BLUE AND RED
Football is not just a game, its a religion

Pussay Patrol Flag 06 Nov 15 11.55pm

Quote bilbo at 06 Nov 2015 7.36pm

... and of his solo stuff Corpses In Their Mouths was a tune. Loved the harmonica bit.


F.E.A.R. is a great track too, and has one of the best ever videos IMO !

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Modcyril Flag Cherry Hill, New Jersey 07 Nov 15 4.21pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 03 Nov 2015 6.04pm

The can't sing accusation is a bit ridiculous.

You can argue alot of band's front men cannot sing. Liam Gallagher is a notable example. They are not polished crooners who would do a duet with Aretha Franklin. But they do have distinctive iconic voices which compliment the bands style and sets them apart. You wouldn't swap him for anyone else - it wouldn't work, if you put Michael Buble in it would sound awful


Ian Brown's voice? Graham Coxon summed it up quite nicely when he said that "the show isn't over until the flat laddie sings".

Edited by Modcyril (07 Nov 2015 4.22pm)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Stone Roses