You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > If a manager plays Kelly and Ward as fullbacks
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

If a manager plays Kelly and Ward as fullbacks


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Lakeview Flag Lincoln 18 Dec 16 7.30pm

Anyone who thinks Chelsea are less than an impressive side probably doesn't know too much about football. I went to see Chelsea v Man City a few weeks back as a guest. Chelsea, including Victor Moses, gave a thoroughly impressive performance in every aspect of their play. You may have a point about our full back weakness, but the strange line about why Chelsea gave us nothing to fear (despite their 11th straight victory) tells us something about you and either your views on football or your motives for visiting this site.Still, a wide range of views is part of what makes this site worth visiting.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 18 Dec 16 9.03pm

Kelly and Ward are currently the best two full backs at the club .The problem is they are both right full backs and though neither are any good on the left Ward is less useless than Kelly .

Kelly is obviously lacking confidence ,he is a decent right back who has had his confidence shot after poor games on the left .His early crossing is poor ,he needs to take the ball to the line when he has the chance which he did have on at least two occasions yesterday .

Pardew doesn't fancy Fryers so makes do with what he has got ,a decent left back is a must in the transfer window .

 

mattteo Flag 19 Dec 16 7.20am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3095931]

Have you watched how ineffective he is on the left? He wants to play on the right, but we have Wilf playing there, who is arguably better at it. Remind me, where did he play for England?


I've watched him a lot since his QPR days. Then at Tottenham, then at Newcastle. he is very effective in the left wing. Effective doesn't only mean scoring. He provides numerous cross, assists, he runs a lot and does defence too.
The England position is not representative, he's only played a few matches for the national team.

 

mattteo Flag 19 Dec 16 7.25am

Originally posted by Lakeview

Anyone who thinks Chelsea are less than an impressive side probably doesn't know too much about football.

It's not just about Chelsea. Crystal Palace doesn't beat anyone these days. Didn't even beat Hull, who is the last in the league and has the weakest morale.

What did that statistic say about 2016? Crystal has been one of the worst teams from the first 4 leagues, making the least points.
It's an ongoing situation and I attribute it to the policies of the manager, who chose the wrong players in the wrong position and let go of some very good players.

 

mattteo Flag 19 Dec 16 7.32am

Originally posted by Elpis

Kelly and Ward are currently the best two full backs at the club .The problem is they are both right full backs and though neither are any good on the left Ward is less useless than Kelly .

Kelly is obviously lacking confidence ,he is a decent right back who has had his confidence shot after poor games on the left .His early crossing is poor ,he needs to take the ball to the line when he has the chance which he did have on at least two occasions yesterday .


Kelly stands at 1,91. He is not a full back. He can't cross, he isn't fast enough and he has only provided 2 assists in 5.000 Premier League minutes in his entire career.
The man is a center back, he started off as such at Huddersfield Town and was only made to play as a right back by Kenny Daglish (who didn't turn up to be the best manager)

Ward and Souare haven't had 2 crosses turned into assists in a PL season SINCE EVER either!!

 

mattteo Flag 19 Dec 16 7.33am

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Why don't you apply? You certainly seem to know what you're talking about....

Irony aside, thank you.
Where do I apply?

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 19 Dec 16 8.40am

Originally posted by mattteo

It's not just about Chelsea. Crystal Palace doesn't beat anyone these days. Didn't even beat Hull, who is the last in the league and has the weakest morale.

What did that statistic say about 2016? Crystal has been one of the worst teams from the first 4 leagues, making the least points.
It's an ongoing situation and I attribute it to the policies of the manager, who chose the wrong players in the wrong position and let go of some very good players.

It is about Chelsea when you specifically bring them into your argument and insist that just about every pundit/journo is wrong when they say Chelsea appear unstoppable or have no obvious weaknesses.

And if there is one thing Hull have in abundance it is spirit/morale - every player is fighting for his & the club's future which is clear in every game. They were unlucky on Saturday & should have smashed Wet Spam who look like they have a lot less spirit about them.

Finally, concentrate on how poor we've been this season - the calendar year is irrelevant in these situations. Ask Leicester.........

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

mattteo Flag 19 Dec 16 9.43am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

It is about Chelsea when you specifically bring them into your argument and insist that just about every pundit/journo is wrong when they say Chelsea appear unstoppable or have no obvious weaknesses.

And if there is one thing Hull have in abundance it is spirit/morale - every player is fighting for his & the club's future which is clear in every game. They were unlucky on Saturday & should have smashed Wet Spam who look like they have a lot less spirit about them.

Finally, concentrate on how poor we've been this season - the calendar year is irrelevant in these situations. Ask Leicester.........


The calendar year IS relevant. It reveals a situation without exit under Pardew.

Ask Leicester if the calendar year is relevant? They won a PL title. That's relevant to me.

Yeah, I get your point, Leicester and Crystal are kind of tied now, but for them it's just a bad break, while for Palace it's normality

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Dec 16 10.32am

Who should he play? Fryers? A player who's taken two years to earn a place on the bench (I think Fryers has improved massively, but he's not as good defensively as Kelly or Ward).

Kelly is playing because Soare had a terrible car crash, and is a back up. Unsurprisingly, as such he's not as good as a first choice, first 11 every week player.

This is true of all clubs. the players on their bench and back up, are not as good as the first 11. If they were, they'd..... be in the first 11.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 19 Dec 16 11.09am

Originally posted by mattteo


The calendar year IS relevant. It reveals a situation without exit under Pardew.

Ask Leicester if the calendar year is relevant? They won a PL title. That's relevant to me.

Yeah, I get your point, Leicester and Crystal are kind of tied now, but for them it's just a bad break, while for Palace it's normality

Leicester didn't win the title in a calendar year though & prior to last season survived after a real scare. The reality could be that they had a fluke season last time out.

The point is, different season playing a different way with different players against different teams (there's a theme here) means that a calendar year comparison doesn't make sense.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Dec 16 12.14pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

Leicester didn't win the title in a calendar year though & prior to last season survived after a real scare. The reality could be that they had a fluke season last time out.

The point is, different season playing a different way with different players against different teams (there's a theme here) means that a calendar year comparison doesn't make sense.

What a difference a DM makes. Kante without doubt was one of Leicester City's key important players, and that has become very apparent this season just how important he was for them.

Sure Marahez and Vardy were instrumental in the wins but the role that Kante played there, and now at Chelsea shows just how influential and important a quality defensive midfielder is to a team.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

mattteo Flag 19 Dec 16 4.02pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Who should he play? Fryers? A player who's taken two years to earn a place on the bench (I think Fryers has improved massively, but he's not as good defensively as Kelly or Ward).

Kelly is playing because Soare had a terrible car crash, and is a back up. Unsurprisingly, as such he's not as good as a first choice, first 11 every week player.

This is true of all clubs. the players on their bench and back up, are not as good as the first 11. If they were, they'd..... be in the first 11.

It's the manager's job to build the squad. He's been here for such a long time and he's had soo many transfer windows.

He's brought in no wide defenders of value. I don't know about Fryers (of whose bringing Pardew is also responsible), but the other 3 are average or poor, mediocre at best, will never rise higher than this. So what's the point in keeping them? They'd better promote players from the academy.

Selling Dwight Gayle was also a horrendous move by the manager. Not seeing the potential in that player....that's unforgivable

 

mattteo Flag 19 Dec 16 4.05pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

And if there is one thing Hull have in abundance it is spirit/morale - every player is fighting for his & the club's future which is clear in every game. They were unlucky on Saturday & should have smashed Wet Spam who look like they have a lot less spirit about them.


You're mixing morale with determination. They don't have morale because everybody keep defeating them in the Premier League (well, almost everybody )

They might have determination. Most squads do, but without wins you can't have morale

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 19 Dec 16 4.10pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Who should he play? Fryers? A player who's taken two years to earn a place on the bench (I think Fryers has improved massively, but he's not as good defensively as Kelly or Ward).

Kelly is playing because Soare had a terrible car crash, and is a back up. Unsurprisingly, as such he's not as good as a first choice, first 11 every week player.

This is true of all clubs. the players on their bench and back up, are not as good as the first 11. If they were, they'd..... be in the first 11.

In my opinion yes, he should play Fryers now. He is (nearly) ready and we have little option.

It is absolutely true that Kelly is a centre back and not a right back and certainly not a left back. We need to be grateful to him for stepping in, it can't be comfortable. And we need to learn from not signing back up for Souare before his accident. This is the root of the problem.

 

Username Flag Horsham 19 Dec 16 4.34pm

Originally posted by mattteo

It's the manager's job to build the squad. He's been here for such a long time and he's had soo many transfer windows.

He's brought in no wide defenders of value. I don't know about Fryers (of whose bringing Pardew is also responsible), but the other 3 are average or poor, mediocre at best, will never rise higher than this. So what's the point in keeping them? They'd better promote players from the academy.

Selling Dwight Gayle was also a horrendous move by the manager. Not seeing the potential in that player....that's unforgivable

He didn't bring in Fryers? Souare and Tomkins are fine, provided they are actually healthy. One of the biggest problems our back four has faced is how many different combinations we've put out (even with a small pool of players). I don't think you can blame a manager for a car accident.

Gayle? Come on. Benteke has as many goals as Gayle managed in the previous two seasons (in less minutes), and Wickham offers more than Gayle does in open play.

The summer was an unfinished job for sure, but that's definitely been exacerbated by injury.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Aray Flag South London 19 Dec 16 5.12pm

Originally posted by mattteo

But Fryers doesn't play. He only has 100 minutes all season, it's like he's not even considered by Pardew.

Townsend was rubbish cause he's used in the wrong position. Still, he was better than Puncheon. And Zaha was really rubbish against Chelsea too. If I think about it, the entire team was rubbish, I can't name one good player.

Delaney was close to calling an ambulance on grounds that he was old and sick in the 70th minute

Fryers clearly wasn't/isn't up to it. If he was he'd be starting, given the alternative was Kelly.

As for the rest - I thought we played quite good on Saturday. You do realise they're flying, in great form and at top of the league don't you?

 

mattteo Flag 19 Dec 16 8.20pm

Originally posted by Username


Gayle? Come on. Benteke has as many goals as Gayle managed in the previous two seasons (in less minutes), and Wickham offers more than Gayle does in open play.

The summer was an unfinished job for sure, but that's definitely been exacerbated by injury.


DUDE! BODY!!!!! Come on!!!!


I think your problem is only counting goals in matches. WHAT'S IMPORTANT IS THE TIME SPENT ON THE PITCH! You can't say that a player who is on for 80 minutes and one who came on for 10 minutes both played the same 1 match!! And there are sites specialized which can show EXACTLY how much one has played in the pas few years.

Gayle has had 15 goals and 2 assists in 2.700 minutes in the Premier League. Nevermind the Championship and the Cups, where he rocked.

IN the last 2.800 minutes in the PL Benteke has had 17 goals and 4 assists. That MAY seem better than Gayle, but 3 of his goals were penalty kicks, therefore I only leave him at 14 goals and 4 assists in 2.800 minutes, very much as Gayle.
So why does one cost 50 million and the other 5 million?
And before that he had 12 action goals and 2 assists in 2.400 minutes in the PL, not that satisfying.

Anyway, I WAS RIGHT when I told you Gayle is too good to keep on the bench. Now he's gone, he's the star of the Championship, the goalscorer, on his way up with Newcastle and he's wanted by half the Premier League clubs. Good for him! Who lost in this?


Don't even get me started on Wichkam. The guy has 10 goals and 4 assists in the last 4.000 minutes in the PL.
When will Wickham be as fast as Gayle? When will he be better in open play concerning pressing, winning balls, forcing the opposition to play long balls that can be easily recovered? When in this century will Wickham be able to do on the pitch the things Dwight Gayle is capable of?

Newcastle knew this, you don;t

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 19 Dec 16 8.22pm

Originally posted by mattteo


DUDE! BODY!!!!! Come on!!!!


I think your problem is only counting goals in matches. WHAT'S IMPORTANT IS THE TIME SPENT ON THE PITCH! You can't say that a player who is on for 80 minutes and one who came on for 10 minutes both played the same 1 match!! And there are sites specialized which can show EXACTLY how much one has played in the pas few years.

Gayle has had 15 goals and 2 assists in 2.700 minutes in the Premier League. Nevermind the Championship and the Cups, where he rocked.

IN the last 2.800 minutes in the PL Benteke has had 17 goals and 4 assists. That MAY seem better than Gayle, but 3 of his goals were penalty kicks, therefore I only leave him at 14 goals and 4 assists in 2.800 minutes, very much as Gayle.
So why does one cost 50 million and the other 5 million?
And before that he had 12 action goals and 2 assists in 2.400 minutes in the PL, not that satisfying.

Anyway, I WAS RIGHT when I told you Gayle is too good to keep on the bench. Now he's gone, he's the star of the Championship, the goalscorer, on his way up with Newcastle and he's wanted by half the Premier League clubs. Good for him! Who lost in this?


Don't even get me started on Wichkam. The guy has 10 goals and 4 assists in the last 4.000 minutes in the PL.
When will Wickham be as fast as Gayle? When will he be better in open play concerning pressing, winning balls, forcing the opposition to play long balls that can be easily recovered? When in this century will Wickham be able to do on the pitch the things Dwight Gayle is capable of?

Newcastle knew this, you don;t

Yeah but your favourite player is Andros Townsend.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 19 Dec 16 10.18pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Yeah but your favourite player is Andros Townsend.

Gayle always seemed fine when he had some time on the ball. You get more time on the ball in the Championship, and I assume he's not a lone striker again top class CBs.

Gayle would have been great to have on the bench, but he didn't want to sit on the bench. He got many opportunities, but he didn't make the most of them.

Next season he'll have the chance to prove he's prem quality, and prove all the managers who saw him as a bench player wrong.

If he bangs in 15 next season, he'll be able to say "I told you so". If not, he'll be like Murray, a legend in the Championship, but just a good player in the Prem.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 19 Dec 16 10.22pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

In my opinion Kelly was one of our better players yesterday. He was solid in defence and put in 2 or 3 excellent crosses. Ward also looked OK down the left. I have never thought Fryers is perm class but not seen enough of him to judge. Hennessy was at fault for the goal. His position was wrong and should have come for it.

Kelly was excellent

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > If a manager plays Kelly and Ward as fullbacks