You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > £43 million to try and replace Glenn Murray
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

£43 million to try and replace Glenn Murray


Page 2 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 07 Sep 16 3.44pm

Originally posted by LegalEagle2010

I know right!

And let's get that Simpson back in, his record for us is second to none.

If we hadnt let Jacko go we wouldnt have needed Mandanda

Edited by Sedlescombe (07 Sep 2016 3.44pm)

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 07 Sep 16 3.59pm

I really love Murray (I have his shirt), but he wasn't getting it done anymore. Bournemouth paid a nice chunk of coin to find out that they agreed with Pardew.

Wickham was our joint top Prem scorer in only 21 games. 1 goal per 3 starts. I still think he's quality, but maybe not elite. He's great to have on the bench, or as an option. Heck he might even start banging them in with the pressure off. He replaced Murray and is 10 years younger.

Trouble is, if we don't want to hang around the bottom of the table, we needed to upgrade and get some elite strikers who can bang in 10+, which I think we did.

Murray was great, but time moves on.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 07 Sep 16 3.59pm

Originally posted by JohnB

Also, Murray only scored 2 more goals in his first season for us than Wickham but played 3 times the amount of games. To write Wickham off already is just stupid.

Exactly.

Glenn's first season (in the championship): 7 goals, 43 appearances

Connor's first season (in the premier league): 6 goals, 24 appearances

GM will always deserve gratitude for what he achieved in the championship with the club. And even in the back end of 14/15 season in the premier league. But Connor Wickham has his whole career ahead of him to top Glenn's achievements.

Glenn's best days are sadly behind him.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 07 Sep 16 4.01pm

Think we've already surpassed last seasons entire 'daft post' quota

 


Red & Blue since 73'

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Sep 16 4.09pm

Originally posted by paperhat

the way you're ranting is as if it's your bank account that's been plundered!

How many matches, since he left, has Glen Murray played a full 90 mins in? How many goals did he score for Bournemouth last season?

Whilst many off us were sad to see him go (and at the time, we should have kept hold until we had a replacement), you cannot seriously think that getting the likes of Benteke and Remy in, leaves us in a worse position?

Wickham is a different type of striker and whilst its not worked for him, he's had little or no service to speak of. Hold on to your lacy bits and watch the next few months, i'm pretty sure you'll bite your tongue.

Edited by paperhat (07 Sep 2016 2.54pm)

In fairness to Glenn, he did score 3 in 10 for Bournemouth. I think its safe to say it was a mistake to let him go last season, with hindsight. Issue was always going to be that Murray was very clear about not wanting to be a squad player.

To say it hasn't worked for Wickham is a bit unfair, he's been plagued with knocks, but when out of his wheelchair and match sharp, he gets goals and makes goals for us.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Sep 16 4.11pm

Originally posted by miles18

Wickham scored in the semi final and gave us another FA Cup final. (My first) He's worth the money we paid just for that imo. Also he's gonna be a good player to have on the bench, don't forget he's only 23! A good 10 years at least left in him so he will get better.

Benteke a Liverpool flop? He didnt suit Liverpool style and will have his Villa form with us. Class signing and may well end up being the best striker we've ever had at Palace.

Edited by miles18 (07 Sep 2016 3.20pm)

A flop who only managed to score 1 in 3 playing for a side that barely played him.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

citizensmudge Flag midlands 07 Sep 16 4.11pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Obviously I expected to be slaughtered. That is the nature of this site.

I am not slagging Benteke, I hope he will be great for us.

I was trying to illuminate the true cost of replacing Murray and the failure of Pardew to achieve that for a reasonable sum.

Now he has thrown absolutely mental money at it, he may have finally solved the problem that Freedman did with a free transfer.

What you are doing is sticking more pins in your extremely worn out AP Voodoo doll and trying to convince us your right. You do however generate some priceless responses so please continue with the good work.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Sep 16 4.12pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

It's very important to realise if £9m Connor Wickham had been the player Pardew thought he was (and most people with a clue knew he never would be) we would never have signed Benteke.

We have splashed £32m on the Liverpool flop because Wickham has been absolutely terrible - one of the worst buys in the history of the football club.

In fact, so bad that last season we signed £100,000 a-week Adebayor as our new centre-forward for about four months.

That came on the back of the dreadful Sanogo the season before, who kept Murray out of the team until thankfully he got injured.

By the way Glenn then came in and scored a goal every other game, plus put in one of the best Number 9 displays ever seen at Selhurst Park vs Manchester City.

So, I make that around £43m to replace a Dougie Freedman free transfer.

Keep up the good work Alan!

Its been downhill for us since we let Peter Simpson go.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 07 Sep 16 4.17pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Obviously I expected to be slaughtered. That is the nature of this site.

I am not slagging Benteke, I hope he will be great for us.

I was trying to illuminate the true cost of replacing Murray and the failure of Pardew to achieve that for a reasonable sum.

Now he has thrown absolutely mental money at it, he may have finally solved the problem that Freedman did with a free transfer.

Why is it mental money?

£50M for stones is mental money.

Don't think £9M for Wickham is mental

£3M for Remy isn't mental

And £27M for someone of Bentekes class isn't mental in today's world.

So I'm still trying to figure out what your point is?

You believe he should have signed Benteke for free ?

Or found another solution to bring in a free transfer?

Your getting slaughtered becuase your not making any sense.

This is on the day we sign a DM on a free.

Plus Mandanda was virtually free.

Our net spend this window for overhauling the squad is tiny and yet you moan we've spent bonkers amounts of money.

Couldn't make it up.

Anti Pardew posts for not spending enough and now anti Pardew posts for spending to much !!!!!


 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 07 Sep 16 4.22pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Obviously I expected to be slaughtered. That is the nature of this site.

I am not slagging Benteke, I hope he will be great for us.

I was trying to illuminate the true cost of replacing Murray and the failure of Pardew to achieve that for a reasonable sum.

Now he has thrown absolutely mental money at it, he may have finally solved the problem that Freedman did with a free transfer.

The cost of replacing a Championship player bought in the Championship with a Premier League proven player playing in the Premier League?

Think of how silly you sound.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 07 Sep 16 4.23pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

If we hadnt let Jacko go we wouldnt have needed Mandanda

Edited by Sedlescombe (07 Sep 2016 3.44pm)

Yeah - Bert Head OUT!!

 

Pierre Flag Purley 07 Sep 16 4.33pm

This has to win the worst thread of the week award hands down.

There have been a few contenders knocking around, must be the International break!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Sep 16 4.36pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Obviously I expected to be slaughtered. That is the nature of this site.

I am not slagging Benteke, I hope he will be great for us.

I was trying to illuminate the true cost of replacing Murray and the failure of Pardew to achieve that for a reasonable sum.

Now he has thrown absolutely mental money at it, he may have finally solved the problem that Freedman did with a free transfer.

What on earth are you on about?

DF scouted Murray in League 1 for the Champ and got him to agree shortly before his contract ended. That doesn't happen very often and happens hardly ever in the Prem.

The nearest you get is bringing Defoe back but he is proven anyway.

Or you sign bargain after bargain and never find the answer, and haven't we just done that? And we are not the only ones to do that either.

It can be the difference between Prem survival or Championship oblivion.

And end result is you're left with 3 or 4 mediocre to not good enough at Prem level strikers on more wages than 1 that IS PROVEN. Now we have 1 on a huge wage and one on a medium one and one on loan. There is no problem upfront fella.

 


COYP

chris123 Flag hove actually 07 Sep 16 4.43pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Obviously I expected to be slaughtered. That is the nature of this site.

I am not slagging Benteke, I hope he will be great for us.

I was trying to illuminate the true cost of replacing Murray and the failure of Pardew to achieve that for a reasonable sum.

Now he has thrown absolutely mental money at it, he may have finally solved the problem that Freedman did with a free transfer.

The way things operate these days, your issue rests with the Board.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 07 Sep 16 4.45pm

what a f***ing retarded OP. Benteke a flop hahahahaha

 

johnfirewall Flag 07 Sep 16 4.46pm

Best case we've wasted £5m upgrading to Wickham as a backup. Worst case we still don't get goals and would have been no worse off with Murray therefore £40m odd down.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 07 Sep 16 4.47pm

also, people need to quickly get used to spending £5-10m on backups

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 Sep 16 4.49pm

I have carefully considered the contents of the OP and have come to the conclusion that it's absolute bollocks.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Username Flag Horsham 07 Sep 16 4.50pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

What on earth are you on about?

DF scouted Murray in League 1 for the Champ and got him to agree shortly before his contract ended. That doesn't happen very often and happens hardly ever in the Prem.

The nearest you get is bringing Defoe back but he is proven anyway.

Or you sign bargain after bargain and never find the answer, and haven't we just done that? And we are not the only ones to do that either.

It can be the difference between Prem survival or Championship oblivion.

And end result is you're left with 3 or 4 mediocre to not good enough at Prem level strikers on more wages than 1 that IS PROVEN. Now we have 1 on a huge wage and one on a medium one and one on loan. There is no problem upfront fella.

Defoe was hardly free anyway considering they had to give him a 5 year deal on huge wages.

We paid under £10m for a 22 year old kid who has shown massive potential. When fit last season and after a run in the side he showed he is as good if not better than Murray and at ten years his younger is a good bet to improve.

Mental money for Benteke?

We paid £30m for a player who has scored 51 in 118 Premier League games and in his 'terrible' season when he was a flop at Liverpool, still banged in more league goals than anyone in our squad.

Seems a pretty fair deal to me.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

tonymikejoe Flag UK 07 Sep 16 4.53pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

I have carefully considered the contents of the OP and have come to the conclusion that it's absolute bollocks.


What? Are you seriously suggesting the four big target men (Sanogo, Wickham, Adebayor and Benteke) were not attempted replacements for Murray.

While I'm on here a quick message to everyone: Nowhere in the original post did I express a desire for Glenn Murray to still be our centre-forward.


 

Page 2 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > £43 million to try and replace Glenn Murray