You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Yet another decision for Man U?
November 22 2026 8.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Yet another decision for Man U?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 9.48pm

Originally posted by Willo

The Assistant will have his own explanation and no doubt he has seen the 'Slow-Mo' and discussed this with his 'Team'.

There was a player in a Southampton shirt and what he might say is that in the end this influenced his decision.

EFA.

 


============
The Ferret
============

palaceontheup Flag 26 Feb 17 9.48pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect I never accused you of using the word "Conspiracy".
I used such terminology to describe what many on HOL believe is a deliberate ploy to assist Man Utd and the big clubs which of course is total and utter bunkum and hogwash to boot.

Why have United scored 8 offside goals this season then? EIGHT! that would take their tally of GS to 30. We have 33. Not gonna do your trick of researching online but how many points have them offside goals won them. That's just so far. think its 9 now including Cup Final Fix. We're only in Feb!


Willy, I REALLLLY look forward to your answer.

 


Yannick Bolasie - Glenn Murray - Wilfried Zaha

Most exciting attacking trio at Selhurst Park in years.

lancseagle Flag burnley 26 Feb 17 9.53pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect I never accused you of using the word "Conspiracy".
I used such terminology to describe what many on HOL believe is a deliberate ploy to assist Man Utd and the big clubs which of course is total and utter bunkum and hogwash to boot.

Like 1 poster said there's 600 million supporters behind the club not sure on the accuracy of that figure. I don't see Man Utd as a football club it's a global money making business which attracts colossals amounts of money & needs to be successful whether that's through honest or dishonest ways remains to be proven. You'd have to be pretty naive not to make the reasonable assumption that all these irrefutable incorrect decisions which favour Man Utd are a result of something more sinister than honesty.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 9.56pm

Originally posted by palaceontheup


Why have United scored 8 offside goals this season then? EIGHT! that would take their tally of GS to 30. We have 33. Not gonna do your trick of researching online but how many points have them offside goals won them. That's just so far. think its 9 now including Cup Final Fix. We're only in Feb!


Willy, I REALLLLY look forward to your answer.

Firstly, where do you get this statistic from ?
I'm not going to do any online research as I refuse to accept there is any 'Conspiracy' to particularly favour Man Utd or any big club.

Maybe they (And other clubs) have had key decisions which go in their favour but for all I know might have had some which have not.

I simply do NOT accept that officials go out of their way to favour clubs in the sense they purposely make decisions knowing them to be wrong.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 10.00pm

Originally posted by lancseagle

Like 1 poster said there's 600 million supporters behind the club not sure on the accuracy of that figure. I don't see Man Utd as a football club it's a global money making business which attracts colossals amounts of money & needs to be successful whether that's through honest or dishonest ways remains to be proven. You'd have to be pretty naive not to make the reasonable assumption that all these irrefutable incorrect decisions which favour Man Utd are a result of something more sinister than honesty.

If they have been incorrect decisions then these are down to honest mistakes made in the 'Pressure cooker' of a game.

It is a nonsense to assert that referees are instructed to favour Man Utd or any other big club if this is what you are insinuating.

 

lancseagle Flag burnley 26 Feb 17 10.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

If they have been incorrect decisions then these are down to honest mistakes made in the 'Pressure cooker' of a game.

It is a nonsense to assert that referees are instructed to favour Man Utd or any other big club if this is what you are insinuating.

I'm trying to be patient here as I'm not sure on you're on a wind up. Do you realise just how much money can be made by doing something 1 way as opposed to another? There shouldn't be any pressure cookers there's that many officials we are not detonating bombs here in a hostage situation.

Edited by lancseagle (26 Feb 2017 10.07pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 10.08pm

Originally posted by Willo

I'm not going to do any online research as I refuse to accept there is any 'Conspiracy' to particularly favour Man Utd or any big club.

There is none so blind as he who will not see.

 


============
The Ferret
============

lancseagle Flag burnley 26 Feb 17 10.10pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

There is none so blind as he who will not see.

True. Some folk cannot see further than the end of there nose or refuse to see for some strange unknown reason.

Edited by lancseagle (26 Feb 2017 10.10pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 10.12pm

Originally posted by lancseagle

I'm trying to be patient here as I'm not sure on you're on a wind up. Do you realise just how much money can be made by doing something 1 way as opposed to another? There shouldn't be any pressure cookers there's that many officials we are detonating bombs here in a hostage situation.

I have a polarised view which goes against a consensus and I am on a 'Wind-up' !

I can assure you, all I am giving is my honest opinion which you clearly disagree with.That's fine, you are entitled to your opinion and I respect it.

And most certainly referees and assistants are in 'Pressure cooker' situations not only from big crowds but due to the intense scrutiny of TV cameras.They of course make mistakes but NOT on purpose.And trust me IF they have made a bit of a 'Ricket' which is highlighted over and over on TV they are often mortified and upset with themselves.Ever think of this aspect ????

 

lancseagle Flag burnley 26 Feb 17 10.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have a polarised view which goes against a consensus and I am on a 'Wind-up' !

I can assure you, all I am giving is my honest opinion which you clearly disagree with.That's fine, you are entitled to your opinion and I respect it.

And most certainly referees and assistants are in 'Pressure cooker' situations not only from big crowds but due to the intense scrutiny of TV cameras.They of course make mistakes but NOT on purpose.And trust me IF they have made a bit of a 'Ricket' which is highlighted over and over on TV they are often mortified and upset with themselves.Ever think of this aspect ????

No not really because I'm in the opinion & steadfast belief that these mistakes aren't REALLY mistakes & its quids in if you get my drift. Look we are never going to agree whilst we have a hole in our orifices. I give up I'm a defeated man. Night.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 10.21pm

Originally posted by lancseagle

No not really because I'm in the opinion & steadfast belief that these mistakes aren't REALLY mistakes & its quids in if you get my drift. Look we are never going to agree whilst we have a hole in our orifices. I give up I'm a defeated man. Night.

Totally disagree.
We have polarised views and I simply do NOT accept that the game is 'Corrupt' as you suggest.
Yes I'm afraid we will have to agree to disagree.

Edited by Willo (26 Feb 2017 10.27pm)

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 26 Feb 17 10.28pm

Thanks to the people that answered the question, so as I suspected yet another controversial decision favours Man U.
It's strange how consistently that happens.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 26 Feb 17 10.33pm

Crazy isn't it?

According to the survey there are 1.6 billion football fans in the world and 600 million claim to be Man United fans!!!

Manchester United has 659 million followers worldwide:
- 71 million in Americas
- 90 million in Europe
- 173 million in Africa and the Middle East
- 325 million in Asia
Source: Kantar, May 2012

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

HeathMan Flag Purley 26 Feb 17 11.19pm

I have been receiving an education regarding the quality of officials' decision making as a Palace Season Ticket Holder, and reader of many HOL posts. I accept that referees are under pressure during a game, and while helped by three others the referee is guided by 22 players and vocal fans. At one time Palace seemed to be running at a penalty every other game. This is no longer the case. The bare statistics will suggest that Palace are a dirty team (yellow cards Palace 3 - Middlesboro 1). In addition there is also the quality aspect, with England (and other) International Players (Rooney Costa) words to the referee being more highly regarded than our Wilf where the referee's decision seeming to be based on either "he is making out that he has been severely clattered - is he looking for a penalty?" or "he is a forward, why (when he is still able to stand) is he becoming frustrated by the bashings he is receiving?"

I would like to think that referees should be discouraged from regarding very highly regarded players as able to produce sunlight from their bottoms. COYP.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 27 Feb 17 7.30am

From Gossip column:-

Southampton manager Claude Puel has called for video technology after a Manolo Gabbiadini effort was disallowed for offside in Sunday's EFL Cup final against Manchester United.

This could end their Cup winning feats.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 27 Feb 17 9.23am

I hate Man U ,their cheating players , the way they always get the decisions ,plastic supporters and refs who melt at the sight of a red shirt .

The thing is I also think that all teams get bad decisions , the good ones are good enough to get over it .

 

paperhat Flag croydon 27 Feb 17 9.44am

Originally posted by lancseagle

I think footballs just corrupt it's a million pound money making industry. I honestly believe that lots of these big games cup finals title deciders key games etc I think the outcome of these games has already been decided before a ball as even been kicked. The money at stake is humongous with all the Far East betting syndicates etc. It's the only explanation I can think of for all these peculiar decisions which seem to arise so often regarding certain teams.

Edited by lancseagle (26 Feb 2017 8.20pm)

The sad thing is that letting a smaller team win would actually be better for the game overall. big decisions going the way of the bigger teams does no one a favour in the long run

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Hoof Hearted 27 Feb 17 10.29am

2 things....

The sooner video replays are used to clear up bad decisions by the officials the better.

The sooner you lot stop responding to Willo's "bating" the better.

 

becky Flag over the moon 27 Feb 17 11.16am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

2 things....

The sooner video replays are used to clear up bad decisions by the officials the better.

The sooner you lot stop responding to Willo's "bating" the better.

Second both those points!

In respect of the video comment, having been watching the 6-nations rugby where this is used by the officials, it actually seems to take no more time for a video check to be run and a clear decision made and conveyed to the players (and accepted without question by all parties), than it does in football for the players to mob the referee, argue the point and get back to playing with an incorrect decision often having been made and a nasty taste left in the mouths of a lot of people.

Bring it on I say, and the sooner the better!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 27 Feb 17 2.55pm

I'm not a massive fan of video replays honestly but it seems inevitable it will eventually arrive.

I am sort of with Willo on this one. I think some referees make catastrophic mistakes, but I don't believe that for the overwhelming majority of decisions that is as a result of any conspiracy to ensure the big teams win.

Yes the big teams get the majority of big decisions. But the big teams will also be in a position to get those decisions (penalties, offside goals, etc) given in their favour more often because they tend to be better. They'll be having more shots and more shots from offside positions and so every so often one will be given incorrectly.

And some referees do enjoy the limelight more than others and make decisions they shouldn't make due to a subconscious desire to be influential (Clattenburg), but even there I don't think he is deliberately trying to shaft us (even if it seems that way sometimes).

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Yet another decision for Man U?