You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Substituting Cabaye against Arsenal kills the team
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Substituting Cabaye against Arsenal kills the team


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
mattteo Flag 01 Jan 17 6.14pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Sure you do...


I do actually. I can name you over 100 players that would cost less than 10 million and would improve the Crystal Palace side this winter.

But you wouldn't understand anyway....

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 01 Jan 17 6.16pm

Originally posted by stateside

With the players fit Sam did OK , Wilf had a stinker yet again against a top 6 team, he just is not good enough against the class players , lost the ball so many times , his tricks dont work against the class teams.
But lets hope against Swansea he can do the magic.

Agree totally, lost the ball on numerous occasions trying to beat players when a pass and move was the correct option.We were terrible today,Sam must be luckier than Alan,as a lot of those chances for Arsenal would have ended up in the back of the net under Pardew.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 01 Jan 17 6.17pm

Originally posted by mattteo


I do actually. I can name you over 100 players that would cost less than 10 million and would improve the Crystal Palace side this winter.

But you wouldn't understand anyway....

Go on

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 01 Jan 17 6.18pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

Agree totally, lost the ball on numerous occasions trying to beat players when a pass and move was the correct option.We were terrible today,Sam must be luckier than Alan,as a lot of those chances for Arsenal would have ended up in the back of the net under Pardew.

Yeah , real lucky when Giroud stuck a leg up and it flew in the top corner .

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 01 Jan 17 6.20pm

Originally posted by mattteo


I do actually. I can name you over 100 players that would cost less than 10 million and would improve the Crystal Palace side this winter.

But you wouldn't understand anyway....

Riiight! Sure you can.

Is that your list of scouted players on Football Manager? You know that's not real life, right?

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

mattteo Flag 01 Jan 17 6.32pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Riiight! Sure you can.

Is that your list of scouted players on Football Manager? You know that's not real life, right?

Hah.

So, what will you do if I name them?

You'll just say that they're cheap and bad, that they're past their prime, that they aren't good enough.
I'd have to make this overly long post to explain why and how for any of those players and it would take me a really long time.

But the truth is that there are close to 200 players that could improve a Premier League squad AT THIS MOMENT and they are A BARGAIN

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 01 Jan 17 6.39pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Hah.

So, what will you do if I name them?

You'll just say that they're cheap and bad, that they're past their prime, that they aren't good enough.
I'd have to make this overly long post to explain why and how for any of those players and it would take me a really long time.

But the truth is that there are close to 200 players that could improve a Premier League squad AT THIS MOMENT and they are A BARGAIN

I wait with bated breath for you to copy and paste from the FIFA website, I'm sure it'll be an exciting read.

Good to see the anti-Pardew group start getting narky after two games though. Enjoy that greener grass because I hated watching that shocking 6-4-0 formation.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 01 Jan 17 6.46pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Hah.

So, what will you do if I name them?

You'll just say that they're cheap and bad, that they're past their prime, that they aren't good enough.
I'd have to make this overly long post to explain why and how for any of those players and it would take me a really long time.

But the truth is that there are close to 200 players that could improve a Premier League squad AT THIS MOMENT and they are A BARGAIN

So far you've claimed "Even I know all the players in the Premier League and the Championship and what foot they kick the ball with."

You've also claimed "I can name you over 100 players that would cost less than 10 million and would improve the Crystal Palace side this winter." Is that collectively 10 million, or 10 million each? I assume it's the latter, but if it is the former I am impressed.

Finally you claimed "But the truth is that there are close to 200 players that could improve a Premier League squad AT THIS MOMENT and they are A BARGAIN."

Those are some impressive claims. So, will you provide a screen shot from your save game, or will you type it up?

As Southampton Eagle said, you could always just copy and paste it from one of the many football websites. It's entirely up to you.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Kieranemm Flag Towcester 01 Jan 17 6.49pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Hah.

So, what will you do if I name them?

You'll just say that they're cheap and bad, that they're past their prime, that they aren't good enough.
I'd have to make this overly long post to explain why and how for any of those players and it would take me a really long time.

But the truth is that there are close to 200 players that could improve a Premier League squad AT THIS MOMENT and they are A BARGAIN

Ok I challenge you to name just 3 players out of these 200 odd players you think we could buy for under 10 million each that would improve our squad, with justifications?

We can then email it to big Sam.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 01 Jan 17 6.50pm

Originally posted by Kieranemm

Ok I challenge you to name just 3 players out of these 200 odd players you think we could buy for under 10 million each that would improve our squad, with justifications?

We can then email it to big Sam.

We might have to wait, as the load times for the full Football Manager database are quite long.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

vflynn Flag Perth 01 Jan 17 6.57pm

...............loading........................

 


"If you wana get ahead............Get a hat.....
Malcom Allison 1975-76 the glory year.

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 01 Jan 17 7.10pm

Originally posted by mattteo


I do actually. I can name you over 100 players that would cost less than 10 million and would improve the Crystal Palace side this winter.

But you wouldn't understand anyway....

2/10 for trolling

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

speediej Flag Northampton 01 Jan 17 7.12pm

Probably resting them for the must win game against Swansea? Realised we were shocking and knew we were going to lose so looked forward? Just a thought?

 


COYP

peterg Flag Anerley 01 Jan 17 7.15pm

Originally posted by speediej

Probably resting them for the must win game against Swansea? Realised we were shocking and knew we were going to lose so looked forward? Just a thought?

Resting them must have been on his mind - in his post-match interview he complained that Palace had only two days to recover before the Swansea match, whereas Swansea get three. It's well-known that top sportsmen and women need a three-day recovery period after matches like today's.

 


The right place at the right time

lefty27 Flag ipswich 01 Jan 17 7.19pm

Originally posted by speediej

Probably resting them for the must win game against Swansea? Realised we were shocking and knew we were going to lose so looked forward? Just a thought?

Correct, we were never getting anything out of this game, it was done at 2-0. Tuesday is more important, thought chungy looked OK when he came on.

 

mattteo Flag 01 Jan 17 7.26pm

GK: Vorm, Ruffier, Ochoa, M'bolhi (but not necessarily Palace's weak spot as Mandanda is world class)

RB: Weiser, Janmaat, Figueiras, Layun, Yedlin, Smolnikov, A. Vidal, Esgaio

CB: Ginter, Mbemba, Federico Fernandez, Caceres, Papadopoulos, Cristian Zapata, Abdennour (would cost more than 10 mil, but is behind Mangala and Garay at Valencia and they might sell), M. Sakho, Rakitsky, Nkoulou, Bastos, Kabasele

LB: Gibs, Rausch, Brady, Ali Adnan, Plattenhardt, Antonelli, Coentrao, C. Erkin, A. Moreno, Augustinsson, L. Ibanez, Jefferson

DM/ CM: Pascal Gross, Hiljemark, Giaccherini, M. Fernandez, Onazi, Jozabed, H. Herrera, van Ginkel, Rupp, Rode, Bertolacci, Poli, B. Cesar (Benfica, also qualifies as left back and left wing), Muntari, Koziello, de Guzman, R. Pardo

Right footed winger: Depay, Hermann, Deulofeu, Njie, Mina, Canos, M. Niang (Milan want to sell for disciplinary reasons), Ntep, Susaeta, Samperio, Khazri, Younes (Ajax), Carillo, Carlos Mane , Ola John (but you'll just go "what? he's in the Championship playing for a bad team and injured", A. Bueno

Left footed winger: Ben Arfa, P. Sarabia, I. Falque, G. Tore, Kishna, Refaelov, Toral, Didavi, M. Gonzalez, C. Vela, Rebic, H. Costa, Alessandrini, Melgarejo, Ozbiliz, Raphina (not the Barcelona one, the one playing in Portugal), Cornet, Cartabia, Cheryshev, J. Murphy (Norwich- they play the right footed twin but not the left footed one, who is, in my opinion, even better), Atsu, R. Alvarez, Berghuis, Hernani, Medeiros, Quintero

Second striker: El Shaarawy, Stindl, Junuzovic, E. Vargas, Marega, Niasse (Everton want him out for disciplinary reasons), S. Long, Iturbe, Taison, Vydra, L. Vibe, Afobe, Dicko, Araujo

Striker: N. Petersen, D. Zapata, Muriel, P. Cisse, O. Martins, D. Pabon, Ighalo, Gestede, A. Ramos, Locadia, Karelis, Emenike, G. Hooper, Enrich, Baston, Aggiretxe

All of the above either don't play as starters anymore or play as starters in teams that have problems and are willing to sell for a fee less that what they would deserve. All of the above are accomplished to a level. Now I can't compare a rising sensation like Santi Mina of Valencia with Hermann of Moenchengladbach. But Santi Mina has scored and assisted 18 times in his last 3.300 minutes in La Liga. That's promising.
You will say that even Derby wants Vydra out because he doesn't score and that Ben Arfa has been in the Premier League and hasn't confirmed and neither had Iturbe.

Then I'd have to make a long post about how Vydra scored and assisted 29 in the 12/13 Championship edition and 23 times in the 14/15 Championship edition. He's just going through a tough period and, notice, he's not that high on the list, but his assets like pressing and recovering put him there.
Then, I'd have to explain how Iturbe only played 50 minutes in the Premier League and that if you don't give someone time then you can't judge that player.

And I'd have to tell you that Ben Arfa scored and assisted 27 times in 4.900 minutes and that is better than most attacking midfielders who play in mid-table if not high-ranking teams and he is in no way a Newcastle flop even though pundits have characterized him as such. And last year he almost took Nice to first place in France after Newcastle tossed him away. And this year Unay Emery will also throw him away. He was a free transfer so I doubt they'd be asking for much. At the amounts they have, they probably don't even care for 2-3 millions and would let him go on a free if someone would just support his wages.


And all this is disregarding the players who would cost around 15-20 millions, but would most probably decline to come to Palace, like Aurier, Gonzalo Castro, Matuidi, Ward Prowse, Robben, Tadic, Ghezal, Immobile, Bas Dost.


And here I wasted 10 minutes of my time to write this for some unfaithful who won't even understand what I'm talking about.......

Little is your faith people! I know all this and much more, but if I don't have the audience to discuss.......why bother?

Edited by mattteo (01 Jan 2017 7.29pm)

Edited by mattteo (01 Jan 2017 7.30pm)

Edited by mattteo (01 Jan 2017 7.32pm)

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 01 Jan 17 7.45pm

Originally posted by soulboy

Can I have some of what you are smoking??

I thought Townsend was playing for Arsenal...number of errors he made

Funny I thought he had a s***e game too.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 01 Jan 17 7.58pm

Originally posted by mattteo

GK: Vorm, Ruffier, Ochoa, M'bolhi (but not necessarily Palace's weak spot as Mandanda is world class)

RB: Weiser, Janmaat, Figueiras, Layun, Yedlin, Smolnikov, A. Vidal, Esgaio

CB: Ginter, Mbemba, Federico Fernandez, Caceres, Papadopoulos, Cristian Zapata, Abdennour (would cost more than 10 mil, but is behind Mangala and Garay at Valencia and they might sell), M. Sakho, Rakitsky, Nkoulou, Bastos, Kabasele

LB: Gibs, Rausch, Brady, Ali Adnan, Plattenhardt, Antonelli, Coentrao, C. Erkin, A. Moreno, Augustinsson, L. Ibanez, Jefferson

DM/ CM: Pascal Gross, Hiljemark, Giaccherini, M. Fernandez, Onazi, Jozabed, H. Herrera, van Ginkel, Rupp, Rode, Bertolacci, Poli, B. Cesar (Benfica, also qualifies as left back and left wing), Muntari, Koziello, de Guzman, R. Pardo

Right footed winger: Depay, Hermann, Deulofeu, Njie, Mina, Canos, M. Niang (Milan want to sell for disciplinary reasons), Ntep, Susaeta, Samperio, Khazri, Younes (Ajax), Carillo, Carlos Mane , Ola John (but you'll just go "what? he's in the Championship playing for a bad team and injured", A. Bueno

Left footed winger: Ben Arfa, P. Sarabia, I. Falque, G. Tore, Kishna, Refaelov, Toral, Didavi, M. Gonzalez, C. Vela, Rebic, H. Costa, Alessandrini, Melgarejo, Ozbiliz, Raphina (not the Barcelona one, the one playing in Portugal), Cornet, Cartabia, Cheryshev, J. Murphy (Norwich- they play the right footed twin but not the left footed one, who is, in my opinion, even better), Atsu, R. Alvarez, Berghuis, Hernani, Medeiros, Quintero

Second striker: El Shaarawy, Stindl, Junuzovic, E. Vargas, Marega, Niasse (Everton want him out for disciplinary reasons), S. Long, Iturbe, Taison, Vydra, L. Vibe, Afobe, Dicko, Araujo

Striker: N. Petersen, D. Zapata, Muriel, P. Cisse, O. Martins, D. Pabon, Ighalo, Gestede, A. Ramos, Locadia, Karelis, Emenike, G. Hooper, Enrich, Baston, Aggiretxe

All of the above either don't play as starters anymore or play as starters in teams that have problems and are willing to sell for a fee less that what they would deserve. All of the above are accomplished to a level. Now I can't compare a rising sensation like Santi Mina of Valencia with Hermann of Moenchengladbach. But Santi Mina has scored and assisted 18 times in his last 3.300 minutes in La Liga. That's promising.
You will say that even Derby wants Vydra out because he doesn't score and that Ben Arfa has been in the Premier League and hasn't confirmed and neither had Iturbe.

Then I'd have to make a long post about how Vydra scored and assisted 29 in the 12/13 Championship edition and 23 times in the 14/15 Championship edition. He's just going through a tough period and, notice, he's not that high on the list, but his assets like pressing and recovering put him there.
Then, I'd have to explain how Iturbe only played 50 minutes in the Premier League and that if you don't give someone time then you can't judge that player.

And I'd have to tell you that Ben Arfa scored and assisted 27 times in 4.900 minutes and that is better than most attacking midfielders who play in mid-table if not high-ranking teams and he is in no way a Newcastle flop even though pundits have characterized him as such. And last year he almost took Nice to first place in France after Newcastle tossed him away. And this year Unay Emery will also throw him away. He was a free transfer so I doubt they'd be asking for much. At the amounts they have, they probably don't even care for 2-3 millions and would let him go on a free if someone would just support his wages.


And all this is disregarding the players who would cost around 15-20 millions, but would most probably decline to come to Palace, like Aurier, Gonzalo Castro, Matuidi, Ward Prowse, Robben, Tadic, Ghezal, Immobile, Bas Dost.


And here I wasted 10 minutes of my time to write this for some unfaithful who won't even understand what I'm talking about.......

Little is your faith people! I know all this and much more, but if I don't have the audience to discuss.......why bother?

Edited by mattteo (01 Jan 2017 7.29pm)

Edited by mattteo (01 Jan 2017 7.30pm)

Edited by mattteo (01 Jan 2017 7.32pm)


Im not going to lie, I do not know every single player on this list but firstly the majority of these players would cost way more than 10 mil and would high wage bills.

Secondly many of these players would not leave their current clubs just because they are not starting every week

Thirdly if you are talking about Robbie Brady, he is not even a left back, he is a sh*t winger who Norwich are currently playing in that position and seen as you seemto be so agaisnt playing Townsend on the right and Kelly at left back, this suggestion doesn't really make sense

Fourthly, many of these players are not improvements on the players that we already have

Fithly, I doubt that this isn't just copied and pasted from fifa or an article

There are some good players on this list who I agree would do well at Palace but saying that we have poor players in our team so we should get rid of them all and build a new team cos there are 200 better players does not make sense, the world does not work that way. But you sould email this list to big Sam because I'm sure he hasn't got any idea of who he wants to buy.

 

mattteo Flag 01 Jan 17 8.24pm

Originally posted by Shifty97


Im not going to lie, I do not know every single player on this list but firstly the majority of these players would cost way more than 10 mil and would high wage bills.

Secondly many of these players would not leave their current clubs just because they are not starting every week

Thirdly if you are talking about Robbie Brady, he is not even a left back, he is a sh*t winger who Norwich are currently playing in that position and seen as you seemto be so agaisnt playing Townsend on the right and Kelly at left back, this suggestion doesn't really make sense

Fourthly, many of these players are not improvements on the players that we already have

Fithly, I doubt that this isn't just copied and pasted from fifa or an article

There are some good players on this list who I agree would do well at Palace but saying that we have poor players in our team so we should get rid of them all and build a new team cos there are 200 better players does not make sense, the world does not work that way. But you sould email this list to big Sam because I'm sure he hasn't got any idea of who he wants to buy.

I NEVER said the club should buy them all. It's a list of unhappy players, who COULD be tempted into coming and from clubs who might actually sell them cheapER than the modern, average prices in England.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 01 Jan 17 8.26pm

Originally posted by mattteo

I NEVER said the club should buy them all. It's a list of unhappy players, who COULD be tempted into coming and from clubs who might actually sell them cheapER than the modern, average prices in England.

How do you know that they are unhappy?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Substituting Cabaye against Arsenal kills the team