You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player Ratings v Swansea
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player Ratings v Swansea


Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Tez Flag Epsom 04 Jan 17 8.23am


Hennessey 4 - Should have saved the second goal. Has the vocal leadership of a mouse.

Kelly 2 - Out of his depth. Can't cross to save his life, can't defend to save his life.

Tomkins 2 - Scared to pass out from the back. Was responsible for giving the ball away constantly.

Delaney 3 - Only got a higher score than Tomkins because in the second half he actually tried to pass the ball on the floor.

Ward 3 - Get's slated a lot but he's playing out of position. Tried to get forward in the second half and put in a few good passes and crosses.

Ledley 2 - Completely anonymous.

Cabaye 5 - On the ball he was one of our only positives, didn't go hiding and always wanted to receive the ball. On the negative side he misplaced plenty of passes and he can't tackle or mark.

Townsend 1 - Awful.

Puncheon 1 - See Townsend.

Zaha 6 - First half was anonymous played out of position. Second half a lot better on the right.

Benteke 1 - Coward. And s***. Sell to China.

SUBS:

Campbell 4 - At least he tries. Still s*** though. We played better football when we stopped hoofing it to Benteke. He caused their defence some problems with his tireless closing down.

Sako 6 - Good effort from free kick, some good crosses, infinitely better than Townsend.

Mutch N/A - Did he touch the ball?

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 04 Jan 17 8.57am

A bit overly negative I think with some of them. Maybe your forgetting the difference in the second half?

This is how the Mirror rated us last night, something a bit more level headed than your ratings look...

Hennessey 6 - Wales goalkeeper wrong-footed for for Mawson goal. Good save from Cork

Kelly 5 - Given rough ride by Sigurdsson. Did not get forward

Delaney 6 - Torrid return to action for Palace captain after suspension against Llorente

Tomkins 5 - Not as good as Scott Dann. Lacks physical presence at the back

Ward 6 - Got to grips with Routledge as the match wore on. Palace’s best defender

Ledley 6 - Was the sole holding midfielder in chaotic first half. Needed more help

Townsend 5 - Apart from one first-half run, just did not get in the game. Subbed off

Puncheon 5 - Failed to produce anything in crucial role behind central striker

Cabaye 5 - Played deeper in second half to protect his back four. Needs possession to play

Zaha 7 - Frustrating final appearance before stunning volley

Benteke 5 - Borderline penalty appeal after hurdling Fabianski. Subbed at break

 

Hansy Flag 04 Jan 17 9.01am

No one deserved a rating except for Zaha, Campbell, Sako and Cabaye. 6 for all those 4.

We need some good investment this month to turn this season around.

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 04 Jan 17 9.05am

Yes but they were tired poor darlings, some even played 90 minutes of football on Sunday.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 04 Jan 17 9.05am

Originally posted by steven_t92

A bit overly negative I think with some of them. Maybe your forgetting the difference in the second half?

This is how the Mirror rated us last night, something a bit more level headed than your ratings look...

Hennessey 6 - Wales goalkeeper wrong-footed for for Mawson goal. Good save from Cork

Kelly 5 - Given rough ride by Sigurdsson. Did not get forward

Delaney 6 - Torrid return to action for Palace captain after suspension against Llorente

Tomkins 5 - Not as good as Scott Dann. Lacks physical presence at the back

Ward 6 - Got to grips with Routledge as the match wore on. Palace’s best defender

Ledley 6 - Was the sole holding midfielder in chaotic first half. Needed more help

Townsend 5 - Apart from one first-half run, just did not get in the game. Subbed off

Puncheon 5 - Failed to produce anything in crucial role behind central striker

Cabaye 5 - Played deeper in second half to protect his back four. Needs possession to play

Zaha 7 - Frustrating final appearance before stunning volley

Benteke 5 - Borderline penalty appeal after hurdling Fabianski. Subbed at break

Ran quicker when subbed off than he did all match - I read on facebook last night someone saying he should make a public apology for that performance - i make them right

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 04 Jan 17 9.24am

Originally posted by Hansy

No one deserved a rating except for Zaha, Campbell, Sako and Cabaye. 6 for all those 4.

We need some good investment this month to turn this season around.

Yeah but who wants to come here, ? It has to be someone on the rise and hungry and not expensive flops like Townsend, tbh any of the fringe players like chungy sako mutch are worth a place in front of Townsend imho, I hope BFS can tempt the right players to come here, benteke to China 40m ? Oh yes please.

 

Part Time James Flag 04 Jan 17 9.27am

Do we only do player ratings when it's all gone t*ts up? I don't remember seeing player ratings posted on here when we've played well.

Maybe I just can't remember us playing well

 




Part Time James Flag 04 Jan 17 9.31am

Originally posted by collier row eagle

Yes but they were tired poor darlings, some even played 90 minutes of football on Sunday.

Exactly. Said something similar on another thread. They are professionals who only play football for their living and are surrounded by other professionals in terms of coaches, physios, fitness experts and of course facilities (which I concede may not be as good as some other Premier League clubs but they are a lot better than you and I would be privy to after we played a game of football in the park). I don't know if I blame the players, because I don't know if the players have used it as an excuse (not watched any post match interviews) but anyone using it as an excuse is letting them off the hook way too much.

 




20 Spaces Isnt Enoug Flag Bolton 04 Jan 17 9.32am

Originally posted by Part Time James

Do we only do player ratings when it's all gone t*ts up? I don't remember seeing player ratings posted on here when we've played well.

Maybe I just can't remember us playing well


And that would have been on .........

 

paperhat Flag croydon 04 Jan 17 9.34am

Originally posted by Part Time James

Exactly. Said something similar on another thread. They are professionals who only play football for their living and are surrounded by other professionals in terms of coaches, physios, fitness experts and of course facilities (which I concede may not be as good as some other Premier League clubs but they are a lot better than you and I would be privy to after we played a game of football in the park). I don't know if I blame the players, because I don't know if the players have used it as an excuse (not watched any post match interviews) but anyone using it as an excuse is letting them off the hook way too much.

They must have run their hearts out against Watford then because from what i saw at the arsenal game, none of em put a shift in there either.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


CJr94 Flag Holmesdale Road 04 Jan 17 10.11am

Originally posted by Hansy

No one deserved a rating except for Zaha, Campbell, Sako and Cabaye. 6 for all those 4.

We need some good investment this month to turn this season around.

Don't even think he deserved one tbh. He was piss poor. Brilliant goal, but that doesn't redeem him.

Campbell & Sako were the only two who even deserve a rating.

 

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 04 Jan 17 1.47pm

Hennessey 5 (Poor communication)
Kelly 5 (Not his worst game to be honest)
Tomkins 4 (Very ordinary)
Delaney 5 (Didn't do much wrong but not much right either)
Ward 3 (Poor performance not helped by the fans abuse and wrong position)
Townsend 0 (A complete waste of space)
Cabaye 5 (Tried his hardest, but poor passing)
Puncheon 0 (Completely negative)
Ledley 4 (Sideways and backwards)
Zaha 7 (Just for the 2nd half and a great goal)
Benteke 2 (Totally ineffective and no movement whatsoever)
Sako 6 (Worked hard and quite effective on the ball)
Much 0 (What is the point of having him on the pitch)
Allardyce 4 (Chose the wrong team)

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 04 Jan 17 4.10pm

I'm not quite sure what else is expected of Benteke when the only way he touches the ball is from passes 50 meters out. The percentages are not in your favor and doing so even makes the Swansea defenders look world class. Its mind numbing to watch..

 

cpj Flag Kent 04 Jan 17 4.36pm

Hennessey 5
Kelly 4
Tomkins 5
Delaney 5
Ward 5
Ledley 4
Cabaye 6
Puncheon 2
Zaha 5
Townsend 4
Benteke 4

Campbell 5
Sako 6

 

Badadmcmad Flag Leeds 04 Jan 17 4.38pm

Hen - 6 could have done better for the second, but it's not an uncommon mistake for any keeper.

Kelly - 2 only for the cross that lead to the goal and a couple of balls into the box that we got on the end of. Otherwise a complete plane crash of a performance in every respect. Way out of position and played Rangel onside for the second

Delaney - 5 solid enough, not much got through, but didn't organise/command those effectively around him

Tompkins - 5 looks like an average defender, needs more game time.

Ward - 5 battled and looked to get forward, but is guilty of over committing occasionally.

Cabaye - 5 not an influence as a holding midfielder - far better pushed up the pitch as at Watford. Created the goal with a good long ball to Campbell.

Puncheon - 4 cannot be played with Cabaye as they both play a similar role. As a result looked lost. He is an expert in counter attacking and works best with three genuine outlets in front of him (Murray, Bolasie, Zaha). If he's pushed deeper and is not the main playmaker, he looks lost.

Ledley - 5 does his job but cannot do it alone. Cannot rely on Cabaye and Puncheon to be disciplined enough to do the simple/dirty work and so ends up trying to cover too much ground.

Zaha - 7 as our best player he needs to be on the right, or given the freedom to switch wings more often to get in the game. Second half he was great. Strength, determination and aggression. Got to the byline, put crosses in and scored a great goal. But for the first half, would have scored higher.

Townsend - 3 a complete enigma. All the ability, but seems to play his own game. Charged around like a headless chicken most of the time when he needed to keep the team's shape. Needs to be managed better to get him on the same wavelenght as the rest of the twam.

Benteke - 4 very isolated and which reflected his poor showing. Needs service or players closer to him who know how to play off him to be more effective.

Campbell - 6 gave it a go but is light weight and is really a poacher first and foremost.

Sako - 6 gave us more of a threat although looks cumbersome.

Allardyce 3 - needs to get up to speed fast as games and points are passing us by.

 


D'oh!

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 04 Jan 17 4.47pm

Originally posted by paperhat

Ran quicker when subbed off than he did all match - I read on facebook last night someone saying he should make a public apology for that performance - i make them right

To be fair to Townsend the whole team should make a public apology for the performance last night. Apart from one sublime finish from Zaha there is very little to enthuse about.

 

cpj Flag Kent 04 Jan 17 4.54pm

Worrying if Benteke is out for any time. OK, he doesn't move about much and Campbell does, but Campbell has had just 2 shots in 113 minutes on the pitch this season. I know a lot of that has been a few minutes here and there, but still not exactly encouraging. I'd still like to know where Appiah is as he was in the 25 and was back in training in October so ought to be fit.

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 04 Jan 17 9.11pm

Hennessey 6 He wasn't amazing but dealt with some of the balls, shame i felt he could have done better for the 2nd goal.

Kelly 2 I think he is a real weak link and most teams know this. He does try but makes too many errors time and time again.

Tomkins 4 I didn't think much of the side and back passing for 60 mins and he was spineless at trying to make a difference for 60 or so mins but I think that he is a good player in general.

Delaney 5 I thought he could have done better like most the others.

Ward 6 Needs to play in his correct position and concentrate on game not 'supposed' supporters. I feel his heart is with CPFC though and tries every game even with mistakes. I hope he finds his top form again as I think he is a brilliant player

Ledley 4 I didn't feel he added much.

Cabaye 5 I think he plays much better when able to attack but needs to stop getting angry at everything and maybe focus his energy on leading the team.

Puncheon 2 I can't see whether he added anything to the game and I would have been happy if he was subbed.... I hate to say it but i feel he is a weak link, he has spells of brilliance that seems to come and go faster than an english summer.

Zaha 7 First half he was terrible but when put on the other side, looks formidable and has the drive to attack. I think people do not give him the credit he deserves, he does lose the ball when he takes on too much but he wins free kicks, scored a brilliant goal, scares defences, racks up the oppositions yellow cards and is vital to the squad. If we had a fast paced attacking midfielder, I think we would do so much better.

Townsend 2 - Plays for himself as far as I'm concerned, shows no love for the club and I would rather somebody who at least wants to try like Lee, on the pitch.

Benteke 3 If he put in as much effort as Campbell like he did for Aston Villa, he would be worth his price tag. I expect it is to do with him having zero confidence in himself at present but that cannot be an excuse on his wages. I do not agree with the 'If he is given the support he needs' as an excuse because he jogged for most of his time on the pitch. Like many great forwards (example) Murray poached goals through sheer hardwork and determination as well as having a footballers brain, I think Benteke needs a kick up the arse. When supporters have to worry about a £30 mil player taking a penalty and expecting him to miss or do that stupid slow walk up to the ball, it's not a good sign.

Campbell 6.5 If only he had some end product, his work ethic is great and to be admired, shame he just can't cut it.

Sako 7 I thought he worked hard and looked like a player that without injuries for an extended period of time, has potential if he is here long enough.

Mutch - Needs to be sold, I'm not sure what benefit he brings when coming on, is he meant to be attacking? Is he meant to be more defensive? Not sure what gameplan he brings because impact it certainly isn't.

I think we will stay up as I do still believe the squad has massive potential, just sweet FA confidence.

 

Jacey Flag 04 Jan 17 9.26pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

To be fair to Townsend the whole team should make a public apology for the performance last night. Apart from one sublime finish from Zaha there is very little to enthuse about.

Pardew's legacy.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 04 Jan 17 9.56pm

IMO the poor movement and leg weariness came from a thin squad and unfit group of players being run off their feet at at Arsenal. This was reinforced by the fact that Sako and Campbell looked our most lively players when they came on.

We had little height in the team as an option aside from Benteke and Delaney. Tomkins is really poor in the air for a CB and has no presence.

Despite having made some decent saves in games recently Hennessey doesn't ever come into his own at the business end of the game when you need him to and may have done better for the winner last night as well as those scored by United, City and Chelsea. Also the roll out in the first half ??

The number of points lost from missed penalties, goals conceded late in the game etc will be playing heavy on minds and undermining confidence and Allardyce has a huge job on his hands lifting the players.

Second half was better but more blood and thunder and a couple of pairs of fresh legs rather than quality.

Convinced many of the injuries are stemming from a poor level of base fitness.


 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player Ratings v Swansea