You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > T1-The Kyle sent back by his son to father himself
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

T1-The Kyle sent back by his son to father himself


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Feb 17 12.58pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

We can't tell if he has free will, but realistically, even if he does, sending Kyle Reese back would be the right choice - even before Kyle Reese is his father. Other than himself, Reese is the person most familiar with Sarah Conner, and the most likely to give 'everything' to save her. We know he's also an experienced and resourceful solider - The ideal choice.

John Conner always existed, and was always Sarah Conner's son. What we don't know is who was his father before Reese is sent back. Remember that the terminator is not successful, and all that happens is that the time line of John Conner is altered.

In fact, the actions of Skynet, actually improve the situation for the future John Conner, because now his whole life is spent in preparation for the future.

Of course its entirely possible people do not have free will, but it likely doesn't matter who JC sends back to save his mother, as long as they are successful, he will be born at some point - Its irrelevant that Reese is his father (because we know a john conner must exist to send him back).

JC could choose not to send anyone back, or someone else, but why would he, even if he knows Reese is his father, they've just won the war, any sacrifice is acceptable. So he sends the best option he has. It would be insane to make any other decision (even from a point where he doesn't know Reese is his father). He knows Reese is incredibly loyal to him, and possibly in love with his mother.

So all that Conners time change involves is minor shifts in his existence, it doesn't involved a contradictory paradox (which him not existing would).

Of course killing Sarah probably just means a different person would lead the surviving humans. It would be erroneous to assume that only John Conner can do it. We believe that, because of the stories told about the great leader. But say if Churchill died in 1938, do you really think the UK wouldn't have fought or that no one would have led the UK.

The war with the machines is inevitable, and the resistance from humans is inevitable. All that changes are small aspects.

So maybe John Conner is born a few years earlier, and has different genetic make up.

Reece was always John Connors father because they are in a causal loop. There was never an alternative father. It is a paradox that could only exist using the rules of time travel as portrayed.

There are more fundamental issues with the whole idea.

The past, from the observers perspective is the past, even if you could change it. Therefore anything a time traveler did in the past would have already happened. As a consequence, the observers present would always be a result of past events and therefore he would be unaware of any change that had happened.
In effect, that means changing the past is impossible because it is always the existing past to the observer. If you erased your own existence by accident in the past you could not have done it in the first place as you never existed.
This renders the whole idea of altering time irrelevant and harmless as the observer only is aware of one time line. Films never get it right because it would be no fun.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Feb 17 4.32pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Reece was always John Connors father because they are in a causal loop. There was never an alternative father. It is a paradox that could only exist using the rules of time travel as portrayed.


There are more fundamental issues with the whole idea.

The past, from the observers perspective is the past, even if you could change it. Therefore anything a time traveler did in the past would have already happened.

Yes, but that's from a perspective within time and space. The ability to travel into the past, and allowing for a non-deterministic universe, means that any change would be the 'already happened' and that must then re-inform the future, implementing a butterfly effect.

I think the idea of the 'creates an alternative universe' provides a decent explaination. For me, I see it that there is universe 1 in which John Conner isn't Reese's son, where he discovers that the terminator has been sent back in time to kill Sarah Conner - and universe 2 in which Reese becomes JC's father.

We follow the events only in Reese's memories of Universe 1 and in the action that occurs once the T-800 and Reese have come back in time (and thus created Universe 2).

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

As a consequence, the observers present would always be a result of past events and therefore he would be unaware of any change that had happened.
In effect, that means changing the past is impossible because it is always the existing past to the observer. If you erased your own existence by accident in the past you could not have done it in the first place as you never existed.
This renders the whole idea of altering time irrelevant and harmless as the observer only is aware of one time line. Films never get it right because it would be no fun.

But here we see the break down of the reliance of an point of observation, a singularity point in essence, where the observer is only capable of seeing actions within our perspective. Its also not necessarily true of all observers either, as the time traveller(s) will have memories of a future that 'no longer exists' - or possibly have constantly shifting memories as the events they change in their now present, potentially change their future.

As Reese existence is not long enough to establish what happens once you change time significantly to affect your own past.

I think the alternative universe theory of time travel makes sense, at least in terms of a thought experiment to get your head around the fact that both universe 1 and 2 can exist in a kind of f**ked up cat in a box kind of way.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

L.E.Eagle Flag 28 Feb 17 5.05pm

I think many of these time travel questions were answered head on by the excellent BBC sitcom Goodbye Sweetheart.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Feb 17 5.07pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

But here we see the break down of the reliance of an point of observation, a singularity point in essence, where the observer is only capable of seeing actions within our perspective. Its also not necessarily true of all observers either, as the time traveller(s) will have memories of a future that 'no longer exists' - or possibly have constantly shifting memories as the events they change in their now present, potentially change their future.

As Reese existence is not long enough to establish what happens once you change time significantly to affect your own past.

I think the alternative universe theory of time travel makes sense, at least in terms of a thought experiment to get your head around the fact that both universe 1 and 2 can exist in a kind of f**ked up cat in a box kind of way.


I think the multi timeline version is the only one that can exist in reality.
In the single time line theory any journey into the past would erase the version of that person in his own time. He would therefor no longer exist as his original self and only as himself in the past. Potentially he could therefore have done none of the things that he had done as his original self if he ever existed at all. He would therefore have no memory of any future since it never happened in the first place. More importantly he might not have traveled back in time in the first place rendering the whole loop a non starter.
The past is always the past no matter who you are or where you observe it from. The future is always the future.
What that means is that if you could see the future it would also be of no use at all because the future is a direct result of the past and therefore unchangeable.


 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Feb 17 5.28pm

I love this kind of stuff and thinking, as it pushes against what we know, to what we can imagine to know.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Feb 17 5.49pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I love this kind of stuff and thinking, as it pushes against what we know, to what we can imagine to know.

I believe there is so much more to know about the universe and humanity and that some of it is already know by a few.
I suspect that there are secrets about our past and our present that would blow people's minds.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Feb 17 5.55pm

I also think the 'multiple universe' is the only way we can understand this kind of thing, without having say a five dimensional perception.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Feb 17 6.19pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I also think the 'multiple universe' is the only way we can understand this kind of thing, without having say a five dimensional perception.

Yeah, it it's the only thing that makes any sense to me.

I'm just wondering how it would be if a time traveler arrives in your time. He must come from a different future that will never happen and that you will not be aware of. On the face of it there will therefore be no consequences for you beyond the fact that a dude has just arrived out of nowhere and claimed to be from an alternative future.
The complexity comes when he brings technology or information with him that could change everything going forward. This means that inter dimensional/timeline beings would impact on your existence from your point of view. In reality, the traveler would be giving up his present to make a new one and he will be the only one aware of the change. He will also remember his original time as it still exists in another timeline. In his original time, he will disappear in the same way as if he had died and that will obviously effect his and his original worlds potential future.

Weird.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > T1-The Kyle sent back by his son to father himself