You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > New Style v Old Style of play
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

New Style v Old Style of play


cardiff eagle Flag 21 Dec 16 1.16pm

Pardew himself has talked about a transition to a new style of play etc.

Just wondering whether anyone found the "new style" any more fun or interesting than the "old style"? For me, I actually preferred the old style of containing teams then breaking quickly on the attack. That was quite exciting to watch and results wise, far more effective.

For me, the only reason that style wasn't working was that we didn't have the striker to make it work properly. We now have so what's the harm in giving it a go?

 

VKR1888 Flag London 21 Dec 16 1.22pm

Would be a backwards step. As a progressive club wanting to establish ourselves not only in the top league but in the top half we want to be moving to the model that Pardew is going for.

I do believe he has went about it too quickly given the injuries and has also been unlucky at times. We need to just apply ourselves better in the current model and be a bit smarter at times.

I do not like losing but I prefer the open, expansive game when we get it right.

 

cardiff eagle Flag 21 Dec 16 1.24pm

Originally posted by VKR1888

Would be a backwards step. As a progressive club wanting to establish ourselves not only in the top league but in the top half we want to be moving to the model that Pardew is going for.

I do believe he has went about it too quickly given the injuries and has also been unlucky at times. We need to just apply ourselves better in the current model and be a bit smarter at times.

I do not like losing but I prefer the open, expansive game when we get it right.

Interesting- for me, we've been told that to progress we need to play a certain way but I don't believe that's true. Looking at last year, Leicester did the complete opposite and stuck to quick counter attacking football and won the league! And Chelsea are now doing the same!

Edited by cardiff eagle (21 Dec 2016 1.24pm)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 21 Dec 16 1.30pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Interesting- for me, we've been told that to progress we need to play a certain way but I don't believe that's true. Looking at last year, Leicester did the complete opposite and stuck to quick counter attacking football and won the league! And Chelsea are now doing the same!


It's quite likely that there's a lesson to be learnt there.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

JacksonEagle Flag Croydon 21 Dec 16 1.51pm

Atletico Madrid have also managed to successfully use that style of play.. with the players at our disposal i do think it would be more effective, it's clear our defence in particular are not comfortable with this style of play.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 21 Dec 16 2.29pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Pardew himself has talked about a transition to a new style of play etc.

Just wondering whether anyone found the "new style" any more fun or interesting than the "old style"? For me, I actually preferred the old style of containing teams then breaking quickly on the attack. That was quite exciting to watch and results wise, far more effective.

For me, the only reason that style wasn't working was that we didn't have the striker to make it work properly. We now have so what's the harm in giving it a go?

Whatever the style of play is that we are trying to play,the Team is now worse than it was at the end of Pardews first Season.

I agree we did not have the striker last year because of injuries to Wickham.

I would have preferred Bolasie and Zaha on the wings crossing to Murray/Gayle.

But it never happened.


 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Dec 16 2.41pm

I personally think it's more exciting, hardly any possession but when we did get the ball, out to bolasie or Zaha to attack straight away but you are limited and we had to change our system as soon as we sold bolasie. Plus we was useless when teams used to sit back and let us play. Also pretty much every week on here last season people were moaning about us not being able to play through the middle so the majority have got what they wanted.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Dec 16 2.57pm

I think with the players we have the old style was bette.most people were saying all we needed was a decentre centre forward. However we never had a 'plan b' for when this wasn't working. In my opinion all we needed was a decent no.10 to allow us to play through the midele would give us that. If we could break quickly through the middle as well as the wings, (much like Leicester ) we'd be quite a handful..

 

Beastie Flag 21 Dec 16 3.05pm

Swansea came up and played nice football – and now they’re sh*t. It shows that this idea that playing pretty football makes you ‘next level’ and somehow more established in this league is not true.

Attractive football is the icing on the cake and right now, we don’t have a f*cking cake. We don’t pass the ball well, it’s not easy on the eye and we’re scoring more goals by sacrificing the basics. There’s nothing clever or futuristic about that.

It can’t go on like this.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Dec 16 3.11pm

Originally posted by Beastie

Swansea came up and played nice football – and now they’re sh*t. It shows that this idea that playing pretty football makes you ‘next level’ and somehow more established in this league is not true.

Attractive football is the icing on the cake and right now, we don’t have a f*cking cake. We don’t pass the ball well, it’s not easy on the eye and we’re scoring more goals by sacrificing the basics. There’s nothing clever or futuristic about that.

It can’t go on like this.

I think pardews problem is that he wants to change to a more attacking style, but he wants to go toe to toe with every team and we're not good enough for that. He needs to pick the games to do that (a sort of plan b) He's changed that for the last two games and I'm hoping he's had a change of heart. But I'm not convinced that he won't consider Watford an easier game and go for them again.....defining game for Pardew I feel.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Dec 16 3.20pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I think pardews problem is that he wants to change to a more attacking style, but he wants to go toe to toe with every team and we're not good enough for that. He needs to pick the games to do that (a sort of plan b) He's changed that for the last two games and I'm hoping he's had a change of heart. But I'm not convinced that he won't consider Watford an easier game and go for them again.....defining game for Pardew I feel.

Yep.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Dec 16 3.32pm

Originally posted by Beastie

Swansea came up and played nice football – and now they’re sh*t. It shows that this idea that playing pretty football makes you ‘next level’ and somehow more established in this league is not true.

Attractive football is the icing on the cake and right now, we don’t have a f*cking cake. We don’t pass the ball well, it’s not easy on the eye and we’re scoring more goals by sacrificing the basics. There’s nothing clever or futuristic about that.

It can’t go on like this.

I like the way we wait for the oppo to all get behind the ball before we pass it across the back 4 to massage the possession stats.

Expansive? At Home no. Away we leak like a sieve. 2 goals conceded from our own corner in one game, goals conceded minutes after going ahead or getting level in others. 1 player from a dross team walking through 4 players or hopping past a right back (yes right back as well as left back). Yes we all wanted that for ages and super al delivered.

A gradual shift should never have taken us from 2-1 outcomes to 3-2, 4-3, 5-3 every week until a poor on the day Southampton and another c0ck up of a sub v Man Utd that shows how Pardew's mind works yet again.

I hope Parish has been talking to someone and our potential signings are listed with his whilst he's been watching this naive, amateur and desperate gamble for points every week because he doubts his ability to earn any like we doubt him and deservedly so.

 


COYP

SurreyEagle16 Flag Next Door 21 Dec 16 3.37pm

For me, one of the biggest fallacies in football is that playing passing, possession based football is "the right way" to play...and is necessary if you want to be successful.
The success of Barca and Spain over the last decade (which incidentally contain a lot of the same players) made that style en vogue. But as other posters have suggested, there are ample examples of teams in different countries enjoying plenty of success with different styles.
In my opinion, this style of football is very difficult to deploy unless you have very good players relative to your opposition...which we do not at the moment...hence our current plight.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Dec 16 3.41pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Pardew himself has talked about a transition to a new style of play etc.

Just wondering whether anyone found the "new style" any more fun or interesting than the "old style"? For me, I actually preferred the old style of containing teams then breaking quickly on the attack. That was quite exciting to watch and results wise, far more effective.

For me, the only reason that style wasn't working was that we didn't have the striker to make it work properly. We now have so what's the harm in giving it a go?

Totally with you on all of this.

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Dec 16 3.45pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Pardew himself has talked about a transition to a new style of play etc.

Just wondering whether anyone found the "new style" any more fun or interesting than the "old style"?

No. We were highly effective when we defended well and got results, both under Pulis and the first year under Pardew. Getting quality strikers and improving the ball up to them should be adding to that, not replacing it. You don't knock down your ground floor in order to build a loft conversion.

 


============
The Ferret
============

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 21 Dec 16 3.47pm

Originally posted by Beastie

Swansea came up and played nice football – and now they’re sh*t. It shows that this idea that playing pretty football makes you ‘next level’ and somehow more established in this league is not true.

Attractive football is the icing on the cake and right now, we don’t have a f*cking cake.
We don’t pass the ball well, it’s not easy on the eye and we’re scoring more goals by sacrificing the basics. There’s nothing clever or futuristic about that.

It can’t go on like this.

Lovely turn of phrase

I agree with the points that you're making 100%.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Dec 16 3.52pm

Originally posted by Beastie

Swansea came up and played nice football – and now they’re sh*t. It shows that this idea that playing pretty football makes you ‘next level’ and somehow more established in this league is not true.

Attractive football is the icing on the cake and right now, we don’t have a f*cking cake. We don’t pass the ball well, it’s not easy on the eye and we’re scoring more goals by sacrificing the basics. There’s nothing clever or futuristic about that.

It can’t go on like this.

Brilliant.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 21 Dec 16 3.53pm

It's easy to forget that when Pardew was at Reading and in his early days at West Ham he was very route one - remember Briane Deane coming on late in the play off final and the ball continuously launched towards his head from their half? Bit like Holloway he's left route one behind and gone more 'continental' and fallen in love with tactics and big ideas - at times he'd be better off returning to his pragmatic approach, as we've seen lately. He'll play it tight and try and nick a win at Watford. Kevin Day was very scathing of Pardew on Hawkbee and Jacobs the other day - said his recent thumbs up to SP was more embarrassing than the cup final dance, and bringing off Jimmy Mac before United scored didn't impress him either. His words are normally couched more subtly, he reckons there's about three fans left who are pro-Pardew, slight under-estimate.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 21 Dec 16 4.02pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

It's easy to forget that when Pardew was at Reading and in his early days at West Ham he was very route one - remember Briane Deane coming on late in the play off final and the ball continuously launched towards his head from their half? Bit like Holloway he's left route one behind and gone more 'continental' and fallen in love with tactics and big ideas - at times he'd be better off returning to his pragmatic approach, as we've seen lately. He'll play it tight and try and nick a win at Watford. Kevin Day was very scathing of Pardew on Hawkbee and Jacobs the other day - said his recent thumbs up to SP was more embarrassing than the cup final dance, and bringing off Jimmy Mac before United scored didn't impress him either. His words are normally couched more subtly, he reckons there's about three fans left who are pro-Pardew, slight under-estimate.

Absolutely; there's at least four on here

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Inapickle Flag South West 27 Dec 16 12.43am

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Interesting- for me, we've been told that to progress we need to play a certain way but I don't believe that's true. Looking at last year, Leicester did the complete opposite and stuck to quick counter attacking football and won the league! And Chelsea are now doing the same!

Edited by cardiff eagle (21 Dec 2016 1.24pm)

..Kanté.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > New Style v Old Style of play