You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Deserved defeat
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Deserved defeat


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Geoff Thomas Flag Tonbridge - 21 Jan 17 10.32pm

Have to win your home matches and we never do! Its been far too long since we had a decent home record.
Setup to draw and got defeated, hope BFS doesn't do that again, as already one foot in the championship and 2 points adrift. In truth it will take us months to achieve 2 points going on form.

GT

 


Eagles S*** on Seagulls, Eagles S*** on Seagulls,
La La La La,!
La La La La!

StainesPalace Flag Staines 22 Jan 17 3.40am

The ref didn't put the ball in the net at the end of the day. And the ref saw Schlupp go down off the pitch. If a player from another team went down off the pitch we'd sll be screaming play on. The team is too weak to cope with being a player light for a couple minutes. Standard Palace this season conceding lategoals. Yet its never our fault?

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 22 Jan 17 9.20am

Originally posted by StainesPalace

The ref didn't put the ball in the net at the end of the day. And the ref saw Schlupp go down off the pitch. If a player from another team went down off the pitch we'd sll be screaming play on. The team is too weak to cope with being a player light for a couple minutes. Standard Palace this season conceding lategoals. Yet its never our fault?

Yes I agree.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 22 Jan 17 9.31am

Originally posted by Pete53

If you are referring to when Schlupp was down the ref. was quite entitled to allow play to go on, even when the throw in was given. When Schlupp first went down he was over the line and off the field of play and could have been attended to by the physio. However, he intentionally rolled back over the line to try to get play stopped.

Edited by Pete53 (21 Jan 2017 10.22pm)

Also surely we had a chance ourselves to kick the ball out ? How long was the passage of play ? If it was long why wan't instructions given to the players with us with 10 players ? What I have seen from the highlights unfortunately Ledley at the back hit it too well, if he had shanked it into the stands/behind for a corner we might well of got the ball back under the circumstances.

Edited by Booted Eagle (22 Jan 2017 9.34am)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 22 Jan 17 9.51am

This deserved bulls*** is doing my head in. Did we deserve to beat Liverpool in the 1990 cup semi final, no. Best team lost that day. Did we deserve to beat Brighton over two legs, no. Over two legs best team lost. We have won many games we didn't deserve to, that's not what footballs about. Pardew attacked and we lost many we didn't deserve to, but was slated, now Sam is trying a different tack and that's wrong also. Make your f***ing minds up.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 22 Jan 17 12.55pm

And one more thing, if we had got the results we've deserved Pardew would still be our manager and we'd be about 10th. Trouble is playing well guarantees nothing, but being organised and disciplined can keep you in games and win points. It's this that baffles me about AP, how could he not see this?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

lightandbitter Flag 22 Jan 17 12.58pm

Question: Would the referee have done the same thing in the same situation if it was a Manure defender on the floor injured at Old Trafford?

 

bicycle repair man 22 Jan 17 1.04pm

Originally posted by lightandbitter

Question: Would the referee have done the same thing in the same situation if it was a Manure defender on the floor injured at Old Trafford?

No.Could you imagine the furore that would cause, they would be talking about it for a week on Talksport.

 

Salford eagle Flag 22 Jan 17 1.22pm

I love how MOTD glossed over the fact that there was a break in play between Schlupp going down and the eventual goal. Nobody was asking for Everton to kick the ball out of play.

The simple fact is the referee denied us the opportunity to assess the player and decide if he could carry on or whether we required a sub. It's common sense, something the referee lacked.

Next time I'd advise the palace player to roll around clutching his head. We're far too nice a team, we need to start doing the cynical nitty gritty that the opposition do! It's the only way we'll get any sort of decision.

On another note on two separate occasions a palace player was tackled from behind, both occasions they won the ball but completely cleaned out the man. I was under the impression this was a foul?

 


California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same

bicycle repair man 22 Jan 17 1.27pm

Originally posted by Salford eagle

I love how MOTD glossed over the fact that there was a break in play between Schlupp going down and the eventual goal. Nobody was asking for Everton to kick the ball out of play.

The simple fact is the referee denied us the opportunity to assess the player and decide if he could carry on or whether we required a sub. It's common sense, something the referee lacked.

Next time I'd advise the palace player to roll around clutching his head. We're far too nice a team, we need to start doing the cynical nitty gritty that the opposition do! It's the only way we'll get any sort of decision.

On another note on two separate occasions a palace player was tackled from behind, both occasions they won the ball but completely cleaned out the man. I was under the impression this was a foul?

Absolutely correct,the fact that there was a thrown in just before the goal was edited out.
So that put a completely different slant on the situation and made it look as though play went on without a break in play.

 

peterg Flag Anerley 22 Jan 17 1.48pm

Sam said their goal was offside.
I haven't felt able to watch the highlights yet - but is Sam right?

 


The right place at the right time

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 22 Jan 17 2.06pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

He was blatantly held, ref had excellent view

yeah but thats only a penalty when we do it.....bent officials again!

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 22 Jan 17 2.08pm

Originally posted by peterg

Sam said their goal was offside.
I haven't felt able to watch the highlights yet - but is Sam right?

It certainly looked at, both at the time, and on the replay.

Furthermore, Remy should have had a penalty for being wrestled to a halt in the Everton box.

Play could also have been stopped for Schlupp when the ball went out of play for a throw in. Ref. could have stopped play then, but chose not to.

That being said one of our lot should have got themselves a yellow for a blatant foul to stop play.

This has been one of the worse seasons I can remember for referee decisions not going our way. Most years we moan, but I can normally think of a quite a few occasions when we have had a run of bad decisions go our way. This season, I can't think of more than one or two at most.

Edited by NickinOX (22 Jan 2017 2.11pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 22 Jan 17 2.51pm

Because the ball went out of play the ref should of stopped play if only to book Schlupp and the physio, so the ref clearly failed to do his job properly, such a surprise this season. The BBC not showing the full story also failed to do their job properly, but I'm used to that with Palace.
As someone said, Schlupp should of rolled around clutching his head. We are far too nice and it is a major problem, someone should of cleaned out an Everton player or just plain caught the ball. Everton have totally been given the points they've won against us this season by inept refereeing. Deserved or not, I'm sick of refs screwing us over this season.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

bashy2 Flag London 22 Jan 17 3.19pm

WH has said the players are devastated at losing to Everton what a load of rubbish that is start playing like we all know they can and win football matches fast and start getting results quickly because if they are relegated at the end of the season than there better not start crying because there grown man and get paid great wages to perform week in week out and from what I've seen and heard there haven't been performing like a top 10 club should

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Jan 17 4.02pm

Originally posted by bashy2

WH has said the players are devastated at losing to Everton what a load of rubbish that is start playing like we all know they can and win football matches fast and start getting results quickly because if they are relegated at the end of the season than there better not start crying because there grown man and get paid great wages to perform week in week out and from what I've seen and heard there haven't been performing like a top 10 club should

Member since yesterday....troll? I think so. You obviously weren't at the game (possibly never have been to a game) but they were devastated at the3 final whistle, I believe, although Everton were the better side, that Palace deserved a point.

 

bashy2 Flag London 22 Jan 17 4.10pm

im not a troll I'm a palace fan have been since 1979 i care about the club as much as everyone else does we are not a bottom 3 club that's for sure we haven't been committed enough on the pitch we have a load of over paid footballers who ain't got the club at heart and when we go down they will all off to other clubs when we are relegated that we show they commit to the club wont it

 

Phil H Flag 22 Jan 17 6.46pm

Like some others on this thread I was there yesterday.Our players worked their socks off, Punch was closing down in midfield, Cabaye chasing everything, Hennessey doing great. Everton are class and Barkley is quick, strong and a right handful. Their right back was a guy I'd never heard of called Holgate, but he is sheer quality and apparently England U21. Our players are outclassed but we have to keep supporting them and hope it will come good against the lower teams.

 

Mo Sizlak Flag 22 Jan 17 7.39pm

Originally posted by bashy2

im not a troll I'm a palace fan have been since 1979 i care about the club as much as everyone else does we are not a bottom 3 club that's for sure we haven't been committed enough on the pitch we have a load of over paid footballers who ain't got the club at heart and when we go down they will all off to other clubs when we are relegated that we show they commit to the club wont it

Well said.

I don't hero worship anymore now I'm all growed up like.
I see our players for what they are - employees.
I've never understood why any Palace fan would take an interest in an ex player.
In my view, when they leave I couldn't care less about them anymore.

 


Babs and Clean Willie were in love they said....

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 22 Jan 17 10.30pm

Originally posted by bashy2

im not a troll I'm a palace fan have been since 1979 i care about the club as much as everyone else does we are not a bottom 3 club that's for sure we haven't been committed enough on the pitch we have a load of over paid footballers who ain't got the club at heart and when we go down they will all off to other clubs when we are relegated that we show they commit to the club wont it

Guff. Yesterday was the most 'committed' they've been for some time & they put a shift in. Yes, they looked nervous or lacking in confidence at times but they've seemed much worse so far this season. For a start, they all seemed to know what system we were playing and how they fitted into it, a novelty last year.

2016 has been the ruin of this side & to simply blame the players and their earnings is both lazy and futile - many were here in 2015 & most of those are on the same contracts.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Deserved defeat