You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Philip Green
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Philip Green


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jul 16 2.58pm

Problem is they will pay no serious price.

Its like a company that lies in its advertising, sees an upturn of 200m in sales, but gets fined 5m for lying.

There in lies the problem of capitalism, we are prone towards excusing its abuses far to easily, especially when that abuse is by those who have status and power within systems of capital.

We've become increasingly Milton Freedman and Ayn Rynd, rather than Adam Smith, seeing capitalism as a tool for personal, rather than social benefit.

Capitalism, at its basis, remains a system of exchange that applies a reasonable methodology for the valuation of limited resources - and will remain relevant until humanity can escape from that limitation through technological means.

The problem is regulation, control and distribution of the benefits and gains from capitalism - which is really what Marx and Engels focused on - The failures of Capitalism, being of greater concern than its success

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 25 Jul 16 3.10pm

Shouldn't this thread's title be "Sir Philip Green"? Notable tax evader, fraudster, con man and wide boy rewarded for service to his country with a knighthood.

Come to think of it ...we don't get an awful lot right do we? Idiots and crooks seem to prevail.

Who's next? Lord David Cameron? Sir George Osborne?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

Stuk Flag Top half 25 Jul 16 3.16pm

Originally posted by Percy of Peckham

Shouldn't this thread's title be "Sir Philip Green"? Notable tax evader, fraudster, con man and wide boy rewarded for service to his country with a knighthood.

Come to think of it ...we don't get an awful lot right do we? Idiots and crooks seem to prevail.

Who's next? Lord David Cameron? Sir George Osborne?

Another Tony Blair decision. Like Fred Goodwin.

 


Optimistic as ever

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 25 Jul 16 3.26pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

As a confirmed definite leftie, capitalism isn't the problem, its people and the way that capitalism is implemented to serve the interests of those people with power and capital.

Capitalism is such a broad subject, as it really refers to the idea of profit and loss accounting, and the means of turning surplus resources into benefit.

You listen to some people and you'd think it is about creating poverty, eating babies and kicking cats. The issue really lies in the failure to regulate and control peoples capacity to use capitalism as an excuse to unethical and immoral ends (which arguably in some cases isn't capitalism anyhow).

Of course there is a problem when its not actually a surplus of resources that are being 'exchanged' with corporate interests (such as child labour or regimes which are bankrolled by western powers to allow exploitation of their resources). We just like to call it capitalism.

Adam Smith would never have stood for that kind of nonsense.

You won't read a better post than this one on this subject.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 25 Jul 16 6.07pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Control of pension schemes should be completely removed from the employer.

If your job has a pension scheme it should be in control of the employee and ringfenced so that funds can only be added to it.

BHS, Tata and all the others swanning off and expecting the government to cover the lack of pension funds is ridiculous.

You must wonder what the Scheme Trustees were doing at this time.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jul 16 6.14pm

Originally posted by pefwin

You must wonder what the Scheme Trustees were doing at this time.

My imagination turns towards such things as complicity and self interest that borders on criminality

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 25 Jul 16 7.54pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Green et al have been ripped apart in this report...

[Link]



“Sir Philip Green, Dominic Chappell and the respective directors, advisers and hangers-on who all got rich or richer are all culpable, with the only losers the ordinary employees and pensioners,”
the MPs verdict on BHS.

Compare the news coverage of this proven scandal with the news coverage of alleged but unevidenced practices by Corbyn's supporters.

Green should do time for this but he won't.

Do time for what, exactly? What he's done, whilst being ethically questionable, isn't illegal. As matters stand, living in a corporate moral vacuum isn't yet criminal.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 25 Jul 16 9.11pm

Originally posted by pefwin

You must wonder what the Scheme Trustees were doing at this time.

I work in pensions. Scheme Trustees can often be fairly clueless, and will go along with whatever the advisers (legal, actuarial or consultants) 'suggest' they do. The advisors are professionals. Most Trustees, especially MNT's, are not.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 25 Jul 16 9.32pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Do time for what, exactly? What he's done, whilst being ethically questionable, isn't illegal. As matters stand, living in a corporate moral vacuum isn't yet criminal.

That's exactly what I was alluding to...

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 25 Jul 16 9.45pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

I work in pensions. Scheme Trustees can often be fairly clueless, and will go along with whatever the advisers (legal, actuarial or consultants) 'suggest' they do. The advisors are professionals. Most Trustees, especially MNT's, are not.

They would be responsible under s61 of the Trustee Act 1925, let alone any recent legislation. They are normally treated as per se Professionals as they have recourse to the advice you mention and the ability to sue advisors.

I would assume that the £571mn is a deficit that the Scheme Actuary flagged, and that there was a deficit plan in place.

The problem with numbers, so large, as pension schemes; stumping up half a billion cash would put even the bigger advisor companies into "trouble".

*From the press, the pension industry have already fallen in line behind the Trustees.*

Edited by pefwin (25 Jul 2016 9.47pm)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

MKGlazier Flag Milton Keynes 25 Jul 16 9.49pm

When you have that much money, you feel you can do what you like! Green has always evaded tax in UK by using his wife's companies ! Chappel was a good patsy for him, ego with no business sense.......At the conclusion he will probably get away with it scotfree, with a s*** reputation but millions in the bank !!

 

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 26 Jul 16 8.25am

Originally posted by pefwin

They would be responsible under s61 of the Trustee Act 1925, let alone any recent legislation. They are normally treated as per se Professionals as they have recourse to the advice you mention and the ability to sue advisors.

I would assume that the £571mn is a deficit that the Scheme Actuary flagged, and that there was a deficit plan in place.

The problem with numbers, so large, as pension schemes; stumping up half a billion cash would put even the bigger advisor companies into "trouble".

*From the press, the pension industry have already fallen in line behind the Trustees.*

Edited by pefwin (25 Jul 2016 9.47pm)

The Trustees were apparently unhappy with the sale to Chappell anyway due to the position it put the Scheme in. Now it's up to Green how much value he puts on that Knighthood. If he doesn't pay up, the PPF ie the taxpayer (as the Levy I think covers around 20% of liabilities)

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 26 Jul 16 11.06am

I don't want to defend Philip Green, but the way the politico-media class has lined up to bash him makes me suspect that there is a bit of scapegoating going on here.

The politicians spewing out humbug on an industrial scale particulary sticks in the craw.

Your average ex-SpAd, safe-seat careerist MP has probably never been in BHS, and almost certainly hasn't given a second thought to its employees until the day before yesterday. But now it's all about the poor "loyal, hardworking" employees and evil Philip Green is to blame.

News flash: if you want to boast about an "open, global, trading economy" you can't also claim to want to protect employees. You can't have it both ways.

Pouring out a load of humbug to avoid a short-term media barrage is a bit rich, too little and too late.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jul 16 11.18am

Originally posted by Johnny Eagles

I don't want to defend Philip Green, but the way the politico-media class has lined up to bash him makes me suspect that there is a bit of scapegoating going on here.

The politicians spewing out humbug on an industrial scale particulary sticks in the craw.

Your average ex-SpAd, safe-seat careerist MP has probably never been in BHS, and almost certainly hasn't given a second thought to its employees until the day before yesterday. But now it's all about the poor "loyal, hardworking" employees and evil Philip Green is to blame.

Your post doesn't really make a lot of sense and it reads more like a rant without anything concrete to back it up.

I certainly have an opinion on Phillip Green's behaviour and I don't shop in BHS either and I have certainly never given their staff any more thought than I give employees of other companies in general.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Jul 16 11.19am

Originally posted by Johnny Eagles

I don't want to defend Philip Green, but the way the politico-media class has lined up to bash him makes me suspect that there is a bit of scapegoating going on here.

The politicians spewing out humbug on an industrial scale particulary sticks in the craw.

Your average ex-SpAd, safe-seat careerist MP has probably never been in BHS, and almost certainly hasn't given a second thought to its employees until the day before yesterday. But now it's all about the poor "loyal, hardworking" employees and evil Philip Green is to blame.

News flash: if you want to boast about an "open, global, trading economy" you can't also claim to want to protect employees. You can't have it both ways.

Pouring out a load of humbug to avoid a short-term media barrage is a bit rich, too little and too late.

very true.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jul 16 11.25am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Do time for what, exactly? What he's done, whilst being ethically questionable, isn't illegal. As matters stand, living in a corporate moral vacuum isn't yet criminal.

Quite, but it may give the lawmakers an indication of what parts of corporate law need to be tightened up.

I see that "The unacceptable face of capitalism" is being trotted out again and it's quite a few years since I heard that expression which I believe was coined by Prime Minister Edward Heath about another corporate rapist Tiny Rowland

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Jul 16 11.35am

Originally posted by Johnny Eagles

I don't want to defend Philip Green, but the way the politico-media class has lined up to bash him makes me suspect that there is a bit of scapegoating going on here.

The politicians spewing out humbug on an industrial scale particulary sticks in the craw.

Your average ex-SpAd, safe-seat careerist MP has probably never been in BHS, and almost certainly hasn't given a second thought to its employees until the day before yesterday. But now it's all about the poor "loyal, hardworking" employees and evil Philip Green is to blame.

News flash: if you want to boast about an "open, global, trading economy" you can't also claim to want to protect employees. You can't have it both ways.

Pouring out a load of humbug to avoid a short-term media barrage is a bit rich, too little and too late.

I agree PG has been sacrificed somewhat here and quite possibly to distract attention away from questionable company practice.

Where I think this case does tip over into unpalatable is that it's a) humble pensions that have been destroyed and b) the sum of money PG has made from taking advantage of them and co, and c) add that to the huge profits from TopShop paid to PG's wife registered in Monaco.

In one way or another PG and wife owe around £1 billion to individuals in Britain or HM Revenue and Customs. Being flash and brash has no doubt meant that some have pounced on this to demolish his reputation.

 


COYP

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 26 Jul 16 11.37am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Your post doesn't really make a lot of sense and it reads more like a rant without anything concrete to back it up.

I certainly have an opinion on Phillip Green's behaviour and I don't shop in BHS either and I have certainly never given their staff any more thought than I give employees of other companies in general.

In what way doesn't it make sense?

I don't want to defend Philip Green. I've only vaguely followed the travails of BHS but to blame its downfall entirely I find a bit simplistic.

A significant factor was that people stopped wanting to shop there.

Retail is a tough old business even if you're good at it, which BHS clearly wasn't. Management was poor. Green and Chappell stitched the company up. They put money in their own pockets instead of investing it. But even if they had invested millions, there's no guarantee these people would still have jobs.

Like Woolworth's or HMV, everyone was shocked at the loss of a "national institution", and there was a lot of humbug too, but nobody misses Woolworth's, do they? It had its time.

The pensions thing is very unedifying. But there's a difference between say, Robert Maxwell, which was outright fraud and theft, and stripping a company whose earnings pay for a pension fund which, while morally highly dubious, is nevertheless legal.

Philip Green is partly responsible. He's a ruthless money-grabber and I believe his behaviour has been morally highly questionable.

But to turn him into a bogeyman is a bit much. Especially when it's POLITICIANS who are doing it! You can't go round knighting people for being ruthless money-grabbers when it suits you and then bashing them for being exactly the same when it turns out ruthless money-grabbing has its darker side!

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 26 Jul 16 11.42am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Quite, but it may give the lawmakers an indication of what parts of corporate law need to be tightened up.

I see that "The unacceptable face of capitalism" is being trotted out again and it's quite a few years since I heard that expression which I believe was coined by Prime Minister Edward Heath about another corporate rapist Tiny Rowland

You can write as many laws as you like, but there is no legislating for morality.

Britain has chosen a path where free-wheeling, lightly-regulated money-making with little or no regard for the moral consequences has become a national cult.

Cf. The banking crisis, privatising the railways, closing down the coalmines.

Politicians - of all parties, the Tories especially, but certainly Blair, Brown and their acolytes - have turned this into a national creed.

So to turn round now and go, "ooh, these evil capitalists, exploiting poor loyal hardworking employees" is a bit rich!

To paraphrase Boris Johnson, you can't be pro-cake (selling everything that isn't nailed down to the Chinese) and pro-eating it (claiming to stand up for oppressed workers.)

p.s. Excellent 1970s political reference, by the way. Just looked up Tiny Rowland, hadn't heard of him before!

Edited by Johnny Eagles (26 Jul 2016 11.54am)

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Jul 16 11.44am

If you ever get to see the footage of PG, probably soon after acquiring BHS and holding up a blouse type garment and presenting positive PR to the tv interviewer, his body language shows his true feelings towards the merchandise, brand etc.

 


COYP

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Philip Green