You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Euroscepticism:Euphenism for rightwing Nationalism
November 22 2026 1.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Euroscepticism:Euphenism for rightwing Nationalism


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 21 Dec 15 11.18pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Dec 2015 10.38am

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Dec 2015 10.27am

Quote nickgusset at 21 Dec 2015 9.47am

What would be nice in the campaign is some form of unbiased, rhetoric free and put in layman's terms detail of the pros and cons of staying or leaving.
To be honest, I don't know if we should stay or go.

No one can look into crystal balls and predict the future.

It comes down to how you see this nation and its place in the world allied with how you think the EU is going.


Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Dec 2015 10.28am)


To be fair we were lied to in 1975 which led to us joining the EU.

Back then the EU was referred to as the "Common Market" and was presented as a trading club between the richer northern countries of Europe. If any of us were told it was going to be a political union (or federal state) with us subsidising the smaller countries and being made to adhere to unworkable laws dictated from undemocratically-elected bureaucrats in Brussels.... none of us would have voted for it.

The UK was a much different place back in 1975.

For me it hasn't changed for the better.


Of course we were lied to - by both sides. But we held a mock election at Balgowan Primary School in Beckenham . The 'no' candidate, who was all of 11 years old, stood on a platform that this was the thin end of the wedge of a federal Europe.

So let's not re-write history and say that the F word did not exist pre-Maastricht.

Federalism was already an issue in 1975, at least at primary school level. We still voted in favour, by the way.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

snytaxx Flag London 22 Dec 15 8.31am

Quote -TUX- at 21 Dec 2015 11.04pm

This irrelevant thread has 3x the amount of the one that truly matters.
No wonder we're in the shape we are in.

Any yet you choose to add to it?

Textbook attempt at closing down an argument.

 

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 22 Dec 15 9.34am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Dec 2015 2.06pm

Europhile:Euphemism for leftwing Socialism?

Wrong, I'm afraid. I'm left leaning and I know the all-out socialists are already (and increasingly) anti-EU. That is mainly to do with that the free (pan-European) market is allowing corporations to profit at the expense of the average worker. Which is true, to some extent.

The Blairite neo-liberals you can say that about. But the socialists, not so much.

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Dec 15 11.53am

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 22 Dec 2015 9.34am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Dec 2015 2.06pm

Europhile:Euphemism for leftwing Socialism?

Wrong, I'm afraid. I'm left leaning and I know the all-out socialists are already (and increasingly) anti-EU. That is mainly to do with that the free (pan-European) market is allowing corporations to profit at the expense of the average worker. Which is true, to some extent.

The Blairite neo-liberals you can say that about. But the socialists, not so much.


WHOOOOOOSH..... I was sort of taking the p1ss out of the thread title and Kermy not really making a serious point FFS!

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 22 Dec 15 12.45pm

I feel that I have much more in common with the Dutch, Germans and Scandanavians than I ever will with Americans. You know, countries where not quite everything has been sacrificed on the altars of corporate consumerism and outsourcing.

If people think that a UK exit from the EU will see it become an independent beacon of "Britishness" and revert to some sort of 50's - 60's (or even Victorian) idyll, then I suggest they think again.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

snytaxx Flag London 22 Dec 15 1.24pm

Quote Mr_Gristle at 22 Dec 2015 12.45pm

I feel that I have much more in common with the Dutch, Germans and Scandanavians than I ever will with Americans. You know, countries where not quite everything has been sacrificed on the altars of corporate consumerism and outsourcing.

If people think that a UK exit from the EU will see it become an independent beacon of "Britishness" and revert to some sort of 50's - 60's (or even Victorian) idyll, then I suggest they think again.

I very much agree with you on this point, but I reject this notion that you have to be part of a federalised Europe just to be close to those countries in question. I'm pretty sure that not every Scandinavian is even in the EU. (Norway?)

Pro EU supporters are very well geared to defending their viewpoint from attacks from the right such as UKIP and eurosceptic conservatives for example. Mocking the idea that we will return to the good old days is all well and just, but what would you say to the idea however that it is you (the in campaign) who is clinging to a bygone era European federalism and that staying in the EU is anchoring the UK to geopolitical strategy that just doesn't suit it anymore?

 

NickRobinson Flag 22 Dec 15 1.34pm

Hopefully, Britain will vote to leave the EU. But even if we don't, the EU will sooner or later collapse under the weight of its contradictions, just like other attempts to create political entities from established countries with different languages, race, religion and culture: USSR,Yugoslavia and the Balkans in general, Indian sub-continent, Middle East, and even the 'United' Kingdom.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 22 Dec 15 4.10pm

Quote snytaxx at 22 Dec 2015 1.24pm

Quote Mr_Gristle at 22 Dec 2015 12.45pm

I feel that I have much more in common with the Dutch, Germans and Scandanavians than I ever will with Americans. You know, countries where not quite everything has been sacrificed on the altars of corporate consumerism and outsourcing.

If people think that a UK exit from the EU will see it become an independent beacon of "Britishness" and revert to some sort of 50's - 60's (or even Victorian) idyll, then I suggest they think again.

I very much agree with you on this point, but I reject this notion that you have to be part of a federalised Europe just to be close to those countries in question. I'm pretty sure that not every Scandinavian is even in the EU. (Norway?)

Pro EU supporters are very well geared to defending their viewpoint from attacks from the right such as UKIP and eurosceptic conservatives for example. Mocking the idea that we will return to the good old days is all well and just, but what would you say to the idea however that it is you (the in campaign) who is clinging to a bygone era European federalism and that staying in the EU is anchoring the UK to geopolitical strategy that just doesn't suit it anymore?

Fair question. I'm actually rather hopeful that the potential for a "Federated States of Europe" has gone away thanks to the Euro and immigration / migration crises.

I'd argue that UK geopolitical strategy is best served by being part of European Institutions for global trade, policing and participation in international forums. Our voice as an "independent with a few nukes" on the periphery of everything will be diminished. Like you, I don't want any part of currency integration.

Where would you see us "anchored"?

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

snytaxx Flag London 23 Dec 15 9.10am

Quote Mr_Gristle at 22 Dec 2015 4.10pm

Quote snytaxx at 22 Dec 2015 1.24pm

Quote Mr_Gristle at 22 Dec 2015 12.45pm

I feel that I have much more in common with the Dutch, Germans and Scandanavians than I ever will with Americans. You know, countries where not quite everything has been sacrificed on the altars of corporate consumerism and outsourcing.

If people think that a UK exit from the EU will see it become an independent beacon of "Britishness" and revert to some sort of 50's - 60's (or even Victorian) idyll, then I suggest they think again.

I very much agree with you on this point, but I reject this notion that you have to be part of a federalised Europe just to be close to those countries in question. I'm pretty sure that not every Scandinavian is even in the EU. (Norway?)

Pro EU supporters are very well geared to defending their viewpoint from attacks from the right such as UKIP and eurosceptic conservatives for example. Mocking the idea that we will return to the good old days is all well and just, but what would you say to the idea however that it is you (the in campaign) who is clinging to a bygone era European federalism and that staying in the EU is anchoring the UK to geopolitical strategy that just doesn't suit it anymore?

Fair question. I'm actually rather hopeful that the potential for a "Federated States of Europe" has gone away thanks to the Euro and immigration / migration crises.

I'd argue that UK geopolitical strategy is best served by being part of European Institutions for global trade, policing and participation in international forums. Our voice as an "independent with a few nukes" on the periphery of everything will be diminished. Like you, I don't want any part of currency integration.

Where would you see us "anchored"?

I think most people like the idea of some sort of European trade bloc but I think thats where the support ends. If you look at the history of the EU it has essentially moved from a simple trade movement towards a political union. At no point has it ever looked at moving the other way. This is why i'm skeptical that the notion of a United States of Europe has or ever will truly go away.

For me EU needs total and complete reform, kind of like a two tier membership level where you have countries who wish to politically integrate and countries who just want free trade. The problem is the EU is fundamentally unwilling to offer that. Instead it goes on about having its own police force, defence budget and foreign policy, you name it!.

For me, the UK needs to wield its soft power by looking towards the BRICS and commonwealth countries as well as the developing world. Alot of countries out there want to trade with us, why we are prioritising countries based on geographical location as opposed to economical and political suitability? It just doesn't seem a particularly good idea to me.

 

Hoof Hearted 23 Dec 15 11.34am

Quote Mr_Gristle at 22 Dec 2015 12.45pm

I feel that I have much more in common with the Dutch, Germans and Scandanavians than I ever will with Americans. You know, countries where not quite everything has been sacrificed on the altars of corporate consumerism and outsourcing.

If people think that a UK exit from the EU will see it become an independent beacon of "Britishness" and revert to some sort of 50's - 60's (or even Victorian) idyll, then I suggest they think again.

Is that it....that's your persuasive argument?

LOL

For a start we'll save ourselves billions by not subsidising the rest of Europe - remember this EU directive...?


[Link]

£1.7 Billion FFS...we were expected to pay because our economy was doing better than everyone else's!

Time we stopped stumping up our hard earned cash to a faceless bureaucracy and spent it on our own people.


 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Dec 15 2.35pm

Quote snytaxx at 23 Dec 2015 9.10am

Quote Mr_Gristle at 22 Dec 2015 4.10pm

Quote snytaxx at 22 Dec 2015 1.24pm

Quote Mr_Gristle at 22 Dec 2015 12.45pm

I feel that I have much more in common with the Dutch, Germans and Scandanavians than I ever will with Americans. You know, countries where not quite everything has been sacrificed on the altars of corporate consumerism and outsourcing.

If people think that a UK exit from the EU will see it become an independent beacon of "Britishness" and revert to some sort of 50's - 60's (or even Victorian) idyll, then I suggest they think again.

I very much agree with you on this point, but I reject this notion that you have to be part of a federalised Europe just to be close to those countries in question. I'm pretty sure that not every Scandinavian is even in the EU. (Norway?)

Pro EU supporters are very well geared to defending their viewpoint from attacks from the right such as UKIP and eurosceptic conservatives for example. Mocking the idea that we will return to the good old days is all well and just, but what would you say to the idea however that it is you (the in campaign) who is clinging to a bygone era European federalism and that staying in the EU is anchoring the UK to geopolitical strategy that just doesn't suit it anymore?

Fair question. I'm actually rather hopeful that the potential for a "Federated States of Europe" has gone away thanks to the Euro and immigration / migration crises.

I'd argue that UK geopolitical strategy is best served by being part of European Institutions for global trade, policing and participation in international forums. Our voice as an "independent with a few nukes" on the periphery of everything will be diminished. Like you, I don't want any part of currency integration.

Where would you see us "anchored"?

I think most people like the idea of some sort of European trade bloc but I think thats where the support ends. If you look at the history of the EU it has essentially moved from a simple trade movement towards a political union. At no point has it ever looked at moving the other way. This is why i'm skeptical that the notion of a United States of Europe has or ever will truly go away.

For me EU needs total and complete reform, kind of like a two tier membership level where you have countries who wish to politically integrate and countries who just want free trade. The problem is the EU is fundamentally unwilling to offer that. Instead it goes on about having its own police force, defence budget and foreign policy, you name it!.

For me, the UK needs to wield its soft power by looking towards the BRICS and commonwealth countries as well as the developing world. Alot of countries out there want to trade with us, why we are prioritising countries based on geographical location as opposed to economical and political suitability? It just doesn't seem a particularly good idea to me.

I think ultimately the EU can serve a useful process. There is a massive need for a cross European police force (kind of a federal force) i.e. Interpol with actual powers - Cross national border crime is a massive problem and whilst each country does have its own National Crime teams, it really needs to be centralised around avoiding things like extradition.

Despite the usual right wing rants about the ECHR its actually has made enforcement of UK law easier and beneficial towards the population of the Europe (as well as serving to arbitrate on conflicts within nations laws that previously took decades and millions to resolve).

Problem of the EU is that it doesn't serve the interests of nations, but businesses (particualy trans-national corporations). The biggest issue isn't soverignity, but working migration that serves to undermine low salary and increasingly medium level salaried jobs through importation of foreign talent (leading to issues both nations, the supplied and supplier - try getting a polish plumber in Poland during the period prior to the crash).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Dec 15 2.38pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Dec 2015 11.34am

Quote Mr_Gristle at 22 Dec 2015 12.45pm

I feel that I have much more in common with the Dutch, Germans and Scandanavians than I ever will with Americans. You know, countries where not quite everything has been sacrificed on the altars of corporate consumerism and outsourcing.

If people think that a UK exit from the EU will see it become an independent beacon of "Britishness" and revert to some sort of 50's - 60's (or even Victorian) idyll, then I suggest they think again.

Is that it....that's your persuasive argument?

LOL

For a start we'll save ourselves billions by not subsidising the rest of Europe - remember this EU directive...?


[Link]

£1.7 Billion FFS...we were expected to pay because our economy was doing better than everyone else's!

Time we stopped stumping up our hard earned cash to a faceless bureaucracy and spent it on our own people.


Yeah because that's exactly what would happen - In no way would it be spunked up the wall on tax cuts to win elections. We can't even apply austerity cuts without racking up increased spending.

I'm not against the idea of the EU using money from wealthier nations to support economies elsewhere in the EU, and nor should you be, if you don't want to see migration from those countries to the UK for work.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 23 Dec 15 4.01pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Dec 2015 11.34am

Is that it....that's your persuasive argument?

No. Was I meant to produce one?

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 23 Dec 15 4.09pm

Also, if we did Brexit wouldn't loads of new EU peeps come here before the new rules kicked in?

oh, the irony of that happening. Thanks, eurosceptics.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


nhp61 Flag Goring-By-Sea born, now in Brackne... 23 Dec 15 4.26pm

Quote Kermit8 at 20 Dec 2015 9.11pm

Says ex-PM John Major

[Link]

Read the article properly and you'll see it was Ken Clarke who said "euroscepticism is, I think, a euphemism for right-wing nationalism"

Clarke will say anything to try and ensure the UK remains a member of his precious eu.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 23 Dec 15 4.28pm

Quote nhp61 at 23 Dec 2015 4.26pm

Quote Kermit8 at 20 Dec 2015 9.11pm

Says ex-PM John Major

[Link]

Read the article properly and you'll see it was Ken Clarke who said "euroscepticism is, I think, a euphemism for right-wing nationalism"

Clarke will say anything to try and ensure the UK remains a member of his precious eu.


Oops. Sorry John. The quote was right above his pic. Ken Clarke it is.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Dec 15 6.03pm

Quote nhp61 at 23 Dec 2015 4.26pm

Quote Kermit8 at 20 Dec 2015 9.11pm

Says ex-PM John Major

[Link]

Read the article properly and you'll see it was Ken Clarke who said "euroscepticism is, I think, a euphemism for right-wing nationalism"

Clarke will say anything to try and ensure the UK remains a member of his precious eu.

In fairness for some people its true, their issue with the EU isn't about pragmatic reasons of politics or economics reasons, so much as to do with ideology around sovereignty.

The only real concern about right wing nationalism is where it becomes mired in the ideals of nationalism over the practical realities of a functional society.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 26 Dec 15 8.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Dec 2015 6.03pm

Quote nhp61 at 23 Dec 2015 4.26pm

Quote Kermit8 at 20 Dec 2015 9.11pm

Says ex-PM John Major

[Link]

Read the article properly and you'll see it was Ken Clarke who said "euroscepticism is, I think, a euphemism for right-wing nationalism"

Clarke will say anything to try and ensure the UK remains a member of his precious eu.

In fairness for some people its true, their issue with the EU isn't about pragmatic reasons of politics or economics reasons, so much as to do with ideology around sovereignty.

The only real concern about right wing nationalism is where it becomes mired in the ideals of nationalism over the practical realities of a functional society.


A society can exist with rampant racist inequalities, eugenics as practised by the national socialists in the 30s etc, but are they really "functioning" for the populace?

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Dec 15 9.49pm

Quote pefwin at 26 Dec 2015 8.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Dec 2015 6.03pm

Quote nhp61 at 23 Dec 2015 4.26pm

Quote Kermit8 at 20 Dec 2015 9.11pm

Says ex-PM John Major

[Link]

Read the article properly and you'll see it was Ken Clarke who said "euroscepticism is, I think, a euphemism for right-wing nationalism"

Clarke will say anything to try and ensure the UK remains a member of his precious eu.

In fairness for some people its true, their issue with the EU isn't about pragmatic reasons of politics or economics reasons, so much as to do with ideology around sovereignty.

The only real concern about right wing nationalism is where it becomes mired in the ideals of nationalism over the practical realities of a functional society.


A society can exist with rampant racist inequalities, eugenics as practised by the national socialists in the 30s etc, but are they really "functioning" for the populace?

No, they aren't, because ultimately the eugenics of the 30s was based on a very flawed idea of genetics and evolution, and national socialism only managed to deliver destruction to its people.

A functioning society is one that can deliver not only to those who support the government, but to those who don't, which remains one of the single most significant appealing capacities of democratic systems of government - the necessity to provide for minorities within society (admittedly to some degree).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 26 Dec 15 10.21pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Dec 2015 9.49pm

Quote pefwin at 26 Dec 2015 8.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Dec 2015 6.03pm

Quote nhp61 at 23 Dec 2015 4.26pm

Quote Kermit8 at 20 Dec 2015 9.11pm

Says ex-PM John Major

[Link]

Read the article properly and you'll see it was Ken Clarke who said "euroscepticism is, I think, a euphemism for right-wing nationalism"

Clarke will say anything to try and ensure the UK remains a member of his precious eu.

In fairness for some people its true, their issue with the EU isn't about pragmatic reasons of politics or economics reasons, so much as to do with ideology around sovereignty.

The only real concern about right wing nationalism is where it becomes mired in the ideals of nationalism over the practical realities of a functional society.


A society can exist with rampant racist inequalities, eugenics as practised by the national socialists in the 30s etc, but are they really "functioning" for the populace?

No, they aren't, because ultimately the eugenics of the 30s was based on a very flawed idea of genetics and evolution, and national socialism only managed to deliver destruction to its people.

A functioning society is one that can deliver not only to those who support the government, but to those who don't, which remains one of the single most significant appealing capacities of democratic systems of government - the necessity to provide for minorities within society (admittedly to some degree).


Indeed for many if not all, in all things, it is the "some degree".

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Euroscepticism:Euphenism for rightwing Nationalism