You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Martin kelly
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Martin kelly


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
sprites Flag Auckland 26 Oct 16 10.24am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

I can recall one great cross by Souare that was converted into a goal by a great header by Wickham against Watford in the semi final , I can't recall many others creating a goal for us, most others of his I recall are randomly thrashed across the goal in a bit of hit and hope, perhaps I am wrong but it's what I have seen .
Perhaps you can tell us of more goals from his crosses.

Can't recall specifically sorry...just remember thinking time and time again, "man that guy whips a dangerous ball in". He gets those crosses over that just seem to float across right in between the keeper and defensive line. Just because no one got on the end of them, doesn't make them bad crosses. Can't wait to see Benteke on the end of them.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Oct 16 10.50am

Originally posted by sprites

Can't recall specifically sorry...just remember thinking time and time again, "man that guy whips a dangerous ball in". He gets those crosses over that just seem to float across right in between the keeper and defensive line. Just because no one got on the end of them, doesn't make them bad crosses. Can't wait to see Benteke on the end of them.

Raises the question as to what constitutes a good cross ?
Cross might be delivered into a "Dangerous area" but bypasses players who are not in this area.Is this cross a "Bad cross" as it hasn't picked out a player ? Points for debate I suppose !

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 26 Oct 16 10.56am

Originally posted by Willo

Raises the question as to what constitutes a good cross ?
Cross might be delivered into a "Dangerous area" but bypasses players who are not in this area.Is this cross a "Bad cross" as it hasn't picked out a player ? Points for debate I suppose !

if you put them in the right areas they are good crosses and bad positional play from the strikers. Beckham new if he put the ball in the right area - Cole, Nistelrooy, Yorke or whoever would be there or thereabouts.

 


@sxp55555

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Oct 16 11.10am

Originally posted by sxp55

if you put them in the right areas they are good crosses and bad positional play from the strikers. Beckham new if he put the ball in the right area - Cole, Nistelrooy, Yorke or whoever would be there or thereabouts.

I suppose one could debate as to what is a "Right area" or "Dangerous area".! It is said that a "Dangerous cross" is one delivered curling away from the keeper in that so called "Area of uncertainty" waiting to be attacked centrally but certain players like Andy Carroll like to take up a position at the back post so this sort of cross is not ideal for him.A cross to the far post for Carroll is a cross delivered into the "Right area".
I suppose at the end of the day if a cross picks out a player who scores it is a good cross !

I am meeting up with an assistant manager of a league club tonight so I will ask him about all this "Crossing" business !!!!


Edited by Willo (26 Oct 2016 11.16am)

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 26 Oct 16 12.23pm

Originally posted by Willo

I suppose one could debate as to what is a "Right area" or "Dangerous area".! It is said that a "Dangerous cross" is one delivered curling away from the keeper in that so called "Area of uncertainty" waiting to be attacked centrally but certain players like Andy Carroll like to take up a position at the back post so this sort of cross is not ideal for him.A cross to the far post for Carroll is a cross delivered into the "Right area".
I suppose at the end of the day if a cross picks out a player who scores it is a good cross !

I am meeting up with an assistant manager of a league club tonight so I will ask him about all this "Crossing" business !!!!


Edited by Willo (26 Oct 2016 11.16am)

Another argument would be that top strikers make average crosses into good ones! Kellys cross to Benteke Saturday springs to mind.

 


@sxp55555

taylors lovechild Flag 26 Oct 16 12.30pm

Souare is left footed and is quick to deliver, which can work out brilliantly and other times the ball disappears into the heavens. He delivered a peach of a ball which Wickham scored off at the end of last season (I seem to remember). Kelly meanwhile is right footed and nearly always cuts in on his right foot in order to cross. I think his lack of a decent left foot was also exposed against West Ham. Souare does make mistakes but he's so quick and athletic that he can often recover, which is something Kelly and Ward often struggle with.

I worry about teams becoming aware of our weakness and exploiting it. I know others have suggested it but perhaps try Ledley there. He is good in the tackle and can pass and he's no slower than Kelly, plus he's struggled (in my opinion) in centre midfield of late.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 26 Oct 16 1.02pm

Personally think Kelly's done well, considering he's a centre back playing left back. I think it says more about Fryers that AP prefers a right footed centre in that position than an actual left footed left back.

As for the attacking threat, Souare is far superior to Kelly but is that really a surprise to anyone?! Regardless of his crossing ability Souare seemed to develop an understanding with each winger last season and I can only imagine he would of done the same with Townsend.

His crossing when he puts one in by the byline is of a high standard but all too often he hits them first time, too early and far outside the left hand side of the opposition box. Once he's back, hopefully it will allow him to overlap on the outside whilst Townsend has the opportunity to cut inside leaving the opposition with a difficult decision to make on whether to go with the ball or anticipate the pass to the outside runner thus leaving more space for our attackers to work in and him the opportunity to cross closer to the box.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 27 Oct 16 2.32pm

Judging PS's crossing ability based on direct assists? Oh please, don't waste my time replying to that-we've had nobody in the right areas to convert them, or the wrong players ie Zaha, Yala, cabaye, Campbell. Whilst I agree he usually looks to cross early (pros and cons) his consistently is excellent, occasionally they go back stick but in theory a big man should be there. I sit on half way I'm the AW so have the perfect view. With Benteke or Wickham in there he'll get assists. As for kelly, the cross for Tekkers was excellent, but it was also a one off.

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

paperhat Flag croydon 27 Oct 16 3.06pm

why are people talking about Souare? He could be better than beckham/Ronaldo/Bale/Messi at delivery but its academic now, you wont see him on a pitch in anger this season I can assure you.

In that comparison, Kelly is a million % better.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 27 Oct 16 3.15pm

Tomkins at right back, ward at left back could work, with dann and delaney at centre back. On paper very solid.

That or fryers at left back, who i would pick over kelly.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 27 Oct 16 6.51pm

Originally posted by rossboss29

Tomkins at right back, ward at left back could work, with dann and delaney at centre back. On paper very solid.

That or fryers at left back, who i would pick over kelly.

The quicker Delany is demoted to the bench the better. Love the guy...but his lack of quality on the ball is screwing us.

 

james03 Flag Bangkok 28 Oct 16 3.07am

It is all a game of opinions.

Mine is that defensively we really do need to upgrade in a big way.

Mandanda, Dann and Tomkins are fine but then there is the rest.

Ward is an okay full back who has good games and bad. to take us to the next level though we need someone better.

Kelly is a poor mans Ward. He does a job when required but is never going to be first choice anywhere across the back line.

Souare, well we have to assume he will recover just fine. We do though need someone as good if not better than him especially as regards defensive duties.

Delaney I have huge respect for and will remember him forever. This season though he is being exposed and perhaps the years have sadly caught up with him.

Fryers is not the answer whatever the question may be. I can see his forward runs, I can see his closing down but I have not yet seen him put in one tackle!

Just my thoughts and I appreciate I am watching the games on television rather than live.

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

comeonlad Flag In a Palace 28 Oct 16 6.14am

I think the lad gets a lot of unfair criticism.
Put Wardy at left back see how he performs , Kelly is a good solid professional who has been asked to perform at all positions across the back and performed well.
His cross to Benteke should have put us one up but hey it didnt and we got beat. He is no way inferior to Wardy , from what ive seen Wardy is a shadow of himself and very poor , fryers no way is Prem class , soure obviously is missed hes dynamic but lets not forget his defensive qualities are very limited !!!! Lets get behind what weve got and get the bin dippers beat at the weekend !!!

Edited by comeonlad (28 Oct 2016 6.15am)

Edited by comeonlad (28 Oct 2016 6.16am)

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 28 Oct 16 6.55am

Originally posted by The_Aviator

Whilst not the best, Kelly is better defensively than Fryers. We've had worse and I don't think Souare is that much better anyway - he doesn't get too many decent crosses away. I think Kelly's crossing is better than Souare's.

Fryers has been brought on for his pace in attack when we have been chasing games.

I don't think Fryers would have got on the pitch at all if we'd have been winning.

I'd worry if he started over Kelly.

But I'd love to be proven wrong.

Jesus! No my 20 years of Palace I can't think of a Palace player who can cross better than Soare- that's his main asset. Absolutely whips them in and gets them in early. Kelly on the other hand is a right footed CB playing at LB which says enough.

On the conversation however I think Kelly is a better defender than Fryers so would prefer him at present. Perhaps swap with Ward and get him in a RB

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 28 Oct 16 7.32am

let's put it this way: LB should be the number one priority (underline it and go over with a highlighter if you want) in January. Kelly is not good enough.

with a new manager of course

 

comeonlad Flag In a Palace 28 Oct 16 9.50am

Lets have a right back too my friend as Ward is not good enough either !!

Underline and Highlight that too !!


Edited by comeonlad (28 Oct 2016 9.51am)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Martin kelly