You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish and Pardew
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish and Pardew


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 12 Dec 16 5.07pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Its wierd how split down the middle we are as fans when it comes to Pardew, the last 2 weeks opposition have said we looked decent, commentators have said we look much better, opposition fans say we look better, stats say we look better, all these 'power rankings' and stuff say we have improved massivly, the players look better, yet the 'pardew out' fans dont care about that.
We have conceded double figures in the last 3 games, have one of the worst records in the whole of european top flifht teams, hold a lead for an average of about 4 minutes and we as fans have almost no faith in our ability to hold out for even a draw when we are ahead, yet the 'pardew stay' crowd will not care about that...

The fact is whatever camp you are with, you have a hell of a case to make!

How do you know its split down the middle. A few regulars gobbing off on here doesnt mean every one is anti Pardew. When you start seeing falling attendances (as at west brom) would be a true barometer. Some of us are still happy to be here for an extended top flight run. Its called realism.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 12 Dec 16 5.09pm

I don't really get the obsession with using a calendar year to rate managers. Teams play by seasons, not calendars. If we got Benteke in January, I think last season would have been different.

As far as I'm concerned, Pards had a great start in 2015-16, and a horrific finish. (Mourinho just had a horrific start and he was finished). The squad wasn't that strong, and was weakened by injuries. Not sure how much people expected with Adebayor leading the line, and a Centre Back as out top scorer. Our Goalkeepers were not seen to be top class around here.

This season, we are scoring for fun, a total change. But Pape's injury screwed our Defence. Yes, it would be nice to have a £8m replacement sitting on the bench, but that's not Palace --so it's Kelly and Fryers till January. Tomkins is taking time to settle in, but he keeps getting injured.

The way I see it, Pards has two stars (Zaha and Big Ben). Four good players who can be dominant on their day (McArthur, Dann, Puncheon, Tomkins). Two players who haven't lived up to their expectations (Cabaye, Townsend). And three players who are solid (Damo, Ward, Ledley), but would not make the bench of a top-half team. Our Keepers have been average. Then we have squad players who can fill in, but really shouldn't be starting, and those in the physio room.

With this team I don't expect Palace to light the world on fire, even if we had Mancini as a Manager.

I imagine Parish did not succeed in bringing in all the players he'd wanted (James McCarthy, Jack Wiltshire, or Saido Berahino would be useful right now).

He realizes he's left Pards with little cover and no depth (with Pape and Wickham done, and Remy never begun).

So it makes sense to give Pards to the window, bring in 3 more players so Pards has a chance to field 11 Prem-quality players, and maybe actually have some decent choices on the bench.

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 12 Dec 16 5.26pm

Originally posted by sickboy

How do you know its split down the middle. A few regulars gobbing off on here doesnt mean every one is anti Pardew. When you start seeing falling attendances (as at west brom) would be a true barometer. Some of us are still happy to be here for an extended top flight run. Its called realism.

Your right, i dont think 'down the middle' was good wording, its genuinly impossible to tell from here where the split is exactly...a lot of noise is not the same as a majority.
My point still stands though that most people have an opinion one way or another and wont be swayed by facts from the other side.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 16 5.32pm

Problem is petrolrelation is that whether we have the strongest 11 or not quite the strongest 11 we are playing like a team that isn't focused or disciplined, not fit enough or mentally strong enough. They are all prem players, not championship players unready for this.

Conceding goals from corners or our own corners, not backing each other up or covering each other, letting oppo (hull ffs) walk the ball from midfield, into the box and into the 6 yard area to slot it away. And that's some player at the bottom of the league taking it past 2 internationals and 1 who we thought should be in Dann before now.

I'm sorry but this cr&p has to be dealt with now. Without Zaha we would be without hope of surviving and relying on one player and punts.to striker and penalties isn't good enough. I reckon the players know AP isn't good enough but can't afford to let points slip so plod on knowing he'll have to go soon anyway.

 


COYP

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 12 Dec 16 5.49pm

What Steve Parish mentioned on talkSPORT was Pardew's good win ratio of 41%. Full managers' list here [Link] But do those stats count for anything?

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 12 Dec 16 6.24pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Problem is petrolrelation is that whether we have the strongest 11 or not quite the strongest 11 we are playing like a team that isn't focused or disciplined, not fit enough or mentally strong enough. They are all prem players, not championship players unready for this.

Conceding goals from corners or our own corners, not backing each other up or covering each other, letting oppo (hull ffs) walk the ball from midfield, into the box and into the 6 yard area to slot it away. And that's some player at the bottom of the league taking it past 2 internationals and 1 who we thought should be in Dann before now.

I'm sorry but this cr&p has to be dealt with now. Without Zaha we would be without hope of surviving and relying on one player and punts.to striker and penalties isn't good enough. I reckon the players know AP isn't good enough but can't afford to let points slip so plod on knowing he'll have to go soon anyway.

Well against Hull, Ledley totally watched as they walked by him on that goal --I was screaming at the TV. The other goal was a nice turn, but seeing Dann get nutmegged and turned made me yell. We have been a shambles defensively, but often it is player errors, not tactics.

How many times has Kelly been beaten cleanly one-on-one this year? What can Pards do about that (other than play Fryers).

When we had Tomkins on the right and Ward on the left against Southampton it was one of the few times we looked sorted at the back. Our DMs have been inconsistent too, with Cabaye never having it since the Euros, MacArthur has been up and down, and Ledley is solid but slow and his concentration has been off this year.

How do you build a solid back 4 with what we have? Damo is solid but slow, and we get ripped apart by fast fullbacks who pull him out of position --because they know they can run riot over Kelly or Fryers. Ward is better, but against talented full backs he has to hang back and the winger gets no support.

Perhaps we looked like sh*te at the beginning because of the calls against contact in the box, but Dann and Damo haven't recovered. Mandanda is good with his feet but doesn't challenge crosses well in the box (yet). Hennessey is a nightmare on freekicks, but he's solid on corners and crosses (Sunderland oopsie notwithstanding).

I think we have been poor defensively because right now we have poor defenders. Half of them their form may pick up, but the other half are fading or were never that good to begin with. God help us if Tomkin's injury is serious, or we'll be playing 3 at the back till January. But how else can Pards set up with these defenders?

 

Stuart Shave Flag Hampshire 12 Dec 16 7.24pm

Originally posted by speediej

I know this sounds ridiculous, but could there be something in Pardews contract that means sacking him would be too costly? Something behind scenes that we don't know about and it is kept private?

I just don't understand why the board haven't got rid of him after 6 wins in 33 games?

Just a thought

Maybe he just has faith in Pardew and isn't as trigger happy as silly unrealistic fans and other Chairman.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 12 Dec 16 8.42pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

True - but I think Man Utd were at least winning games on a regular basis at the time.

Not many they weren't. They had been down in the bottom six for much of the season, and pulled together a run of decent results only in the last six games.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

KAOS Flag In a tree 12 Dec 16 8.51pm

Utterly bored and frustrated with this ongoing saga of Pardew clearly not being good enough yet keeping his job! It's a f*cken joke and all the hard work over the last 3 seasons is being undone with this period of sustained madness!

He's gotta go but Parish is digging his heels in about it and it makes no sense at all! We need someone in now to get the best out of our current squad and prepare for urgent January acquisitions! But I'm now starting to think it'll be Pardew spending the kitty even if we don't win until then ... never seen or known anything like it before!

 

Jacey Flag 12 Dec 16 9.17pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Utterly bored and frustrated with this ongoing saga of Pardew clearly not being good enough yet keeping his job! It's a f*cken joke and all the hard work over the last 3 seasons is being undone with this period of sustained madness!

He's gotta go but Parish is digging his heels in about it and it makes no sense at all! We need someone in now to get the best out of our current squad and prepare for urgent January acquisitions! But I'm now starting to think it'll be Pardew spending the kitty even if we don't win until then ... never seen or known anything like it before!

Agreed, and worse is yet to come over the next 4 games,none of which I expect us to win and at best get just the one point,away at Watford.
Shocking result at Hull where I fully expected 3 points before the next3/4 challenging fixtures.
Just how long can Parish continue to back this no hoper,who will take us down if he is not removed before the new window.,mark my words.

 

derby eagle Flag Derby 12 Dec 16 9.34pm

So say hypothetically we somehow get 4 points out of next 4 games...are we all pleased looking forward to an easier run of games? Or miserable as sin because the results don't mean pardew can be sacked?

Edited by derby eagle (12 Dec 2016 9.35pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 16 10.31pm

Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation

Well against Hull, Ledley totally watched as they walked by him on that goal --I was screaming at the TV. The other goal was a nice turn, but seeing Dann get nutmegged and turned made me yell. We have been a shambles defensively, but often it is player errors, not tactics.

How many times has Kelly been beaten cleanly one-on-one this year? What can Pards do about that (other than play Fryers).

When we had Tomkins on the right and Ward on the left against Southampton it was one of the few times we looked sorted at the back. Our DMs have been inconsistent too, with Cabaye never having it since the Euros, MacArthur has been up and down, and Ledley is solid but slow and his concentration has been off this year.

How do you build a solid back 4 with what we have? Damo is solid but slow, and we get ripped apart by fast fullbacks who pull him out of position --because they know they can run riot over Kelly or Fryers. Ward is better, but against talented full backs he has to hang back and the winger gets no support.

Perhaps we looked like sh*te at the beginning because of the calls against contact in the box, but Dann and Damo haven't recovered. Mandanda is good with his feet but doesn't challenge crosses well in the box (yet). Hennessey is a nightmare on freekicks, but he's solid on corners and crosses (Sunderland oopsie notwithstanding).

I think we have been poor defensively because right now we have poor defenders. Half of them their form may pick up, but the other half are fading or were never that good to begin with. God help us if Tomkin's injury is serious, or we'll be playing 3 at the back till January. But how else can Pards set up with these defenders?

A good manager would have ironed out these players and have them alert to everything around them but they are getting taken to pieces at the back by Burnley, Hull FFS and Swansea FFS and 3-5 goals each. Do other teams have their problems? Yes. Do they deal with them? Yes. Yet we excuse Pathetic Pardew.

We are not talking about teams worth £300 million taking the pish. We are talking about Burnley, Swansea, Hull FFS and no I don't expect us to beat all these teams but 1 point from 9 out of them is bollox tbh. These teams are more alert, focused, determined, drilled, working and looking out for each other and giving everything for every point. Everything we are not. This stuff is not even that sophisticated which makes it even more unacceptable. It's the sort of stuff that a Sunday League side can sort out by shouting at each other and a few home truths said by the characters at half time.

I am fackin fed up with watching us play like teenagers on their summer holidays from midfield back to goal. Somebody is ultimately responsible if it happens every week and I can tell you now that there are weeks when there are 4 able defenders and however many midfielders playing in front of them yet still it's the not the manager's responsibility.

There is therefore something wrong with the culture and thinking within the squad. Whatever it is, we are walking backwards into the drop zone and the championship and someone needs to address it. There isn't enough there to tell me Pardew can.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 16 10.34pm

Originally posted by derby eagle

So say hypothetically we somehow get 4 points out of next 4 games...are we all pleased looking forward to an easier run of games? Or miserable as sin because the results don't mean pardew can be sacked?

Edited by derby eagle (12 Dec 2016 9.35pm)

I want us to collect points in every game but it's unfortunate that the longer Pardew is in the job, the harder it will be sometime later in the season. If he does stay and just about pathetically has us stumble over the line then he can go as he ideally should've done in June and saved the club millions by not extending his contract.

 


COYP

Jacey Flag 13 Dec 16 11.54am

Just an observation, Pardew has been our manager for almost 2 years and throughout 2016, has achieved just 6 wins in some 34 games.Bearing in mind who we play in the next 4,his return could very well move to just 6 wins in 38 games.
We still have him talking about this being a transitional season and the press references to our being an ' entertaining mess'.
Contrast Pardew with Conte,who has hit the ground running immediately and of course,other class managers who have performed very well from the start and you begin to identify the problem.Such a shame Parish and Pardew are such good chums as we continue to look like chumps while he remains our manager.
After the next few games, hopefully with a word in his ear from the US, a replacement in the form of Big Sam will be instrumental in saving our status in this league before it is to late.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Dec 16 12.06pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Just an observation, Pardew has been our manager for almost 2 years and throughout 2016, has achieved just 6 wins in some 34 games.Bearing in mind who we play in the next 4,his return could very well move to just 6 wins in 38 games.
We still have him talking about this being a transitional season and the press references to our being an ' entertaining mess'.
Contrast Pardew with Conte,who has hit the ground running immediately and of course,other class managers who have performed very well from the start and you begin to identify the problem.Such a shame Parish and Pardew are such good chums as we continue to look like chumps while he remains our manager.
After the next few games, hopefully with a word in his ear from the US, a replacement in the form of Big Sam will be instrumental in saving our status in this league before it is to late.

At the moment there is a bit of a "Cushion" (Not much I appreciate) between ourselves and the relegation places.Psychologically it is a positive we are not in the bottom three.We have also won 1 and drawn 1 (Away) of our last 2 games after a run of 6 defeats so some decent news.

Situation changes if we lose our next 3 games and slip into that dreaded "Bottom three" and at this point there MIGHT be pressure to make a change at the top.We could reach the stage where matters are really looking grim but alas some managers have already been snapped up by other clubs and if this happens one can only imagine the vitriol delivered in the direction of Parish & Co. At the present time, Pardew is in charge until the "Foreseeable future".

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 13 Dec 16 12.42pm

It's amazing how much people are panicking. I guess it's a symptom of how bad this year as a whole has been and the increased expectations we now have.

Just reading some posts on here would make you think we are cut adrift at the bottom of the league, but we are 15th, with just a -2 goal difference. It is not the time to panic yet. Hull was bad, but we always struggle to play against a 3 at the back.

I think we will continue to pick up results. We are not one of the worse 3 teams in the league (on performances or results) this season, so that is why Parish is keeping the faith.

Even with our 6 game losing streak, in the last 10 games, Hull City and Everton have picked up less points, and Swansea the same.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

The Dolphin Flag 13 Dec 16 12.53pm

From a survival point of view the fact that others are doing worse is a good thing.
From our own Club's point of view we are going backwards not forwards and that is a worry.
we should be staying the same or getting a little better really.
2013/2014 - 45 points - Holloway/Pulis
2014/2015 - 48 points - Various/Pardew
2015/2016 - 42 points - Pardew with a relegation scare
2016/2017 - ?? points - Pardew and who knows

 

Jacey Flag 13 Dec 16 1.06pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

From a survival point of view the fact that others are doing worse is a good thing.
From our own Club's point of view we are going backwards not forwards and that is a worry.
we should be staying the same or getting a little better really.
2013/2014 - 45 points - Holloway/Pulis
2014/2015 - 48 points - Various/Pardew
2015/2016 - 42 points - Pardew with a relegation scare
2016/2017 - ?? points - Pardew and who knows

Very worried that if he remains in charge until after the Arsenal game, he would have presided over just six wins in 2016 and we will be sleep walking to the Championship.
Just when will Parish wake-up and smell the coffee??
Hopefully,some discussion is being had with Big Sam who can be our saviour and we can have a seamless ' transition'.No sentimentality in a results driven business,even though they are big mates.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 13 Dec 16 1.52pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Very worried that if he remains in charge until after the Arsenal game, he would have presided over just six wins in 2016 and we will be sleep walking to the Championship.
Just when will Parish wake-up and smell the coffee??
Hopefully,some discussion is being had with Big Sam who can be our saviour and we can have a seamless ' transition'.No sentimentality in a results driven business,even though they are big mates.

Big Sam a saviour, I don't think so.

 

jimruss Flag Sidcup 13 Dec 16 3.00pm

Man Utd (H) - 0
Chelsea (H) - 0
Watford - 1
Arsenal - 0
Swansea (H) - 3
West Ham - 1
Everton (H) - 1
Bournemouth - 0
Sunderland (H) - 3
Stoke - 1
Middlesbrough (H) - 3
West Brom - 0
Spurs (H) - 1
Watford (H) - 1
Chelsea - 0
Soton - 1
Arsenal (H) - 0
Leicester (H) - 3
Liverpool - 0
Burnley (H) - 3
Man City - 0
Hull (H) - 1
Man Utd - 0

Just purely because I'm bored at work and people are talking about points I've gone through the league games we have left and the points I think we'll get out of them.

I make it 38 points which would have kept us up in the last few seasons but would make for a very tense last few weeks

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish and Pardew