You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Poor white kids failing at school - Maggie's fault
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Poor white kids failing at school - Maggie's fault


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
JHB Flag London 06 Apr 16 9.07am

Originally posted by Kermit8

By all means lay the blame rightfully at mis-management, inequality and ongoing social ills but I can't stand all this ethnic lumping. It's just divisive. Either you come from a good family with positive role models or you don't.

Either you want to do well at school or for one reason or another you don't/aren't able to. Either your peers are a good influence or they are not and either you are unlucky enough to have been born poor and probably go to a crap school or you are not.

You can't just target whites when it is obvious the problems go beyond skin colour.

I'd agree with most of this. It was striking that when I was at school in the 90s there were some very bright kids whose parents cared more about whether their children were perceived as being 'tough' and able to 'handle themselves' than whether they were doing well academically. I got a lot of grief from some kids for being a "boffin" just because I worked hard and did well in my results. For these kids that was the worst possible thing you could be. I often think how some of those kids could have done if they'd been given a bit more encouragement at home.

As others have pointed out often the parents had few qualifications as well but had decent jobs. Unfortunately a lot of those jobs simply don't exist anymore or are a lot harder to find so the prospects for the kids are much worse. That was back in the mid 90s as well and the situation has worsened since.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Apr 16 9.28am

When I was a poor white kid, admittedly living in an area with a lot of wealth, there was a lot of emphasis with my parents on the importance of education, not necessarily educational success. To my parents, education was something that wasn't available to them, and they saw that their lives were limited because of it.

This certainly seems to be true of some of the working class in the past, particularly among trade unionist organisation members and a significant section of the working class (left wing and right wing) that education was vital to opportunity.

Obviously there were those who didn't care, and invariably among my family, their kids achievements have been minimal in life, echoing their parents, rather than surpassing them - and some of them definitely have made a good life for themselves in spite of a s**ty start - but the great advantage of education and a willingness to learn and exploit your own intelligence, is that it means opportunities exist and continue to exist, that simply would otherwise be closed.

Most important thing a child can get, is a good basis in education. You don't have to be the best student, you just need to understand the 'why and how', be able to read proficiently, communicate and write. One thing I noticed when I did my apprenticeship, was that a large part of it was focused on skills that appeared to have nothing to do with my job (writing skills, computer literacy, presentation skills and comprehension skills).

To me, the failure to obtain a reasonable competency in these skills, along with a respect for intelligent achievements, dooms a white working class to simply to repeat its previous generation.

Indian parents, Asian parents, Black parents, Muslim parents etc seem to understand that knowledge and the capacity to use knowledge is inherently rewarding in life (which may well have not been an option for their parents).

A reasonably stable background and competency in education are essential to the improvement of the working class, especially in an era where work otherwise will be limited, and prospects entirely defined by the options their employment can provide.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

DanH Flag SW2 06 Apr 16 10.23am

There's an interesting paper written by Steven Levitt (recommend reading Freakonomics if anyone is looking for a good book) which looks at how much impact school choice has on a child's attainment and then looking at what factors do actually have a bearing on it if the school choice is almost irrelevant (it was).

Turns out that the IQ of the parents and those from a good socio-economic background were the main factors affecting attainment. Perhaps the non-white demographic in Britain are catching up in the socioeconomic stakes and achieving far better test results as a result.

 

johnfirewall Flag 06 Apr 16 3.13pm

Originally posted by DanH

There's an interesting paper written by Steven Levitt (recommend reading Freakonomics if anyone is looking for a good book) which looks at how much impact school choice has on a child's attainment and then looking at what factors do actually have a bearing on it if the school choice is almost irrelevant (it was).

Turns out that the IQ of the parents and those from a good socio-economic background were the main factors affecting attainment. Perhaps the non-white demographic in Britain are catching up in the socioeconomic stakes and achieving far better test results as a result.

Good book. I particulary relished reading the evidence the dispells most of what people think about everything (not that you're allowed to mention any pattern where race is a variable, even when presented alongise the statistics, but that's another story)

I'll confess that I don't know many highly educated people or any with children old enough require too much of an educational kick-up-the-backside but these people are generally white lower middle-class and are happy as long as the kids are focussed and have interests outside of schools such as sport or art.

Whatever the stats say, money buys an education, which in turn yields a greater income.. And repeat.

Looking at kids from my school, I can't see any deviation from the established norms, I mean none of them are millionaires. Can I derive from that this is because none of the parents were well-off? Sadly the working class part of me does cling to that assumption.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Poor white kids failing at school - Maggie's fault