This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| exitstageright |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
The nonsense of enforcing citizens legally defined rights against the state. I don't see how that's ludicrous or nonsense. Its worth noting that UK human rights were established in 1998, very little of the legislation was anything new to UK law, most of it was simply in precident rather than law. The failure of governments to actually legislate for the rights of their citizens is the problem, NOT the existence of the rights. You say its a waste, I say that the rights of citizens should always trump the state, as the states duty is the representation of all citizens, not just some. Its fashionable to blame the ECHR, but in truth, all they do is ratify existing UK law, which the Government has failed to implement or has legislated against. How much time and money would you say the Norwegians should spend on investigating Brevik's lack of moisturiser?
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Deabo2030
Human rights surely go hand-in-hand with human responsibilities, i.e. you are responsible for your own actions! No, they don't, rights are not about individuals responsibilities, but the responsibility of the state to citizens. The law covers individual responsibilities of the citizen to the state. Originally posted by Deabo2030
So if you choose to kill someone in cold blood (premeditated murder) then you choose to forgo your rights, because you have taken someone else right to live. Rights aren't from individual to individual, but from the state to individuals. As such, provision exists within the law on Human Rights to allow for justice and law enforcement, provided it allows for the preservation of rights. Surrendering the states rights to prisoners because they've become prisoners, serves no purpose except to allow the state unlimited power over a group of people who have no political representation or influence. The state still has a responsibility to its citizens, even if they're convicted of a minor or major crime. Originally posted by Deabo2030
Breivik has chosen his own destiny by doing what he did, surely he has to pay for his actions! He is paying for his actions though, he's been convicted and received the maximum sentence in Norwegian law for murder. The same as anyone else who has been convicted of the same crime. Just because he is Breivik, doesn't mean the state gets a special pass to treat him differently to anyone else convicted of the same offence. Originally posted by Deabo2030
My question is why does he have to right to live if he is guilty of the crimes for which he has been charged? Because at the time Norway did not have a death penalty (and still doesn't). I don't think that even the Human Rights Act comes into that, as none of the signatories had a death penalty except in 'obsolete legislation' at the time. Norway abolished Capital Punishment in 1979. Ironically Breviek seems to actually want the death penalty, which to me is a very good reason to not give it to him.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Side note, Norway, in peacetime, hasn't executed someone since 1876. Between 16-25% of the population favour the idea of capital punishment.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Doesn't matter if he's guilty or innocent, rights apply to everyone, even if they're the best of us, or the worst of us. Our rights, are only trumped by a state of national emergency or national security issues such as terrorism. Does he deserve them, certainly not, but its something that separates us, from 'them' our capacity to respect their rights and attribute them with protections from abuses of power. Its our Judicary that deems it in conflict, not the EU. They passed it to the ECHR. No it isn't. In 2001, three prisoners challenged the explicit ban on all prisoners—except those on remand and a few other minor exceptions—being able to vote in any parliamentary or local government elections. They claimed that the ban was a breach of the European Convention on Human Rights, but lost in the High Court. That's our judiciary. One of the prisoners, John Hirst, convicted of manslaughter in 1980, argued at the human rights court in Strasbourg that this rules out a 'blanket' ban on prisoner votes. In 2005, the Court's Grand Chamber agreed that it was. Not our judiciary. It didn't say that all prisoners should have the vote. It's up to the UK to find a way of changing the law so that it's in keeping with what the Convention requires. Or we can just use the one in the act I mentioned before, which is more than adequate, and is what 3 successive, different, governments have done.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
No it isn't. In 2001, three prisoners challenged the explicit ban on all prisoners—except those on remand and a few other minor exceptions—being able to vote in any parliamentary or local government elections. They claimed that the ban was a breach of the European Convention on Human Rights, but lost in the High Court. That's our judiciary. One of the prisoners, John Hirst, convicted of manslaughter in 1980, argued at the human rights court in Strasbourg that this rules out a 'blanket' ban on prisoner votes. In 2005, the Court's Grand Chamber agreed that it was. Not our judiciary. It didn't say that all prisoners should have the vote. It's up to the UK to find a way of changing the law so that it's in keeping with what the Convention requires. Or we can just use the one in the act I mentioned before, which is more than adequate, and is what 3 successive, different, governments have done. I thought they were granted leave to appeal, and that resulted in it being passed to the ECHR. The European court is part of our judiciary, and has ratified UK law since its inception, in the 50s I think. The UK also provides input into the ECHR, which serves as a final court of arbitration. Yes, quite right, it stated that the government of the UK needs to pass legislation in keeping with the Human Rights act - Its not just the UK either, several other European countries had similar findings - It suggested that some kind of enfranchisement of prisoners should occur (such as for those serving less than 4 years or serving time for minor offences). The problem isn't the ECHR, its that the UK hasn't acted in a manner coherent with its own laws, or passed legislation that determines an outcome to this conflict of being both entitled to vote and banned from voting. You can't just pick and choose based on convenience. Its an interesting area, because at present the only people not represented by government are prisoners, who correspondingly have seen excessive cuts in funding, overcrowding and generally decreasing levels of both conditions and rehabilitation rates. Edited by jamiemartin721 (16 Mar 2016 3.38pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by exitstageright
How much time and money would you say the Norwegians should spend on investigating Brevik's lack of moisturiser? As much as anyone else would be legally entitled to. Its not for the state to determine what is and isn't a possible violation of human rights, it down to the legal system. I don't think laws should necessarily be explicitly obeyed, but hold with the notion of the social contract, that in knowingly violating a law, even one you believe to be unjust, that you are then exposed to the consequences of those laws. Rights correspondingly restrict the capacity of the law to be used unfairly or in a biased manner, by the state, and serve to protect citizens in a similar manner to how the law protects the state.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| exitstageright |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
As much as anyone else would be legally entitled to. Its not for the state to determine what is and isn't a possible violation of human rights, it down to the legal system. I don't think laws should necessarily be explicitly obeyed, but hold with the notion of the social contract, that in knowingly violating a law, even one you believe to be unjust, that you are then exposed to the consequences of those laws. Rights correspondingly restrict the capacity of the law to be used unfairly or in a biased manner, by the state, and serve to protect citizens in a similar manner to how the law protects the state. Fine, you believe that time and money should be spent on criminals complaining about lack of moisturisers and anything else that they care to dream up.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I thought they were granted leave to appeal, and that resulted in it being passed to the ECHR. The European court is part of our judiciary, and has ratified UK law since its inception, in the 50s I think. The UK also provides input into the ECHR, which serves as a final court of arbitration. Yes, quite right, it stated that the government of the UK needs to pass legislation in keeping with the Human Rights act - Its not just the UK either, several other European countries had similar findings - It suggested that some kind of enfranchisement of prisoners should occur (such as for those serving less than 4 years or serving time for minor offences). The problem isn't the ECHR, its that the UK hasn't acted in a manner coherent with its own laws, or passed legislation that determines an outcome to this conflict of being both entitled to vote and banned from voting. You can't just pick and choose based on convenience. Its an interesting area, because at present the only people not represented by government are prisoners, who correspondingly have seen excessive cuts in funding, overcrowding and generally decreasing levels of both conditions and rehabilitation rates. Edited by jamiemartin721 (16 Mar 2016 3.38pm) It's not, it's another entity altogether that we are unfortunately signed up to. There isn't a problem, it's as clear as it can be: The Representation of the People Act 1983 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. It changed the British electoral process in the following ways: Amended the Representation of the People Act 1969. Stated that a convicted person cannot vote at any parliamentary or local election whilst in prison. f*** what the 1998 Human rights act says (or any other act or European ruling), that covers it quite succinctly. Edited by Stuk (16 Mar 2016 4.06pm)
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by exitstageright
Fine, you believe that time and money should be spent on criminals complaining about lack of moisturisers and anything else that they care to dream up. I'd recommend looking at the application, the primary areas of complaint are to do with segregation and isolation of the prisoner (essentially indefinite solitary confinement). A secondary issue is over the degree of restriction on visitors and correspondence. Much as certain outlets might like you to believe its not about moisturiser. They're selectively picking from the rambling list of complaints of how he is treated differently than other prisoners. The key issues of appeal are segregation, solitary confinement, visitors and the restrictions on mail and correspondence.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
It's not, it's another entity altogether that we are unfortunately signed up to. There isn't a problem, it's as clear as it can be: The Representation of the People Act 1983 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. It changed the British electoral process in the following ways: Amended the Representation of the People Act 1969. Stated that a convicted person cannot vote at any parliamentary or local election whilst in prison. f*** what the 1998 Human rights act says (or any other act or European ruling), that covers it quite succinctly. Edited by Stuk (16 Mar 2016 4.06pm) To you maybe, but in terms of law, its contradicts the right to vote, passed in the 1998 Human Rights act. Rights in law, generally take precedence over government legislation, as they're universal in their application, and immutable (a government cannot pass laws that violate a constitutional right). As such, the government actually needs to redress what its a practical problem, without resorting to moralist posturing to popularism. Interestingly the government of the UK did try to introduce legislation to resolve the conflict, but it didn't pass through the House.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
To you maybe, but in terms of law, its contradicts the right to vote, passed in the 1998 Human Rights act. Rights in law, generally take precedence over government legislation, as they're universal in their application, and immutable (a government cannot pass laws that violate a constitutional right). As such, the government actually needs to redress what its a practical problem, without resorting to moralist posturing to popularism. Interestingly the government of the UK did try to introduce legislation to resolve the conflict, but it didn't pass through the House. The 1998 act allows for declarations of incompatibility. Job done. The government just needs to keep doing what it's doing. Ignoring the requests.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
The 1998 act allows for declarations of incompatibility. Job done. The government just needs to keep doing what it's doing. Ignoring the requests. Then the government should probably look at doing that. Curiously, the Conservative government wanted to pass legislation allowing some enfranchisement of prisoners. My personal view, is that prisoners should be allowed to vote in elections, as they are the only people there is no necessity for MP's in society to represent the interests of.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| exitstageright |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I'd recommend looking at the application, the primary areas of complaint are to do with segregation and isolation of the prisoner (essentially indefinite solitary confinement). A secondary issue is over the degree of restriction on visitors and correspondence. Much as certain outlets might like you to believe its not about moisturiser. They're selectively picking from the rambling list of complaints of how he is treated differently than other prisoners. The key issues of appeal are segregation, solitary confinement, visitors and the restrictions on mail and correspondence.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by exitstageright
You could read the news accounts of the hearing. He's been kept in segregation from all other prisoners, apparently denied reasonable communication, visitation and effectively suffered as a result of being in an effective solitary confinement. This his lawyer claims, amounts to a failure to meet several human rights (as well as conditions of the prison service in Norway).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
The 1998 act allows for declarations of incompatibility. Job done. The government just needs to keep doing what it's doing. Ignoring the requests. Or just occasionally attempt to pass legislation that's then defeated in the commons. The problem of incompatibility, is that the two aren't incompatible; I think it would be very difficult to construct a reasonable argument as to why prisoners cannot have some access to enfranchisement, that couldn't be countered effectively.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| exitstageright |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Or just occasionally attempt to pass legislation that's then defeated in the commons. The problem of incompatibility, is that the two aren't incompatible; I think it would be very difficult to construct a reasonable argument as to why prisoners cannot have some access to enfranchisement, that couldn't be countered effectively. Aren't they suffering enough with lack of moisturiser without having to put up with Jeremy Corbyn knocking on their cell-doors canvassing for votes?
|
|
| exitstageright |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
You could read the news accounts of the hearing. He's been kept in segregation from all other prisoners, apparently denied reasonable communication, visitation and effectively suffered as a result of being in an effective solitary confinement. This his lawyer claims, amounts to a failure to meet several human rights (as well as conditions of the prison service in Norway). So you haven't seen his application either, so moisturiser and not hot enough coffee could be his primary complaints for all you know.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by exitstageright
So you haven't seen his application either, so moisturiser and not hot enough coffee could be his primary complaints for all you know. No, because they wouldn't be sufficient for a case to be heard, as access to those wouldn't violate human rights, as they aren't an article of the 1998 act.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| exitstageright |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
No, because they wouldn't be sufficient for a case to be heard, as access to those wouldn't violate human rights, as they aren't an article of the 1998 act. Do you mean to tell me that the right to moisturiser is not in the Human Rights Legislation! Shocking. Has Jeremy Corbyn been told? To signal his solidarity,I'm sure he would want to attend the mass-demonstrations that are bound to take place once this gets out. "What do we what?", "E45", "When do we want it?", "When we are serving a prison sentence for mass-murder!".
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.