You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jonjo Shelvey =The kind of midfielder we need
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jonjo Shelvey =The kind of midfielder we need


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
bodge Flag 19 Jan 17 7.04pm

Originally posted by Willo

Shelvey is a far more accomplished midfielder than Puncheon who in all honesty has been a real disappointment this season.

Do you think Shelvey would do better he did not do well in Newcastles poor run that ended with relegation. Punchoen is more skilful and less of a liability IMO.

 

IMMER PALACE Flag BIELEFELD 19 Jan 17 7.11pm

Anyone thinking that Shelvey is what we need should seek medical help immediately.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Jan 17 7.16pm

Originally posted by bodge

Do you think Shelvey would do better he did not do well in Newcastles poor run that ended with relegation. Punchoen is more skilful and less of a liability IMO.

In my humble estimation Shelvey is a much more accomplished player than Puncheon and yes he would be an upgrade on "Punch".

 

bicycle repair man 19 Jan 17 7.39pm

Who should we go for next ?
Joey Barton.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 19 Jan 17 7.43pm

Originally posted by Gyro1780

Your joking right...??

No, he's not...under improved levels of management and guidance for professional development.

 

bicycle repair man 19 Jan 17 7.55pm

Leopard.......spots

 

mattteo Flag 20 Jan 17 11.13am

Originally posted by Willo

In my humble estimation Shelvey is a much more accomplished player than Puncheon and yes he would be an upgrade on "Punch".

Offensively, probably yes. He has quite a few assists for Newcastle despite playing waay down and he opens play with some great "through passing".
Defensively....Puncheon covers a lot more ground and runs a lot more. He hasn't been used quite right in the last 3 years, his best game was on the wing, using his left foot.

Movement is worth more than skill in today's football, I'd go with Puncheon

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Jan 17 11.19am

I had been going on to people about signing Livermore and now see he has gone to WBA for £10 Mill.
I have memtioned on here about strengthening our "Engine room" - I believe that a Shelvey type player alongside Livermore would have been good for our team.Not impressed with the likes of Ledley,Puncheon and even Cabaye in that vital midfield area not forgetting Mutch etc etc.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 20 Jan 17 11.44am

With Shelvey PL sides would close him down and prevent him pinging the ball so it became difficult to play his natural game.

Seems to have more space in the Championship.

 

Glazed Over Flag Sevenoaks 21 Jan 17 5.29pm

Far better player than Puncheon.

Fairly sure that not a single championship manager would build their squad round him like Benitez has done with Shelvey.

The ideal player for the current predicament.

Edited by Glazed Over (21 Jan 2017 5.30pm)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jonjo Shelvey =The kind of midfielder we need