This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Oscars racism storm
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
palace845 21 Jan 16 1.49pm |
|
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 20 Jan 2016 10.30pm
Last time I looked you had to deserve it.
This is all that matters, and barring that it's a non argument in my opinion.
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 21 Jan 16 1.59pm |
|
Quote beagle at 21 Jan 2016 12.17pm
The question I can't find answered is which black actors/filmakers from last year are considered to have been excluded and for which roles/films?
The director of Selma, which was nominated for best picture springs to mind.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 21 Jan 16 2.01pm |
|
Quote Cucking Funt at 21 Jan 2016 12.34pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Jan 2016 10.53am
Quote npn at 21 Jan 2016 10.36am
The whole Oscars thing is horribly skewed towards 'successful' movies - why do you think so often 2 or 3 films sweep the board?
I can believe they may have great acting, great directing, and great screenplays etc - but they always win best cinematography, soundtrack, and the raft of jobs you didn't even realise were involved too. Surely there are small obscure films which were really good at something, though the film itself sucked? Maybe Saw XXIV had a great soundtrack, or Debbie Does Dallas Again had great costumes, or Friday the Thirteenth XII was really well cast, but they'll never win anything because the movie itself is not deemed worthy
Very true. Its hard to fault the method acting in Debbie does Dallas. You don't see too many so called celebrity stars going to the kind of deep performance seen in Anal Rampage 4 either.
The exception is maybe when a big star performs in a smaller scale flick, in which case the daisy chain chokes itself (Dallas Buyers Club).
You obviously never saw Anal Rampage 3 or 5.

"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Stuk Top half 21 Jan 16 2.49pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Jan 2016 10.05am
Quote suicideatselhurst at 20 Jan 2016 11.25pm
If in someone's opinion your performance isn't any good your not going to get nominated....on a plus side you might have been paid 5 million dollars for not being good enough...so oh dear how sad never mind
Its notable that Jada Pinket Smith is complaining, but she was in Magic Mike XXL (apparently she's very good in it) but how seriously can you be taken as a candidate based on a throw away film about strippers.
Of course Selma did get nominated for best picture, but its director wasn't nominated in the best director category, which is a bit odd.
She's just moaning because her husband didn't get nominated.
I do find it funny that quite a few black actors, singers etc are trying to put pressure on Chris Rock to step down from the job of hosting as they're "under represented".
I don't hear calls for the head of the Academy to step down in solidarity, and she's in a more powerful position than him.
The main problem is once you're accepted to vote, you're in for life. So voting patterns are unlikely to change for decades.
Optimistic as ever
|
Stuk Top half 21 Jan 16 2.50pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2016 12.34pm
Quote beagle at 21 Jan 2016 12.17pm
The question I can't find answered is which black actors/filmakers from last year are considered to have been excluded and for which roles/films?
Idris Elba 'Beasts of No Nation' should have been in there. Very well received film by even the harshest of critics.
Not that I disagree, but who should he have taken the place of?
Optimistic as ever
|
Kermit8 Hevon 21 Jan 16 5.43pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 21 Jan 2016 2.50pm
Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2016 12.34pm
Quote beagle at 21 Jan 2016 12.17pm
The question I can't find answered is which black actors/filmakers from last year are considered to have been excluded and for which roles/films?
Idris Elba 'Beasts of No Nation' should have been in there. Very well received film by even the harshest of critics.
Not that I disagree, but who should he have taken the place of?
Wilfred Hyde White, of course.
I don't know but if he had been chosen it would have (and should have) been on merit. But as Jim said earlier box office flops don't really cut the mustard where nominations are concerned for some daft reason.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
suicideatselhurst crawley 21 Jan 16 6.00pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2016 12.34pm
Quote beagle at 21 Jan 2016 12.17pm
The question I can't find answered is which black actors/filmakers from last year are considered to have been excluded and for which roles/films?
Idris Elba 'Beasts of No Nation' should have been in there. Very well received film by even the harshest of critics.
It premiered on Netflix, good film but never going to get a nomination
Theres someone in my head ... But its not me
X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)
|
DanH SW2 21 Jan 16 6.08pm |
|
|
Idris Elba should just win every Oscar going just for being cool as f*ck.
|
Stuk Top half 21 Jan 16 6.09pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2016 5.43pm
Quote Stuk at 21 Jan 2016 2.50pm
Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2016 12.34pm
Quote beagle at 21 Jan 2016 12.17pm
The question I can't find answered is which black actors/filmakers from last year are considered to have been excluded and for which roles/films?
Idris Elba 'Beasts of No Nation' should have been in there. Very well received film by even the harshest of critics.
Not that I disagree, but who should he have taken the place of?
Wilfred Hyde White, of course.
I don't know but if he had been chosen it would have (and should have) been on merit. But as Jim said earlier box office flops don't really cut the mustard where nominations are concerned for some daft reason.
That was my point. It's very easy for people to say that there should be x amount in the acting categories but none of them would dare say who should be replaced. They clearly think someone is less deserving than a black actor, but they won't say it. Just that it's not right.
If it was about box office do you think The Hurt Locker would've won over Avatar?
Optimistic as ever
|
Hrolf The Ganger 21 Jan 16 7.06pm |
|
|
Well that;s done it. Wil Smith is boycotting the ceremony. A real tragedy since his body of work is impressive. If he stars in more films as great as After Earth and Bad Boys he is bound to be nominated before long. 
|
johnfirewall 21 Jan 16 8.14pm |
|
|
Saw a rant about black actors not being respected enough by the BBC and having to move to America. As in Hollywood, like every other serious actor?!
|
nairb75 Baltimore 22 Jan 16 4.12pm |
|
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 21 Jan 2016 7.06pm
Well that;s done it. Wil Smith is boycotting the ceremony. A real tragedy since his body of work is impressive. If he stars in more films as great as After Earth and Bad Boys he is bound to be nominated before long. 
i'll have you know that he was in independence day, which is the greatest film of all time by a mile.
|
Frickin Saweet South Cronx 22 Jan 16 4.24pm |
|
|
queue a load of token nominations for people of colour at next year's awards, which is just as farcical as none at all.
|
Hrolf The Ganger 22 Jan 16 4.33pm |
|
Quote nairb75 at 22 Jan 2016 4.12pm
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 21 Jan 2016 7.06pm
Well that;s done it. Wil Smith is boycotting the ceremony. A real tragedy since his body of work is impressive. If he stars in more films as great as After Earth and Bad Boys he is bound to be nominated before long. 
i'll have you know that he was in independence day, which is the greatest film of all time by a mile.
Only if it's the only film you have ever seen.
Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (22 Jan 2016 4.34pm)
|
Stuk Top half 22 Jan 16 4.43pm |
|
|
No gay nominees either so does that make them racist and homophobic?
Optimistic as ever
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 22 Jan 16 4.44pm |
|
Quote nairb75 at 22 Jan 2016 4.12pm
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 21 Jan 2016 7.06pm
Well that;s done it. Wil Smith is boycotting the ceremony. A real tragedy since his body of work is impressive. If he stars in more films as great as After Earth and Bad Boys he is bound to be nominated before long. 
i'll have you know that he was in independence day, which is the greatest film of all time by a mile.
LOL
To be honest this a nonstory, I doubt there is any deliberate racism, perhaps there is a bias towards mainstream Hollywood movies.
As Ice Cube said on the BBC, who cares, the Oscars is the old way to market films and in a few years this will all be an anathema. As for Chris Rock the guy is in a no win situation.
It ain't like it is the Good Ole Boys Movie awards.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 22 Jan 16 4.45pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 22 Jan 2016 4.43pm
No gay nominees either so does that make them racist and homophobic?
Are you sure?
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
Stuk Top half 22 Jan 16 4.50pm |
|
Quote pefwin at 22 Jan 2016 4.45pm
Quote Stuk at 22 Jan 2016 4.43pm
No gay nominees either so does that make them racist and homophobic?
Are you sure?
Unless you know something that hasn't been made public?
Optimistic as ever
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 22 Jan 16 4.51pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 22 Jan 2016 4.50pm
Quote pefwin at 22 Jan 2016 4.45pm
Quote Stuk at 22 Jan 2016 4.43pm
No gay nominees either so does that make them racist and homophobic?
Are you sure?
Unless you know something that hasn't been made public?
Surely one of the actresses drinks from the furry cup?
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
Stuk Top half 22 Jan 16 4.55pm |
|
Quote pefwin at 22 Jan 2016 4.51pm
Quote Stuk at 22 Jan 2016 4.50pm
Quote pefwin at 22 Jan 2016 4.45pm
Quote Stuk at 22 Jan 2016 4.43pm
No gay nominees either so does that make them racist and homophobic?
Are you sure?
Unless you know something that hasn't been made public?
Surely one of the actresses drinks from the furry cup?
Closest one is Cate Blanchett but she's married and only said as much while promoting a film where she played a lesbian.
Optimistic as ever
|