You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Osborne & Google SHOCKER
November 22 2026 1.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Osborne & Google SHOCKER


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 12 Feb 16 1.13pm

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!


HSBC have moved a huge amount of their workforce to Hong Kong so I am not sure its right to be complacent.

I have worked for a few small to medium sized companies over the years and arranged 'deals' over VAT and Tax, whether this is correct or not those deals kept companies afloat and people in jobs and put money into the Government coffers that they might not have got if they had been hard nosed.

I am sure there were a lot of things taken into consideration including the historical nature of the debt, is it right? not strictly but anyone involved in business or finance knows sometimes you have to negotiate to get deals done and move on.

Actually I have a of of insight into what HSBC are doing currently, especially property wise and despite all of the sabre rattling of last year about them pissing off to the Far East or Frankfurt they are currently hoovering up as much UK and London space as they can...

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Only 10 a year!! Flag 12 Feb 16 1.20pm

Originally posted by The Sash

Actually I have a of of insight into what HSBC are doing currently, especially property wise and despite all of the sabre rattling of last year about them pissing off to the Far East or Frankfurt they are currently hoovering up as much UK and London space as they can...

I know someone very high up in HR there :-)

Anyway I have said my bit and I am out, it is a complex issue and I am not sure it has as clearer cut answer as some would want it to have.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 12 Feb 16 2.19pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

From the company's point of view, this would make it easier. They would know exactly what they have to pay in tax. In addition if a global company wanted to expand into a country, it could do that without increasing it's tax burden, making it attractive to expand and employ people globally.

It would incentivise nations to attract global companies so they could get a share of that global pot. Which in the case of some global companies is billions. Some countries have corporate tax rates so low that the only benefit they get is the handful of people they employ in that country. With my system a each nation would get some revenue from this world company as well as the employment.

National corporate tax rate setting has been a way of attracting companies but it doesn't work. You set a rate and then another country offers a lower rate which is what the problem is in the first place, some countries set a rate so low to get the employment and these companies end up hardly paying anything to anyone, because each nation is competing with is neighbour.

In regards the share of the pot for each country, the problem that is created by each country trying to work out how much tax to charge has lead to the the situation we face now, with companies able to move or hide revenue by claming that they don't do much business in the host country.

Say, as you point out a company does 50% in one country and 10% in the others, the country where the 50% is done will get other benefits, more business in the 50% country, will relate to more employment in that country, with the company not having to worry about how much tax it will pay in one country as opposed to another. This will save that company money as well as the country trying to collect tax.

The share of the pot element could maybe be tweeked in some way if it turms out truly unfair but my suggestion aims to simplify the system for both host nations and companies alike. Encourage expansion and growth by making it easier for companies to set up in many different countries and also it would focus countries wanting corporate investment to use other ways, such as infrastructure improvement, skilled work force, pay rates etc to attract investment.

I'm not a tax expert, this is just an idea. It may have some flaws, I don't know but I think the principle is a good one. We need to treat global companies as just that, global. Imagine you have 50 Corporates all doing business in a particular country. That would add up to some serious tax income for that country. Right now, no one really gets anything at all and we all lose out.

Forcing companpies to pay, 15% here and 2% there and so on ends up with no one getting anything. IT has taken 10 years for our government to get just 130 million out of Google and at what cost to HMRC. What a joke.

How?

You've essentially just created a tax version of the EU. Which i'd wager is a damn sight more corrupt than corporate tax avoidance.

Edited by robdave2k (12 Feb 2016 2.21pm)

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 12 Feb 16 2.35pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

How?

You've essentially just created a tax version of the EU. Which i'd wager is a damn sight more corrupt than corporate tax avoidance.

Edited by robdave2k (12 Feb 2016 2.21pm)

As to how, well, nations would know that they would get a share of the tax pot of the various companies that trade in their nation. Also, if all companies were obliged to pay their portion at what ever rate was set internationally there would be a lot more money floating around for nations to claim.

How is it like a tax version of the EU? I don't quite get your point there.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

DanH Flag SW2 12 Feb 16 2.54pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Dan.... you fancy yourself (literally too LOL) as a bit of an accountant no?

Do you have any ideas for designing and creating new future proof tax laws to stop Google and others like them taking the p1ss?

It's all very well criticising the existing laws but many have tried to have wordings that they thought were watertight only to find accountancy firms like KPMG creating ways round them within days of their announcement.

Well I work in tax and I'm chartered qualified so have an inkling of how it all works.

Tax laws are all political. The industry knows it, big business knows it, the government knows it. Every sector in tax has a forum between the government and industry which is effectively for the industry to lobby the government on behalf of their major clients. HMRC stand no chance.

The existing corporate tax rules are are still largely based around the time when the UK was a manufacturing economy producing actual phyiscal goods. It's never really moved on to cope with the big boys selling IP and intangibles.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 12 Feb 16 3.22pm

Originally posted by Only 10 a year!!

I know someone very high up in HR there :-)

Anyway I have said my bit and I am out, it is a complex issue and I am not sure it has as clearer cut answer as some would want it to have.


Who probably aren't in the loop as much as I am to be honest. Know that from some transaction work of last year

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 12 Feb 16 4.22pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

As to how, well, nations would know that they would get a share of the tax pot of the various companies that trade in their nation. Also, if all companies were obliged to pay their portion at what ever rate was set internationally there would be a lot more money floating around for nations to claim.

How is it like a tax version of the EU? I don't quite get your point there.

First question - who will administer it?

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 12 Feb 16 9.23pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

First question - who will administer it?

Well that is a good question. Without Googling it I don't know who would be responsible for implimenting international tax/business law. Obviuously there would have to be international agreement.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 12 Feb 16 10.46pm

The answer is (relatively) simple. You just abolish corporate tax completely and increase VAT. You could also increase employer NI and business rates but that would simply reduce jobs in the UK.

Large companies will of course still generally exploit VAT loopholes much more effectively than small ones but at least their sales are generally much easier to measure than their costs.

The problem is that it is politically unacceptable to reduce tax on faceless companies and burden johnny taxpayer with the cost.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Hoof Hearted 13 Feb 16 11.38am

Originally posted by DanH

Well I work in tax and I'm chartered qualified so have an inkling of how it all works.

Tax laws are all political. The industry knows it, big business knows it, the government knows it. Every sector in tax has a forum between the government and industry which is effectively for the industry to lobby the government on behalf of their major clients. HMRC stand no chance.

The existing corporate tax rules are are still largely based around the time when the UK was a manufacturing economy producing actual phyiscal goods. It's never really moved on to cope with the big boys selling IP and intangibles.

So that's a no then?

I was hoping for a pithy wording/strategy from you that would tie Google etc up in knots!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 13 Feb 16 12.04pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Well that is a good question. Withouft Googling it I don't know who would be responsible for implimenting international tax/business law. Obviuously there would have to be international agreement.

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (13 Feb 2016 12.04pm)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Mr Palaceman Flag 13 Feb 16 1.23pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (13 Feb 2016 12.04pm)

LOL, I looked at the bit you highlighted 4 times before I saw it.. Good time to use a smiley..


 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Sportyteacher Flag London 15 Feb 16 8.43am

Originally posted by DanH

Well I work in tax and I'm chartered qualified so have an inkling of how it all works.

Tax laws are all political. The industry knows it, big business knows it, the government knows it. Every sector in tax has a forum between the government and industry which is effectively for the industry to lobby the government on behalf of their major clients. HMRC stand no chance.

The existing corporate tax rules are are still largely based around the time when the UK was a manufacturing economy producing actual phyiscal goods. It's never really moved on to cope with the big boys selling IP and intangibles.

DanH: Really interesting contribution from you to this thread. Given your background or anybody else who works in Tax, how would you change the system to make it fairer for everybody?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 15 Feb 16 9.27am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

DanH: Really interesting contribution from you to this thread. Given your background or anybody else who works in Tax, how would you change the system to make it fairer for everybody?


The quickest way to sort it out would be flat rates of tax - and a simple transparent system.


The worrying thing is that HMRC is held up in Government circles as a beacon as to how the public sector should operate. Which is frankly staggering.

 

DanH Flag SW2 15 Feb 16 10.48am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

DanH: Really interesting contribution from you to this thread. Given your background or anybody else who works in Tax, how would you change the system to make it fairer for everybody?


No easy answer unfortunately. Even with transfer pricing rules multinationals are still able to shift profits around for certain types of sales so that they arise in lower tax jurisdictions. Agree that the simplification of the systems would go some way to helping. I work in personal rather than corporate tax though so can't profess to be the saviour of corporate tax avoidance.

 

Hoof Hearted 15 Feb 16 10.52am

Originally posted by DanH


No easy answer unfortunately. Even with transfer pricing rules multinationals are still able to shift profits around for certain types of sales so that they arise in lower tax jurisdictions. Agree that the simplification of the systems would go some way to helping. I work in personal rather than corporate tax though so can't profess to be the saviour of corporate tax avoidance.

Booooooo

We were all hoping the Messiah of Tax Reform was going to enlighten us!

:'(

 

DanH Flag SW2 15 Feb 16 11.04am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Booooooo

We were all hoping the Messiah of Tax Reform was going to enlighten us!

:'(


Unfortunately I'm no Messiah. Just a very naughty boy.

 

Eustace H. Plimsoll Flag Aldershot 15 Feb 16 6.54pm

Originally posted by The Sash


Who probably aren't in the loop as much as I am to be honest. Know that from some transaction work of last year

What's worse - someone gloating "I told you so" or someone displaying remarkable grace and restraint when you know, however they're internally high-fiving themselves and saying "Nerr ner, ner ner nerr!"?

[Link]

Come on, Sash, you big prescient bugger, give us a big showboating gloat - you've earnt it.

(Oh, the various quote-references-links probably need to be clicked for this post to make any sense. (I regret I cannot offer any advice as to how to make this post interesting, however.))


Edited by Eustace H. Plimsoll (15 Feb 2016 7.01pm)

 


As a woman, I can step aside, or step up my game...

Sportyteacher Flag London 15 Feb 16 6.57pm

Originally posted by DanH


Unfortunately I'm no Messiah. Just a very naughty boy.

Oh dear! Profoundly disappointed. I cast you to medical supervision under the so-called expert watchful support of George's Osborne's private practioning brother, Dr.Adam! Such a paragon of supreme healthcare...NOT!
Watch yer back!


[Link]

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 15 Feb 16 7.05pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Oh dear! Profoundly disappointed. I cast you to medical supervision under the so-called expert watchful support of George's Osborne's private practioning brother, Dr.Adam! Such a paragon of supreme healthcare...NOT!
Watch yer back!


[Link]

Umm...make that 'practising'. If you have a 'practitioner' on your hands, then be prepared for indecipherable behaviour!!!?!

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Osborne & Google SHOCKER