You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew -- when would you admit u were wrong?
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pardew -- when would you admit u were wrong?


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
simonmdt Flag x 08 Dec 16 10.41pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Ask Everton fans what they think of Koeman

He left Newcastle in 10th place, hardly a disaster.

Were you not even convinced albeit temporarily when we finished 10th that he could be the man?


Ask a Southampton fan what they think of Koeman

At Newcastle his derby record against Sunderland was the worst since 1892. In the 2013/14 season he lost 15 out of 21 games. Hardly a success.

No. As I said. I have NEVER rated him as good enough for the top league.

You can't take a snap shot and use that as proof of anything. Look at the trend/his record. He's never been good enough.

Edited by simonmdt (08 Dec 2016 10.41pm)

 

simonmdt Flag x 08 Dec 16 10.42pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Everything about him says he is Palace.

Inconsistent, frustrating, joyous occasionally, money problems, yo-yo career, good at snatching defeat from the jaws of victory, a bit of flair, needs a makeover and you know he is gonna end up in The Championship in the not too distant future.

We are a perfect fit.

I'd only have a problem with him if he shagged my wife. If. He hasn't already.


WELL SAID

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 08 Dec 16 11.03pm

I want Pardew to stay and succeed, but last season he convinced me that he's not an able manager - but I have my fingers crossed that I am wrong about that. If you think about the 3-0 win against Southampton, what did it prove? It proved that the team is really capable of performing well. Pardew had to have his neck on the block before he made the necessary changes, listened to others instead of himself, and allowed the team to get its result. Great, we probably won't go down now, but Pardew is still Pardew and when this heat if off him it's reasonable to expect he'll be up to his usual methods in the near future. I don't think it's a good thing to have to drag a manager kicking and screaming to what's required to get a victory. He will probably be ok this season, but I think we can get better, not for top 5 finishes but top ten. But I truly hope he makes me eat my words and I have to post that I was wrong! Honest!

 


[Link]

Aray Flag South London 08 Dec 16 11.12pm

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

I want Pardew to stay and succeed, but last season he convinced me that he's not an able manager - but I have my fingers crossed that I am wrong about that. If you think about the 3-0 win against Southampton, what did it prove? It proved that the team is really capable of performing well. Pardew had to have his neck on the block before he made the necessary changes, listened to others instead of himself, and allowed the team to get its result. Great, we probably won't go down now, but Pardew is still Pardew and when this heat if off him it's reasonable to expect he'll be up to his usual methods in the near future. I don't think it's a good thing to have to drag a manager kicking and screaming to what's required to get a victory. He will probably be ok this season, but I think we can get better, not for top 5 finishes but top ten. But I truly hope he makes me eat my words and I have to post that I was wrong! Honest!

fair comment parch more. i was amazed to see Kelly start at left back for for so many games. and yet... 2 years with the same manager seems like an improvement. we really need to build a squad and infrastructure - that doesn't happen when you're chopping and changing managers.

 

Gidge Flag Romsey 08 Dec 16 11.30pm

I walked away from the 5-1 thrashing of Toon with a real feeling that we've finally found a decent manager and we're on our way to great things. However, being a Palace fan of over 30 years, I said to myself, "Remember this feeling because we're bound to f*ck it up sooner or later". And that's exactly what has happened.....and some!

I've tried so hard to like Pardew but I really ran out of patience after the defeat to Liverpool game last season. Yes, that penalty was a disgrace but we should never have allowed Liverpool anywhere near our box in the first place! The same thing happened at Burnley this year. Man City a few weeks back,....terrible substitutions and we lose again. Rank bad management time and time again. As for Swansea, a total shambles.

So, on Saturday, we come up against a well out of sorts Southampton and get a win. I always want us to win and it was nice to have that winning feeling again (finally) but what does Pardew do? Makes it all about him with his public gestures to Parish and makes patronising remarks about the US Investors in post-match pressers, forcing Parish to explain him out of it on the radio.

He has a hell of a long way to go before he's out of the woods. Lose at Hull and we're back to square 1 really.

I am happy to eat humble pie if we have a good season, but I will be very surprised if he's still our manager by the end of the season.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Dec 16 11.53pm

Originally posted by Gidge

I walked away from the 5-1 thrashing of Toon with a real feeling that we've finally found a decent manager and we're on our way to great things. However, being a Palace fan of over 30 years, I said to myself, "Remember this feeling because we're bound to f*ck it up sooner or later". And that's exactly what has happened.....and some!

I've tried so hard to like Pardew but I really ran out of patience after the defeat to Liverpool game last season. Yes, that penalty was a disgrace but we should never have allowed Liverpool anywhere near our box in the first place! The same thing happened at Burnley this year. Man City a few weeks back,....terrible substitutions and we lose again. Rank bad management time and time again. As for Swansea, a total shambles.

So, on Saturday, we come up against a well out of sorts Southampton and get a win. I always want us to win and it was nice to have that winning feeling again (finally) but what does Pardew do? Makes it all about him with his public gestures to Parish and makes patronising remarks about the US Investors in post-match pressers, forcing Parish to explain him out of it on the radio.

He has a hell of a long way to go before he's out of the woods. Lose at Hull and we're back to square 1 really.

I am happy to eat humble pie if we have a good season, but I will be very surprised if he's still our manager by the end of the season.

That definition has changed though hasn't it ?

At the beginning of the season , '' good '' would be upper mid table or mid table.

Now it would probably be to stay in the Premier League. Which, to be fair, would satisfy the majority I suspect - me included.

I admire Parish's loyalty to his man, and Parish is no fool so he won't be taken in by the Saints result.

A defeat at Hull would spell real trouble given the next run of fixtures.

Without listing my perception of Pardew's strengths and weaknesses, I would simply say that as a Palace manager I think he has peaked and is past his best.


 


Old, Ungifted and White

Gidge Flag Romsey 08 Dec 16 11.57pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

All fair points mate

That definition has changed though hasn't it ?

At the beginning of the season , '' good '' would be upper mid table or mid table.

Now it would probably be to stay in the Premier League. Which, to be fair, would satisfy the majority I suspect - me included.

I admire Parish's loyalty to his man, and Parish is no fool so he won't be taken in by the Saints result.

A defeat at Hull would spell real trouble given the next run of fixtures.

Without listing my perception of Pardew's strengths and weaknesses, I would simply say that as a Palace manager I think he has peaked and is past his best.


 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 09 Dec 16 1.10am

I remain unconvinced about Pardew but he's clearly going nowhere at the moment and I wouldn't be unhappy if by some miracle I was proved wrong.

Edited by Henry of Peckham (09 Dec 2016 8.00am)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 09 Dec 16 7.36am

So far, a few of those have who want him out have actually answered the question. Their response equates to low-to-mid 40s points wise and low-to-mid table finish. Then they'd admit they were wrong.

Those who want him to stay aren't so far prepared to imagine they might be wrong or put that into words.


Makes me think that they think supporting the club and supporting the manager is the same thing.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 09 Dec 16 8.49am

If I'd been told, when we were promoted that we'd now be in our forth season, I'd have hoped that, by now, we'd be competing for a mid-table finish and not struggling to stay up. The second half of last season was abysmal, as far as the league was concerned, and it was my view that Pardew should have been sacked after the FA Cup final so that we had plenty of time to make an appointment before the pre-season and the transfer window.

In light of how last season finished, I revised my expectations downwards and fully expected us to continue to struggle this season, which we have. In light of the continuation of our poor form, I would have got rid of Pardew after Swansea, to give us time to appoint before the January window. We didn't and now we're manacled together for the time being, for better or worse.

I'm not setting too much store, in terms of corner-turning, from the Southampton result as it appeared to be less about Pardew having a Damascus moment and more about player-pressure and his being in the last chance saloon. His comments after the game didn't convince me that he's actually learnt anything. He needs a result at Hull, and if he gets one, he'll have taken some of the pressure off himself.

However, what he actually needs to do is show, over the rest of this season, that he can set teams up well, with a proper plan, make sensible substitutions and close out games to get results. If he does that, I'll tentatively accept that he could be the long-term solution, but I'll be nervously awaiting the next bad run, which always seems to be just around the corner.

I really wanted him to succeed when we appointed him and he undoubtedly had a good start, but it seems that good runs go to his head and he starts to believe his own hype and lose the plot. If we do stay up, I'd suggest that, in our fifth season, we should be doing better than just trying to avoid relegation.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

The Dolphin Flag 09 Dec 16 8.55am

I repeat what I said elsewhere.
We have gone backwards since he first came and yet with a (supposedly) much better squad of players.
This season we should really have been looking for a 50+ point finish - based on results to date taken over the remainder of the season we will be lucky to reach 40.
Survival yes - great - but you cannot dress it up you Pardew lovers - he is not doing the job that he was brought in to do - which was to make us better season on season and become a Club that looks like it is going to be a fixture in the League for a long time to come.
When that happens - and if he gets the time to do that then I will admit I am wrong.
Until then he is no way the right Manager for us.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 16 9.11am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I repeat what I said elsewhere.
We have gone backwards since he first came and yet with a (supposedly) much better squad of players.
This season we should really have been looking for a 50+ point finish - based on results to date taken over the remainder of the season we will be lucky to reach 40.
Survival yes - great - but you cannot dress it up you Pardew lovers - he is not doing the job that he was brought in to do - which was to make us better season on season and become a Club that looks like it is going to be a fixture in the League for a long time to come.
When that happens - and if he gets the time to do that then I will admit I am wrong.
Until then he is no way the right Manager for us.

Can a club of our stature really expect such progression ? Logically this would take us into the 'Champions League' and eventually to the top of the PL !!!!

We had made progress in the sense that nobody had predicted us to go down this season and if this is a regular occurrence and we end up like a Stoke etc then maybe this would be a 'Positive' for our club.Maybe this would represent our "Next level".

Edited by Willo (09 Dec 2016 9.12am)

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 09 Dec 16 9.21am

Originally posted by Willo

Can a club of our stature really expect such progression ? Logically this would take us into the 'Champions League' and eventually to the top of the PL !!!!

We had made progress in the sense that nobody had predicted us to go down this season and if this is a regular occurrence and we end up like a Stoke etc then maybe this would be a 'Positive' for our club.Maybe this would represent our "Next level".


Agreed Willo,some Holers expectations are so high.
They seem to forget that the other 19 teams are also trying to Win.
As I have said previously we are about 6 points short at the moment.
That would put us 7th.
24 Games to go.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Dec 16 9.48am

Originally posted by bexleydave

If I'd been told, when we were promoted that we'd now be in our forth season, I'd have hoped that, by now, we'd be competing for a mid-table finish and not struggling to stay up. The second half of last season was abysmal, as far as the league was concerned, and it was my view that Pardew should have been sacked after the FA Cup final so that we had plenty of time to make an appointment before the pre-season and the transfer window.

In light of how last season finished, I revised my expectations downwards and fully expected us to continue to struggle this season, which we have. In light of the continuation of our poor form, I would have got rid of Pardew after Swansea, to give us time to appoint before the January window. We didn't and now we're manacled together for the time being, for better or worse.

I'm not setting too much store, in terms of corner-turning, from the Southampton result as it appeared to be less about Pardew having a Damascus moment and more about player-pressure and his being in the last chance saloon. His comments after the game didn't convince me that he's actually learnt anything. He needs a result at Hull, and if he gets one, he'll have taken some of the pressure off himself.

However, what he actually needs to do is show, over the rest of this season, that he can set teams up well, with a proper plan, make sensible substitutions and close out games to get results. If he does that, I'll tentatively accept that he could be the long-term solution, but I'll be nervously awaiting the next bad run, which always seems to be just around the corner.

I really wanted him to succeed when we appointed him and he undoubtedly had a good start, but it seems that good runs go to his head and he starts to believe his own hype and lose the plot. If we do stay up, I'd suggest that, in our fifth season, we should be doing better than just trying to avoid relegation.

I agree with you again. The thing is that even if he turns it around, there's always that concern the big bad winless run is not far away. It is risky, dangerous and unhealthy to a club's premier league status.

I think Parish is hoping he gets to the end of January in 14th+ position and then new signings mean bad results and winless runs stop. I think the problem there is that teams watch videos of our last few games plus the odd one v a similar club to them and in a relevant home or away fixture and have him completely sussed. So any form lasts a handful of games because once the formula he uses is worked out and a formula to beat him with is found, its used by all opponents thereafter. He can't stop the rot and they have the upper hand to stop him. Doesn't really fill you with confidence.

I came away from Southampton happy from a good result but some luck to get it from a poor Southampton and lucky goals. But the general experience hasn't been good for a long time. Turning up knowing it's going to be LLLLLLL.

 


COYP

Crystal99 Flag Kalmar, Sweden 09 Dec 16 9.54am

After 6 straight defeats we beat Southampton, a poor performance from them, but they still had 2 or 3 clear chances that of course they didn't take. My concern is that our defending was still shaky and we were very lucky to get a clean sheet, our goals were the result of poor defending and we made plenty of unforced mistakes on the ball. All in all I'm not convinced that we will make the improvements needed to have a good season. With CW out for the season, and having 5 or 6 players in the squad that aren't good enough, I just hope I'm proved wrong!!

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 09 Dec 16 9.58am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

I'm annoyed with him because, when he was appointed, I really, really wanted him to succeed (obviously, as long he's the manager, I still do) and it seemed he and Palace were a natural fit for each other. Over the last year, though, he's really put my nerves through the shredder and it was only after the Swansea game that I started to think enough was enough.

This for me. He seemed like an ideal fit despite what the Geordies were warning us. In fact maybe a little bit because of it. Because everyone was saying what a basket case the Toon were and so it was going to make it even sweeter when we showed what could really be done when he was supported.

I wanted a former player, who held an important role in our history (even if he wasn't that good a player), to come in and turn us around.

The relationship with the chairman seemed a dream and he had positive long term ambitions.

But the problem is that even if he does well now (and even in this transition season, doing well should have been mid table with no real flirtation with relegation given the gross outlay on players) his arrogance, intransigence, and lack of humility make it almost impossible to really like him. I don't think there is much he can do to be fully redeemed in my eyes. I just feel like the relationship has run its course and everyone is just delaying the inevitable.

I don't think there is anything - short of a miraculous run that lifts us into upper mid table - that could turn around the negativity for me this season.

If he has a decent run, we end up 12th-15th, and then build on it next season, then that will start getting us back there.

Edited by OknotOK (09 Dec 2016 9.58am)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

The Dolphin Flag 09 Dec 16 10.00am

Improvement is a general term - when we can see something tangible and maybe equal previous seasons points total?
Tangible so far is that we seem to be able to score goals but at the same time leak like a sieve at the back.
It is not about high expectations just gradual progression.
People have not invested $100,000,000 just to see us regress have they?

 

Beastie Flag 09 Dec 16 10.08am

Like a lot of others on here, I was with Pardew until the Swansea game. So, if you like, I admit I was wrong.

I actually still think we’ll stay up with him in charge but only just and after a season of pain.

It has always been about whether there is a good replacement available. If there is, please snap him up. If not, let’s support Pardew and hope for the best.

 

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 09 Dec 16 10.10am

A win at Hull is a must, otherwise he should go.
Cause we got a though program ahead and we can`t expect to mutch of them but Hull has to be beaten, I could settle for a draw but think we got to win this

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 09 Dec 16 10.12am

Originally posted by Asian Eagle

A win at Hull is a must, otherwise he should go.
Cause we got a though program ahead and we can`t expect to mutch of them but Hull has to be beaten, I could settle for a draw but think we got to win this

he is not going to get the sack he he has won one and drawn one of his last two games.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew -- when would you admit u were wrong?