You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 10-man hoodoo history?
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

10-man hoodoo history?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 21 Mar 17 6.11pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

Ahaa, but that player would still have to leave the pitch after receiving some treatment, and we wouldn't have been allowed to take the freekick with Niang still sobbing and rolling around.

Do you travel to matches from Penzance PZ Eagle?! That's one hell of a journey if so! Beautiful part of the World and really off topic but The Pirates Of Penzance was excellent at the Minack Theatre about 20 years ago. The Pirate boat sailing into the sunset was like the end of Goonies! 10/10

Yes agreed that a seriously injured player would have to leave the pitch after treatment but then play would, as you say, been suspended until that happened.

I haven't been to a Palace home match since my mum left Croydon after my Dad died but did go up to Plymouth for a couple which we lost. Used to be a Friend of the Minack and loved going to shows but getting a bit old now to sit on a cliff and climbing up to get out after the show. If I won the lottery I would fly up for home games but then if wishes were horses beggars would ride!.


 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 21 Mar 17 6.32pm

It would seem that since promotion we have been 'awarded' 8 red cards, with none so far this season, and only 2 of those being straight reds - KG and Yannick.

2013/14
KG v Man U (away) lost 2-0
Bolasie v Hull (away) won 1-0

2014/15
Murray v West Ham (away) won 3-1
Jedinak v Sunderland (home) lost 3-1
Delaney v Chelsea (home) lost 2-1 (+ C.Azpilicueta red)
Puncheon v Arsenal (away) lost 2-1

2015/16
Gayle v West Ham (home) lost 3-1
Souare v Watford (home) lost 2-1

From that alone you can see that 3/4 of the times we lose a player, we lose the match, and that is only away from home. Does this highlight the additional pressure we put on our team to win when we are a man up, or is it just coincidence?

The amount of times we lose with a man over does not seem to correlate with oppositions' reds, but I'm struggling to find any solid stats regarding opponents' teams' reds though and the resultant score-lines.

Screen Shot 2017-03-21 at 18.15.03.png Attachment: Screen Shot 2017-03-21 at 18.15.03.png (702.49Kb)

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 22 Mar 17 7.44am

Oh ok. I assumed you meant a watford player was sent off. Just to clear up i watched on an online stream, and was aware Niang was injured when the goal was scored just didn't connect that for what you were saying. What i was more happy with was that the foul that led to the goal was Pudl trying to get back at zaha for his earlier punch/throw, which directly led to our goal through a deeney own goal. Comedy gold.

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 23 Mar 17 1.31pm

Originally posted by rossboss29

Oh ok. I assumed you meant a watford player was sent off. Just to clear up i watched on an online stream, and was aware Niang was injured when the goal was scored just didn't connect that for what you were saying. What i was more happy with was that the foul that led to the goal was Pudl trying to get back at zaha for his earlier punch/throw, which directly led to our goal through a deeney own goal. Comedy gold.

Very much so. All too often it has been Wilf who gets more wound up and gets cautioned, hopefully BigSam can point this out to him. ..mind you, his arm swing at Prödl could've been treated very differently.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 10-man hoodoo history?