You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is a new penalty taker needed ?
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is a new penalty taker needed ?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Hilaire44 Flag Southern England 27 Dec 16 9.36am

From listening to Big Sam's press conf yesterday it looks like Benteke might be relieved of his penalty taking duties pretty swift. He referred to Mark Noble who's only missed 1 out of about 27, pretty consistent!!....i think Noble is in the style of make your decision, run up to the ball and hit it low and hard into either corner, its not rocket science!!
Pardew mentioned in a previous interview that he spoke with Benteke after the last miss and they had a "difference of opinion" of how a penalty should be taken, that suggests to me that Benteke wont be told what to do and wont change his style for anyone, maybe that's the arrogance you get from a 32 million pound player?
Something tells me Big Sam wont put up with that!!!

 

Mad4palace Flag 27 Dec 16 10.08am

Time to reinstate Puncheon to the duties? He cannot never take a penalty again because of one horror miss.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 27 Dec 16 10.13am

there seems to be two threads now on the same subject, but all are agreed that it was a crap penalty and a change in taker is needed. I would be happy with JP or maybe Wilf or Townsend. he has a good boot.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 27 Dec 16 11.03am

It wouldn't surprise me if its in Benteke's contract that he takes the penalties.

 


Bring back Brolin

stateside Flag Norfolk 27 Dec 16 11.15am

Who ever takes a penalty at least one player should follow up and get any rebound , They just did not move, I think that was worse than the bad penalty .

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 27 Dec 16 12.23pm

Quote

Presumably he can hit a ball hard and accurately therefore he should be able to put it where the keeper can't get to it in time whether he guesses correctly or not. The technique he's using just now is easily dealt with: the keeper jsut stays put whilst he fartarses about before hitting the ball.

Whom else have we got? Cabaye has a history of fluffing penalties. Puncheon for putting them in Row Z. Townsend probably try to be a wise guy as well. Campbell has that issue with banjos and cows' arses. Wilf?

I thought Cabaye had a fairly good record with penalties?

Scored 16 out of 18. Surely that's a good return?

[Link]

Benteke on is 11 with 5 misses!!

[Link]

Cayabe is missing one in nine and Benteke is missing one in three.

This should not even be a discussion.

Cayabe is back on penalties, surely ???


Edited by Goldfiinger (27 Dec 2016 12.24pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Dec 16 12.29pm

In training Hennessey is a brilliant penalty taker but alas we cannot afford to have our keeper take a penalty which is saved and then the opposition break away !!!!

 

chateauferret Flag 27 Dec 16 12.58pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Quote

Presumably he can hit a ball hard and accurately therefore he should be able to put it where the keeper can't get to it in time whether he guesses correctly or not. The technique he's using just now is easily dealt with: the keeper jsut stays put whilst he fartarses about before hitting the ball.

Whom else have we got? Cabaye has a history of fluffing penalties. Puncheon for putting them in Row Z. Townsend probably try to be a wise guy as well. Campbell has that issue with banjos and cows' arses. Wilf?

I thought Cabaye had a fairly good record with penalties?

Scored 16 out of 18. Surely that's a good return?

[Link]

Benteke on is 11 with 5 misses!!

[Link]

Cayabe is missing one in nine and Benteke is missing one in three.

This should not even be a discussion.

Cayabe is back on penalties, surely ???


Edited by Goldfiinger (27 Dec 2016 12.24pm)

But Cabaye bottled his last two, against Newcastle and against Bournemouth. That suggests to me that he might have been good at it once but has now lost it, maybe teporarily.

We are out of the cup if we get taken to penalties so lots of folk need to be practicing the things.

Edited by chateauferret (27 Dec 2016 12.59pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 27 Dec 16 1.48pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

But Cabaye bottled his last two, against Newcastle and against Bournemouth. That suggests to me that he might have been good at it once but has now lost it, maybe teporarily.

We are out of the cup if we get taken to penalties so lots of folk need to be practicing the things.

Edited by chateauferret (27 Dec 2016 12.59pm)

And his penalty against Reading in the Cup last season didn't deserve a goal.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 27 Dec 16 1.50pm

Yes and his name is Glen Murray! His penalty v. QPR just now was a model of how it should be done, the keeper didn't move.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 27 Dec 16 2.39pm

Benteke's effort on Monday was crap.

When the pressure is on during a match we are in dire need of a a reliable penalty taker having them saved is costing us dear.

Jedinak was one such character we now need another how about Jimmy Mac, Joel Ward, Wilf, Andros or Punch? All got good shots on them.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Dec 16 2.52am

Originally posted by chateauferret

But Cabaye bottled his last two, against Newcastle and against Bournemouth. That suggests to me that he might have been good at it once but has now lost it, maybe teporarily.

We are out of the cup if we get taken to penalties so lots of folk need to be practicing the things.

Edited by chateauferret (27 Dec 2016 12.59pm)

So he missed two penalties, his stats show he's very good at pens and yet people over look that becuase he missed two.

If Aguero misses two pens back to back do you think he'd all of a sudden forgotten where the goal is? s*** happens but he's got pedigree at pens and as far as I can see Benteke hasn't.

Stats say hes by far a better penalty taker than Benteke.

Not sure why so many people seem to think he shouldn't be taking them.


Edited by Goldfiinger (28 Dec 2016 2.54am)

 

timbob Flag 28 Dec 16 3.49am

Wilf is your man or MacArthur

Have we sacked the tw..t of a goal keeping coach yet?

He would be challenging BFS for the greggs pies..!

Who is Benteke practising against re pens ? Not sure Hennessy is that great a pen stopper of course Jules was back in the day..!

I know it's unsporting but two seasons ago we won so many pens and scored there needs to be more emphasis on this and taking our time in choosing who to take them etc Benteke was puffed out and clearly not settled prior to taking that pen if you gonna pull that trick you need to be calm centred and in control to unsettle the keeper...surely

Sam is great at prep so I have faith that this will be well sorted by the we visit the ass at 'The library'
Coyp

R.i.p Staffie

 

dmendenhall_9 Flag 28 Dec 16 3.52am

Our penalty taking has been awful and is one of the reasons we are in a relegation battle. League average is 87% and we are at 40%.

Screen Shot 2016-12-27 at 4.28.45 PM.png Attachment: Screen Shot 2016-12-27 at 4.28.45 PM.png (97.39Kb)

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 28 Dec 16 10.31am

I think we need to buy Noble or Lampard to solved our problems

 

Part Time James Flag 28 Dec 16 10.42am

Jason Puncheon gets my vote.

 




jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 11.17am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

The answer the OPs question the answer is yes. It's a ridiculous way to take a penalty unless you are any good at it and I'm sorry but Benteke isn't.

The problem is, is that when you stutter like that it's then difficult to a) get any power on the penalty and b) it's easy for the goalkeeper to read your body language.

Either change the taker or get Benteke to change his style.

Its a classic dilemma, the stutter gives you an idea of which way the keeper will go, but it also makes it easier for a keeper to tell which way you'll go. And Gomes is an excellent penalty saver (at around 33%), he moves first.

Problem of course with lashing it, is that you're more likely to miss (ala West Ham) or hit the post (or simply go down the middle - probably your best bet as you never see a keeper standing still). Of course if you lash them all down the middle, they will.

But you always, have to try to get it towards the posts.... not just to the keepers left or right....

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 28 Dec 16 11.18am

Anyone but Benteke. He will only score 50% of pens at best the way he takes them. If the keeper guesses right he saves it.
I think Puncheons bottles gone following the Spurs pen. Cabaye also seems to have lost it although as someone has pointed out his stats are reasonable. I would prefer Cabaye over Benteke any day.
They will all be practicing them in training judging by the look on Sam's face when he missed it.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 11.18am

Originally posted by Uphill

Yes and his name is Glen Murray! His penalty v. QPR just now was a model of how it should be done, the keeper didn't move.

His penalty against Millwall for us, could have taken out the corner flag.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Dec 16 11.20am

Can you refuse a penalty?

Thanks ref but we'd rather get on with the game...

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is a new penalty taker needed ?