This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 28 Nov 2015 10.23am
Quote Bert the Head at 27 Nov 2015 11.23pm
In a democracy the press is meant to be an information system. I would say 70% of the political comments on here are based on information provided by the press rather than any deeper academic writing. We don't need spin doctors. We need a free press. A decent honest information system.
I doubt that very few people on here read Newspapers anymore Bert. I gather my information from TV, Radio and online sources... I suspect most others do too. I accept that some of it might be biased, but by getting it from different sources I can judge it's validity. To a certain degree this forum is a good filter for what the truth might be with contributors from all political and religious spectrums. Your continued assertion that we are all sheep being fed information by the right wing "press" is outdated and wrong. You are living in Epsom Bert, not Pyongyang. What linguistics and discursive analysis of media tends to show isn't so much a necessity of political bias, but that it functions as a means of manufacturing consent in the public, rather than discussion and critical analysis of the public psyche. Left and right wing media will often target different priorities, and parties but ultimately will fall behind promotion of one perspective, rather than present a critical analysis Different sources won't make a difference, because its essentially two different views, that conflict, what media requires is critical analysis and discursive enagement with politics and the public opinion, rather than attempting to influence one, and sell to the other.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 28 Nov 2015 12.09pm
Quote nickgusset at 28 Nov 2015 11.49am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 28 Nov 2015 11.15am
Quote legaleagle at 28 Nov 2015 10.54am
Apologies in advance for rambling... Good to see the usual suspects engaging in the usual irrelevant "left" bashing. Bert has a point and makes some sense if readers can see beyond their own knee jerk prejudices,as does Hoof.
You've made a good case for the unfair nature of Corbyn's reporting, but you have not mentioned the totally unfair nature of the bombardment that Nigel Farage has taken from the media! Not only that, he has had to put up with being shouted down whilst campaigning by left wing activists and even had a quiet family Sunday lunch in a pub invaded by scumbags that cannot campaign peaceably or in a socially acceptable fashion. I don't remember you or anyone else making an impassioned plea on Nigel Farage's behalf? Just accept, that any message imparted into the arena will have some sort of spin on it, and if you want to get nearer to the truth, read a few different sources and make your own mind up as to who is most likely to be the most honest. What percentage of the population read / watch / listen to a wide range of information sources for balance? I doubt it's very high. Look at the important debate on immigration. The way it's reported by sections of the media is done so in an inflammatory way to raise heckles thus fuelling unnecessary repercussions. A massive increase in islamophobic attacks on ordinary law abiding people is one example. The issue about bombing Syria is a very important one. So why is the focus on division in political parties rather than the pros and cons of launching airstrikes? The thing is Nick you are taking the approach that you and your beliefs are right. We all do, so anyone who disagrees is naïve, stupid, illinformed etc When was the last time anyone actually changed their mind after reading anything in General Talk? Their views may softened slightly if you're lucky. As for Corbyn, he is an unmitigated disaster but I think most people have quickly seen through the not so hidden agenda of much of the press. His problem is he seems unable to anticipate the s*** storm that follows after stunts like Mao's book Ironically of course it was the Conservative government that was doing business with Mao's legacy, one of the most oppressive anti-democratic countries in the world. That was the point of the stunt, to draw attention to the fact that the party that bangs on about Western Values and Freedoms, will doing something like 20bn worth of business with the Chinese state for UK power.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
George Monbiot makes Bert right!
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote snytaxx at 29 Nov 2015 12.15pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 28 Nov 2015 8.58pm
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 28 Nov 2015 12.09pm
Quote nickgusset at 28 Nov 2015 11.49am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 28 Nov 2015 11.15am
Quote legaleagle at 28 Nov 2015 10.54am
Apologies in advance for rambling... Good to see the usual suspects engaging in the usual irrelevant "left" bashing. Bert has a point and makes some sense if readers can see beyond their own knee jerk prejudices,as does Hoof.
You've made a good case for the unfair nature of Corbyn's reporting, but you have not mentioned the totally unfair nature of the bombardment that Nigel Farage has taken from the media! Not only that, he has had to put up with being shouted down whilst campaigning by left wing activists and even had a quiet family Sunday lunch in a pub invaded by scumbags that cannot campaign peaceably or in a socially acceptable fashion. I don't remember you or anyone else making an impassioned plea on Nigel Farage's behalf? Just accept, that any message imparted into the arena will have some sort of spin on it, and if you want to get nearer to the truth, read a few different sources and make your own mind up as to who is most likely to be the most honest. What percentage of the population read / watch / listen to a wide range of information sources for balance? I doubt it's very high. Look at the important debate on immigration. The way it's reported by sections of the media is done so in an inflammatory way to raise heckles thus fuelling unnecessary repercussions. A massive increase in islamophobic attacks on ordinary law abiding people is one example. The issue about bombing Syria is a very important one. So why is the focus on division in political parties rather than the pros and cons of launching airstrikes? The thing is Nick you are taking the approach that you and your beliefs are right. We all do, so anyone who disagrees is naïve, stupid, illinformed etc When was the last time anyone actually changed their mind after reading anything in General Talk? Their views may softened slightly if you're lucky. As for Corbyn, he is an unmitigated disaster but I think most people have quickly seen through the not so hidden agenda of much of the press. His problem is he seems unable to anticipate the s*** storm that follows after stunts like Mao's book Ironically of course it was the Conservative government that was doing business with Mao's legacy, one of the most oppressive anti-democratic countries in the world. That was the point of the stunt, to draw attention to the fact that the party that bangs on about Western Values and Freedoms, will doing something like 20bn worth of business with the Chinese state for UK power. Don't take this as targeted attack but I think your statement above is incorrect for the following reasons. The China of today economically has very little in common with how Mao left China or the China he would of wanted. I would argue it is Deng Xiao Ping's legacy which the Tories are currently buying into. It was Deng and certainly not Mao who set up the current economic and political system which China currently uses. The Conservative Party has always been a secret admirer of the "邓小平理论 - Dèng Xiǎo píng lǐ lùn, or to give it its full English name, The Deng Xiaoping theory of the foundation of PRC economic development after the cultural revolution, building the capitalist economy within Chinese communist party control. Whew! Ironically of course, Deng Xiao Ping actually tried to suppress the 'little red book' as it was Mao's Cultural Revolution and the Gang of Four's "Criticize Deng and Oppose the Rehabilitation of Right-leaning Elements campaign" that led to his political purging and his son being thrown out of a third story window. Still, lets not let any of that get in the way of a nice political attention seeking stunt in the form of throwing a little red book across the dispatch box. Unsurprisingly that clip is yet to feature on the subway TV bulletins. After comment - apologies about the random numbers... it appears the HOL HTML scripting is unable to display Chinese Characters, what linguistic bigotry eh? Edited by snytaxx (29 Nov 2015 12.18pm) Great post - I agree with it entirely. However I still find the idea of doing business with the PRC, a brutal oppressive regime and regular human rights abuser, abhorrent.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
The mistake is to see the media as being pro-left, pro-right when its actually in the business of making money. News media tends to pander to its audience and pursues demographics that provide it with funding through things like advertising. The media isn't really socialist or liberal bias, media is in the business of profit, revenue generation and sales. People like Murdoch couldn't give a sh*t whether or not subsidiary company media slant is, provided it makes money.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.