This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| Hoof Hearted 29 Mar 17 12.09pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
It would appear that the Geneva Convention doesn't apply in this case. "The Conventions apply to a signatory nation even if the opposing nation is not a signatory, but only if the opposing nation "accepts and applies the provisions" of the Conventions.[14]" I strongly doubt if the Taliban either accepts or applies its provisions. THere probably isn't a phrase that covers it in their language.... "Shabbaly duck duck... blah blah" they say as they light their tuareg fires...
|
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
. Edited by legaleagle (29 Mar 2017 12.27pm)
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 29 Mar 17 12.38pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
War, by its very definition, is a breakdown of civilised discourse. Acts are committed by both sides that, during peacetime, would be considered unacceptable. In the heat of battle, decisions are frequently forced on participants without the luxury of being able to carefully think through the consequences. Bad things often happen. Sgt Blackman clearly saw many bad things happening. To this extent, he is very much a victim of war. No-one is seeking to commend what he did but perhaps a little more appreciation of the situation he found himself in wouldn't go amiss. THat "dot" by legaleagle really irked you Dermot didn't it. I found it to be a rather flippant response!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
THat "dot" by legaleagle really irked you Dermot didn't it. I found it to be a rather flippant response! Very wisely, he chose to retract it, while i was replying.
|
|
|
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
Ultimately the original poster and all his supporters have not one clue what combat of that nature is like. It doesn't matter how much training you receive, seeing hacked off body parts from your oppo's hanging from the tree's your patrolling through surprisingly has an effect on your ability to be nice to the perpetrators. If you've never played the game don't scrutinise the rules. That's another bullsh*t argument imo, should we not be able to criticise politicians because we are not politicians ourselves, or bankers because we haven't 'played the game'? Edited by coulsdoneagle (29 Mar 2017 1.40pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
That's another bullsh*t argument imo, should we not be able to criticise politicians because we are not politicians ourselves, or bankers because we haven't 'played the game'? Edited by coulsdoneagle (29 Mar 2017 1.40pm) I think he's suggesting that, until we find ourselves in a similar situation, it's unwise to pass judgement as glibly as many (including yourself) have done. Sounds reasonable to me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
That's another bullsh*t argument imo, should we not be able to criticise politicians because we are not politicians ourselves, or bankers because we haven't 'played the game'? Edited by coulsdoneagle (29 Mar 2017 1.40pm) I can't even be bothered, Cucking has said it all.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
That's another bullsh*t argument imo, should we not be able to criticise politicians because we are not politicians ourselves, or bankers because we haven't 'played the game'? Edited by coulsdoneagle (29 Mar 2017 1.40pm) Have you ever been in the military or in a warzone just out of interest? Something tells me call of duty is the closest you have come or ever will come to combat
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
Ultimately the original poster and all his supporters have not one clue what combat of that nature is like. It doesn't matter how much training you receive, seeing hacked off body parts from your oppo's hanging from the tree's your patrolling through surprisingly has an effect on your ability to be nice to the perpetrators. If you've never played the game don't scrutinise the rules. Have to agree with you dannyh people who have never been in a combat zone just do not understand the pressure when coming under fire and being attacked. Its a s***ty job at the best of times and I can remember many times when we came under fire and were attacked in Aden, Suez, Iraq, Cyprus, Northern Ireland and many other hot spots. We did our job as you probably have and did it as second nature. The Geneva convection never entered our minds. The enemy was the enemy and it was either him or us so you shot them and made sure they did not shoot anymore of our lads. Sgt Blackman must have been under a lot of pressure having had a really bad few weeks and his men getting killed around him. The b****** he shot was trying to kill them and him but got shot by helicopter fire which once hit by those rounds had little or no chance of survival. Sgt Blackman put him out of his misery and probably saved him a lot of pain so really he did him a favour. The lad who filmed it was a bit naïve by letting the footage leak out. We had a saying when I was a Marine "what happens in war stays in the war zone" and we did not talk about it except in a debrief. I think quite honestly that the poster and some others should not be so quick to run Sgt Blackman down as he was serving in a very difficult war zone and was under immense pressure both his command and what had happened prior to incident that took place. In his shoes many of you WOULD have done the same thing I can assure you about that.
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
|
Originally posted by susmik
Have to agree with you dannyh people who have never been in a combat zone just do not understand the pressure when coming under fire and being attacked. Its a s***ty job at the best of times and I can remember many times when we came under fire and were attacked in Aden, Suez, Iraq, Cyprus, Northern Ireland and many other hot spots. We did our job as you probably have and did it as second nature. The Geneva convection never entered our minds. The enemy was the enemy and it was either him or us so you shot them and made sure they did not shoot anymore of our lads. Sgt Blackman must have been under a lot of pressure having had a really bad few weeks and his men getting killed around him. The b****** he shot was trying to kill them and him but got shot by helicopter fire which once hit by those rounds had little or no chance of survival. Sgt Blackman put him out of his misery and probably saved him a lot of pain so really he did him a favour. The lad who filmed it was a bit naïve by letting the footage leak out. We had a saying when I was a Marine "what happens in war stays in the war zone" and we did not talk about it except in a debrief. I think quite honestly that the poster and some others should not be so quick to run Sgt Blackman down as he was serving in a very difficult war zone and was under immense pressure both his command and what had happened prior to incident that took place. In his shoes many of you WOULD have done the same thing I can assure you about that. Well said. In the heat of battle imo all bets are off . Geneva convention or not the rules of normal life are suspended to a degree. I am not talking about acts such as rape and torture which have been mentioned upthread but life or death situations . They would have done exactly the same thing or worse without a moment's hesitation if it were a reverse situation
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Seems reasonable to me. Proof obtained. If you don't give someone a kit for drawing blood or a DNA sample (assuming you have such on record) then there isn't really too much reliable left to prove 'mission accomplished'
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
I think he's suggesting that, until we find ourselves in a similar situation, it's unwise to pass judgement as glibly as many (including yourself) have done. Sounds reasonable to me. Guess that's why they have military court martials tribunals. Once he was convicted of murder, the sentence could only be a life sentence (mandatory for anyone convicted of murder). Its the Army service that convicted him or murder. Oddly its civilian courts that have reversed their decision and quashed the murder conviction (the Royal Courts of Justice). Personally, I cannot judge the guy, quite rightly, I've never been in that situation. I don't agree with what he did, but I can understand why he did it.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
Have you ever been in the military or in a warzone just out of interest? Something tells me call of duty is the closest you have come or ever will come to combat That's close enough for me. Although being in a warzone isn't necessarily all that bad. I spent six weeks as a consultant on a project in Iraq. The most boring six weeks of my life. The only armed people I saw were some US soldiers and some contractors / mercenaries (who I got on quite well with, as I brought quite a bit of p*** with me). Even travelling too and from the compound, the armour on the bus, made it almost impossible to see out the windows but for a slat. All I saw was the airport, the inside of a bus and a compound surrounded by f**k all but sand. But if you're going into a warzone, as a civilian, take p*** and whiskey.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
That's close enough for me. Although being in a warzone isn't necessarily all that bad. I spent six weeks as a consultant on a project in Iraq. The most boring six weeks of my life. The only armed people I saw were some US soldiers and some contractors / mercenaries (who I got on quite well with, as I brought quite a bit of p*** with me). Even travelling too and from the compound, the armour on the bus, made it almost impossible to see out the windows but for a slat. All I saw was the airport, the inside of a bus and a compound surrounded by f**k all but sand. But if you're going into a warzone, as a civilian, take p*** and whiskey. Can you give us a clue as to what p*** is. The only thing I can think of, that would be in short supply in Iraq, is pork.
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Can you give us a clue as to what p*** is. The only thing I can think of, that would be in short supply in Iraq, is pork.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Guess that's why they have military court martials tribunals. Once he was convicted of murder, the sentence could only be a life sentence (mandatory for anyone convicted of murder). Its the Army service that convicted him or murder. Oddly its civilian courts that have reversed their decision and quashed the murder conviction (the Royal Courts of Justice). Personally, I cannot judge the guy, quite rightly, I've never been in that situation. I don't agree with what he did, but I can understand why he did it. And that's why now the government is looking at Court Marshalls due to being so biased and making themselves look good to the public. I have stood as a guard at a court martial and it was a load of bollocks and we guessed what the outcome would be from the start and we were not wrong. The poor bloke in the dock went down and his defence was just not given the chance to prove their case. As in the case of Sgt Blackman the board wanted to look the part in the eyes of the press and the public.
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.