You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So what are the problems?
November 16 2026 10.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

So what are the problems?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
palace99 Flag New Mills 05 Feb 17 11.39am

My take on what's gone wrong is as follows:

1. contracts. After 2 or so years suriving in the prem with predominantly championship standard players, many have now been given big premier league contacts - supposedly Ward is on £35k a week. These are life changing sums and it is only natural that a little hunger and desire has now been lost. Players like Ward, Punch etc are definitely not the same player as 2 years ago

2. Unbalanced squad - this goes back to Pulis era who released 2 left backs and didn't buy a replacement. In the summer Pards let 2 centre backs go and replaced with just 1. We only had 1 recognised left back in the whole squad and he then got injured (driving his 120k car too fast!!).
A lack of No 10s has not been addressed. This is a critical position in our formation yet we have lacked one for 2 years now - Punch can't do it and Pardew's replacements have been poor (e.g. Lee and Mutch - Mutch will cost the club 10m plus in transfer fee and wages over his contract)

3. New players coming in on silly money has unsettled the squad - Cabeye on £86k and Beneteke on £120k will has caused unrest. Zaha 'only' on £40k is a prime example and his agent has unsettled him.

4. Pardew's philosophy - think he lost sight of what made Palace a decent team - hard work and organisation. I applaud him for trying to get us playing more football but these steps were made too quickly. Home form in particular has been a massive issue for 2 seasons. Having said that we usually in games and rarely lost heavily

4. Big Sam's appointment. Let's be honest in ideal circumstances he would have had consider Palace as an employer so we knew we were buying damaged goods. I think he has one way of managing , just like Redknapp, and times have changed. He has spent massive quantities of money in a desperate trolley dash and yet palace have got worse.
He always has an excuse for everything and it is never his fault. The defence has got worse. 5 at the back at home against the bottom club is a bizarre formation. He reminds me of Van Gaal at Man U - this way has worked for me before so i keep doing the same thing.

I am concerned for the future, especially when you look at Swansea and Hull and how they've improved recently

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 05 Feb 17 12.34pm

The problems are as much off the pitch as they are on it, probably more so.

The change of manager has altered absolutely nothing. Players who, on paper, should make us an upper-mid table side are simply not performing. I don't think there's a single manager out there who could change it.

Something, and I simply cannot work out what, happened at the end of 2015 where a massive cloak of negativity suddenly and without warning descended on the club. Players who played creatively and cohesively just stopped functioning. Our mentality changed almost overnight, it was that sudden. Under Pardew, we finished the 14/15 season and started 15/16 very promisingly but spectacularly (and it really was spectacular) fell apart afterwards. How can it simply be down to one man, who got us playing so attracively and so consistently, for this collapse, and if it was, why can his successor (who, like him or hate him, has a rep for putting out tight and disciplined sides) not halt the slide?

There seems to be an atmosphere almost like death about the place - everything we built up, the support, the obvious team spirit, the 'never say die' mentality, Fortress Selhurst has evaporated in a puff of smoke. Is it really possible that one man could have destroyed all that, and so suddenly? It's the sudden-ness of the collapse that perplexes me. What can possibly bring about such a dramatic change in so short a period of time?

It beats me, it really does.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 05 Feb 17 12.44pm

i just cant get how our players have turned so s**t..our captain was being touted as england potential, we had 1 french 1 belgian 2 welsh 1 scottish & 1 ivory coast international playing yesterday really cant understand what is going on, dont get this scared to play at home b****ocks

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

Beanyboysmd Flag 05 Feb 17 1.09pm

Our problem is very simple, if our home record was the same as our away record we would be on 24 points and that would put us safe...ish...
If our away record was the same as our home record then we would be on 10 points, thats Aston Villa stuff...
Away form for the season we are 10th and home we are 5 points adrift at the bottom.
Thats why we are in this position, we can argue about fine tuning and what formation or team to put out but the problem is this simple, we are dogsh1t at home, there is literally nothing else to debate...

 

The Dolphin Flag 05 Feb 17 1.12pm

We are not a team in the true sense of the word.
I said a long while back that getting rid of Jedi would be the biggest mistake Pardew could ever make and so it has proven to be.
Playing or on the bench he was CPFC, he was the leader off and on the park.
I am convinced that even with him not always playing but still being with us we would not be where we are now.
He would have dealt with so much and again how much happier i would have felt with him there yesterday.
I blame AP for that and much more besides but it is now down to the players to sort this out.
They need to become a unit again as opposed to a highy paid bunch of individuals!
Team, team, team!!!!!

Edited by The Dolphin (05 Feb 2017 1.13pm)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Feb 17 1.19pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

The problems are as much off the pitch as they are on it, probably more so.

The change of manager has altered absolutely nothing. Players who, on paper, should make us an upper-mid table side are simply not performing. I don't think there's a single manager out there who could change it.

Something, and I simply cannot work out what, happened at the end of 2015 where a massive cloak of negativity suddenly and without warning descended on the club. Players who played creatively and cohesively just stopped functioning. Our mentality changed almost overnight, it was that sudden. Under Pardew, we finished the 14/15 season and started 15/16 very promisingly but spectacularly (and it really was spectacular) fell apart afterwards. How can it simply be down to one man, who got us playing so attracively and so consistently, for this collapse, and if it was, why can his successor (who, like him or hate him, has a rep for putting out tight and disciplined sides) not halt the slide?

There seems to be an atmosphere almost like death about the place - everything we built up, the support, the obvious team spirit, the 'never say die' mentality, Fortress Selhurst has evaporated in a puff of smoke. Is it really possible that one man could have destroyed all that, and so suddenly? It's the sudden-ness of the collapse that perplexes me. What can possibly bring about such a dramatic change in so short a period of time?

It beats me, it really does.

I have no argument with those sentiments and find myself equally perplexed.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 05 Feb 17 1.23pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

We are not a team in the true sense of the word.
I said a long while back that getting rid of Jedi would be the biggest mistake Pardew could ever make and so it has proven to be.
Playing or on the bench he was CPFC, he was the leader off and on the park.
I am convinced that even with him not always playing but still being with us we would not be where we are now.
He would have dealt with so much and again how much happier i would have felt with him there yesterday.
I blame AP for that and much more besides but it is now down to the players to sort this out.
They need to become a unit again as opposed to a highy paid bunch of individuals!
Team, team, team!!!!!

Edited by The Dolphin (05 Feb 2017 1.13pm)

The mistake was not replacing Jedinak. After all, he was with us for the second half of the 15/16 season which is when we slumped and his performances in that period weren't particularly impressive. We were already in a downward spiral while he was with us.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Beanyboysmd Flag 05 Feb 17 1.26pm

Players almost feel cursed at home, anyone who plays football at any level will get it.
When you atart to thin 'we never seem to beat this team' or 'we never win when its raining' or 'we never win monday night matches'. Ours is 'we always lose horribly at home', once you feel like that then it becomes a permernant change in mentality. If you turn up convinced you are going to lose then nothing anyone says is going to change that. Sam will try but the mindset is so hard but it has to happen.
The game against Bournemouth helped the players with thier away mentality but the home mentality still has to be fixed.
On the upside, i think we will beat Stoke for exactly that reason!!!

 

cpj Flag Kent 05 Feb 17 1.42pm

We've replaced players who cared with big-money signings who know that if we go down we won't be able to afford to keep them, so they'll be back in the PL with another club after another lucrative move.

Tactically, everything is too slow and laboured. Even Puncheon's quite clever free-kick yesterday took so long to reach Zaha that any advantage from it was lost.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 05 Feb 17 1.50pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

The mistake was not replacing Jedinak. After all, he was with us for the second half of the 15/16 season which is when we slumped and his performances in that period weren't particularly impressive. We were already in a downward spiral while he was with us.

Indeed, we were worse when he played in his last year at the club. We never replaced him and, apparently, needed no more cover at the back.

If Hangeland is telling the truth about scouting his replacement, that tells us a lot about AP's attitude to the defence.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

cpj Flag Kent 05 Feb 17 1.52pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Indeed, we were worse when he played in his last year at the club. We never replaced him and, apparently, needed no more cover at the back.

If Hangeland is telling the truth about scouting his replacement, that tells us a lot about AP's attitude to the defence.

What did he say?

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 05 Feb 17 1.52pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

The problems are as much off the pitch as they are on it, probably more so.

The change of manager has altered absolutely nothing. Players who, on paper, should make us an upper-mid table side are simply not performing. I don't think there's a single manager out there who could change it.

Something, and I simply cannot work out what, happened at the end of 2015 where a massive cloak of negativity suddenly and without warning descended on the club. Players who played creatively and cohesively just stopped functioning. Our mentality changed almost overnight, it was that sudden. Under Pardew, we finished the 14/15 season and started 15/16 very promisingly but spectacularly (and it really was spectacular) fell apart afterwards. How can it simply be down to one man, who got us playing so attracively and so consistently, for this collapse, and if it was, why can his successor (who, like him or hate him, has a rep for putting out tight and disciplined sides) not halt the slide?

There seems to be an atmosphere almost like death about the place - everything we built up, the support, the obvious team spirit, the 'never say die' mentality, Fortress Selhurst has evaporated in a puff of smoke. Is it really possible that one man could have destroyed all that, and so suddenly? It's the sudden-ness of the collapse that perplexes me. What can possibly bring about such a dramatic change in so short a period of time?

It beats me, it really does.

It as though, collectively, they saw a ghost at Christmas 2015.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 05 Feb 17 1.54pm

Originally posted by cpj

What did he say?

He claimed that Pardew made him scout out his replacement, and he picked Tomkins.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Beanyboysmd Flag 05 Feb 17 2.02pm

Under Pardew when we were playing a dide near the bottom, his mentality was to shock the opposition into mistakes, sometimes it works and sometimes it doesnt, when our confidence went, it consistantly didnt.
I dont want to be 'that guy' but shocking teams into mistakes is a lot easier when you have Bolassie and Zaha on the wings and battering rams in midfield!!! All we have left of that is Zaha and on a bad day, thats not really a threat...

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 05 Feb 17 2.17pm

Excellent post, I think you can add to this no leader on the pitch. Whilst Dann be a good player he is no captain. Just cannot motivate.

 


Bring back Brolin

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 05 Feb 17 2.21pm

And one more thing let's stop blaming Pardew, it's getting boring. Instead concentrate on the here and now. He was here now he is gone. The current manager is the one we should be focussing on both to support and where necessary constructively criticise.

 


Bring back Brolin

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Feb 17 2.47pm

We should have listened to Tara.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 05 Feb 17 2.53pm

problem starts with the manager & the buck stops with him.

the majority of our squad has comfortably kept us up for 2/3 seasons so they just beed organising & motivating properly.

lets not stroll out the lazy line of they arnt PL quality as historically almost every one has proved himself to be.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 05 Feb 17 2.57pm

agree 100% with 99 and cucking re the team - the problem maybe how the club sees itself - I was listening to Pulis recently talk about west brom re developing their squad - getting solid 'spine' players like fletcher and grooming their youngsters to learn from those players and eventually take their place - exotic players with exotic names, hairstyles and salaries being dropped in as a Plan B once plan A goes pear-shaped every season is catching up with us - i'm as desperate as any for us to get to the fifth year in the top flight for the first time, but long term we would probably be better off building in the champ with someone like Kenny Jackett in charge and doing something like what Dyche is doing at Burnley - spend the money on getting the ground up to date, then the big time charlies might feel they've got a suitable arena to show their class. Where are our youngsters?

 

Spitfire Flag Biggin Hill 05 Feb 17 3.17pm

Home form, its been shocking for 2 years.

Away form masked this for a while when Pardew took over but barring home wins over City and Spurs fairly early during Pardews tenure its been woeful since Pulis left.

Also how about being able to score the first goal.
Not checked the stats but I think we scored first in 4 of our 5 Premier league wins this season. The only other game we scored first I can remember is Watford away and we got a point.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So what are the problems?