You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > This (Cameron protest)
November 22 2026 1.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

This (Cameron protest)


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 12.12pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

[Link]

But... there are still limits as to what you can bring in to the UK from France or any other EU nation for it to be deemed "personal use".

Pulling me up on the term "duty free" doesn't change the sentiment (and I noticed your usual attempts to discredit my posts with reference to general ignorance, even though you did it in a light hearted fashion.... if you think I'm generally an ignorant person at least have the cojones to say it openly )

To use the duty free analogy.

I think its ok, when people maybe chance it, and bring back a bit over them limits, and go through the nothing to declare and don't get caught (or bringing in 200 ciggie for a friend etc).

I think its very different when people smuggle alcohol and tobacco into the UK and sell it on. This is where these schemes come in, its like parking a van in dover, going over on foot, loading up in France, coming back, putting it in the van, and then going straight back. All day long - and then selling it at a discounted price.

But in this analogy, some of these people are effectively running an off licence in the UK, selling illegally imported booze and tobacco, and selling it at full bonded prices.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 11 Apr 16 12.27pm

Originally posted by phil19750

He sold his interest before he became Prime Minister.

There can't be one rule for one and one rule for others.

The "tax avoidance" is legal and no different than investing in an ISA.

Edited by phil19750 (11 Apr 2016 9.57am)

He sold the shares in January 2010, His Father died in the September . Did Dave get his inheritance early? If not surely Dave isn't telling us everyything.

Edited by nickgusset (11 Apr 2016 12.27pm)

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 11 Apr 16 12.37pm

Why on earth are MPs declaring their tax returns? It's absolutely ludicrous, it's their personal finances. Clue is in the word, PERSONAL. Surely we shouldn't be making the idea of being an MP even more undesirable, we want to attract the best people to run the country, this is not the way to do it!

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Apr 16 12.39pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

Careful Hoof,or people might attribute your ignorance about duty free within the EU to all your views..There is no duty free for trips to France...abolished in 1999!

You like bandying around the word ignorance don't you.

You must be one of these types with delusions of superiority.

Nothing like a bit of name calling and swerve to cloud an issue.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 11 Apr 16 12.49pm

Nearly laughed out loud on seeing a fellow commuter's Daily Mail scream "Enough is Enough!" this morning. Our poor PM....

I'm sure there will be a benefits cheat scandal along soon enough.

All sarcasm aside, Jamie's points about what can be thought of as little bits of flex around the edges (in both tax and benefits creativity) are very strong.

"Aggressive" (to use HMRC's own language) tactics are where the attention of law makers and law enforcers needs to be. Cameron is guilty of being evasive and hypocritical - we're all in this together Dave - but there are many much bigger schemes and sums out there that need proper scrutiny.

Perhaps they should pursue them with the same vigour that self-employed low earning taxpayers and benefit claimants are policed with?

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 12.51pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

Why on earth are MPs declaring their tax returns? It's absolutely ludicrous, it's their personal finances. Clue is in the word, PERSONAL. Surely we shouldn't be making the idea of being an MP even more undesirable, we want to attract the best people to run the country, this is not the way to do it!

They shouldn't, except of course to HMRC etc.

No ones personal information should be available except with a) their consent b) public necessity.

Of course it'll be interesting in the light of these Panama leaks whether the declarations of earnings to HMRC in a given year, from various sources, listed those held in obfuscated accounts.

And this is I think the key issue, not appearances, but actual 'wrong doing'.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 11 Apr 16 1.07pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

The complete tw*t in that video went on This Week (political programme that's on after Question Time) trying to convince everyone that they shouldn't vote. He was also privately educated, nice place to have socialist views from, isn't it? BBC's wet dream. Watch Andrew Neil tearing him apart here:

[Link]

When will the left learn that the more they moan, the less appealing their cause is to the average man? It's pathetic. They think because they shout the loudest that they are winning the argument, even though time and again this is proved to not be the case.

Cameron has clearly not done anything wrong, his crime is to wisely manage his personal finances. I'd be more worried if he hadn't. Having said that, he hasn't covered himself in glory in his handling of it. Calls for him to resign are ludicrous.


Edited by We are goin up! (11 Apr 2016 11.25am)

The fact that he opened his mouth to drink before he had even picked up his glass at about 1:28 has angered me more than it probably should. What a loathsome individual.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Kingvagabond Flag London 11 Apr 16 3.27pm

See there's a thing about all this totally legal ergo not immoral stuff. Just because you canlegallydo something doesn't mean it is morally right. Tax planning is finding loopholes to be used to pay less tax than you might have to right? If you are intended to have to pay X amount of tax and instead pay Y is that not morally dubious? Especially, when generally screaming from the rooftops about so called benefits cheats.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

JL85 Flag London,SE9 11 Apr 16 4.20pm

Originally posted by Kingvagabond

See there's a thing about all this totally legal ergo not immoral stuff. Just because you canlegallydo something doesn't mean it is morally right. Tax planning is finding loopholes to be used to pay less tax than you might have to right? If you are intended to have to pay X amount of tax and instead pay Y is that not morally dubious? Especially, when generally screaming from the rooftops about so called benefits cheats.

A point that seem's totally lost on the right. They love a hard line approach, until it's aimed at them, then they scuttle back to the left.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 11 Apr 16 5.00pm

Originally posted by phil19750

Yeah, he hasn't handled it particularly well, but then again, what has his private finances got to do with anyone else?

If he acted illegally, then that is a matter for the courts.

Who can honestly say that they have never paid a builder cash in hand, or bought foreign fags that were not subject to import duty?

It's all b0llocks.

Well said that man....... Dave has done nothing wrong or illegal.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Kingvagabond Flag London 11 Apr 16 5.16pm

Originally posted by susmik

Well said that man....... Dave has done nothing wrong or illegal.

Other than deliberately misleading the public for five days until he was sure that he hadn't. However, being that he has released a summary of his tax returns not his full financial accounts we actually have no idea of whether he has or not.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

npn Flag Crowborough 11 Apr 16 5.29pm

Originally posted by Kingvagabond

See there's a thing about all this totally legal ergo not immoral stuff. Just because you canlegallydo something doesn't mean it is morally right. Tax planning is finding loopholes to be used to pay less tax than you might have to right? If you are intended to have to pay X amount of tax and instead pay Y is that not morally dubious? Especially, when generally screaming from the rooftops about so called benefits cheats.

I do get that, it's just that you can't really define what you're 'intended' to pay. For instance, ISAs are, presumably, considered legitimate tax efficient mechanisms, intended to be taken advantage of, but as you get deeper into the ins and outs of tax law, the rules get more complex and difficult to compartmentalise into "legit" and "taking liberties". For instance, I have no idea why the 'gift' rules (exempt from inheritance tax) are in place - it makes no sense to me. What is the difference between someone giving me 10 grand as a gift, and someone bequeathing me 10 grand in their will for me to receive once they know they won't be needing it any more - why is one subject to tax and the other isn't?

I don't know all the rules, and I'd wager nobody on here (unless we have a few accountants) does. I claimed CGT back on a failed business venture against a CGT profit on a house sale purely because my accountant told me I could. That's what he's paid for, and it saved me a good few quid. There was no hiding funds, or avoiding tax going on. I suspect one way we could alleviate the p*ss-taking is to somehow make the facilitating of schemes designed to hide funds from the tax man illegal so that someone is ultimately held responsible, which again comes down to chucking money at HMRC to plug the holes in some way.

Set a thief to catch a thief - chuck the top accountants at HMRC with a remit to plug the holes and come up with a solution

 

Kingvagabond Flag London 11 Apr 16 6.04pm

I think the problem is the HMRC is a completely morally corrupt, inefficient and completely inept organisation who commit 'legal' harassment on a regular basis usually whilst acting on totally erroneous information based on their own mistakes and then are completely backed up by unfair tax collection laws unless you prove completely that it's them who have f***ed up, whilst they continue to pass your information onto violent debt collection agencies. All whilst making deals with multinational conglomerates to pay 1% of the amount they should be paying.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Apr 16 6.09pm

Originally posted by npn

For instance, I have no idea why the 'gift' rules (exempt from inheritance tax) are in place - it makes no sense to me. What is the difference between someone giving me 10 grand as a gift, and someone bequeathing me 10 grand in their will for me to receive once they know they won't be needing it any more - why is one subject to tax and the other isn't?

I believe that only gifts given a certain number of years before the person's death will be exempt from inheritance tax.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 11 Apr 16 6.22pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I believe that only gifts given a certain number of years before the person's death will be exempt from inheritance tax.

It's 7, I think, and it still makes bugger all sense to me!

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 11 Apr 16 6.44pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Well said npn.

Morality shouldn't come into it.

If Cameron, or any other MP or celebrity has invested in a totally legal tax efficient instrument that is their business and HRMC's - nobody elses.

If you don't like it, form your own political party, get elected and change the tax laws.


Morality is the weakest stance to make an argument anyway...after everything that Camerons been accused of they've been deflected one by one...and now this is all they have.

Yes its important to change the tax legislation...but for everyone. Its the system that needs to be addressed not the individuals whatever their background...or seemingly more importantly class

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 11 Apr 16 7.19pm

Originally posted by Kingvagabond

I think the problem is the HMRC is a completely morally corrupt, inefficient and completely inept organisation who commit 'legal' harassment on a regular basis usually whilst acting on totally erroneous information based on their own mistakes and then are completely backed up by unfair tax collection laws unless you prove completely that it's them who have f***ed up, whilst they continue to pass your information onto violent debt collection agencies. All whilst making deals with multinational conglomerates to pay 1% of the amount they should be paying.

To be fair, HMRC have been shafted as much as any other branch of the Civil Service by 'austerity'. They are in the position where, they only have a chance of getting anything from the little people. Better (from the governments point of view) to catch 100 'tax cheats' for the headlines which might yield, say, £100K in revenue, than go after a single corporation or individual who can afford lawyers and accountants to tie things up for years, even though HMRC might be able to claim back millions if successful.

If the political will was there, a properly funded HMRC could go after the big fish. However, this government will never, ever back this. 'New Labour' didn't before them. The next government probably won't either.

Who knows? If successive governments (over the last couple of decades, at the very least) had actually made an effort to close tax loopholes and shut evasion schemes, I suspect public finances would be in a much better state. Sadly, cutting public services will always be easier than going after your political donors for the tax they owe.

 

phil19750 Flag Sundridge Park 12 Apr 16 12.13pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

The fact that he opened his mouth to drink before he had even picked up his glass at about 1:28 has angered me more than it probably should. What a loathsome individual.

Haha what an utter tool.

His face at 2.53 is superb!

 


el burro sabe más que tú

Hoof Hearted 12 Apr 16 12.26pm

Originally posted by Kingvagabond

See there's a thing about all this totally legal ergo not immoral stuff. Just because you canlegallydo something doesn't mean it is morally right. Tax planning is finding loopholes to be used to pay less tax than you might have to right? If you are intended to have to pay X amount of tax and instead pay Y is that not morally dubious? Especially, when generally screaming from the rooftops about so called benefits cheats.

JL85's response....

A point that seem's totally lost on the right. They love a hard line approach, until it's aimed at them, then they scuttle back to the left.


It's not a legitimate argument though.

Morality is fine, but it's too woolly a concept to nail someone down and that is why we have laws and a legal system to enforce the laws.

You can't have a system that acts on which way the wind is blowing or if the judge is in a good mood.

That's the sort of system Henry VIII was operating.

Cameron's investments are/were acceptable according to law.

If you don't like our current laws get yourself elected to government to pass ones more attuned to your moral code.

 

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 12 Apr 16 12.42pm

So to conclude:

On the one hand we have those who are against those who wish to govern our country paying less than they should to the country they wish to govern, and on the other we have those that are for those who wish to govern our country paying less to the country that they wish to govern.

Interesting.

 


Time to move forward together.

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > This (Cameron protest)