You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > A representation of Islamic UK attitudes 2015
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

A representation of Islamic UK attitudes 2015


Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
mcduh Flag 22 Nov 15 4.32pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Nov 2015 4.00pm

It is relatively clear that there are a minority of Muslims, and indeed other migrants/ minorities, who have failed to either integrate, or in some circumstances, failed to even engage at all with Western ideologies. Why should people such as Stirling think this is fine?
I'm literally thinking 'if you don't like it in Britain then please f*** off' - even though I am a proud socialist.


This is interesting to me. I have lived for a while in Philadelphia, a huge city which is demographically:

45.5% White
44.2% Black
6.9% Asian
2.3% from other races
2.4%Mixed Race
0.8% Native American
13.3% of the population were Hispanic and Latino. (and note, the 13.3% can identify as black/white/mixed in the above numbers)

I won't even get into the geography of race in Philly.

The point is, as one of the most if not the most "ancient" cities in America, there have been white people in Philly for a long time. And in fact, there have been black people in Philly for a long time, as slaves, as freed, as post-Emancipation.

The African American community in Philly is mixed in its religious identification, but the Muslim (and I mean Muslim, not Nation of Islam or Moorish Science Temple of America, etc. etc.) community is huge and has been for a long time and constantly growing, as a result of a million things, which can be as simple as dissastisfaction with Black Christian church attitudes in the older generations, and the "blindness" that many people see as coming with another generation of hoping for civil rights turning into actual rights, etc.

The black community in Philly and the Muslim community specifically does its own thing. Black neighborhoods feature black owned businesses, many of which are Muslim owned. Especially within the Muslim community, there is little desire to participate in city politics. Etc. etc.

Years and years of bad experiences have created a situation in which huge percentages of the population (of the city where Constitution was signed) have no interest in being a part of the so-called mainstream political or economic systems. And more and more people are finding a closer identification, a greater sense of community, etc. etc. within Islam than with evangelical Protestant churches.

If you asked some of the questions stirlingsays opened this thread with to a black person from Philly (or Washington DC or Detroit or the Bronx or Oakland or etc etc), whether or not they had gone to a regular public school, or an Afrocentric or Islamic charter school, whether they had gone to university or not, whether they identified as Muslim or not....

I think the numbers would alarm an American version of stirlingsays more than the numbers resulting from whoever's poll of the Muslim community in the UK do.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 22 Nov 15 4.36pm

One of my favourite colleagues in the office I work at, is a Muslim, not devout by any means, shes a scouser, drinks and is fun to be around.

I could take the piss out of her from morning til night and she'll never get worked up. Even accuse her of being a poor muslim and she giggles.

But when we talked charlie hebdo I saw a different side to her. She said its their god, why would anyone make fun of their god, if they do they should pay the consequences. As its no ones business to take the mic of out their god.


Must say, i never forgot that moment.

 

mcduh Flag 22 Nov 15 4.37pm

(responding to myself, with Matthau in the middle, as the saying goes, haha!)

That does not automatically make those people who live somewhere but don't like the way they're treated/looked/at by the white majority a terrorist threat. And I think it's okay for people who live in a country where their grandparents were not from, or parents, or who were born in another country themselves but have moved to pursue a better life/escape from a worse one....to disagree with the status quo government and society of where they live.

Then again, I also think it's okay for people whose family has lived in the same 25 mile radius for 100s and 100s of years to be unsatisfied and generally "anti" their native country/its government/etc.

That's what I'm saying.

Edited by mcduh (22 Nov 2015 4.40pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Nov 15 4.53pm

Quote mcduh at 22 Nov 2015 4.37pm

(responding to myself, with Matthau in the middle, as the saying goes, haha!)

That does not automatically make those people who live somewhere but don't like the way they're treated/looked/at by the white majority a terrorist threat. And I think it's okay for people who live in a country where their grandparents were not from, or parents, or who were born in another country themselves but have moved to pursue a better life/escape from a worse one....to disagree with the status quo government and society of where they live.

Then again, I also think it's okay for people whose family has lived in the same 25 mile radius for 100s and 100s of years to be unsatisfied and generally "anti" their native country/its government/etc.

That's what I'm saying.

Edited by mcduh (22 Nov 2015 4.40pm)

I take your point - which is a good one. However, when some people think it's fine to never speak the 'foreign' language, share in 'foreign' traditions, or even, as this survey shows, tolerate the society they have chosen to live in, is that fine too?
In fact, this survey shows tens of thousands of Muslims think it is ok to support hate preaching - to what degree I don't know - why should I think that is fine?
Next stop for one or two of these people is attending secret meetings disguised as Qu'ran studies and then learning how to blow up the 'decadent westerners' they live amongst. That is a problem in my book, no matter how tolerant I am.

 


Red and Blue Army!

mcduh Flag 22 Nov 15 5.04pm

How many of your socialist buds are anarchists?

What can anyone really do about the 1-2 per zillion people who for any reason, religious, schizophrenic, cultist, sociopathic, etc. etc. are willing to take it upon themselves to bring fire?

[Link]

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Nov 15 5.07pm

Quote mcduh at 22 Nov 2015 5.04pm

How many of your socialist buds are anarchists?

What can anyone really do about the 1-2 per zillion people who for any reason, religious, schizophrenic, cultist, sociopathic, etc. etc. are willing to take it upon themselves to bring fire?

[Link]


For your first question the answer is 0.
For your second question the answer would be relatively complicated, however, I will attempt it - shoot them.

 


Red and Blue Army!

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Nov 15 5.12pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Nov 2015 4.03pm

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Nov 2015 3.51pm

That picture link pretty much nails it, mcduh.

There's truth in a generalised sense......Hatred of difference.

It's more accurate to say that both groups are representative of groups from both religions.

Though a terrible and murderous organisation the KKK were far stronger in American generations before the 60s.
IS is obviously a modern organisation killing Muslims and what westerners it can get hold of today. Its scope, size and aims make the KKK look pathetic.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Nov 2015 4.05pm)


I'm not sure that's really true Stirling. I made this point on the other thread as I think it's an interesting parallel but at it's peak the KKK numbered 2.5 million (mid 20s) while IS membership today stands at around 250 000, around a tenth of the size. Aims-wise, although admittedly different, fitting the social and historical contexts of their time, both were extremely conservative in their desires, and both committed violent atrocities on a large scale against both those within their religion and those separate from it.

But I think the KKK parallel is interesting for one main reason. Violence against the KKK was never a considered response by the US government, partly because many Democrats were sympathetic to the group, yet with IS, a group who let's remember holds less political sway and is far numerically inferior to the KKK, armed force is seen as reasonable? Why? Surely the only reasonable conclusion is because of the ethnic make up of Southern America, whereas killing brown people is, as it has been for the past 30 years, far more tolerable from our position of Western privilege.

I do, however, agree with you that suggesting either IS or the KKK aren't religiously motivated is to dangerously misunderstand the specific ideology that drives them.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

mcduh Flag 22 Nov 15 5.19pm

How do you figure out which ones to shoot and at what point?

The whole situation is sad and scary and it's always been like this to some degree for some combination of psychological and political and economic and ethnic reasons.

I just can't stand ethnically directed paranoia (or worse) and the effects that has on people who look similar to but would never even think of approving of the type of stuff that the paranoid or worse people are afraid will happen in their version of Paris next.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Nov 15 5.25pm

Quote mcduh at 22 Nov 2015 5.19pm

How do you figure out which ones to shoot and at what point?

The whole situation is sad and scary and it's always been like this to some degree for some combination of psychological and political and economic and ethnic reasons.

I just can't stand ethnically directed paranoia (or worse) and the effects that has on people who look similar to but would never even think of approving of the type of stuff that the paranoid or worse people are afraid will happen in their version of Paris next.

I understand your point, but your post stated the people 'who bring fire' - suggesting that they are bringing justice on themselves. However, the death sentence is not an option in the UK. You could just about get them bumped off in the US though.
I wouldn't advocate hating muslims and fully understand your point. I have plenty of muslim friends, and have only ever known one who was in any way radical, and he used to drink and smoke so was basically a hypocrite. I have never known any 'radical' ethnically English or C of E people personally but I'm sure they could exist.

 


Red and Blue Army!

mcduh Flag 22 Nov 15 5.53pm

When I said bring fire, I meant, people who would be willing to bomb civilian targets or shoot civilians.

 

mcduh Flag 22 Nov 15 6.03pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Nov 2015 5.25pm

However, the death sentence is not an option in the UK. You could just about get them bumped off in the US though.

And also, it's important to note that the death penalty in the US is nowhere near a universal option. One state condones it, another has prohibited it as "cruel and unusual punishment," and if you click the first link below, you'll see that the federal government doesn't really employ it.

Timothy McVeigh, the bonkers white guy who bombed the Federal building in Oklahoma City was executed via the Federal Government: [Link]

On the other hand, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed who is believed to have been the "principal architecht" of the 9/11 attack, [Link] is still in detention in Guantanamo.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Nov 15 6.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 22 Nov 2015 5.12pm

I'm not sure that's really true Stirling. I made this point on the other thread as I think it's an interesting parallel but at it's peak the KKK numbered 2.5 million (mid 20s) while IS membership today stands at around 250 000, around a tenth of the size. Aims-wise, although admittedly different, fitting the social and historical contexts of their time, both were extremely conservative in their desires, and both committed violent atrocities on a large scale against both those within their religion and those separate from it.

But I think the KKK parallel is interesting for one main reason. Violence against the KKK was never a considered response by the US government, partly because many Democrats were sympathetic to the group, yet with IS, a group who let's remember holds less political sway and is far numerically inferior to the KKK, armed force is seen as reasonable? Why? Surely the only reasonable conclusion is because of the ethnic make up of Southern America, whereas killing brown people is, as it has been for the past 30 years, far more tolerable from our position of Western privilege.

I do, however, agree with you that suggesting either IS or the KKK aren't religiously motivated is to dangerously misunderstand the specific ideology that drives them.

The peak for the KKK was a very long time ago in an era that shares few social norms with today. Modern figures for the Klan that I see estimate that there are 5,000 and 8,000 Klan members operating across the US. I've no doubt that similar versions aboard exist but they aren't going to take orders from a central leadership like IS do. The numbers for IS are interesting.....You are probably in the right ballpark.

In my view,'hate' comparisons are there but it's really apples and oranges when you look under the hood.

Apparently parts of the modern clan have opened up to other racial groups (which is kind of confusing) and have rebranded themselves as 'civil right defenders for the white race'.

I don't know how truthful that is but there you go.

However I think I agree with most of your post whilst lowering the modern charge of western privilege (though obviously like bias it exists and was far stronger in the past).

The media highlight black deaths by white cops for example but you hear very little when the opposite scenario happens.

The media sell to people's prejudges because that's what attracts attention and hence money.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 22 Nov 15 6.41pm

A representation of Islamic UK attitudes 2015

A pointless thread tbh.

 


Time to move forward together.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Nov 15 6.54pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Nov 2015 2.37pm


BBC Radio 4 Today Muslim Poll

More than two in five (46%) feel that being a Muslim in Britain is difficult due to prejudice against Islam.
Almost all Muslims living in Britain feel a loyalty to the country (95%). Just 6% say they feel a disloyalty.
Nine in ten (93%) British Muslims believe that Muslims in Britain should always obey British laws.
One in four (27%) British Muslims say they have some sympathy for the motives behind the attacks on Charlie Hebdo in Paris.
However, two thirds (68%) say acts of violence against those who publish images of the Prophet can never be justified while a quarter (24%) disagree.
Muslim women are more likely than men to feel unsafe in Britain.
One in nine (11%) British Muslims feel sympathetic towards people who want to fight against western interests while 85% do not.
Half (49%) believe Muslim clerics preaching that violence against the west can be justified are out of touch with mainstream Muslim opinion, while 45% disagree.

I'm more comfortable now that we have a more current and easily accessible poll of British Islamic attitudes than the old 7/7 statistics.

What do people think from these stats?


I believe that they are about as likely to be accurate as a how big is you p**** survey.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Nov 15 6.56pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 22 Nov 2015 6.54pm

I believe that they are about as likely to be accurate as a how big is you p**** survey.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 22 Nov 15 7.03pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Nov 2015 6.56pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 22 Nov 2015 6.54pm

I believe that they are about as likely to be accurate as a how big is you p**** survey.


Seconded


 


Time to move forward together.

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Nov 15 7.19pm

Quote -TUX- at 22 Nov 2015 6.41pm

A representation of Islamic UK attitudes 2015

A pointless thread tbh.

When has that stopped anyone?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

mcduh Flag 22 Nov 15 7.25pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Nov 2015 6.18pm

The media highlight black deaths by white cops for example but you hear very little when the opposite scenario happens.

The media sell to people's prejudges because that's what attracts attention and hence money.

The bots get more and more lifelike.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Nov 15 10.28am

Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Nov 2015 3.02pm

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Nov 2015 2.53pm

I think what they tell us, which any rational person would have known anyway, is that the vast majority of UK Muslims are normal people just going about their day and want no truck with the nutters, don't belong to their sect, and can't relate to them one jot.

The only seriously questionable one for me is the one about Imans and violence toward the West. I wish they had broken it down. Are they talking about genuine state military action against aggressors or terrorism? Bit perplexed with that one tbh.

How's your head feeling in that sand Kermy?

Eleven percent of a population of millions supporting the fight against their own society is a very serious problem.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Nov 2015 3.04pm)

Much lower than I expected. It seems high, but its actually quite a low figure, statistically speaking, because the relevant interest is those among those 11% who actually would do something about it (certainly less than 1% of Muslim population has gone to join IS).

Plenty of people in the UK and on here, have reflected that the country needs a revolution, but that doesn't mean they'll do anything about it.

Of course you do need to keep 'an eye' on that 11%, but you have to also remember than most of them 'are hot air' arguably those who would do something, wouldn't respond to a poll that would put them in the 11%.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 23 Nov 15 11.08am

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Nov 2015 3.17pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Nov 2015 3.02pm

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Nov 2015 2.53pm

I think what they tell us, which any rational person would have known anyway, is that the vast majority of UK Muslims are normal people just going about their day and want no truck with the nutters, don't belong to their sect, and can't relate to them one jot.

The only seriously questionable one for me is the one about Imans and violence toward the West. I wish they had broken it down. Are they talking about genuine state military action against aggressors or terrorism? Bit perplexed with that one tbh.

How's your head feeling in that sand Kermy?

Eleven percent of a population of millions supporting the fight against their own society is a very serious problem.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Nov 2015 3.04pm)


Well let's stick up for the 89% then to make sure that the 11% does not go any higher.


I wonder why the 11% continue to live here amongst us when clearly our lifestyle and beliefs are so abhorrent to them?

Then I remember that they are here for themselves not wishing to add anything to our collective society and living in their own little enclaves speaking their own language, building their mosques and despising us. They know their rate of birth will outstrip ours, so they play the waiting game until the balance of power through numbers tips in their favour.

Our only hope Kermit is that the 89% does in fact increase because the 11% are a real problem right now, but we aint seen nothing yet!

 

Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > A representation of Islamic UK attitudes 2015