This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Puncheon
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
cpj Kent 04 Feb 17 6.53pm |
|
|
Well past his best. Lost the ball in CM three times in the opening 15 mins. Even when he did finally pass forwards in the second half he did it so slowly that any momentum was lost. Can't believe that JM was taken off again, yet Puncheon stayed on.
|
cpfc1976 Reading 04 Feb 17 7.12pm |
|
|
Think Punch quite often gets unfairly criticised because he try's to puts his foot on the ball rather than treating it like a hot potato.
That said he can slow us down, especially in that deeper role, and none more so than in the first half today. We were so slow in the build up passing it side ways and back in our own half. We aren't even very good at it, losing possession time and time again.
If they were expecting pacey energised attacks and pressure then Sunderland can't have believed their luck.
Unless we can sort out these slow and laboured build ups I can't see how we can turn it around, for me that means dropping Punch.
|
Dan89 Se25 04 Feb 17 8.43pm |
|
|
Great under Pulis. Good under pardew when he first arrived and scored a crucial goal against Norwich. He's a failed winger playing defensive midfield, when flamini sitting on the bench. Extremely poor in 1st half. Let before 2nd half started.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
ex hibitionist Hastings 04 Feb 17 8.47pm |
|
|
he's an attacking wide player playing in the defensive middle, and he's good as a squad player competing for a place but he switches off after he plays too regularly, he needs to be competing with Wilf, Schlupp and Townsend for two of the wide positions, we might see a bit of his old self back you never know.
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 04 Feb 17 8.55pm |
|
Originally posted by cardiff eagle
It's the pair of them! Ledley enjoys giving goals away and did again today. Puncheon enjoys spinning on spot before doing a 3 yard safe pass. f***ing pathetic.
Just get punch out team and bring Townsend in and put mccarthur where he belongs in the middle.
If cabaye is injured play the new lad instead. Just don't wanna see punch or Ledley anywhere near the team
Agree 100%
|
paperhat croydon 04 Feb 17 8.57pm |
|
|
Getting worse by the match.
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan
|
Spiderman Horsham 04 Feb 17 8.59pm |
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
Undoubtedly technically gifted, but like possession statistics it's the end product which really counts.
Sorry to disagree but a professional footballer who is cant kick a ball with his right foot, doesn't win any aerial duels, very rarely tackles and has the turning circle of a double decker bus is not gifted. Sorry I know he is "one of our own" but his time is up I'm Afraid.
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 04 Feb 17 9.00pm |
|
|
He's been brilliant but is 30 and on his way down.
Never a defensive midfielder in a million years and should be a squad player.
MacArthur is our best DM by a distance but looks as though he's been shoe horned into the number 10 position through lack of other alternatives.
|
curlyeagle crowborough 04 Feb 17 9.02pm |
|
|
Don't normally feel this sour but Puncheon has been piss poor all season for me. Best ballet dancer in the prem every time he receives the ball he pirouettes before passing backwards or sideways.
Ledley just plods around the park like he is running through treacle. Wants all day on the ball and has cost us goal after goal this season. He looks like veteran competing in a veterans game.
And Hennesey well don't get me started.
Curly eagles dad, 45 years of Palace. Never ever a dull moment, Oh Happy Days
|
Alex1991 Ashford 04 Feb 17 9.02pm |
|
|
I don't think Punch has been good enough for while, but I really don't understand why Sam is playing him on the right side of centre midfield and Mcarthur wide on the left. It's so blatantly obvious that Jimmy Mac is better in the middle, and does occasionally drive forward with the ball. Puncheon is slow, doesn't take the quick forward ball when it's available, and playing him on his wrong side just adds to the hesitancy.
"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.
|
Asian Eagle Cebu City 04 Feb 17 9.11pm |
|
|
Sad to see , but he has been poor for a long time and always making wrong choises.Think he should be cleening wardrobes instead. Should never play again in my opinion. Others can do a better job.
|
Dangermouse Hastings 04 Feb 17 9.12pm |
|
|
Punch is having a very poor season, like many. He's done wonders for us in previous years, so I'll cut him some slack. Like many he's suffering from a severe lack of confidence that has been caused by a whole year of losing regularly. Pardew should of gone earlier it's clear as the team has forgotten how to win, but I won't lay it all at his door. Sam had the midweek win to use to push this team on and he set up in a very negative way and he blew it. If Schlupp was fit would he of started Macca wide left again, doubt it. Yet he didn't start Townsend who was coming off a moral boosting cameo at Bournemouth and would of stretched Sunderland more.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Carrick In the Premierleague 04 Feb 17 10.11pm |
|
|
Got some abuse at a corner and turned with the most dirty look at the crowd once he had ran 20 yards away, then started moaning at Dann.
I am not sure what to make of the abuse, i see why people do it, but its a vicious circle once that starts.
Yes i did sing that they were not fit to wear the shirt, as they are not!
Disclaimer The contains of the this message may not be the sober views of the originator. Often the orginator is overloaded with alcohol therefore waffle often gets posted to which the orginator has no responsibility.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 04 Feb 17 10.42pm |
|
|
I think he was one of the sorry excuses that stood and decided not to put themselves in the way of their number 7 having a shot at goal on the corner of the box in the 1st half. Not his job before the others but an example from someone needs to be made. No midfield marshall so who?
It's not his fault he has to turn 360 to get it in his right path at this level. It's our fault he's relied on to be our 1st choice at this level.
Summer signings addressed 50% of issues. Any midfielders weren't scouted properly. Cabaye or Jimmac could've played further forward but without addressing the above can't.
COYP
|
Elpis In a pub 04 Feb 17 10.53pm |
|
|
I think the problem with all our midfielders Punch included is that there is just no movement in front of them and Benteke is often marked by at least two . Any forward passes then look like poor passes as they invariably get intercepted or go where nobodies running . Punch wears his colours with pride and the harder he tries the worse it gets . He needs a break from this poor side
|
elgrande bedford 04 Feb 17 10.53pm |
|
|
Besides not really liking the man,I still think BFS is the right man for the job. But again I thought there were some strange decisions,if Cabaye goes of injured why the f*** bring ledley on,Flamini all day long. Hoping the new man Luka is available next game. Cabaye, macarthur and Luka in the middle,puncheon on the bench.....and anyone but hennesey in goal.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.
|
Big Guy 04 Feb 17 10.57pm |
|
|
thank fcuk weve got jimmy mac. he deserves better than having to play with punch at the minute
Time to go Alan
|
mattteo 04 Feb 17 11.03pm |
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
He's been brilliant but is 30 and on his way down.
Never a defensive midfielder in a million years and should be a squad player.
MacArthur is our best DM by a distance but looks as though he's been shoe horned into the number 10 position through lack of other alternatives.
Pirlo played in front of the defence in his last years. He wasn't very different from Puncheon. Thiago Motta does it for PSG, Kroos for Madrid sometimes.
Not a defensive midfielder, but a deep lying playmaker. If there are 2 central box-to-box midfielders in front of him, it's doable. All he'd have to do is maintain position and close spaces, as the other 2 midfielders would be the ones doing the tackles. McArthur and Cabaye could be those.
But I reckon Allardyce will always play them differently: McArthur and Cabaye lower, Puncheon behind the striker. And not having the necessary pace in that position where you're basically the second striker really damages the pressing and recovery of the team.
|
cpfc1976 Reading 04 Feb 17 11.06pm |
|
|
.
Edited by cpfc1976 (04 Feb 2017 11.07pm)
|
cpfc1976 Reading 04 Feb 17 11.07pm |
|
Originally posted by cpfc1976
Originally posted by mattteo
'Pirlo played in front of the defence in his last years. He wasn't very different from Puncheon. Thiago Motta does it for PSG, Kroos for Madrid sometimes.'
Please stop it my sides hurt. You have to be on the wind up.
|