You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > [SPOILERS] Star Wars VII
November 22 2026 1.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

[SPOILERS] Star Wars VII


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Ray in Houston Flag Houston 23 Dec 15 4.55pm

Quote pefwin at 18 Dec 2015 5.47pm

As my family left the cinema we all said when will the dark side learn not to build large spherical bases with super weapons and trenches.


...or at lest put the self-destruct button on the inside!

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Jamesrichards8 Flag 23 Dec 15 6.57pm

Quote Mr_Gristle at 21 Dec 2015 10.54pm

Thought it was was enjoyable, well written and quite well acted until the last half an hour. I liked all the nods to days gone by (Finn in the Falcons turret, stormtrooper TK338 getting a name check, Han Solo admitting that there's always a way to blow the big uber base up etc).

However, the climax was uninspiring apart from the unexpected patricide by Kylo Ren (who needs to keep his mask on if he wants to look and sound badass).

7.5 / 10.


You're being kind. And yes the villain was another huge problem. He took the mask off and became a puff with enough enormous hooter. Where did he get that nose from? Leia's side doesn't have it (we've seen her lineage quite a ways back), and Han has a pretty small nose. I can't take the cut seriously.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

twist Flag Miami, Florida 26 Dec 15 4.45am

Rey is Luke's daughter, this is why she can do things with the force that Luke took teachings from obi before he could do them.
there are many clues, but none more so than when Ren is interrogating her and he says that he knows she imagines a giant ocean of water to fall asleep, with an island in the middle. Yet she has.lived on Jakku since she was little, a desert planet.
Luke was teaching her from very young, and when things went south he dropped her on Jakku before running away. Ren has his suspicions on who she is.
I too was disappointed with the second half after I watched it, but then thought about it some and then watched it again, catching some things I missed.
yes it's much like to plot line of new hope, but there is good reason.

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 28 Dec 15 8.42am

Watched it last night & thought it was poor.
A mega death star (starkiller base which is a nod to Luke Skywalker who was originally going to be called Luke starkiller)
This mega death star that just so happens to have a vulnerable point on the surface... We have been here before.

Kylo Ren is even more of a whiney bitch than Anakin & when he takes his helmet off all I could do was focus on his rediculous nose, there is absolutely no resemblance to Han or Leia.

Rey, whilst clearly strong in the force is completely untrained yet out of the blue she can use force persuade & then go on to wield a lightsaber like she's mace windu & defeats kylo ren thus confirming Ren as the most pathetic Sith Lord of the entire star wars franchise.

Snoke is played by Andy Serkis so I suspect when he does make a proper debut I expect him to be more Gollum in size than guardians of the galaxy.
There is also more than a passing resemblance to Darth Plagueis.

There's hope for Finn & the mantle of loveable rogue being passed to him.

Thought the tai fighter/x-wing fights were weak.

What they did get right was fleshing out the universe, all the little things happening in the background, the aliens, the speeders all of that was spot on & I found myself enjoying that far more than the awful plot.

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 31 Dec 15 2.50pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 28 Dec 2015 8.42am

Watched it last night & thought it was poor.
A mega death star (starkiller base which is a nod to Luke Skywalker who was originally going to be called Luke starkiller)
This mega death star that just so happens to have a vulnerable point on the surface... We have been here before.

Kylo Ren is even more of a whiney bitch than Anakin & when he takes his helmet off all I could do was focus on his rediculous nose, there is absolutely no resemblance to Han or Leia.

Rey, whilst clearly strong in the force is completely untrained yet out of the blue she can use force persuade & then go on to wield a lightsaber like she's mace windu & defeats kylo ren thus confirming Ren as the most pathetic Sith Lord of the entire star wars franchise.

Snoke is played by Andy Serkis so I suspect when he does make a proper debut I expect him to be more Gollum in size than guardians of the galaxy.
There is also more than a passing resemblance to Darth Plagueis.

There's hope for Finn & the mantle of loveable rogue being passed to him.

Thought the tai fighter/x-wing fights were weak.

What they did get right was fleshing out the universe, all the little things happening in the background, the aliens, the speeders all of that was spot on & I found myself enjoying that far more than the awful plot.


Pay attention Bond... He's not a Sith.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 31 Dec 15 6.11pm

See it Xmas eve and loved it, but I think they do need to get off of the same old theme of having to destroy a Death Star etc at the end.
Also makes you realise how clunky and low budget the originals are now even though they seemed superb at the time!!

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 31 Dec 15 6.52pm

Quote monkey at 31 Dec 2015 6.11pm

See it Xmas eve and loved it, but I think they do need to get off of the same old theme of having to destroy a Death Star etc at the end.
Also makes you realise how clunky and low budget the originals are now even though they seemed superb at the time!!


Yoda you are.

Sorry could not resist.

Edited by pefwin (31 Dec 2015 6.52pm)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 31 Dec 15 9.16pm

Quote EagleEyedAlbert at 31 Dec 2015 2.50pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 28 Dec 2015 8.42am

Watched it last night & thought it was poor.
A mega death star (starkiller base which is a nod to Luke Skywalker who was originally going to be called Luke starkiller)
This mega death star that just so happens to have a vulnerable point on the surface... We have been here before.

Kylo Ren is even more of a whiney bitch than Anakin & when he takes his helmet off all I could do was focus on his rediculous nose, there is absolutely no resemblance to Han or Leia.

Rey, whilst clearly strong in the force is completely untrained yet out of the blue she can use force persuade & then go on to wield a lightsaber like she's mace windu & defeats kylo ren thus confirming Ren as the most pathetic Sith Lord of the entire star wars franchise.

Snoke is played by Andy Serkis so I suspect when he does make a proper debut I expect him to be more Gollum in size than guardians of the galaxy.
There is also more than a passing resemblance to Darth Plagueis.

There's hope for Finn & the mantle of loveable rogue being passed to him.

Thought the tai fighter/x-wing fights were weak.

What they did get right was fleshing out the universe, all the little things happening in the background, the aliens, the speeders all of that was spot on & I found myself enjoying that far more than the awful plot.


Pay attention Bond... He's not a Sith.


what is he then? a very confused boy?
Of course he is a Sith.

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 01 Jan 16 2.13am

Quote Ouzo Dan at 31 Dec 2015 9.16pm

Quote EagleEyedAlbert at 31 Dec 2015 2.50pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 28 Dec 2015 8.42am

Watched it last night & thought it was poor.
A mega death star (starkiller base which is a nod to Luke Skywalker who was originally going to be called Luke starkiller)
This mega death star that just so happens to have a vulnerable point on the surface... We have been here before.

Kylo Ren is even more of a whiney bitch than Anakin & when he takes his helmet off all I could do was focus on his rediculous nose, there is absolutely no resemblance to Han or Leia.

Rey, whilst clearly strong in the force is completely untrained yet out of the blue she can use force persuade & then go on to wield a lightsaber like she's mace windu & defeats kylo ren thus confirming Ren as the most pathetic Sith Lord of the entire star wars franchise.

Snoke is played by Andy Serkis so I suspect when he does make a proper debut I expect him to be more Gollum in size than guardians of the galaxy.
There is also more than a passing resemblance to Darth Plagueis.

There's hope for Finn & the mantle of loveable rogue being passed to him.

Thought the tai fighter/x-wing fights were weak.

What they did get right was fleshing out the universe, all the little things happening in the background, the aliens, the speeders all of that was spot on & I found myself enjoying that far more than the awful plot.


Pay attention Bond... He's not a Sith.


what is he then? a very confused boy?
Of course he is a Sith.

...no, he isn't.

1. He doesn't carry the Sith moniker 'Darth'.
2. He's a member of 'The Knights Of Ren'... You see them briefly in the movie.
3. The Sith get name-checked as a separate entity in the movie.

He ain't no Sith.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

South Devon Eagle Flag Newton Abbot 01 Jan 16 9.21am

Kylo Ren isn't weak. He took a body shot from Chewies gun that Storntroooers took and blew them 20 feet! Kylo took the shot and fell to one knee. Then duelled with Rey and Finn in the lightsaber fight while injured.

He ain't no sith and he isn't weak.

His story will unfold and he will become stronger with further training from snoke.

 


SUPPORTING PALACE SINCE 1986

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 01 Jan 16 9.41am

Good but not great, as said basically a remake of a New Hope but enjoyable all the same. Rey I imagine will be a good heroine for young girls but did seem to gain the force rediculously quickly and I don't think the should have shown Kylo Ren's face...made him softer.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

jeeagles Flag 04 Jan 16 10.45am

I saw it a few days ago and thought it was great.

One of my issues with the original Star Wars was that I found Luke really annoying. Fortunately, they've made all the emo's and geeks bad guys in the new film and pretty much cut Luke out of it.

The plot was similar to A New Hope, but how different could it be. It's essentially a goodies v baddies movie.

I've decided in the next movie that Rey is going to turn out to be the daughter of Qui gon jinn. She's going to get kidnapped, and he will come back from the dead to rescue her.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 04 Jan 16 3.33pm

everyone seems to miss that rey is shown to be a master with a stick-like weapon early on. plus, ren was shot so she was able to hold her own and then some.

i don't think rey is leia or luke's kid. as orphans, would seem impossible that they'd dump a little kid in a desert planet. but what do i know.

i agree that it had a mashup of the 1st 3. i was thinking, "are they really going to blow up the death start again?" and they did, with han leading a team to take out the shield, just like return of the jedi. weird that they couldn't come up with anything different.

took my 5 & 7 year olds - they said it was great and even better than hotel transylvania.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > [SPOILERS] Star Wars VII