You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Axl Rose to front AC/DC?
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Axl Rose to front AC/DC?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 25 Mar 16 6.53pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

BLASPHEMER!!!!

Angus and Slash are rock gods!

To be fair, anyone who can have a 40 year career dressed as a rock version of wee Jimmy Krankie deserves some sort of respect, and Slash's mum did go out with David Bowie for a while, so just one degree of separation from greatness!

 


I used to be immortal

Pussay Patrol Flag 26 Mar 16 10.05am

Originally posted by crystal balls

Ha Ha! Very good! Sorry, I have to confess, I don't know who example is/are/were!

I like many different genres in music, but in terms of hard rock, you can't go too far wrong with The Who and Zep (a bit obvious I know), maybe early Blue Oyster Cult. ACDC are just not in the same league.

To me, Guns n Roses are just a pale, flaccid version of some great British bands, like Free, Jeff Beck Group and Humble Pie. Sorry, but GnR are nothing in comparison. Not even as good as mediocre American bands like Aerosmith.

Aerosmith? There's lowering the bar then there's that

What next ? All the trashy permed cross dressing American bands? Motley Crue? kizz?

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Hoof Hearted 26 Mar 16 10.16am

Originally posted by crystal balls

Ha Ha! Very good! Sorry, I have to confess, I don't know who example is/are/were!

I like many different genres in music, but in terms of hard rock, you can't go too far wrong with The Who and Zep (a bit obvious I know), maybe early Blue Oyster Cult. ACDC are just not in the same league.

To me, Guns n Roses are just a pale, flaccid version of some great British bands, like Free, Jeff Beck Group and Humble Pie. Sorry, but GnR are nothing in comparison. Not even as good as mediocre American bands like Aerosmith.

I wouldn't put GnR on a par with Led Zep, Humble Pie, Black Sabbath, Deep Purple etc., either, but I still think they have talent and as I've already stated Slash is a top drawer guitarist and acknowledged by his peers.

ACDC are up there with the likes of Saxon, Iron Maiden for fast loud rock and Angus is fantastic and great fun - no doubt for me though that the loss of Bon Scott was crucial, and Brian Johnson's vocals don't impress me like Bon did. Axl Rose could easily replace Johnson, but not Bon.... Janis Joplin could have... she's probably belting out a few numbers with Bon in Hell right now!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Mar 16 12.29pm

Originally posted by crystal balls

Ha Ha! Very good! Sorry, I have to confess, I don't know who example is/are/were!

I like many different genres in music, but in terms of hard rock, you can't go too far wrong with The Who and Zep (a bit obvious I know), maybe early Blue Oyster Cult. ACDC are just not in the same league.

To me, Guns n Roses are just a pale, flaccid version of some great British bands, like Free, Jeff Beck Group and Humble Pie. Sorry, but GnR are nothing in comparison. Not even as good as mediocre American bands like Aerosmith.

AC/DC are not comparable to Zeppelin, They are a different animal. The Who have the advantage of being trail blazers but not all of their stuff is that good in retrospect. Blue Oyster Cult don't even register in terms of the best rock bands IMO.
In the end, all bands do good and bad and it is all about personal taste in the end. For example, Deep Purple helped create the genre of heavy rock but I'd rather listen to Sweet any day of the week although they heavily borrowed from Purple and The Who. Compare,Purples "The Rat" 1970 to Sweet's Set Me Free 1974. Purple's is the original but Sweet's rip off is much better. That's not to say that Purple haven't done some good songs albeit with daft lyrics.
Reputation sometimes counts for nothing when it comes to good tunes.


Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (26 Mar 2016 12.30pm)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Axl Rose to front AC/DC?