You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Last Night - Question To All
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Last Night - Question To All


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Sep 16 11.52am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Similar views to mine dazza.

Surely it's better to try and develop KaiKai and Boateng and give us fans something to look forward rather than subjecting us to watching players struggle to make the grade?

Money is not an issue surely?

Pardew clearly feels that these players 'Development' is better served by them getting regular first team football elsewhere.

But I agree that some of our 'Fringe' players are not of the required standard and as such our strength in depth is alarming. I think there is a consensus on here about the players in question !

Edited by Willo (22 Sep 2016 11.55am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 11.54am

Originally posted by Griffish

In response to the OPs message I think the board do realise that some of these players aren't good enough but they possibly can't find clubs who are willing to buy these players, which stops us from buying better players because of our wage bill.

Once Fryers and Campbell run their contracts down at the end of this season well have a extra £2.3m to spend (I believe they're on £10k and £35k respectively a week). Sako, at the time, was a very good free transfer but he has been shocking since returning from his injury last season but who is going to buy an out of form 55k a week player? That's nearly £6m in wages over two season, imagine the financial benefits if we could get him off the books. Maybe Sako will come good? I doubt it but it's a possibility if he keeps fit.

As for the players out on loan, Boateng, Anderson, Croll and Ladapo all need regular 1st team matches. Kaikai, who IMO is our only youth player that might break into the first team, is back in January so a loan to the Championship will do him a world of good and may even force himself into our plans this season (injuries usually are terrible for us around that time).

When Pardew said this would be a transitional year I thought he was talking s*** and making early excuses if we had a poor season. Maybe that was his way of saying the squad isn't good enough but it's going to take at least another season to improve it.

I agree with you on the deadweight players which is why I don't include them in posts. We need some mugs to come in for them but fryers? Could we not have loaned him out for part of his wages and got a decent defender in?

The mistake we've made is releasing 2 CBs and bringing in 1 whilst relying on midfielders to cover full back when that was a thin area before. So we have 6 defenders for 4 positions and 5 midfielders for 3 positions. Of course there could come a time when were stretched.

Let's hope the weakest it'll be is punch and another in midfield with Chungy at 10 and covers at full back.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 11.56am)

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 12.17pm)

 


COYP

Hoof Hearted 22 Sep 16 11.55am

Originally posted by Willo

Pardew clearly feels that these players 'Development' is better served by them getting regular first team football elsewhere.

We all know that Willo.

We're just suggesting he (and Parrish) reconsiders that strategy as we would rather be watching developing talent than struggling journeymen.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Sep 16 12.02pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

We all know that Willo.

We're just suggesting he (and Parrish) reconsiders that strategy as we would rather be watching developing talent than struggling journeymen.

Clearly Pardew belives that these so called "Struggling journeymen" have more to offer than our so called "Developing talent" at this present time and as such would rather the young talent get regular football than be called upon for cameo appearances.All down to matter of opinion about the strength and weaknesses of players and perhaps looking at the "Bigger picture".

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Sep 16 12.04pm

Originally posted by Willo

Clearly Pardew belives that these so called "Struggling journeymen" have more to offer than our so called "Developing talent" at this present time and as such would rather the young talent get regular football than be called upon for cameo appearances.All down to matter of opinion about the strength and weaknesses of players and perhaps looking at the "Bigger picture".

Thank you Captain Obvious... LOL

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Sep 16 12.14pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Thank you Captain Obvious... LOL

There have been calls on here for the "Developing talent" to be given a run in the side.All I have been trying to do is to see it from Pardew's standpoint.

So do you want the likes of Anderson and Ladapo to NOT go out on 'Loan' for regular first team football and instead get limited playing time for us when there are the likes of Benteke,Wickham and Remy in their way ?

We now have 7 senior/established midfielders - How many games would Boateng and Kaikai get ?

In defence would Luke Croll get many minutes with the likes of Dann,Tomkins,Delaney etc etc in his way ?

We have some young 'Developing talent' who perhaps will only develop into what we require if they face the rigours of first team football elsewhere.Yes I understand those suggesting that they would like to see them given a chance but there is always a "Bigger picture".

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 12.14pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Thank you Captain Obvious... LOL

Not obvious to some hence the post.

 


COYP

Griffish Flag Croydon 22 Sep 16 1.30pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I agree with you on the deadweight players which is why I don't include them in posts. We need some mugs to come in for them but fryers? Could we not have loaned him out for part of his wages and got a decent defender in?

The mistake we've made is releasing 2 CBs and bringing in 1 whilst relying on midfielders to cover full back when that was a thin area before. So we have 6 defenders for 4 positions and 5 midfielders for 3 positions. Of course there could come a time when were stretched.

Let's hope the weakest it'll be is punch and another in midfield with Chungy at 10 and covers at full back.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 11.56am)

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 12.17pm)

I agree, we were definitely one defender short in our squad going into the season but we have certainly been unlucky with injuries at this early stage of the season. Fryers looked good in pre season so the management have decided he deserves a chance to be a squad player, but with Souare out we will certainly make left back a priority in January.

I think with Mcarthur, Cabaye, Ledley, Flamini and then Mutch as last resort back up we will be fine for CM this season and that is one of our strongest positions. It's out wingers that worry me slightly if Sako really was that poor last night (I didn't get to see the game), if Wilf and AT get injured then were f***ed! We have Lee but he is far more effective playing through the middle, as is Puncheon. I really hope Kaikai proves himself at Brentford so he can slot into our squad come January.

 

Griffish Flag Croydon 22 Sep 16 1.34pm

Originally posted by Willo

There have been calls on here for the "Developing talent" to be given a run in the side.All I have been trying to do is to see it from Pardew's standpoint.

So do you want the likes of Anderson and Ladapo to NOT go out on 'Loan' for regular first team football and instead get limited playing time for us when there are the likes of Benteke,Wickham and Remy in their way ?

We now have 7 senior/established midfielders - How many games would Boateng and Kaikai get ?

In defence would Luke Croll get many minutes with the likes of Dann,Tomkins,Delaney etc etc in his way ?

We have some young 'Developing talent' who perhaps will only develop into what we require if they face the rigours of first team football elsewhere.Yes I understand those suggesting that they would like to see them given a chance but there is always a "Bigger picture".

I think Kaikai is the only player who would realistically get any game time, but that would only be as a late sub for Wilf or AT or if one of those got injured. He'll be back in January so let's hope he proves himself at Brentford. I can certainly see the logic in the decision to send all of these players on loan.

Edited by Griffish (22 Sep 2016 1.34pm)

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 22 Sep 16 2.13pm

Southampton have a historg of bringing youth players through, they played the youngster who scored against us last night and he looks a good prospect. There would of been a real benefit of playing some one like luke dreher or maybe some of the young attacking talent we have like randell williams, aaron bisakka, jacob
Berkeley or corie andrews. These players are raw and would cause more of a problem for the opposition they say sako. They should be given a go in the cup to see how they performed.

I remember reading a few years back clyne said he didnt think he would make it, and if it wasnt due to an injury crisis he may not off. If they are not going to get a chance to perform what is the point of an academy.

Also kaikai should of been on the fringes and starting the odd game for us, if he performed decently would have been a viable option to become a regular this season.

 

CJr94 Flag Holmesdale Road 22 Sep 16 2.39pm

Our first team are mid table premiership quality. Our squad players / backups range from mid-lower championship (Mutch & Sako) to L2 (Fryers!).

Saying that however, Rome wasn't built in a day? It will take time to remove the dead wood and replace with players of sufficient quality happy to play on a roation / cover / backup basis.

Edited by CJr94 (22 Sep 2016 2.40pm)

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Sep 16 3.57pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Not obvious to some hence the post.

Really?

Everyone knows the benefits of sending players out on loan, but at what stage do you take a leap of faith?

Spurs could still have Harry Kane out on loan or Manure with Rashford.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (22 Sep 2016 3.59pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Sep 16 4.25pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Really?

Everyone knows the benefits of sending players out on loan, but at what stage do you take a leap of faith?

Spurs could still have Harry Kane out on loan or Manure with Rashford.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (22 Sep 2016 3.59pm)

If my memory serves me well (It often doesn't !) Tottenham gave Kane his debut in a 'Europa League' game and then he went out on 'Loan' to a few clubs before he finally established himself back at his parent club.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 22 Sep 16 6.01pm

I am a little surprised there has been no announcement from the club concerning refunds for those fans who went to Southampton.

There is a precedent for such action when loyal supporters have spent a great deal of money watching an abject performance.

Surely Pardew and Parish can't believe that was a satisfactory display?

Anyway, even if the refund does not come from the club how about the players having a whip round to take care of the loyal fans.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 22 Sep 16 6.16pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Do you not think they're trying to improve the squad bit by bit already?

Do you not think that the starting eleven (and fringes of it) are stronger than it was this time last year?

Jaysus some people simply have no patience at all!

-.-'

Good post.

All the Nigel's read this post.This is what is happening to our club.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Sep 16 6.58pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

I am a little surprised there has been no announcement from the club concerning refunds for those fans who went to Southampton.

There is a precedent for such action when loyal supporters have spent a great deal of money watching an abject performance.

Surely Pardew and Parish can't believe that was a satisfactory display?

Anyway, even if the refund does not come from the club how about the players having a whip round to take care of the loyal fans.

Pardew had already said he would make a lot of changes.knowing our squad, did you really expect anything different. ..

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 22 Sep 16 7.46pm

The thing to remember is that Southampton were playing their kids and reserves. They still didn't look disjointed. If they played their first team it would have been a cricket score.

We knew we didn't have defensive cover in the window. Let's be honest, the reason we named Zeki and Kwesi Appiah are not in case we wanted to. We couldn't loan them or get rid so we had to name them in the 25 as you have to name every professional at the club. If we had got rid we would have tried to get in better cover on a free for sure.

I'm glad we are out of the cup, but blaming it on the changes is weak. Every club does that in the cup.

I also agree that we need to sort out the youth. We have all these players in the U23s playing week in week out or we sign people like Randall Williams or Keshi Anderson from non league and we eventually get rid of them and they never play, why? Boateng has played what once, and Kaikai 2 times? If the academy is not producing then why do we bother. It's a huge waste.

This is the academy that kept us solvent and got us promoted with our sales of young players.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Sep 16 7.52pm

Originally posted by DannyH93

I have never seen a Palace player so out of this depth as Fryers was last night against an also weakened southampton side. I fear we are on a kick into nothing with him. Give him away in January or just release him.

My guess is you haven't been a supporter for long.

Its a Mickey Mouse cup, who really cares.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 23 Sep 16 9.17pm

At least it sounds like this year there will be money to go out and get an impact player (or 2) in January.
The strategy of loaning young players out to League 1, then the Championship to gets lots of games in, and learn to be a professional, makes lots of sense and is good long term planning.

Keeping good young players around to help us look better in the odd Cup game and sit on the bench otherwise? That makes no sense.

I doubt AP thought the squad would play as bad as they did. But with the number of rusty, barely fit, or just plain lower-tier players, I'm sure they're not surprised. We were away, so no pressure to put on a show, and we're better out of it.

I expect them to go out in January and buy someone who will be an upgrade, and who will push another starter to the bench --and a bench player to the squad, and a squad player out. I like this plan.

Now we can wait till we play our squad for the FA Cup, and have the same debates all over again

Edited by ThatPetrolRelation (23 Sep 2016 9.18pm)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Last Night - Question To All