You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Grujic foul on Tomkins
November 16 2026 9.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Grujic foul on Tomkins


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
twist Flag Miami, Florida 24 Apr 17 12.02am

Grujic slides in from behind, nowhere near the ball, studs first. I was livid when i saw the replay, could have ended Tomkins season.
Linesman saw it first and flagged, but ref didnt even go talk to him before pulling the yellow.
If that wasnt a red, i really dont know what is.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 24 Apr 17 3.35am

Originally posted by Daddyorc

To be fair, watching Tompkins playing a number 9 was rather amusing. And fair play to Campbell, played well in the 10 or so when he was on. His play in the corner was great, 3 red shirts around him and made them really work.

did his job. well done.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 24 Apr 17 3.38am

Originally posted by twist

Grujic slides in from behind, nowhere near the ball, studs first. I was livid when i saw the replay, could have ended Tomkins season.
Linesman saw it first and flagged, but ref didnt even go talk to him before pulling the yellow.
If that wasnt a red, i really dont know what is.

it's the definition of a red card. you couldn't draw it up better. immediately after our last sub. completely intentional to get our defender off. wonder if klopp put their subs up to it. scum.

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 24 Apr 17 5.53am

Originally posted by twist

Grujic slides in from behind, nowhere near the ball, studs first. I was livid when i saw the replay, could have ended Tomkins season.
Linesman saw it first and flagged, but ref didnt even go talk to him before pulling the yellow.
If that wasnt a red, i really dont know what is.

They may have spoken over their headsets, but Marriner did have the yellow out awfully quick.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

timmyb Flag Banstead 24 Apr 17 6.54am

I believe the same ref has now done the last 3 Palace v Liverpool games. Strange to tell, he gave Bentekkers a pen against us when he was still in a red shirt.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 24 Apr 17 7.09am

Originally posted by timmyb

I believe the same ref has now done the last 3 Palace v Liverpool games. Strange to tell, he gave Bentekkers a pen against us when he was still in a red shirt.

But now Ben plays for us it was a Stonewall penalty. !!!!!!!!

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Jacey Flag 24 Apr 17 7.47am

Originally posted by kevlee

It was a bad tackle and of course it came straight after we had made our last substitution. I was quite worried that 10 men wouldn't hold out for those last minutes, but then to see him come back on, swop with Campbell and play on as a hobbling centre forward while Campbell went back in defence was a mark of what the team has become - a real team playing like one where they all back each other up and show some bottle.
A complete metamorphosis from three months ago.

Agreed,it just shows how far we have come under a good manager,Sam,after the chaotic shambles created by the last incumbent!!
Brilliant result.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 24 Apr 17 8.12am

Poor MOTD coverage you would think they could get a camera on the game somewhere near the pitch its only for the long sighted.

And the 'pundits' revisiting in great detail Liverpool angst over a foul so minor you would need a microscope to see any contact.

Its a great story winning these 3 games yet they whinge on about how dreadful Arse and Pool are until they score a goal.

Germans and Aussies are really bad losers it is national disaster losing at football or cricket.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 24 Apr 17 8.33am

Watched El Classico after our game & was impressed that the ref had the balls to send Ramos off at the Bernabeu - especially as he didn't make much contact with Messi at all. Clear red due to intent etc.

It's a shame Mariner (and many of his colleagues) don't seem to have enough bottle when it comes to such situations when it's the big boys committing the offence in the EPL.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 24 Apr 17 8.34am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Poor MOTD coverage you would think they could get a camera on the game somewhere near the pitch its only for the long sighted.

And the 'pundits' revisiting in great detail Liverpool angst over a foul so minor you would need a microscope to see any contact.

Its a great story winning these 3 games yet they whinge on about how dreadful Arse and Pool are until they score a goal.

Germans and Aussies are really bad losers it is national disaster losing at football or cricket.

They had plenty of guys at ground level. Must have just been filming upskirts in the crowd.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Apr 17 9.01am

I think if our player was Grujic and got a 'Red', HOL would be criticising the referee.
Incidentally, Grujic was Klopp's first signing at Liverpool.

 

Szeredy Flag Budapest 24 Apr 17 9.02am

Excellent performance from Palace.

Grujic must be given a retrospective ban for his horrifying challenge on Tomkins.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 24 Apr 17 9.02am

A blatant straight red. Disgraceful tackle.

 

essetwentyone Flag london 24 Apr 17 9.12am

No chance of restropective action because the ref gave a yellow.

It should have been a straight red and when you compare it to the red card for that Hull player on Saturday it's a joke. Big team bias once again !!

 

Part Time James Flag 24 Apr 17 9.17am

Teams often step up their game when down to ten. We won so I'd not change anything. Retrospective red would be good though, even though it won't happen.

 




Red Eagle Flag Crawley 24 Apr 17 9.31am

Sadly, Big Sam thinks Tomkins will be out for some considerable time. That was in his interview for Palace's members' site with Terry Byfield. Sam was furious about the tackle.

If Sky Sports News don't mention that tackle in their Monday morning ref watch feature and just gloss over it, you then do wonder what games these people are watching. Is it because the bloke's name wasn't Joey Barton or Lee Cattermole?

That was Grujic's sixth appearance this season...and four of those have been as a sub...and he's been booked three times!!! I don't know what the other two were for but that's quite a strike rate!!!

If a Palace player had done that to a Liverpool player old Jurgen Klapptrap would have gone mad on the touchline! And because he's seen as a likeable passionate character his reaction to the tackle would remain in the edit.

Edited by Red Eagle (24 Apr 2017 9.38am)

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 24 Apr 17 9.34am

Originally posted by Willo

I think if our player was Grujic and got a 'Red', HOL would be criticising the referee.
Incidentally, Grujic was Klopp's first signing at Liverpool.

And?


I'm not sure they would have! It was a shocking challenge. I think we'd at least on here say it was a poor challenge made due to desperation at losing the ball and them being 2-1 down at home. I think the other way round we'd be saying he was lucky not to get sent off if it was a yellow!

Your obsession with defending every bungling referee and every bad/wrong/incompetent decision they make continues to mystify me.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 24 Apr 17 9.39am

It was a straight red challenge ,the guy should thank his lucky stars that he was booked which stops any retrospective action from the FA .

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 24 Apr 17 10.31am

Originally posted by Willo

I think if our player was Grujic and got a 'Red', HOL would be criticising the referee.
Incidentally, Grujic was Klopp's first signing at Liverpool.

I don't think so. If one of our players did that tackle, we would be criticising him for such a reckless tackle. I'm amazed that it didn't get shown on MOTD when they spent so much time discussing Liverpool not getting a penalty (which they should have).

The FA can still act retrospectively, just because a yellow was shown doesn't stop them. However they wont.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

SeagullHunter Flag Reading 24 Apr 17 11.11am

Originally posted by topcat

I don't think so. If one of our players did that tackle, we would be criticising him for such a reckless tackle. I'm amazed that it didn't get shown on MOTD when they spent so much time discussing Liverpool not getting a penalty (which they should have).

The FA can still act retrospectively, just because a yellow was shown doesn't stop them. However they wont.

'which they should have' - really? The referee allowed play to go on, in a goalscoring opportunity which they didnt take. You can't have the best of both worlds. If a referee plays advantage and the allotted time is up, he shouldn't bring the play back.

 


Dont let Cabaye go

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Grujic foul on Tomkins