This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
5 years for carrying a knife does nothing for the problem, only ruins the lives of those who get caught without doing anything to change their situation. Smacks of an American model where they use prison wily July and do nothing to stop the issues from arising. A lot of people involved in gangs are not bad kids, just unfortunate kids. Not saying I have a solution, just that I think 5 years for having something you shouldn't is absolutely barmy. Don't take a knife out then. Ask most parents who have lost a child to knife crime and they'll want the aggressor to be put away forever. Ask most parents of aggressors if they thought 5 years (2-3 years after good behaviour) 5 years was a price to pay (getting caught) before their child became a possible murderer, they'd take that all day. It's not just the child at either end of the knife that pays the price.
I refuse to believe there are that many people out there that can't spell. Too f**king lazy, that's what I think. |
|
|
Originally posted by Boooo
Don't take a knife out then. Ask most parents who have lost a child to knife crime and they'll want the aggressor to be put away forever. Ask most parents of aggressors if they thought 5 years (2-3 years after good behaviour) 5 years was a price to pay (getting caught) before their child became a possible murderer, they'd take that all day. It's not just the child at either end of the knife that pays the price. You're right, we need to get the message across that carrying a knife is totally unacceptable and if you carry one, you do so at tremendous risk. Communities need to work hard, get the message across, if ya carrying you're gonna get a big sentence if caught. Anyone who glamorises gang culture or drug dealing should be demonised.
|
|
|
Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo
I felt that I have to write this. last night a young lad of 19 yrs old was stabbed on the Monks Hill estate and later died in hospital of his wounds. I didn't know the young lad or whether he was into football or any kind of sport, that really doesn't matter, what matters is that at 19 years old he had the world to look forward. I really don't know what I'm trying to say here, I don't usually put pen to paper, so to speak, on these matters, a complete and utter waste of life,Just like so many others that have been stabbed. Horrific incident and tragic for the family concerned. You're so right to also pull apart the stupidity of these knife-carrying idiots who like to think that they are so hard but are nothing more than shallow-minded boneheads. There should ALWAYS be a zero tolerance attitude to knife crime by police and schools however resources on both fronts continue to be increasingly stretched thanks to continuing government cuts and workload pressures. There is also a danger that society becomes desensitised to knife crime fatalities due to its frequency. Sport can also do much more to promote positive role models to younger generations.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Boooo
Don't take a knife out then. Ask most parents who have lost a child to knife crime and they'll want the aggressor to be put away forever. Ask most parents of aggressors if they thought 5 years (2-3 years after good behaviour) 5 years was a price to pay (getting caught) before their child became a possible murderer, they'd take that all day. It's not just the child at either end of the knife that pays the price. I'm in agreement. Again I can see why some do it but its a vicious circle much like US gun culture and before you know it people are losing their lives over nothing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
5 years for carrying a knife does nothing for the problem, only ruins the lives of those who get caught without doing anything to change their situation. Smacks of an American model where they use prison wily July and do nothing to stop the issues from arising. A lot of people involved in gangs are not bad kids, just unfortunate kids. Not saying I have a solution, just that I think 5 years for having something you shouldn't is absolutely barmy. That's like saying there's no point in jailing drug/arms/people smugglers. They're all guilty of just having something they shouldn't too. If there was no punishment for being caught they'd simply do it again, like someone found carrying a knife would. If you'd just been inside for 5 years it might not make your keys, phone, wallet checklist for going out in future.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
That's like saying there's no point in jailing drug/arms/people smugglers. They're all guilty of just having something they shouldn't too. If there was no punishment for being caught they'd simply do it again, like someone found carrying a knife would. If you'd just been inside for 5 years it might not make your keys, phone, wallet checklist for going out in future. Exactly. I think five years is harsh but if the consequences of carrying are ramped up, fewer people will do it and it'll save lives. We need to get away from the idea that carrying a dangerous weapon is a benign act. It isn't.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CJr94
I personally believe that the law isn't strict enough on people who carry knives. Along with people that house dangerous dogs. The punishment should be deterrent enough, but it isn't. I would assume a lot of first time offenders (no crim-rec) would be released with more or less no further action. People aren't scared to carry a knife. OT: I know (loosely speaking) one of the people arrested for the murder. When that is how you live your life, that is what happens - as harsh as it sounds. Law abiding citizens usually aren't chased up the street and stabbed to death. Still not a nice thing, feel sorry for his family - God bless. Other than to go and purchase a replacement.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
More stop and search. Make it difficult for these young thugs to carry. If someone gets caught in violent crime they should allow police to stop n search them whenever they want for the next 3 years. Generally gang members don't carry the knives. They're either stashed in an area, or they have 'clean skin' members who transport them. Similar to how gangs use guns. You transport it and store it with people who aren't members, and use young gang affiliates and associates to move them around. You only carry the weapon when your about to use it. Gangs will typically meet up with weapon carriers in specific locations, and only take up the weapon when they're going to use it. One of the bog problems of knives is that its influence is in terms of 'escalation' a lot of people will end up carrying a blade 'in case'. Of course the consequence of that is that invariably that your in possession of knife, which if means even if you end up in a fight with someone who isn't carrying a knife, chances are you'll use it (what with people being angry or scared not being the most rational or reasonable of people). People tend to either get stabbed because they did something, or because someone else is carrying a knife 'just in case' and gets into a situation or fight.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by A89M
When I was 15-16, me and my mates were constantly stopped and searched outside shopping centres, I hated it (as I wasn't an offender) but I preferred it to happen because I knew it was keeping people safe - just like I don't mind seeing a metal detector when I walk into a bar/club as depressing as that is. Why have they stopped it? I'm pretty sure the percentage of knife crimes dropped as a direct result of these stop and searches taking place more frequently. Edited by A89M (22 Aug 2016 4.34pm) Its an illusion that its keeping people safe, because its based on the presumption that stop and search is an effective means of crime prevention. In truth, the people it picks out are usually on the prephery of the problem. Its like Stop and Search with drugs, typically you pick up a lot of people in possession but rarely anyone who's dealing - Because the people you really want to catch, figure out ways around stop and search. A good example of this, is the number of kids who are now picked up as 'runners'. Kids make good runners, because a) the sentence tends to be low b) they're far more loyal than adults c) their records are sealed d) they're cheap Similarly with knives. Younger gang members transport knives and guns, because they'll never get a serious sentence, and often too beholden to be disloyal.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by CJr94
I personally believe that the law isn't strict enough on people who carry knives. Along with people that house dangerous dogs. The punishment should be deterrent enough, but it isn't. I would assume a lot of first time offenders (no crim-rec) would be released with more or less no further action. People aren't scared to carry a knife. OT: I know (loosely speaking) one of the people arrested for the murder. When that is how you live your life, that is what happens - as harsh as it sounds. Law abiding citizens usually aren't chased up the street and stabbed to death. Still not a nice thing, feel sorry for his family - God bless. Problem is, in some parts of the country, not having a knife can cost you your life and 'not being in' means no one is protecting you. Friend of mine, comes from Easterhouse in Glasgow, where not being 'with someone' meant you were fair game for everyone. That said, he did manage to pretty much stay out of it. Although his parents bought him a machete for his 13th birthday, just in case.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by blackpalacefan
Exactly. I think five years is harsh but if the consequences of carrying are ramped up, fewer people will do it and it'll save lives. We need to get away from the idea that carrying a dangerous weapon is a benign act. It isn't. They won't, if they're thinking that not having a knife when you need one can be death. The problem is we go after the knives, the guns and gang members, without ever addressing the problems that cause gangs to flourish.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
One thing we, those who are outside enough to say 'they made choices' is that we don't understand that often the choice is to be in a gang, or to be unprotected entirely from everyone. Most gangs originate as a means of protection from the predatory nature of existing gangs. People tend to get involved because it offers protection, and power, that simply being 'alone' on the estate doesn't. Status etc plays a role. But gangs typically form to protect neighbourhoods from other gangs, which is of course a vicious cycle (its why protection is called protection).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
One thing we, those who are outside enough to say 'they made choices' is that we don't understand that often the choice is to be in a gang, or to be unprotected entirely from everyone. Most gangs originate as a means of protection from the predatory nature of existing gangs. People tend to get involved because it offers protection, and power, that simply being 'alone' on the estate doesn't. Status etc plays a role. But gangs typically form to protect neighbourhoods from other gangs, which is of course a vicious cycle (its why protection is called protection).
Parents need to get there kids out more and show them there is more to life.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
They won't, if they're thinking that not having a knife when you need one can be death. The problem is we go after the knives, the guns and gang members, without ever addressing the problems that cause gangs to flourish. That young people in urban areas are f***ing t***s? with one or two t***s for parents?
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
One thing we, those who are outside enough to say 'they made choices' is that we don't understand that often the choice is to be in a gang, or to be unprotected entirely from everyone. Most gangs originate as a means of protection from the predatory nature of existing gangs. People tend to get involved because it offers protection, and power, that simply being 'alone' on the estate doesn't. Status etc plays a role. But gangs typically form to protect neighbourhoods from other gangs, which is of course a vicious cycle (its why protection is called protection). My cousin (mentioned earlier in this thread) dabbled in this world because of greed. He made a choice, he didn't wanna work in Sports Direct for minimum wage. His dad was off pretty much from the start, his mum worked in central London (on the underground), they never pushed him in terms of school/education. So he gets to 17, and his options ar minimum wage or crime.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Sportyteacher
Horrific incident and tragic for the family concerned. You're so right to also pull apart the stupidity of these knife-carrying idiots who like to think that they are so hard but are nothing more than shallow-minded boneheads. There should ALWAYS be a zero tolerance attitude to knife crime by police and schools however resources on both fronts continue to be increasingly stretched thanks to continuing government cuts and workload pressures. There is also a danger that society becomes desensitised to knife crime fatalities due to its frequency. Sport can also do much more to promote positive role models to younger generations. Yep shame the millions invested in sport went to elite not grassroots movements, meanwhile the government still allow the sale of (once public owned) school fields to make academy chains a bit of profit. More needs to be done in schools to educate kids about the dangers of knife carrying - alas a narrowing maths and english lead curriculum doesn't allow time for this.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by CJr94
I would say for some, that definitely is the motivation. However, me and a number of my friends grew up in areas that probably frequent crimewatch often. We didn't come from well off homes. We had good parents pushing us in the right direction. I think a lot of the blame has to be held at the parents doors. It is obviously easy for me to say that, but I do believe that is the case. A number of people from where I grew up were "affiliated" so to speak, but never involved. Went to school / college / uni and had friends who did what they did, but they never followed suit and never did it themselves. When you grow up in horrible shytehole places, young kids often look up to the young lads, they've got cars, money, respect.. etc etc. Think it's a good way of life. Get so involved, that they can't un-involve (if that's a real world rofl) themselves as they've got criminal records, etc etc.. no employer will touch them. They sort of condemn themselves to a life of "illegitimate" living, it's a one-way road. Parents need to get there kids out more and show them there is more to life. Probably the single biggest factor I'd imagine. Whilst by no means a consistent decider, having options, good influences and 'good parents' is a major factor. Unfortunately, that's not something that's controllable. Whilst families must take some of the blame, there isn't too much our society can do to ensure good parenting. Problematically, any one can become a parent, even if they don't want to. Poor choices are common place, and it doesn't help that we have large influential elements in society that foster the idea of propogation as achievement in life.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.