You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Weirdly Big Sam makes sense......
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Weirdly Big Sam makes sense......


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
regal_eagle Flag somewhere 29 Nov 16 4.25pm

Originally posted by Loz83

I would have big Sam he's done well FINANCIALLY nearly everywhere he goes. Yes please! I don't care how we win, I just like winning! Could be a great fit!

EFA

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

And claiming HMRC are the corrupt ones
[Link]

Do I need to carry on?!?

Ok, just one more...
[Link]

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 29 Nov 16 4.33pm

Originally posted by georgey wood

Having travelled back from Burnley and Swansea and chatted to many angry (and slightly pist away fans) it seems Pardews' job is untenable for a 100 different reasons. Two main replacements have come up Manchini and Big Sam. After going through the potential Pros and cons (and dismissing the return of Venables, Alan Smith and Stevey Kember) Big Sam makes total sense hear me out:

1. He fits the Parish profile in regards to experience in league, improving infrastructure at training ground, can handle the bigger egos we now have at club like Benteke and Cabaye, although will utilise the old school pros like Delaney too as he's old school. He guarantees motivation and discipline that we've clearly lost this season. Basically a mix of the best bits of Pards and Pulis. ( replacing brown envelopes for dodgy touch line dancing and bad trainers)
2. Has a point to prove, has settled in London before, is fresh out of the league and I'm sure would have an immediate Impact over this important Xmas run with lots of points on offer. I would argue he would plateau out but should produce I instant improvement if only at set plays and a more defensive mind set. I'm sure he'd get more work rate from Benteke too.
3. I think he would fancy it, we have the money to throw at him in bonuses and salary (as Parish said in summer money been held back for jan if things were going wonky. Well they are Steve.) Also I think players like Dann, Mcarthur and Benteke be right up his street. He'd put an arm round the stroppy ones like Wilf, Townsend and Cabaye. He also would add some power in midfield in the window I'm sure like he did at West Ham and Sunderland with big strong midfield signings.
So despite not believing he's any good for a top 6 side or international team. Our current squad that's a mixture of top players and championship level players I feel he would bring a balance of old school and new school and appeal to both types. Thus making him weirdly for me a perfect appointment bar the recent baggage and potential to grow an old school Movember......

He did do a great job with Sunderland last season, but is now totally discredited in the public eye, and was sacked in disgrace by the FA. He might possibly have lost the dressing room before he's started. Personal preference: Roy Hodgson

 

The Dolphin Flag 29 Nov 16 6.37pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Do you take the p1ss out of all disabilities?

Jeez - only having a bit of fun!

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 29 Nov 16 7.03pm

In many ways Sam would fit the bill in terms of motivation and tactical nous plus the all important PL experience; its really whether he would command respect from the players given the England debacle and this is the big question. I feel that the pro's would outweigh the Con's (so to speak!).

His past without this is rather cloudy and the little dilemma for SP is could the board be accused of being hypocritical in appointing Sam when they went to Court over Pulis who was labelled by the Judge as being deceitful and I believe a number of other things?

 


Bring back Brolin

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 30 Nov 16 1.31am

Originally posted by black eagle.

Would rather Hodgson than Big Sam.

Hodgson got Fulham in to europa league semi final.

has managed all over europe.

speaks 6 or 7 languages.

he would really want to be a success at his home town club.

and he'd probably bring Ray Lewington back to the club who is a top coach.

I'd strangley prefer this....

 


This was once a quality forum....

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 30 Nov 16 1.40am

What has Sam A. really done wrong except for talking to some fake reporters (as an England manager)how the system is working? Yeah, stupid to meet up with them in the first place, but Palace is in an urgent need for a manager that can drag out of this mire. 5 wins in soon 40 PL games - c'mon who can live that?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Nov 16 6.48am

Why don't we take Chris Hughton off Brighton? This would be good as a) it would really pi** off Brighton fans and b) we'd still get those lovely Geordies coming on here, but this time to say how much they love him

Although this is partially tongue in cheek he has actually got a very good record and I think would be a great fit.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 30 Nov 16 7.41am

wouldn't mind betting discussions are already underway

 

REBECCA Flag Rustington 30 Nov 16 8.20am

Can't believe Pardew is still in a job team not doing well Zaha,Cabaye,Benteke,Townsend and Mandada all unhappy,leaders like Jedi shipped out Speroni ditched and Pardew giving jobs to his mates with absolutely no qualification to be where they are.

Woodman goalkeeping coach I mean if you were any of our keepers being coached by him would he inspire you?what has he done apart from being Pardews sole mate.

Everything about Pardew infuriates me and always has and has now started lambasting the players as it couldn't possibly be his training methods etc,no clean sheets in 18 suggests to me it could well be.

Saying all this I honestly believe Pardew will unfortunately survive

 


This roller coaster I am on just won't stop.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 16 8.41am

Originally posted by REBECCA

Can't believe Pardew is still in a job team not doing well Zaha,Cabaye,Benteke,Townsend and Mandada all unhappy,leaders like Jedi shipped out Speroni ditched and Pardew giving jobs to his mates with absolutely no qualification to be where they are.

Woodman goalkeeping coach I mean if you were any of our keepers being coached by him would he inspire you?what has he done apart from being Pardews sole mate.

Everything about Pardew infuriates me and always has and has now started lambasting the players as it couldn't possibly be his training methods etc,no clean sheets in 18 suggests to me it could well be.

Saying all this I honestly believe Pardew will unfortunately survive

I stated on HOL that Pardew would be given time to turn things around even if we lost to Swansea and I was pilloried on here by some who gave me all this "purporting to be In the know" tirade.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 30 Nov 16 8.59am

Originally posted by black eagle.

Would rather Hodgson than Big Sam.

Hodgson got Fulham in to europa league semi final.

has managed all over europe.

speaks 6 or 7 languages.

he would really want to be a success at his home town club.

and he'd probably bring Ray Lewington back to the club who is a top coach.

Hodgson for me. At least until the end of the season whilst we look for Someone we want and who wants us.

He got Fulham to the final. Lost against Athletico I think.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Nov 16 9.02am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Why don't we take Chris Hughton off Brighton? This would be good as a) it would really pi** off Brighton fans

Why would Hughton leave a club that is well on the way to the Premiership next season for one that's in freefall and quite likely to be taking Brighton's place in the Championship neaxt season

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 30 Nov 16 9.27am

Going to put a £10 on Big Sam, feels like the right move.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

buzby1 Flag Devon 30 Nov 16 9.30am

Would hate to see Allardyce appointed as our manager. He's not the only corrupt manger out there but he got caught. We'd be the laughing stock of other clubs. Don't want Hodgson either. He's too old and would come to us on the back of a huge failure. Coleman doesn't have what it takes and he wouldn't be welcomed by many fans. Would like to see Hoddle given a chance. He's bright, knows the game and was the best England manager by a mile. Perhaps he could faith heal Wickham as well.

 

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 30 Nov 16 9.43am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

What has Sam A. really done wrong except for talking to some fake reporters (as an England manager)how the system is working? Yeah, stupid to meet up with them in the first place, but Palace is in an urgent need for a manager that can drag out of this mire. 5 wins in soon 40 PL games - c'mon who can live that?

At West Ham he pretty much demanded players changed agents to his preferred man, he was definitely wetting his beak there... however I agree that we should get him in, mostly down to the lack of a single other realistic candidate that's up to it. There's literally no one realisticly IMHO. Say what you like about Fat Sam but he won't relegate us, have absolute confidence in that...

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 16 9.43am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why would Hughton leave a club that is well on the way to the Premiership next season for one that's in freefall and quite likely to be taking Brighton's place in the Championship neaxt season

My view as well.

At the end of the day, Brighton are on the "Up", they have a modern stadium, they attract crowds in excess of 25,000 in the Championship and they have modern and impressive training facilities at Lancing.

It really hurts me to admit this, coming from someone who "Shudders" when he drives past their ground on the A27 !

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 16 9.47am

Some high profile names have been mentioned but none might be remotely interested in joining us.

We might be in the PL and in London but we are hardly "Sexy" - we have a stadium in dire need of modernisation with a capacity of only 26,000 and as such do not play in a modern stadium with sizeable crowds.Furthermore we are not an established PL club.We really have to be realistic about who we could possibly attract.

Edited by Willo (30 Nov 2016 9.49am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Nov 16 9.48am

FFS this is football not a Brighton Green Party meeting or coffee and biscuits after Sunday church service. Who gives a sh1t what people think. We'll be in the top league again rather than holier than though in mid table in the championship.

Just appoint the man who can organise and discipline our defence and turn the goals we score into wins rather than 5,7,9 goal thrilling, entertaining and humiliating losses. That man is Allardyce. I think everyone knows it.

And yes we might have to show him the door in 18 months but we'll be in the prem rather than crumbling away in the championship and can we do it in May this time like we should've done Parishs LLLLLLLLLLLLDLLLDLLLL travel pal we have now.

 


COYP

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 30 Nov 16 9.50am

Originally posted by Willo

My view as well.

At the end of the day, Brighton are on the "Up", they have a modern stadium, they attract crowds in excess of 25,000 in the Championship and they have modern and impressive training facilities at Lancing.

It really hurts me to admit this, coming from someone who "Shudders" when he drives past their ground on the A27 !


Quite so, Willo. It's us who have become the joke, I mean aside from our current form, when is any work ever going to start on the stadium? We've been promised something is going to happen for six years and we didn't even manage to build a new shop in the car park, which we had planning permission for. It's always jam tomorrow with us.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Nov 16 9.51am

Originally posted by Willo

Some high profile names have been mentioned but none might be remotely interested in joining us.

We might be in the PL and in London but we are hardly "Sexy" - we have a stadium in dire need of modernisation with a capacity of only 26,000 and as such do not play in a modern stadium with sizeable crowds.We really have to be realistic about who we could possibly attract.

They will care about contract and pay and transfer budget in January, same as always. They will size that up vs Sky Spirts Sunday or will the next offer be better or even be a next offer.

This is the prem, Willo. It changes things.

 


COYP

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Weirdly Big Sam makes sense......