This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by tonymikejoe
I think the club are insulting our intelligence with signings like this. Parish said on talksport yesterday Flamini was a replacement for Jedinak. Hold on a minute, if that's the sort of player the squad need then why jettison the mighty Jedi? Flamini does not have the same connection with the club, the desire or can make as great an all-round contribution on and off the pitch. He will not win as many headers, tackles or interceptions. He will not be as powerful on set pieces. Will he convert penalties and free kicks from outside the box? Pardew probably thinks Flamini is better, which is the real danger the club are currently in because he simple does not know a player or cannot handle big personalties that have done so much to put the club where it is. I think people are missing the point with comments like this. Players leave, that's football. OK, Jedi left under Somewhat of a grey cloud, but AP is trying to change the way we play(a whole nother argument), and Jedi obviously wasn't in the forefront of those plans. We tried to replace him in the Window, and failed. Because of this, the club then realised that they were one midfielder short of a full squad once the window closed. so with only free transfers left to go after, went after the best that was available. and got him. You should not slate cpfc for this. they tried their best, some transfers didn't happen. That's the transfer window for you. If we'd have gotten Wilshere, we wouldn't have went for Flamini. I cannot remember a better transfer window ever. We've brought in players for (nearly) all of our problem positions, pulling off some transfer coups in the process. That we could not only interest someone of his stature, but compete with - and beat - the likes of Roma, AC Milan et al for his signature speaks volumes of what this club has achieved. Edited by CrazyBadger (08 Sep 2016 1.35pm)
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Very exciting. Can't believe there are still moaners and whingers and negative posters. Get a life!
|
|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
100% agree with this, the club were right to sell jedi.
|
|
|
Deffo a good signing. Like everyone else I'd have rather lost Mutch and / or Ledley instead of Jedi but that doesn't make this a bad move.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mad4palace
Agree. Whilst Flamini is a useful addition, he can't replace a unique player like Jedinak. Would have preferred to see Ledley or Mutch go, Ledley probably does a role similar to Flamini but Flamini is better in his passing and tackling. We no longer have the tactical option of Jedinak which would have benefitted us in more physical games; marking Fellaini at Man utd, Deeney for Watford, Carroll for West Ham, West Brom. Still, we have what we have now, we ought to be better in the passing department. Is this the same Jedinak who gave away a penalty against Deeney last season and lost Fellaini for Mata's equaliser in the cup final? Just saying.
|
|
| ParchmoreEagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
this
|
|
|
Originally posted by tonymikejoe
I think the club are insulting our intelligence with signings like this. Yesterday you moan we've spent to much on strikers today you moan about a free signing. Couldn't make it up. Why do you hate the owners of the club? You'd rather live in this parel world where palace doesn't move forward and players like Murrary and Jedi are in the first XI. Well guess what Parish has moved us forward. Get used to it, or get lost. Your negativity is BORING Ridiculous, opinons....
|
|
|
Awesome player The dog's mate
|
|
|
This guy was good enough to play 246 times for Arsenal and 123 for Milan. Does anyone seriously think Jedi was that level?
|
|
|
Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle
I am elated at SP, AP and everyone else involved in the transfer biz at DOING SOMETHING that needed doing this last window. I don't know how long it will take for this squad to start playing like we need them to, but IMO THIS is the squad. We were living on luck the and pure heroism of the great players we had to stay in this league the last 3 seasons. We were predictable, gloriously brave, hoof-ballers, with incredible character and heart, but THIS NEEDED TO BE DONE. God bless you Jedi, Yala and all the others. Now let's hope this team can do them justice and take us to the next level we so desperately needed. TY Parish & Co. This. Good post. So grateful to the players who have represented Palace in the last 5 years or so, for the most part they've done us proud and it's been a great journey. Now we're moving on to the next loop in the rollercoaster, hope we come out of it on the up...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Flow
Is this the same Jedinak who gave away a penalty against Deeney last season and lost Fellaini for Mata's equaliser in the cup final? Just saying. Fair point to an extend but no player is perfect. Dann and Delaney have been caught with their pants down by Benteke in previous years. Ward's had plenty of s***ty games. Find me a defensive player that doesn't make mistakes. There were a series of about 5 players at fault for Mata's goal, plus you ignore that Deeney was non existent in the Semi-final because of Jedinak's work, Mile was probably MOTM. He worked tactically in some games and was getting his mojo back. Flamini for the departure of Ledley would have been a great bit of business.
|
|
|
Originally posted by tonymikejoe
I think the club are insulting our intelligence with signings like this. Parish said on talksport yesterday Flamini was a replacement for Jedinak. Hold on a minute, if that's the sort of player the squad need then why jettison the mighty Jedi? Flamini does not have the same connection with the club, the desire or can make as great an all-round contribution on and off the pitch. He will not win as many headers, tackles or interceptions. He will not be as powerful on set pieces. Will he convert penalties and free kicks from outside the box? Pardew probably thinks Flamini is better, which is the real danger the club are currently in because he simple does not know a player or cannot handle big personalties that have done so much to put the club where it is. Flamini has played at the highest level, Jedinak hasn't, why do you think that's is? Superior player, great addition to the squad. Too many people on here live in the past, time moves on.
|
|
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mad4palace
Fair point to an extend but no player is perfect. Dann and Delaney have been caught with their pants down by Benteke in previous years. Ward's had plenty of s***ty games. Find me a defensive player that doesn't make mistakes. There were a series of about 5 players at fault for Mata's goal, plus you ignore that Deeney was non existent in the Semi-final because of Jedinak's work, Mile was probably MOTM. He worked tactically in some games and was getting his mojo back. Flamini for the departure of Ledley would have been a great bit of business. With AP wanting to "pass the ball and control games" Jedi was always going to be behind Ledley in the pecking order.Ledley lacks pace but you just have to look at the pivotal role he plays for Wales to see how much better he is at playing possession football than Jedi. Jedi was a warrior and will be sorely missed but you know what, he will get games at Villa a lot of which will be on the box.
|
|
|
Has he signed yet?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.