You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedinak and Murray
November 16 2026 10.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jedinak and Murray


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Mad4palace Flag 07 Feb 17 12.12pm

Originally posted by Username

Jedinak was not inspiring for most of last season.

Delaney, Ward, Puncheon and Ledley, all the 'established' players who supposedly have this drive, leadership and connection with the club were beyond awful on Saturday.

Looking back with rose tinted glasses isn't going to help right now.


Pardew was at fault for trying to fit Jedinak into the same kind of system we played with Puncheon, McArthur and Cabaye in midfield. He didn't let Jedinak just sit in front of the back 4 and do what he's best at. Despite all that I still thought Jedinak was good for the Cup semi and final and our best player in the opening day defeat to West Brom this season. Jedinak has always taken a while to get back up to speed, he did when he first joined us, didn't impress for a while at Villa but has started doing well for them recently.

I agree, looking back to player that have gone won't help us but sometimes it just feels good to say and identify where the problems began. I don't want Jedinak's last season to be remembered as being one where he was passed it because I don't believe he was, just our manager at the time lacked the intelligence to use him properly.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 07 Feb 17 2.15pm

Originally posted by glaziermart

I really think we miss them not just because i think they could have still played a part on the pitch, but because of their character and determination. We have some outstanding individual talents now, way above the players that Jedi and Glenn played with when they first joined the club, but some of our renowned spirit and never say die attitude that we had was exemplified by these two. To all those who still support Pardew, just remember it was him that changed our whole philosophy, what made us the team that could come back from 3-0 down against Liverpool with 10 minutes left to draw a game. Yes we have more quality now, but we could have kept these two for at least another year. Big Sam would have loved them. We simply lack leaders on the pitch

Sigh, I was thinking a similar thing about Ninja and Thorn and then about Wright and Bright........and then I woke up and realised I'm living in the 'here and now' and not in the past!

#FFSjustgetoverit

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 07 Feb 17 2.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

He hasn't played for A.Villa in the last few games - don't know if this is because of injury or not.

In my humble estimation he is not PL level at this stage of his career
.But of course there will be those who fervently disagree with me.Opinions, opinions !

Edited by Willo (06 Feb 2017 11.03pm)

I agree, but my god we need a leader within that club.

Clint hill and shaun derry would be welcome right now

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 07 Feb 17 4.31pm

Originally posted by becky

Another one to add to that list, in my opinion, would be Yannik Bolasie - we haven't had the same excitement going forward since he went.

Was there anything more fun to watch than him and Wilf changing sides and totally bewildering the opposition?

My thoughts exactly. I beleive this took the pressure offf the defence to a certain extent.
COYP

 

Username Flag Horsham 07 Feb 17 4.33pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace


Pardew was at fault for trying to fit Jedinak into the same kind of system we played with Puncheon, McArthur and Cabaye in midfield. He didn't let Jedinak just sit in front of the back 4 and do what he's best at. Despite all that I still thought Jedinak was good for the Cup semi and final and our best player in the opening day defeat to West Brom this season. Jedinak has always taken a while to get back up to speed, he did when he first joined us, didn't impress for a while at Villa but has started doing well for them recently.

I agree, looking back to player that have gone won't help us but sometimes it just feels good to say and identify where the problems began. I don't want Jedinak's last season to be remembered as being one where he was passed it because I don't believe he was, just our manager at the time lacked the intelligence to use him properly.

We could have moved on from Jedinak easily IMO if:

a) we'd signed a better replacement (which we hopefully now have). Someone who could screen the defence and actually pass and be more mobile

b) Flamini had actually been fit and able to play.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Mad4palace Flag 07 Feb 17 5.38pm

Originally posted by Username

We could have moved on from Jedinak easily IMO if:

a) we'd signed a better replacement (which we hopefully now have). Someone who could screen the defence and actually pass and be more mobile

b) Flamini had actually been fit and able to play.

I agree we quite easily could have replaced him but we didn't.

It's Parish's fault for sanctioning the transfer without a replacement ready, IMO he should have had the foresight to see that Pardew's poor form of last season could continue to this season and he might just have had to give Pard's the sack at some point, so SP should have held off selling one of the greatest captains this clubs ever had. If Pardew wanted Jedinak out of the club so badly then Parish could have allowed for a loan.

Flamini had barely played for 2 years so it was always going to be a risk on his fitness.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 07 Feb 17 9.43pm

Originally posted by becky

Another one to add to that list, in my opinion, would be Yannik Bolasie - we haven't had the same excitement going forward since he went.

Was there anything more fun to watch than him and Wilf changing sides and totally bewildering the opposition?


They bewilder themselves more than the opposition
Hence we have struggled every year in the prem

 

Keeley97 Flag 07 Feb 17 10.14pm

We miss them both massively. They both just worked so well for us. You seem team like Stoke and West Brom keep their old guard (Whelan, Adam, Crouch, Morrison, Brunt) despite the fact they're not the most fashionable players. Grass not always greener. We're getting relegated and they're not.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 07 Feb 17 10.31pm

Originally posted by Keeley97

We miss them both massively. They both just worked so well for us. You seem team like Stoke and West Brom keep their old guard (Whelan, Adam, Crouch, Morrison, Brunt) despite the fact they're not the most fashionable players. Grass not always greener. We're getting relegated and they're not.

If Jedinak and Murray are still such awesome players, that we allowed to be sold, why did no other Premier team want them?
They are now playing in Championship, which to be fair is now their level.
This obsession with old players on here is amusing. They did well for us, no doubt, but times move on. They were well paid for their services.
To compare Crouch with Murray is laughable, Crouch has been on the sidelines at Stoke for about a year, kept his head down and supported his team, now got recalled. If I recall Murray threw his toys out of the Priam, when told he wasn't an automatic start and wanted away.


Edited by Painter (07 Feb 2017 10.32pm)

 

harpmj Flag Lancaster 07 Feb 17 10.46pm

Pardew managed to ruin a decent defence - pretty much the same defence that learnt how to do it properly under Pulis. Selling Murray was a huge mistake, he and Gayle worked so well together. Now we've just got a big guy in the box to lob them up to and hope he gets his head on it. 15 goals a season from a 32 million player isn't going to be enough if we're leaking goals at the other end. Shudve kept hold of Bolasie.......

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 08 Feb 17 12.31am

If it is a choice between Jedi and Pardew then I choose number 15 all day long.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 08 Feb 17 4.13am

Originally posted by Painter

If Jedinak and Murray are still such awesome players, that we allowed to be sold, why did no other Premier team want them?
They are now playing in Championship, which to be fair is now their level.
This obsession with old players on here is amusing. They did well for us, no doubt, but times move on. They were well paid for their services.
To compare Crouch with Murray is laughable, Crouch has been on the sidelines at Stoke for about a year, kept his head down and supported his team, now got recalled. If I recall Murray threw his toys out of the Priam, when told he wasn't an automatic start and wanted away.


Edited by Painter (07 Feb 2017 10.32pm)

Add to that Crouch has scored 100 Premier League goals
And Murray has er ? ~ Ill get my coat

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 08 Feb 17 4.55am

Originally posted by harpmj

Pardew managed to ruin a decent defence - pretty much the same defence that learnt how to do it properly under Pulis. Selling Murray was a huge mistake, he and Gayle worked so well together. Now we've just got a big guy in the box to lob them up to and hope he gets his head on it. 15 goals a season from a 32 million player isn't going to be enough if we're leaking goals at the other end. Shudve kept hold of Bolasie.......

everyone is forgetting that things were as bad under neil warnock as they are now under allardyce in my opinion. we had jedi, murray, delaney, speroni, mccarthy even behind the scenes. but we were stil crap- i believe that these 'driving forces' are overrated and their absence is not why we're poor. maybe the players that have substituted them are not willing to fight to turn the season around, but i don't think jedinak was the lucky gem that some suggest

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (08 Feb 2017 4.56am)

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 08 Feb 17 9.19am

Originally posted by harpmj

Pardew managed to ruin a decent defence - pretty much the same defence that learnt how to do it properly under Pulis. Selling Murray was a huge mistake, he and Gayle worked so well together. Now we've just got a big guy in the box to lob them up to and hope he gets his head on it. 15 goals a season from a 32 million player isn't going to be enough if we're leaking goals at the other end. Shudve kept hold of Bolasie.......

Er Bolasie wanted to leave as did Murray.

 

Username Flag Horsham 08 Feb 17 9.32am

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

everyone is forgetting that things were as bad under neil warnock as they are now under allardyce in my opinion. we had jedi, murray, delaney, speroni, mccarthy even behind the scenes. but we were stil crap- i believe that these 'driving forces' are overrated and their absence is not why we're poor. maybe the players that have substituted them are not willing to fight to turn the season around, but i don't think jedinak was the lucky gem that some suggest

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (08 Feb 2017 4.56am)


Good point.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 08 Feb 17 10.18am

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

everyone is forgetting that things were as bad under neil warnock as they are now under allardyce in my opinion. we had jedi, murray, delaney, speroni, mccarthy even behind the scenes. but we were stil crap- i believe that these 'driving forces' are overrated and their absence is not why we're poor. maybe the players that have substituted them are not willing to fight to turn the season around, but i don't think jedinak was the lucky gem that some suggest

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (08 Feb 2017 4.56am)

This....Jedinak was a great player and captain, but 2nd half of last season we were still crap even when he played. Time to knock this one on thd head...as has been said many times, selling Jedinak was not the problem, not replacing him was.

 

Username Flag Horsham 08 Feb 17 1.02pm

Originally posted by Keeley97

We miss them both massively. They both just worked so well for us. You seem team like Stoke and West Brom keep their old guard (Whelan, Adam, Crouch, Morrison, Brunt) despite the fact they're not the most fashionable players. Grass not always greener. We're getting relegated and they're not.

Not about being fashionable.

Whelan, Adam, Morrison and Brunt are all Premier League midfielders who have been doing it for years, and Crouch is an England international and former Champions Leagues striker.

There were also plenty of Stoke fans grumbling about Whelan keeping his place in the team.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 08 Feb 17 2.30pm

Actually I'm not sure we really miss either of them. Murray, scored less than Beneteke, in a much longer period of premiership time.

Jedi, made little difference when he played in the s**t half of last season, and barely featured in the first tweleve Pardew months. Now don't get me wrong, I think we could do with Jedi, but he was struggling to get ahead of Cabaye, McArthur and Ledley.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 09 Feb 17 2.08pm

We miss Don Rogers and Jim Cannon and Sansom too , why not get them back ???
Jedi and Murray are not good enough for the premiership , hence they were average in our Premiership games

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 09 Feb 17 3.19pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

We miss Don Rogers and Jim Cannon and Sansom too , why not get them back ???
Jedi and Murray are not good enough for the premiership , hence they were average in our Premiership games

Er, we are not getting those three players you name because, you may not realise it, they are retired.

Just to inform you, they don't play football for a living anymore.

However, the second two players still play professionally.

Get It?

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedinak and Murray