You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The left and Jewish people
November 22 2026 12.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The left and Jewish people


Page 2 of 22 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 10 Apr 16 10.01pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Semites are classified as a race under the wider Caucasian umbrella.

[Link]

I see these guys along 125TH St all the time.

 


Pro USA & Israel

legaleagle Flag 10 Apr 16 10.10pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


Not sure what any of this has to do with anything on this thread.

1. Jews are not a race. Their claim to be so and to be the chosen children of God mirrors similarly deluded Nazi claims.
2. To criticise one group of people for oppressing another is not racism or idiotic.
3. Antisemitism was not created by multiculturalism in this country but it does mean that we now have religious groups at odds with each other here on home soil. It will now invade our politics as it has begun to do already and effect the wider population negatively.


So Jews "mirror" the Nazis...a very mixed up analysis indeed IMHO...

To criticise any group for oppressing another is of course not racist or idiotic. viz. criticism say of the Pinochet junta in Chile or Britons historically in Ireland.Though a whole religious/ethnic group should not ignorantly and lazily be tarred collectively with the sins of their governments or a part of their "group".

To discriminate against a group collectively and/or stereotype it negatively,in the way the councillor highlighted by the OP was, is the very essence of ignorance and idiocy

Crass and idiotic discrimination by one religion against another has unfortunately been a part of the domestic territory here for a very very long time..viz. anti-catholicism.....

Edited by legaleagle (10 Apr 2016 10.19pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 10 Apr 16 11.14pm

Originally posted by legaleagle


So Jews "mirror" the Nazis...a very mixed up analysis indeed IMHO...

To criticise any group for oppressing another is of course not racist or idiotic. viz. criticism say of the Pinochet junta in Chile or Britons historically in Ireland.Though a whole religious/ethnic group should not ignorantly and lazily be tarred collectively with the sins of their governments or a part of their "group".

To discriminate against a group collectively and/or stereotype it negatively,in the way the councillor highlighted by the OP was, is the very essence of ignorance and idiocy

Crass and idiotic discrimination by one religion against another has unfortunately been a part of the domestic territory here for a very very long time..viz. anti-catholicism.....

Edited by legaleagle (10 Apr 2016 10.19pm)


Really?
I see very little difference between the two.
Both have the delusion of being special and superior and have trodden on the rights of others using that as a justification. Both have systematically tried to wipe out a people to further their own ambitions.

We quite rightly condemn one as a byword for evil and yet sympathise and defend the other simply because one was the victim of the other at a point in history.

Understandable? Perhaps. But the Jewish status as victim cannot be allowed to justify all the crimes of Israel or any one who happens to be Jewish.
Crying Anti Semitism every time someone raises an objection to the treatment of Palestine is not credible.
Having said that. What this woman has said, if reported accurately, is unacceptable because of the language she has chosen.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (10 Apr 2016 11.15pm)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 11 Apr 16 6.32am

Originally posted by nickgusset

What do you propose they do?

I'd kick them out. By all means state Palestine's case for self determination and recognition as a nation worldwide.
Anti Semitism is not the way to achieve this. It's racist.

Replace the leader with someone who is more moderate. If Hilary Benn was leader, cannot imagine that all of these anti Semitic weirdos would be allowed anywhere near office.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

sydtheeagle Flag England 11 Apr 16 8.12am

Originally posted by Kermit8

Correct me if I am wrong but was it not some of those on the Right who nearly wiped the entire Jewish race off the face of the earth and neo-groups of similar persuasion keep that warped fantasy alive?

As for the councillor - she should be prosecuted and jailed if she has broken any law and I hope she has.


You're somewhat wrong, unless Stalin has suddenly been shifted to the right hand side of the ledger.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 9.23am

Originally posted by Kermit8

Correct me if I am wrong but was it not some of those on the Right who nearly wiped the entire Jewish race off the face of the earth and neo-groups of similar persuasion keep that warped fantasy alive?

As for the councillor - she should be prosecuted and jailed if she has broken any law and I hope she has.

Pretty much agree with the second paragraph, there is a massive difference between Israel, its policy towards the Palestinians and being Jewish.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Al from Oki Flag Okehampton 11 Apr 16 9.28am

Not a good time to be a Spurs fan then

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 9.29am

Originally posted by johnfirewall

It's obvious why that one woman would take such a vile stance. More generally I'd say the left support Palestine as the weaker entity. However there's still plenty of sympathy directed towards oppressed groups turning to terror, but quite selectively. The official British line in 1948 was quite confused and I can't speculate on what liberal views may have dictated around that time, but I'd hope they were as partisan as they are at present. To be fair I can't say how much of this venom is directed at individuals in the UK, I'd hope none, but I've not seen this many boycotts since the Apartheid era and I while on the wrong side of the river today I walked past a Jewish community centre which had 3 security guards. Maybe it's just a lefty trend like supporting St Pauli or Dulwich Hamlet. I mean how would one actually 'Free Palestine?'. I suppose the litmus test would be whether the left would support a movement which resulted in Israeli (read Jewish, because this could affect all citizens not just those acting or fighting on behalf of the government) bloodshed.

Back to the story though, Luton is clearly fcuked up and this only gets addressed when some IDL morons go up there.

Edited by johnfirewall (10 Apr 2016 7.29pm)

How else are oppressed groups supposed to protect themselves and escape from oppression. The term 'terrorist' is often used politically against groups that opposed a countries interests. Its easy to forget that often terrorist groups evolve out of a political isolation and systematic oppression - in which violence is commonly used against the oppressed peoples or groups. It should not then be surprising that such people resort to political violence to establish themselves.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Apr 16 10.38am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Pretty much agree with the second paragraph, there is a massive difference between Israel, its policy towards the Palestinians and being Jewish.

In the same way that Germans were not the same as Nazis?
In ideological terms you are right of course but in practice we still bombed German cities because they were under the control of Nazis. Israel was created solely for Jews in line with Jewish tradition and is run by Jews.
I'm sure the Palestinians or Arabs in general don't really care too much about ideological definitions.

Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters but the bulk of Jewish opinion which carries much weight in the US media supports Israel.
Personally I have no particular love or dislike for either party but the irony of the Jewish occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, that they claim in the name of the semi mythical, Biblical land of Israel, is unavoidable.

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 11 Apr 16 11.28am

Originally posted by Kermit8

Correct me if I am wrong but was it not some of those on the Right who nearly wiped the entire Jewish race off the face of the earth and neo-groups of similar persuasion keep that warped fantasy alive?

As for the councillor - she should be prosecuted and jailed if she has broken any law and I hope she has.


Up there with the most stupid posts I've ever seen on an internet forum.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

legaleagle Flag 11 Apr 16 11.34am

quote=Hrolf The Ganger;2978635]

In the same way that Germans were not the same as Nazis?
In ideological terms you are right of course but in practice we still bombed German cities because they were under the control of Nazis. Israel was created solely for Jews in line with Jewish tradition and is run by Jews.
I'm sure the Palestinians or Arabs in general don't really care too much about ideological definitions.

Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters but the bulk of Jewish opinion which carries much weight in the US media supports Israel.
Personally I have no particular love or dislike for either party but the irony of the Jewish occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, that they claim in the name of the semi mythical, Biblical land of Israel, is unavoidable.

....................................................

Thank you for that.It is certainly very insightful indeed in terms of "where you are coming from".

Ignorance speaks volumes...So,Jews are more or less a monolithic block?Hoary old chestnut...there may be one or two exceptions but basically they're all alike...Jesus wept!

Bit like holding everyone on here collectively responsible for,say,Bloody Sunday or the entire populations of the USA and UK collectively for the invasion of Iraq.......or anyone who happens to be a muslim for ISIS...

Reality...sizeable number of Israelis opposed to Israel government actions...

Large numbers of Jews around the world opposed to Israeli government actions...

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2016 11.35am)

 

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 11 Apr 16 12.08pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

quote=Hrolf The Ganger;2978635]

In the same way that Germans were not the same as Nazis?
In ideological terms you are right of course but in practice we still bombed German cities because they were under the control of Nazis. Israel was created solely for Jews in line with Jewish tradition and is run by Jews.
I'm sure the Palestinians or Arabs in general don't really care too much about ideological definitions.

Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters but the bulk of Jewish opinion which carries much weight in the US media supports Israel.
Personally I have no particular love or dislike for either party but the irony of the Jewish occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, that they claim in the name of the semi mythical, Biblical land of Israel, is unavoidable.

....................................................

Thank you for that.It is certainly very insightful indeed in terms of "where you are coming from".

Ignorance speaks volumes...So,Jews are more or less a monolithic block?Hoary old chestnut...there may be one or two exceptions but basically they're all alike...Jesus wept!

Bit like holding everyone on here collectively responsible for,say,Bloody Sunday or the entire populations of the USA and UK collectively for the invasion of Iraq.......or anyone who happens to be a muslim for ISIS...

Reality...sizeable number of Israelis opposed to Israel government actions...

Large numbers of Jews around the world opposed to Israeli government actions...

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2016 11.35am)

Indeed. In fact there are even anti Zionist Jews. Anti Zionism is not Anti Semitism. Anti Semites will almost certainly be anti Zionist, but the opposite doesn't hold true.

If you take Zionism to be the pursuit of establishing a Jewish state in the Holy land/Palestine/whatever definition you choose and regardless of who currently lives in those lands (and given that this extends to parts of other countries e.g. Jordan), then Anti Zionism is easy to understand. Anti Zionists are not even necessarily opposed to the principle of a Jewish state.

What this woman posted is clearly Anti Semitic, no grey areas as far as I can see. It shouldn't be mixed up with Anti Zionism, whatever your views are on that.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 11 Apr 16 12.10pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

quote=Hrolf The Ganger;2978635]

In the same way that Germans were not the same as Nazis?
In ideological terms you are right of course but in practice we still bombed German cities because they were under the control of Nazis. Israel was created solely for Jews in line with Jewish tradition and is run by Jews.
I'm sure the Palestinians or Arabs in general don't really care too much about ideological definitions.

Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters but the bulk of Jewish opinion which carries much weight in the US media supports Israel.
Personally I have no particular love or dislike for either party but the irony of the Jewish occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, that they claim in the name of the semi mythical, Biblical land of Israel, is unavoidable.

....................................................

Thank you for that.It is certainly very insightful indeed in terms of "where you are coming from".

Ignorance speaks volumes...So,Jews are more or less a monolithic block?Hoary old chestnut...there may be one or two exceptions but basically they're all alike...Jesus wept!

Bit like holding everyone on here collectively responsible for,say,Bloody Sunday or the entire populations of the USA and UK collectively for the invasion of Iraq.......or anyone who happens to be a muslim for ISIS...

Reality...sizeable number of Israelis opposed to Israel government actions...

Large numbers of Jews around the world opposed to Israeli government actions...

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2016 11.35am)

The thread title is just one sweeping generalisation anyway.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Apr 16 12.25pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

quote=Hrolf The Ganger;2978635]

In the same way that Germans were not the same as Nazis?
In ideological terms you are right of course but in practice we still bombed German cities because they were under the control of Nazis. Israel was created solely for Jews in line with Jewish tradition and is run by Jews.
I'm sure the Palestinians or Arabs in general don't really care too much about ideological definitions.

Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters but the bulk of Jewish opinion which carries much weight in the US media supports Israel.
Personally I have no particular love or dislike for either party but the irony of the Jewish occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, that they claim in the name of the semi mythical, Biblical land of Israel, is unavoidable.

....................................................

Thank you for that.It is certainly very insightful indeed in terms of "where you are coming from".

Ignorance speaks volumes...So,Jews are more or less a monolithic block?Hoary old chestnut...there may be one or two exceptions but basically they're all alike...Jesus wept!

Bit like holding everyone on here collectively responsible for,say,Bloody Sunday or the entire populations of the USA and UK collectively for the invasion of Iraq.......or anyone who happens to be a muslim for ISIS...

Reality...sizeable number of Israelis opposed to Israel government actions...

Large numbers of Jews around the world opposed to Israeli government actions...

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2016 11.35am)

A very predictable response.

I'm not coming from anywhere other than drawing a comparison between the Nazi treatment of Jews in the name of Germany and the Jewish treatment of Palestinians in the name of Israel.

Do you have figures on how many non Israeli Jews oppose the occupation of Gaza and the West Bank?

You sound like you have some expertise on the subject.

 

legaleagle Flag 11 Apr 16 12.51pm

About 22% of Israeli Jews said they strongly supported the establishment of a Palestinian state in a January 2016 opinion poll.

If we took that across to the UK,it would mean a point of view (albeit minority) subscribed to by more than 10 million people,hardly the odd one or two...For example, to give a sense of proportion to our right wing bretheren, UKIP currently poll at about 16%.

A US poll in November 2014 recorded that 72% of US Jews supported the establishment of a Palestinian state including E. Jerusalem as its capital.80% supported a complete ban on settlement building in the occupied territories.


Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2016 12.54pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Apr 16 1.08pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

About 22% of Israeli Jews said they strongly supported the establishment of a Palestinian state in a January 2016 opinion poll.

If we took that across to the UK,it would mean a point of view (albeit minority) subscribed to by more than 10 million people,hardly the odd one or two...For example, to give a sense of proportion to our right wing bretheren, UKIP currently poll at about 16%.

A US poll in November 2014 recorded that 72% of US Jews supported the establishment of a Palestinian state including E. Jerusalem as its capital.80% supported a complete ban on settlement building in the occupied territories.


Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2016 12.54pm)

I never said that "just the odd one or two" Jews opposed Israeli policy. It just suited your argument to suggest that.
In the end, Israel is all about Jewish belief and exists for that reason only. Does that mean all Jews think the same? Of course not. But is it not a sad irony that the oppression of Jews has lead directly to the oppression of Palestinians by the offspring of those same Jews?
No doubt you would rather deal in semantics that acknowledge that.


 

legaleagle Flag 11 Apr 16 1.15pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I never said that "just the odd one or two" Jews opposed Israeli policy. It just suited your argument to suggest that.
In the end, Israel is all about Jewish belief and exists for that reason only. Does that mean all Jews think the same? Of course not. But is it not a sad irony that the oppression of Jews has lead directly to the oppression of Palestinians by the offspring of those same Jews?
No doubt you would rather deal in semantics that acknowledge that.


Your own words:

"Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters..."

I suspect I would not be the only one to view your words as referring to Jews in general bar the odd dissenter.

Your inability to not regard Jews as a monolithic bloc cause you to post:

(Jews)"have systematically tried to wipe out a people to further their own ambitions".

It is indeed a horrible irony that the right wing in Israel has acted as it has,though to compare the situation to the holocaust would be obscene.The causes of,mutation of, and effects of zionism in Israel/Palestine are somewhat less simplistic than ascribing them simply to the holocaust,though it is far from irrelevant.

But that irony is not (and getting back to the origins of the thread) an excuse to trot out hoary old canards about Jews under the guise of "legitimate" criticism of Israel.

Anyone who has been on here a while will know I have been a strong critic of the actions of the Israeli government in Gaza and the occupied territories.


Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2016 1.26pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Apr 16 1.26pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

Your own words:

"Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters..."

That was a question and directed toward Jamie where I acknowledged that not all Jews feel the same way.

He obviously feels justified in making his statement. He is usually considered and informed and has a fairly balanced view.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Apr 16 1.31pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

Your own words:

"Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters..."

I suspect I would not be the only one to view your words as referring to Jews in general bar the odd dissenter.

Your inability to not regard Jews as a monolithic bloc cause you to post:

(Jews)"have systematically tried to wipe out a people to further their own ambitions".

It is indeed a horrible irony that the right wing in Israel has acted as it has,though to compare the situation to the holocaust would be obscene.The causes of,mutation of, and effects of zionism in Israel/Palestine are somewhat less simplistic than ascribing them simply to the holocaust,though it is far from irrelevant.

But that irony is not (and getting back to the origins of the thread) an excuse to trot out hoary old canards about Jews under the guise of "legitimate" criticism of Israel.

Anyone who has been on hear a while will know I have been a strong critic of the actions of the Israeli government in Gaza and the occupied territories.


Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2016 1.26pm)

Perhaps in detail and scale but it is about the principles as you well know.

It is good to hear you condemn the treatment of Palestinians for the first time though. Well done.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (11 Apr 2016 1.33pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 2.14pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

In the same way that Germans were not the same as Nazis?

For a starter, yes. Not every German was a member of the Nazi Party or supporter. Something like 75,000 Germans were executed for resistance activities against the state during the war.

Not everyone who is Jewish, is automatically aligned to Israeli, or the policy of its ruling government (in fact arguably not all Isaraeli's support Israeli policy towards Palestine either).

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

In ideological terms you are right of course but in practice we still bombed German cities because they were under the control of Nazis. Israel was created solely for Jews in line with Jewish tradition and is run by Jews.

True, but Israel doesn't speak for all Jews. Only those in Israel, and even then... The problem for me, that alienates groups like Hamas, is that they're indiscriminate in their targeting, rather than directive against the tools of occupation and oppression (the illegal settlements, Israeli state infrastructure, military, police, courts, politicians etc).

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Do you know any Jews who condemn Israeli policy? There are dissenters but the bulk of Jewish opinion which carries much weight in the US media supports Israel.
Personally I have no particular love or dislike for either party but the irony of the Jewish occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, that they claim in the name of the semi mythical, Biblical land of Israel, is unavoidable.

Well for a start Noam Chomsky is Jewish and is quite outspoken on Israeli Policy. But a quick scout around the web demonstrates that they exist (even among Israeli Jews).

I think its just a lazy tradition in reporting towards a selective bias to 'blur the distance', and ultimately it leads to a situation where in a lot of people just regard Palestinian with Terrorism and Jew with the nation of Israeli. Certainly on both sides that seem to have been exploited to justify soft targets and unacceptable focuses on civilian casualties.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 2 of 22 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The left and Jewish people