You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Playing for a clean sheet is a dangerous game
November 16 2026 9.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Playing for a clean sheet is a dangerous game


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
bodge Flag 11 May 17 7.55pm

With WH in goal and Kelly and DD as c/bs its not dangerous its suicide. We need our attacking players to be at their best or it will be another Burnley and they did not need to win they just hit high balls up to two front men and we could not cope. This will be a tough game they are playing well and it took a very good keeper to stop them last week.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 May 17 8.35pm

Originally posted by bodge

With WH in goal and Kelly and DD as c/bs its not dangerous its suicide. We need our attacking players to be at their best or it will be another Burnley and they did not need to win they just hit high balls up to two front men and we could not cope. This will be a tough game they are playing well and it took a very good keeper to stop them last week.

Tomkins may start with Kelly and Dann might be on the bench.

We can tell from Man City that Sam knows Delaney is not good enough.

 


COYP

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 11 May 17 9.55pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Tomkins may start with Kelly and Dann might be on the bench.

We can tell from Man City that Sam knows Delaney is not good enough.

As others have also opined I am of the opinion that we are unable to keep a clean sheet with the current defensive frailties. Hull losing Markovic to injury is a big bonus for us but we need to score ourselves. If Tomkins can return for Sunday that would be another bonus. I believe though that Dann is only 'possible' for the Utd game?

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 11 May 17 10.12pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

We dont have the players at the moment to set up for a clean sheet. My guess is we have to score 2 goals if we want a win or draw, so we should set up with that in mind. Even if Dann is back he hasn't played in ages and we don't know how fit he is.

Apparrently its much more likely that Tomkins will play than Dann

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 11 May 17 10.29pm

Watching Big Sam's presser I thought he was trying to play down expectations. He didn't commit on who would be healthy enough for selection and he said we wanted the players to go in with the attitude of "We can't lose this match." Normally I prefer the can-do attitude to the can't fail but given the last three matches and the thinness of the squad right now I don't think he wants to give too much away publicly. His presser was before Hull's as well.

He also said that training this week was "light." I hope he means on the pitch with more of an emphasis on building up spirit. A clean sheet means survival at this point, therefore it must be a priority. They have to get back to basics, tight in the back but attack when the opportunity arises. Above all, play as a unified team and not go off on individual tangents.

What he said about Wilf is also important. He can't let frustration get into his game. Leave the officiating to others and just play his game within the framework of the team. The ref will call what the ref will call. He can't control that (and neither can we) but at least we can't be sent off for dissent. He can.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

GladAllOver27 Flag 11 May 17 10.41pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

Watching Big Sam's presser I thought he was trying to play down expectations. He didn't commit on who would be healthy enough for selection and he said we wanted the players to go in with the attitude of "We can't lose this match." Normally I prefer the can-do attitude to the can't fail but given the last three matches and the thinness of the squad right now I don't think he wants to give too much away publicly. His presser was before Hull's as well.

He also said that training this week was "light." I hope he means on the pitch with more of an emphasis on building up spirit. A clean sheet means survival at this point, therefore it must be a priority. They have to get back to basics, tight in the back but attack when the opportunity arises. Above all, play as a unified team and not go off on individual tangents.

What he said about Wilf is also important. He can't let frustration get into his game. Leave the officiating to others and just play his game within the framework of the team. The ref will call what the ref will call. He can't control that (and neither can we) but at least we can't be sent off for dissent. He can.

Good post

 

jeeagles Flag 11 May 17 10.56pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Spot on. Swansea result is irrelevant to how they will play against us. They really have to go for the win. This will suit us as they have to come out and play and we can punish them on the counter attack. Crucial that we don't panic early on and get sloppy. Let them come to us and hit them. The more it stays level the more pressure on them, gaps will show and we can strike then. If we do score first then the pressure is really on them, they will up the ante and we could easily finish them off. Major thing is not to concede any sloppy goals early as we would be then under pressure.

Agreed. From their point of view, Hull will be the most incentivised team in the league wanting a win come Sunday. All the other teams are pretty much on holiday all ready. From their point of view they would be wanting to play anyone else apart from us, as we are only looking for a point. Big Sam has reinforced that with his press conference, effectively telling Hull that if they are planning to take us on the break it won't work as we are happy to take the draw.

One of the positives about Palace this year is that we always look like scoring on the break, this means when they come at us they can't overly expose themselves at the back. If they do go 1-0 up they won't be able to risk 10 men behind the ball in case of the equaliser either.

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 11 May 17 11.31pm

1. Defend, defend, defend.
2. Zaha shut up and don't get carded.
3. Don't commit forward AT ALL, except for hoof-balls.
4. Lock up shop. 1 plan. For 90 mins.
5. Don't allow them to play.

A team needing to score a goal cannot beat a team only defending. I know this will get negative responses, but this match is different. All we need to do is hoof the ball way for 90 mins. They'll be forced to commit more players, and we'd probably get goals anyway from only a Zaha/Tomkins + Benteke. I'd be very disappointed if we can't manage this simple objective.

 


[Link]

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 11 May 17 11.37pm

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

1. Defend, defend, defend.
2. Zaha shut up and don't get carded.
3. Don't commit forward AT ALL, except for hoof-balls.
4. Lock up shop. 1 plan. For 90 mins.
5. Don't allow them to play.

A team needing to score a goal cannot beat a team only defending. I know this will get negative responses, but this match is different. All we need to do is hoof the ball way for 90 mins. They'll be forced to commit more players, and we'd probably get goals anyway from only a Zaha/Tomkins + Benteke. I'd be very disappointed if we can't manage this simple objective.

Ah! Got Tomkins on the brain - meant Townsend. And don't get me wrong about defending only, as I don't mean the whole team sitting deep, but AGGRESSIVE defending all over the pitch starting in their first third. I'm not even contending we change our usual shape, just that the wingers, mids and Benteke will be slightly more defensively biased in their game. I don't mean everyone sitting deep.

 


[Link]

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 12 May 17 2.36am

And keep back-passing in own half to a minimum. This time around a hoof-ball (most of the time) a better option.....

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 12 May 17 7.18am

I can see where the proponents of hoof-ball are coming from but, if we do concede a goal can anyone believe we will score with these tactics?

We will need some ball control and passing skills to set Benteke up. He will score - IF he gets the ball.

I am praying that Cabaye is fit and I would also play Lee instead of Puncheon who needs more time to get a pass away as he struggles with his ball control.

Zaha is a match winner except he will have three markers so we need someone who can link with him and utilise the space these markers concede.

Hoof-ball shows panic and only puts the pressure back on our depleted defence.

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 12 May 17 7.36am

Originally posted by Uphill

I can see where the proponents of hoof-ball are coming from but, if we do concede a goal can anyone believe we will score with these tactics?

We will need some ball control and passing skills to set Benteke up. He will score - IF he gets the ball.

I am praying that Cabaye is fit and I would also play Lee instead of Puncheon who needs more time to get a pass away as he struggles with his ball control.

Zaha is a match winner except he will have three markers so we neeed someone who can link with him and utilise the space these markers concede.

Hoof-ball shows panic and only puts the pressure back on our depleted defence.

They need a win so I don't think they can commit three players to Wilf. I think he'll get some freedom playing on the right especially as Robertson likes to get forward for them and will thus be open to a quick break down that side.

Edited by Direwolf (12 May 2017 7.38am)

 

PhuketEagle Flag Phuket 12 May 17 8.40am

As we've only kept about 6 clean sheets all season its not a good idea IMO to play for one. The chances are the oppo will score, so we need to get that first goal. That means controlling possession & attacking them when chances come. If it works then Hull would be so desperate they'd be likely to make mistakes leading to GAME OVER.
Think there will be goals in this. Counting down the minutes almost now! 2 days 3 hrs 50 mins....

 

chateauferret Flag 12 May 17 9.09am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

1. Defend, defend, defend.
2. Zaha shut up and don't get carded.
3. Don't commit forward AT ALL, except for hoof-balls.
4. Lock up shop. 1 plan. For 90 mins.
5. Don't allow them to play.

A team needing to score a goal cannot beat a team only defending
. I know this will get negative responses, but this match is different. All we need to do is hoof the ball way for 90 mins. They'll be forced to commit more players, and we'd probably get goals anyway from only a Zaha/Tomkins + Benteke. I'd be very disappointed if we can't manage this simple objective.

It can if the defending is tom tit. It had better not be.

 


============
The Ferret
============

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 12 May 17 10.05am

Originally posted by chateauferret

It can if the defending is tom tit. It had better not be.

Point taken. I could have added 'all things being equal' it's a damn sight easier to JUST defend than to score.

Our recent defensive errors are (IMO) because we've been asking our once solid CBs (Damo, Kelly, Dann) to both defend AND launch attacks. If you think about most of our gaffs this season it's trying to do exactly this, both for Pardew and Sam.

Now, for Hull's game, all we're asking is, "Forget that fancy sh1t and just do what you always did before".
Damo and Kelly will be fine for this. Here's hoping.

 


[Link]

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 12 May 17 10.13am

Originally posted by Uphill

I can see where the proponents of hoof-ball are coming from but, if we do concede a goal can anyone believe we will score with these tactics?

We will need some ball control and passing skills to set Benteke up. He will score - IF he gets the ball.

I am praying that Cabaye is fit and I would also play Lee instead of Puncheon who needs more time to get a pass away as he struggles with his ball control.

Zaha is a match winner except he will have three markers so we need someone who can link with him and utilise the space these markers concede.

Hoof-ball shows panic and only puts the pressure back on our depleted defence.

Sorry mate but what is your problem? You really think people are suggesting we keep the defensive 'hoofball' tactics IF THEY FRIGGIN SCORE? The idea is that they DON'T. If they do, then that strategy is f&cked ain't it?

 


[Link]

Waynetta191177 Flag Camborne 12 May 17 10.17am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

1. Defend, defend, defend.
2. Zaha shut up and don't get carded.
3. Don't commit forward AT ALL, except for hoof-balls.
4. Lock up shop. 1 plan. For 90 mins.
5. Don't allow them to play.

A team needing to score a goal cannot beat a team only defending. I know this will get negative responses, but this match is different. All we need to do is hoof the ball way for 90 mins. They'll be forced to commit more players, and we'd probably get goals anyway from only a Zaha/Tomkins + Benteke. I'd be very disappointed if we can't manage this simple objective.

We cant defend so we should use our best arsenal wiv our front 3. Give the ball to them and bloody pray

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 12 May 17 10.19am

Originally posted by Waynetta191177

We cant defend so we should use our best arsenal wiv our front 3. Give the ball to them and bloody pray

Okaaaaay...

 


[Link]

Monty the Eagle Flag Lima 12 May 17 12.26pm

I don't actually expect Hull to go all out attack against us. They will just commit men on the numerous free kicks that we concede in our own half.

Silva is a good coach and therefore he won't want to give us the ability to counter attack.

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 12 May 17 12.34pm

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

Sorry mate but what is your problem? You really think people are suggesting we keep the defensive 'hoofball' tactics IF THEY FRIGGIN SCORE? The idea is that they DON'T. If they do, then that strategy is f&cked ain't it?

I think I'd be happier with this if I thought that hoofball was actually a strategy. Sadly I think it reflected a lack of passing accuracy more than deliberate intent.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Playing for a clean sheet is a dangerous game