You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A question on the Pulis case etc.
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

A question on the Pulis case etc.


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Dan1994 Flag Wallington 05 Mar 17 11.11pm

He's been a Premierleague manager for years... I'm pretty sure he'll be able to pay.

 


[Link]

Pierre Flag Purley 05 Mar 17 11.41pm

There have been alleged stories of Pulis involving tranfer dealings and payoffs in the past.

However in this court case SP well and truly reeled TP in over the bonus payment in terms of reasons given for the early payment by TP-Needed money to purchase land for his children - however no land dealings were found to be done by TP
Heated Players Meeting (HPM) date-date given by TP he stated it was held on 12 August and had O'keefe, Bannan and Price in court to back TP's lawyer up.

Also in court TP's lawyer had argued that TP had agreed to stay at Palace at least until 31/08/14-(An undertaking SP had asked TP prior to agreeing to paying him the bonus early) but apparently comments made at the HPM had changed his mind that's why he left the club.

But TP had been paid the bonus early by SP on 12/08 and left the following evening 13/08.

The Panel said there is not one single item of objective contemporaneous or forensic evidence that positively puts Mr Parish at the training ground on the morning of 12 August and in fact the HPM had taken place on the 8th August.
The original ruling by Sir Michael Burton had found TP standard of conduct 'to be disgraceful'

Panel outcome-The real reason for wanting the bonus paid early was as TP had secured a more lucrative contract elsewhere.
Thats why TP has been facing a bill of £3.76m plus interest and costs which presumably has been rising ever since it was awarded!!

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 05 Mar 17 11.56pm

He will answer: 'The lawyers have told me I can't talk about it,' for however long he is asked the question.

If that is one, two, three, four years then so be it, he's a stubborn old sod.

The case is over, judgement has been made, he is free to talk about the case, but does not want to because he has been exposed as the liar he is.

 

lancseagle Flag burnley 06 Mar 17 12.09am

Originally posted by cpfc1976

We don't know the reason he left but he did put himself before the club whom had/were giving him millions of pounds. That is his prerogative. He kept us up and did an amazing job.

He left when he did and it left us in the lurch big time and I have no sympathy for him whatsoever. Felt exactly the same when Dowie left like he did.

Frankly these people do fantastically well out of football, I don't shed one tear if the reason for leaving is that great they can't wait a week or so for getting several million or however much it was. Lots of people stay in minimum wage jobs for years, hating what they do, but still turning up every day because they aren't as fortunate as TP and many others in football.

His leaving left us in a bad way and if anyone looks cheap it's him in my opinion. Screw him.


Agree 100% it just boils down to greed in my opinion he didn't fulfil the terms of his contract regarding the bonus it's a open & shut as well as being greedy you could say idiotic as well for not doing things the correct way. All this was easily preventable don't blame SP for pursuing it whatever disagreement happened beforehand all he had to do was sit tight for a couple of weeks then take the money & run.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Mar 17 6.05am

Originally posted by m/k mick

Its about honouring the contract, he knew the details, he asked for it to be paid early, he knew what he was up to, why did he lie about buying a property as being his reason, and i bet we are honouring pardews contract, rightly so

Aren't we the club that tried to renege on the players bonuses not so long ago nearly causing the team to go on strike?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Mar 17 6.07am

Originally posted by Gidge

Everyone's entitled to their opinion but I cannot believe some people on here saying that we "look cheap" for taking Pulis to court over this.

Here's my understanding of what happened;

He didn't get the signings he wanted so he got on the blower to his contacts and pimped himself out for another job. He got job offers pretty quickly and, with the the clock ticking, lied to Parish to get his bonus paid early and left as soon as he could.

He obviously didn't give a rat's arse about Palace or us fans. He's got history for this kind of behaviour with other clubs as well. The Judge even said his conduct had "been shown to be disgraceful" when ruling against him. Horrible, horrible man who deserves everything he gets.

That's not "your understanding" at all but merely a guess that is possibly as inaccurate as most of the other guesses put forward by other conspiracy theorists

 

lancseagle Flag burnley 06 Mar 17 8.27am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

That's not "your understanding" at all but merely a guess that is possibly as inaccurate as most of the other guesses put forward by other conspiracy theorists

Not a bad assessment from what i understand i think some people seem to forget that he was actually lying about things in court its pretty damning what the judge said for that part we are CERTAIN add that to the hasty departure. You dont have to be a detective to surmise from all this we was dealing with a dishonest person from the outset it was PROVEN he was lying in order to obtain the money falsely.

Edited by lancseagle (06 Mar 2017 8.28am)

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 06 Mar 17 8.42am

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

I'm not aware of there being any reporting on Pulis' motivation. It was a bizarre sequence of decisions by him to be sure.

The only thing I can think of is that he had another gig lined up that was time sensitive, but then fell through quickly after he freed himself from his Palace contract.

It would be hilarious if it turns out that his new employer binned him once they realised that he'd do something as c***ish as he did to CPFC. Karma's a bitch.

Edited by Ray in Houston (05 Mar 2017 5.21pm)

I thought that the judge said in his summing up that Pullis was hoping that by leaving he thought he could walk into a particular job (west ham was mentioned).

But in a strange twist Allerdyce started getting a few results so west ham didn't sack him as expected.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Mar 17 9.00am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Aren't we the club that tried to renege on the players bonuses not so long ago nearly causing the team to go on strike?

What has that to do with Pulis, what evidence to you have? When did the players go on strike, I don't remember any games being cancelled due to strike action.
Pulis is a slippery dishonest person, he has form at the High Court, when he tried to shaft Gillingham.
There have been 2 court cases regarding the Palace incident, how many appeals are you allowed? He lost both hands down, another will only increase his legal debt, maybe he is hoping Parish will just give up pursuing him, I just hope Parish carries on, until Pulis is forced to pay.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Mar 17 9.49am

Originally posted by eritheagle

I thought that the judge said in his summing up that Pullis was hoping that by leaving he thought he could walk into a particular job (west ham was mentioned).

But in a strange twist Allerdyce started getting a few results so west ham didn't sack him as expected.

Yes someone like him doesn't quit a job paying £30k or £40k per week without a hunch there's something about to come up. And knowing being free and out of contract and able to bump up the signing on fee due to no compensation required will make him even more.

The 20 weeks till December and the definite job offers would've eaten up all his bonus wouldn't it? What was the bonus? £1mil? Chop off £400k to £500k in tax and then 20 weeks X weekly wage. Nothing left. So why resign?

He must've known something was coming up. Why resign otherwise?

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Mar 17 11.25am

Originally posted by Painter

What has that to do with Pulis, what evidence to you have? When did the players go on strike, I don't remember any games being cancelled due to strike action.

It was widely reported at the time as was Parish's response that it was merely a bargaining ploy.

May I suggest that you look up the meaning of the word "nearly" as you either don't understand it's meaning or didn't read my post properly

 

Beastie Flag 06 Mar 17 11.50am

Even after it has been proven in court that Pulis took millions of pounds from the club under false pretences (and left us in the lurch two days before the season started) there are people saying Parish was wrong to pursue this??

You expect to read some bollocks on Palace Talk but that’s unbelievable.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 06 Mar 17 12.24pm

Originally posted by Beastie

Even after it has been proven in court that Pulis took millions of pounds from the club under false pretences (and left us in the lurch two days before the season started) there are people saying Parish was wrong to pursue this??

You expect to read some bollocks on Palace Talk but that’s unbelievable.

Agree with you 100%! Although he did a brilliant job that season, he then went swanning off to Brazil to commentate on the world cup, made three average signings (Haangeland, Kelly and Campbell) and then did the dirty on us (cos he was so sure of getting west ham job) whilst throwing his toys out of the pram. According to Neil Ashton, Parrish even offered him a settlement deal so it didn't go to court to save pulis money. But the arrogance of the man meant that he still believes he did nothing wrong.

He better pay up soon before the bailiffs arrive though!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Mar 17 12.28pm

The only person that looks '' cheap '' in all this is Pulis !

I've referred to it before, but when Pulis was at a Business Club lunch towards the end of the season prior to him leaving, he was asked the question '' will you still be manager here next season '' ? He didn't answer the question , merely gave a politician style response. So he was asked again. And again he didn't answer.

I would suggest that he had no intention - for whatever reason - of staying at Palace.

I do suspect it was related to Wilf returning - which seemed to be Parish's own work.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Mar 17 12.46pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

It was widely reported at the time as was Parish's response that it was merely a bargaining ploy.

May I suggest that you look up the meaning of the word "nearly" as you either don't understand it's meaning or didn't read my post properly

So it never happened then!

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 06 Mar 17 12.50pm

I'd image me that there was a clause that said if he left us mid season any bonuses due were null and void.

He is too savvy to have made such a basic error and Parish is too savvy to not have a clause to protect palace.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Mar 17 1.21pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

I'd image me that there was a clause that said if he left us mid season any bonuses due were null and void.

He is too savvy to have made such a basic error and Parish is too savvy to not have a clause to protect palace.

Well not that savvy, he lost the court case and a lot of money. I suspect he didn't really understand it or contract law, or just assumed that he'd get away with it. Plus for whatever reason, there wasn't a job for him either.

His actions, really caused a lot of problems, and we were lucky to get Pardew at Christmas that season, because under Warnock we were going down. Also it ran us into the Malky Mckay debacle.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 06 Mar 17 1.46pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Well not that savvy, he lost the court case and a lot of money. I suspect he didn't really understand it or contract law, or just assumed that he'd get away with it. Plus for whatever reason, there wasn't a job for him either.

His actions, really caused a lot of problems, and we were lucky to get Pardew at Christmas that season, because under Warnock we were going down. Also it ran us into the Malky Mckay debacle.

I'd assume the latter - he's done similar to at least 3 other clubs in the past, none of which have really had the means(or inclination) to go legal on him. I think Gillingham were going to but he (allegedly) had acquired a case of 'sensitive' documents which stopped any action in its tracks.

My understanding of the bonus in question was it relied on him keeping us up & him still being with us on 1st September - not an unusual combination as it can prevent managers taking a new job between seasons. I guess he thought the two weeks left wouldn't matter especially if he spun a few lines to make it seem he was being reasonable. Unfortunately for him, the judges in the original hearing and the subsequent appeal both believed he deliberately sought to obtain the money under false pretences.

I doubt he'll ever have a more expensive fortnight.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 06 Mar 17 8.40pm

like him or not we are still in the Premier League purely down to him.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

merganser Flag 06 Mar 17 9.04pm

Anyone know how vigorous Palace are being in their efforts to get the money?

Is the club happy just to bide its time?

In his MOTD interview, I thought it was significant when TP said: "congratulations to Palace."

Was he showing some good will in the hope that it might pave the way to a lower settlement being mutually agreed with Palace out of court?

He does have one card up his sleeve. It will probably look ugly and reflect badly on Palace if the club sends in bailiffs.

If Pulis offers to cough up 75 per cent, maybe the club should accept it, shake hands on the deal and draw a line under the matter.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A question on the Pulis case etc.