You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Dann start now fit?
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should Dann start now fit?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
pieman203 Flag Hayes 27 Feb 17 2.57pm

I think all our defenders will play better with Luka in front of them, it gives a little less to worry about. All they need to do now is defend and not worry about the hole that used to be in front of them.

 

stateside Flag Norfolk 27 Feb 17 3.01pm

I stopped counting the amount of free kicks he has given away just outside the box where the opposition have then scored , so probably not start until he is right up to speed & fitness.

 

palaceontheup Flag 27 Feb 17 3.46pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Three CBs is fine if

a) It makes your defence stronger than having two
b) The wing backs get forward and create something.

Taking van Aanholt out of what I am about to say, as I think he's been decent since he joined...I have one word:

SUNDERLAND.


Unfair. The whole team was beyond poor. The guy just scored the winner in a 6 pointer. Christ, Why look back to games like that? BE POSITIVE AND LOOK FORWARD!

 


Yannick Bolasie - Glenn Murray - Wilfried Zaha

Most exciting attacking trio at Selhurst Park in years.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Feb 17 3.51pm

Personallly I would stick with Sakho and Tomkins.
We kept a 'Clean sheet' and won so we should keep the back four intact.

 

Part Time James Flag 27 Feb 17 3.53pm

Originally posted by palaceontheup


Unfair. The whole team was beyond poor. The guy just scored the winner in a 6 pointer. Christ, Why look back to games like that? BE POSITIVE AND LOOK FORWARD!

I think you may have completely misunderstood me. I meant, by saying that van Aanholt was excluded from my criticism, that he has been our only consistently good player under Allardyce including being one of the few half decent performers against Sunderland. Not really an attack on him is it? I thought that was rather complimentary....

 




Part Time James Flag 27 Feb 17 3.59pm

Oh and the reason I looked back to that game is because we lined up with 3 centre backs and 2 wing backs and it didn't work very well. That was exactly what was being discussed on this thread.

The game we just won we had a back four unless my eyes deceive me.

I was giving my opinion on a back four vs three CBs and a wing back. Not being negative. Blimey.

 




Flightsequence Flag 27 Feb 17 4.12pm

Originally posted by Pierre

I think SA will want to play with more height at the back against WBA. He may well go for 3 CB's and include Dann to try and nullify their prowess in the air(as flightsequence has already pointed out)

This also gives us an attacking advantage as well! This could be an afternoon of crosses and aerial dueling!

My thoughts precisely.

 

batcountry Flag Melbourne 27 Feb 17 4.17pm

No.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 27 Feb 17 4.40pm

Play the same team. The first half on Saturday is the best we have played in ages. Continuity breeds confidence, success breeds confidence. On one had a bad game on Saturday so let them play again and build on that performance. Let WBA worry about setting their team up to play against us. Lets try and win the game.

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 27 Feb 17 5.15pm

I'd say keep Tomkins and Sakho together and not play 3 CB's. Let's have some attacking intent against West Brom. With Matty Philips still injured their attack is depleted somewhat and a decent way of dealing with their danger from set pieces is to keep the ball up their end (no pun intended).

 

Mad4palace Flag 27 Feb 17 5.16pm

He picked the same team for Sunderland when we had won at Bournemouth, different games require different systems and players. Personally I think we'll get absolutely thumped if we start with Tomkins, Sakho, PVA and Ward in a 4 at the back. I'd definitely get Dann in there to deal with West Brom's set-piece threat. Might have the same set-up but with Tomkins at RB in place of Ward just to have a little more height to deal with them.

 

est1905 Flag 27 Feb 17 5.39pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Before Saturday I'd of definitely said yes but Tomkins had a great performance.

Him and Sakho looked so assured on the ball and I don't recall seeing too many pointless diagonals from the back.

Only trouble is Dann is much more likely to score and Tomkins will miss sitters but I think our Captain is going to have to fight to get his place back.

Still, nice to have options again!

I think it depends upon how they are both performing on the training ground and then ultimately on the pitch once selected if they are to keep their place.
For me, if Dann finds his best form he is a better player than a form Tomkins. So its up to Dann to get it back.

 

DulwichFan Flag West Dulwich 27 Feb 17 8.29pm

An interesting aspect not mentioned yet is the captaincy - assuming Punch plays I'd like to see him retain the armband as in my view his performance moved up a level with the confidence he gained. Not necessarily reason to keep Dann out the team but it does dodge the issue!

 


I long to accomplish a great and noble task, but it is my chief duty to accomplish small tasks as if they were great and noble.
Helen Keller

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 27 Feb 17 8.44pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Before Saturday I'd of definitely said yes but Tomkins had a great performance.

Him and Sakho looked so assured on the ball and I don't recall seeing too many pointless diagonals from the back.

Only trouble is Dann is much more likely to score and Tomkins will miss sitters but I think our Captain is going to have to fight to get his place back.

Still, nice to have options again!

Like the confidence in the CB partnership, but Borough cannot score for s*** so too early to read much into this

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 28 Feb 17 8.52am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

He picked the same team for Sunderland when we had won at Bournemouth, different games require different systems and players. Personally I think we'll get absolutely thumped if we start with Tomkins, Sakho, PVA and Ward in a 4 at the back. I'd definitely get Dann in there to deal with West Brom's set-piece threat. Might have the same set-up but with Tomkins at RB in place of Ward just to have a little more height to deal with them.

Very true, I would also bring in jimmy mac for punch as we're gona have to fight in midfield!

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 28 Feb 17 9.06am

Dann's also a bigger Goal threat than Tomkins....and we need all the goal threats we've got at the moment!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

bodge Flag 01 Mar 17 9.52pm

We looked more composed v Boro so i would stick with the same back four. If Dann plays i would think its a back three/six respect the point.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 01 Mar 17 11.00pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

He picked the same team for Sunderland when we had won at Bournemouth, different games require different systems and players. Personally I think we'll get absolutely thumped if we start with Tomkins, Sakho, PVA and Ward in a 4 at the back. I'd definitely get Dann in there to deal with West Brom's set-piece threat. Might have the same set-up but with Tomkins at RB in place of Ward just to have a little more height to deal with them.

Agreed and I would always go for keep the winning team together.
But West Brom are a superior team to Boro so Sam might play the extra Centre Half.
We will see.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

bicycle repair man 01 Mar 17 11.02pm

No

 

Gyro1780 Flag Leatherhead, Surrey 02 Mar 17 1.15am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Before Saturday I'd of definitely said yes but Tomkins had a great performance.

Him and Sakho looked so assured on the ball and I don't recall seeing too many pointless diagonals from the back.

Only trouble is Dann is much more likely to score and Tomkins will miss sitters but I think our Captain is going to have to fight to get his place back.

Still, nice to have options again!


It is tough & like you said Tomkins played well & Dann is more likely to score.
Unless like already mentioned we play a back 3 of Tomkins, Dann & Sakho then i would stick with the same team. Gives Dann some more time to get over his injury too.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Dann start now fit?