You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Blessing in disguise?
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Blessing in disguise?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 09 Sep 16 6.29pm

Originally posted by Casual


'Most of our team are capable of scoring'
Are they? Who?
Ward doesn't
Delaney doesn't
Soare doesn't
Kelly doesn't
Delaney doesn't
MacArthur doesn't
Ledley doesn't
Cabaye doesn't
Zaha doesn't
Puncheon doesn't

Benteke, Townsend hopefully will.
Danns great at scoring for a defender.
Not exactly free scoring though are we.

Remy being injured isn't a good thing. Gutted for him and us.

ANSWER:

Ward
Delaney
Souare
Kelly
Delaney
MacArthur
Ledley
Cabaye
Zaha
Puncheon
Townsend
Flamini
Lee
Dann
Tomkins

...are all capable of scoring. This isn't even debatable. Dann was our top scorer last season. Puncheon can go through a purple patch where he's scoring. It is not even debatable.

 


[Link]

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 09 Sep 16 6.50pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well I think Remy was brought in specifically to play a front 2...but at the moment we are all guessing.

Yes, the first 45 against Bournemouth was a mess, but to be fair AP switched it around and he's never going to know if things work or not unless they are tried. Personally, I don't think a Benteke / Wickham partnership is a goer.

I can't agree with your opinion on Wickham - there is nothing to suggest that he can and will outperform Benteke. Indeed if Remy was available, I don't think Wickham would be in the starting line up.

Playing 1 up front hasn't been successful now for close on a year.

And despite what we saw against Bournemouth, I do believe professional teams learn new tactics in training. We didn't always play with just 1 up front, how do you think the players got used to that ??

Most of our team are capable of scoring ? Really ?? The stats suggest otherwise.

Remy will only get sharp by playing regularly.

And if we don't provide a better service from other areas - including the full backs - into Benteke, then we will have wasted our money on him.

LOL! Our 'stats' say we are capable of winning around TWO games a year! I hope 2016 isn't our expected bench-mark! I am refering to how we usually performed BEFORE our terrible 2nd half to last season. It is unfair to take my comments and hold them up for scrutiny based on our ability from last December! When I say 'score', I don't mean capable of 'tapping it in', I mean skilful strikes that result in goals. Lee did, Puncheon did, Cabaye did, Zaha did, Ward has scored from outside the box, Dann could almost be a striker! Souare hasn't yet but is able, MacArthur scores, I mean what did I say that was so odd??? The point I'm making is that with one really good focal striker in Benteke, based on our form PRIOR to last December, defenders concentrating on stopping Benteke can lead to opportunities for chances for other players - that's my point. As for my views on CW, your comment is valid and I have nothing to back up my gut feelings about him - they're just my instincts - as I believe his stats have suffered because of other factors. Also, I hope we actually can be successful at 442, but these are just my opinions - I may be wrong.

 


[Link]

Casual Flag Orpington 09 Sep 16 7.45pm

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

ANSWER:

Ward
Delaney
Souare
Kelly
Delaney
MacArthur
Ledley
Cabaye
Zaha
Puncheon
Townsend
Flamini
Lee
Dann
Tomkins

...are all capable of scoring. This isn't even debatable. Dann was our top scorer last season. Puncheon can go through a purple patch where he's scoring. It is not even debatable.


I said Dann was a good goal scoring defender.
How many goals have the players from the rest of my list scored in the last 12 months from open play?

 

AdelaideEagle Flag Adelaide 09 Sep 16 8.49pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well I think Remy was brought in specifically to play a front 2...but at the moment we are all guessing.

Yes, the first 45 against Bournemouth was a mess, but to be fair AP switched it around and he's never going to know if things work or not unless they are tried. Personally, I don't think a Benteke / Wickham partnership is a goer.

I can't agree with your opinion on Wickham - there is nothing to suggest that he can and will outperform Benteke. Indeed if Remy was available, I don't think Wickham would be in the starting line up.

Playing 1 up front hasn't been successful now for close on a year.

And despite what we saw against Bournemouth, I do believe professional teams learn new tactics in training. We didn't always play with just 1 up front, how do you think the players got used to that ??

Most of our team are capable of scoring ? Really ?? The stats suggest otherwise.

Remy will only get sharp by playing regularly.

And if we don't provide a better service from other areas - including the full backs - into Benteke, then we will have wasted our money on him.

It's a pity we didn't hold onto Dwight Gayle if we were looking to transition to a 4-4-2 formation this season. A front two of Benteke and DG would have been mouth-watering.

However, we've improved with Remy instead of Dwight. Oh but he's injured within 4 hours of signing. That's Palace for you!


Edited by AdelaideEagle (09 Sep 2016 8.50pm)

 


True Blue Red 'n' Blue !!!

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 10 Sep 16 12.55am

Originally posted by glaziermart

There are quite a lot of us who do not think 4-4-2 formation works with us. If Remy had been fit this Saturday, Pardew probably would have played him up front with Benteke. Then Wilf probably would have been dropped to the bench and Punch played out wide which is not his best position anymore, he is better in the Number 10 role, even though he is not playing as well as he did two years ago. The injury to Remy means we will likely see Flamini playing with Jimmy Mac or Cabaye in the middle, or we have the option of moving Cabaye into the number 10 role and playing Jimmy Mac and Flamini behind. Joe Ledley of course could sit behind as well. All this would mean Wilf and Townsend can push up wide and frighten defences. To be honest i was more pleased we got Flamini. That was desperately needed

I'd actually agree to a certain point. I don't think we're ready to switch to an out and out front 2 and it did sound from AP comments as though prior to his injury he was looking to play both Remy and Ben. So for this game I'm a little pleased we won't be. Personally want to see Punch and Lee in the middle both causing havoc behind Ben. As someone else mentioned I think Lee is going to have a great year for us and after his good form it would have been disappointing to see Remy possibly push him out the team. Although obviously I don't actually want one of our squad to be injured for 2 months. But I get the OP main point and kinda agree.

Maybe we can play 2 up top but I don't think we're ready for that yet..

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 10 Sep 16 1.59am

Originally posted by AdelaideEagle

It's a pity we didn't hold onto Dwight Gayle if we were looking to transition to a 4-4-2 formation this season. A front two of Benteke and DG would have been mouth-watering.

However, we've improved with Remy instead of Dwight. Oh but he's injured within 4 hours of signing. That's Palace for you!


Edited by AdelaideEagle (09 Sep 2016 8.50pm)

I was never totally ' sold ' on Gayle, but I also think he was never utilised properly.

He certainly has a goalscorers instincts and I agree, a partnership in a front 2 may have seen him thrive.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Sep 16 10.59am

Originally posted by palace99

Cabeye at No 10 - did you watch a game in 2016?

The guy can't play this role anymore - he wants to drop deep, often leaving Jimmy Mac to try and support the strikers, which is not his best position.

we tried it again in the cup final and he was the worst player on the pitch.

Cabeye on paper was a great signing but other than a few nice touches he's not doing enough for me.

Not saying I wouldn't play him, just not as a No10

By this are you saying that in your opinion he physically can't play this role anymore because if so have his legs gone or a long term injury. Wasn't there reports last season of him having a possible pelvic problem?

At Newcastle he would be a box to box player scoring many goals from outside the box and I assume this is why he was bought but he is a shadow of this.

All in all rather an odd situation.

 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Sep 16 11.08am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

By this are you saying that in your opinion he physically can't play this role anymore because if so have his legs gone or a long term injury. Wasn't there reports last season of him having a possible pelvic problem?

At Newcastle he would be a box to box player scoring many goals from outside the box and I assume this is why he was bought but he is a shadow of this.

All in all rather an odd situation.

There was a great frisson of excitement when we signed Cabaye who was our "Stellar" player etc etc.He has certainly not lived up to expectations and is not the player he was at Newcastle.Would there have been a huge outcry if he had been sold in the 'Transfer Window' ????

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 11 Sep 16 12.47am

Originally posted by Casual


'Most of our team are capable of scoring'
Are they? Who?
Ward doesn't
Delaney doesn't
Soare doesn't
Kelly doesn't
Delaney doesn't
MacArthur doesn't
Ledley doesn't
Cabaye doesn't
Zaha doesn't
Puncheon doesn't

Benteke, Townsend hopefully will.
Danns great at scoring for a defender.
Not exactly free scoring though are we.

Remy being injured isn't a good thing. Gutted for him and us.

I hope you watched the Middlesbrough match because it totally was about what I posted. Benteke scored, and Zaha scored a top class goal and Townsend almost scored a superb strike but for a great save. You want to rewind and change that to 442 with Remy next to Benteke??? They played much better than last week's first 45 minutes - in control - totally deserved win. JUST AS I POSTED.

 


[Link]

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Sep 16 7.16am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

I hope you watched the Middlesbrough match because it totally was about what I posted. Benteke scored, and Zaha scored a top class goal and Townsend almost scored a superb strike but for a great save. You want to rewind and change that to 442 with Remy next to Benteke??? They played much better than last week's first 45 minutes - in control - totally deserved win. JUST AS I POSTED.

I did watch the game and a I can now see your level of football knowledge , outstanding.
Can you work out the scorers and times of goals for the Stoke game?
We could clean up at the bookies, we'd be like a Steve Irwin , Peter Barlow combo. Very excited about this, we will be billionaires

 

Aray Flag South London 11 Sep 16 11.31am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

I hope you watched the Middlesbrough match because it totally was about what I posted. Benteke scored, and Zaha scored a top class goal and Townsend almost scored a superb strike but for a great save. You want to rewind and change that to 442 with Remy next to Benteke??? They played much better than last week's first 45 minutes - in control - totally deserved win. JUST AS I POSTED.

Only problem is you can't prove/show how we'd have played if Remy had been available.

 

Flash Flag Lampeter 11 Sep 16 1.57pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

Christ we haven't even seen Remy play for us yet and you've written him off already

Losing a striker is a disaster when scoring goals is our problem.

Well said, Dave. Got on to this thread late. I haven't even read it through to the end yet. But I'm shocked someone can say that a player getting an 8 week injury is a "blessing". And a player whose signing received widespread acclaim I thought.

 

Flash Flag Lampeter 11 Sep 16 2.01pm

Originally posted by Aray

Only problem is you can't prove/show how we'd have played if Remy had been available.

Or if we would have played 442. We want to increase our options - not limit them!!!

 

Flash Flag Lampeter 11 Sep 16 2.14pm

Originally posted by Casual


I said Dann was a good goal scoring defender.
How many goals have the players from the rest of my list scored in the last 12 months from open play?

IMO the last 12 months is irrelevant. We've a new squad with new capabilities. We can't judge goal scoring expectations on historical performance stats. We've moved on. Sadly one of our new signings to strengthen our squad will be sidelined for 8 weeks. This is not a blessing in any sense. It's bad news for the club and terribly sad for a player who was relishing an opportunity to refresh his career.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Sep 16 2.26pm

Originally posted by Flash

IMO the last 12 months is irrelevant. We've a new squad with new capabilities. We can't judge goal scoring expectations on historical performance stats. We've moved on. Sadly one of our new signings to strengthen our squad will be sidelined for 8 weeks. This is not a blessing in any sense. It's bad news for the club and terribly sad for a player who was relishing an opportunity to refresh his career.

Agree that they can all have a clean slate, but all players are judged on past performance, otherwise Campbell would be worth the same as Messi. On what basis do you think we signed our new players?

 

Flash Flag Lampeter 11 Sep 16 2.36pm

Originally posted by Willo

There was a great frisson of excitement when we signed Cabaye who was our "Stellar" player etc etc.He has certainly not lived up to expectations and is not the player he was at Newcastle.Would there have been a huge outcry if he had been sold in the 'Transfer Window' ????

It's a very good question, Willo. I'm hoping he might be the CAM we're seeking. With Flamini we've strengthened the DM department and I hope this might release Cabaye to do great creative things in the top third. Whilst I'm hoping for this, I must admit that I'm not too confident it will work. The trouble is that Cabaye does not have much of a resale value so I think we've got to give it a try and hope for the best. I still think we will be looking for a CAM in the January transfer window - maybe to supplement him rather than replace him.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 11 Sep 16 2.51pm

Remember the one game in the Euros where France started Cabaye?

He was the best player on the pitch - even Theirry Henry had to admit it.

He was playing slightly deep in midfield, in a combined destroyer / distributor role, not high up the pitch.

Round pegs, round holes.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Flash Flag Lampeter 11 Sep 16 4.08pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Remember the one game in the Euros where France started Cabaye?

He was the best player on the pitch - even Theirry Henry had to admit it.

He was playing slightly deep in midfield, in a combined destroyer / distributor role, not high up the pitch.

Round pegs, round holes.

Fair point. Let's see.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Blessing in disguise?