This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well they were involved in supporting the Japanese Red Army, and attacks across the far east among Western Allies. They're not a threat to the west now either. Its a potential risk, but North Korea isn't going to launch a nuclear strike on a couple of US cities, as it knows that it would cease to exist within 7 minutes or so. Its not even mutually assured destruction - just destruction. Plus the command and elite of North Korea are just as likely to replace the supreme leader as follow any order that ends their comfortable or privillaged existence. Jamie as you have pretty much stated your support for essentially the CND position I don't really have that much faith in your analysis as to what is and what isn't a threat. The leadership of NK feel under constant threat already....and that's just from their own countrymen. I wouldn't be at all surprised if they had built an extensive underground complex for the main bigwigs and a lot of the army. A nuclear war is unlikely but not unfeasible. The main point for NK is to blackmail the region and the west. China is quite happy to have an anti western state dependent state on its flank. I have little trust in the honestly of the face it shows towards the west in this regard. What the Obama era and his supporters have given us is a world in which this region is now in also constant fear of war. They passed the buck....Obama wasn't respected by China nor Russia and we live in a more dangerous world because of it.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
There are two questions. At what point do you do something and when you have made that decision, what are you going to do? The threat from N Korea has evolved over time 1967 sank a S Korean vessel 1994 N Korea threat a sea of fire 2002 Threatened to mercilessly wipe out aggressors Even now, what case does anyone have to take action against N Korea? Sanctions are already in place. Do you think China will sit back and allow military intervention? Trump's position is essentially the correct one. If China doesn't stop NK's nuclear threat then the US will. What the policy is beyond that I can only summise. NK's ability to reach the nearest US bases are now becoming a possible reality. It will just continue on from there. I for one won't countenance paying the danegeld. A very real threat to drop a nuclear missile to wipe out Pyongyang within a time limit unless all weaponized nuclear development is verifiably stopped is the only language this modern day 'Sparta' slave state will understand if it doesn't and China can't change it then it has to go. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 May 2017 11.58am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
This is very true. However, once NK has developed...which it has or is near to developing, missiles which can strike your military bases and from there goes on to develop missiles with the explicit ability to reach your country....Once this option becomes a near reality non action is no longer an option. Well, it is for plenty of people it seems. For me I would no accept what is so obviously coming. North Korea already has missiles capable of striking US bases throughout the far east (notably the US bases in South Korea and Japan). The reality of any attack on North Korea by the US, is that they will launch retaliatory strikes aimed at Japan and South Korea. That has always been their plan. Even if they had intercontinental missiles, I suspect they would still focus their nuclear armoury (around five devices) at Japan and South Korea simply because their certain to strike and neither country has any theoretical capacity to bring them down. Five nuclear strikes on say South Korea or Japan isn't going to be an acceptable price for preventing North Korea having a missile capable of hitting the US (that's without counting their capacity with more conventional weapons of mass destruction). So you'd need to be certain that you could obliterate their capacity to retaliate. Or be absolutely certain that its a bluff. Its a cold war stalemate. They can't assure our destruction, but they probably can assure that the cost in lives to our allies, and economy is catastrophic, whilst we could in theory reduce the whole of the North to a nuclear wasteland (of course that's not going to go down well in South Korea, once the wind changes direction).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
They probably already have nuclear weapons, so utilising any kind of military intervention is going to result in them using them (probably on South Korea and Japan). We know that they certainly have the missile capability to hit those two countries. That's not counting their stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons. Their missile technology is sufficient to deliver mass casualty weapons sufficient to devastate Western Client-States and allies through out the far east. So a direct military intervention is more problematic than waiting. Flooding Japan and South Korea with anti missile systems is their only hope. It is either this or they are soon going to be paying the danegeld or risking being used as a test. Maybe then we shall see if a response happens.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
No it isn't. This is the problem with this analysis is that it is extremely short term. North Korea will continue on to develop its missile technology until it can be accurate and reach all its foes not just the region. From there the danegeld.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Trump's position is essentially the correct one. If China doesn't stop NK's nuclear threat then the US will. What the policy is beyond that I con only summise. NK's ability to reach the nearest US bases are now becoming a possible reality. It will just continue on from there. I for one won't countenance paying the danegeld. A very real threat to drop a nuclear missile to wipe out Pyongyang within a time limit unless all weaponized nuclear development is verifiably stopped is the only language this modern day 'Sparta' slave state will understand if it doesn't and China can't change it then it has to go. I don't think its quite as simple as a moral stance. Either you negotiate the price for peace, and that involves some give, or you work out just how many people you're prepared to see die for your moral high point. Pragmatically, we could be talking about millions of dead people, and the relative destruction of many Japanese metropolises and most of South Korea and that may be before you start to count military casualties. Do I like that we occasionally have to make a deal with North Korea every few years, no. But I don't think that we (or the US) can really influence North Korea militarily to give up its nuclear programs either. So we're back an in impasse. Do we start a war, which we can only likely win with massive casualties, or look at whether the 'dane gold' is reasonable. After all, if the price of peace is reasonable, then why not. Its not like they're demanding that we all join the Communist Party.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No it isn't. This is the problem with this analysis is that it is extremely short term. North Korea will continue on to develop its missile technology until it can be accurate and reach all its foes not just the region. From there the danegeld. So are you saying, we should strike now, whilst the only likely casualties are foreigners and the US servicemen stationed in the area? I think Japan and South Korea would rather be paying the danegold indefinitely, provided the price isn't too extortionate, and the demands aren't unreasonable. In fairness, North Koreas capability with missile technology is such, that it might be able to hit the US. They still won't launch more than a symbolic strike against the US. Their plan has always been to retaliate against US aggression by targeting Japan and South Korea.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I don't think its quite as simple as a moral stance. Either you negotiate the price for peace, and that involves some give, or you work out just how many people you're prepared to see die for your moral high point. Pragmatically, we could be talking about millions of dead people, and the relative destruction of many Japanese metropolises and most of South Korea and that may be before you start to count military casualties. Do I like that we occasionally have to make a deal with North Korea every few years, no. But I don't think that we (or the US) can really influence North Korea militarily to give up its nuclear programs either. So we're back an in impasse. Do we start a war, which we can only likely win with massive casualties, or look at whether the 'dane gold' is reasonable. After all, if the price of peace is reasonable, then why not. Its not like they're demanding that we all join the Communist Party. You are quite the modern day 'Chamberlain' Jamie. Again, I think this analysis is short sighted. Once you accept the danegeld with NK you show that blackmail works and you encourage this approach with other emerging states. For me personally I would never agree to this. Of course...I only represent an opinion as does any individual. Japan and South Korea can make their own minds up or course but I think it's a foolish path. The US needs to draw a line in the sand quickly before it loses all its options here. NK is essentially China's little barking dog and we are the scared tart standing on the chair. I'm afraid it's calculation like yours Jamie that has led us here. Destroying the capital Pyongyang has to be a real possibility. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 May 2017 12.18pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I don't think its quite as simple as a moral stance. Either you negotiate the price for peace, and that involves some give, or you work out just how many people you're prepared to see die for your moral high point. Pragmatically, we could be talking about millions of dead people, and the relative destruction of many Japanese metropolises and most of South Korea and that may be before you start to count military casualties. Do I like that we occasionally have to make a deal with North Korea every few years, no. But I don't think that we (or the US) can really influence North Korea militarily to give up its nuclear programs either. So we're back an in impasse. Do we start a war, which we can only likely win with massive casualties, or look at whether the 'dane gold' is reasonable. After all, if the price of peace is reasonable, then why not. Its not like they're demanding that we all join the Communist Party. Not yet - be patient. I was going to mention Chamberlain, but Stirling has beat me to it.
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
So are you saying, we should strike now, whilst the only likely casualties are foreigners and the US servicemen stationed in the area? I think Japan and South Korea would rather be paying the danegold indefinitely, provided the price isn't too extortionate, and the demands aren't unreasonable. In fairness, North Koreas capability with missile technology is such, that it might be able to hit the US. They still won't launch more than a symbolic strike against the US. Their plan has always been to retaliate against US aggression by targeting Japan and South Korea. You can't be certain of NK's intentions and you don't build a defence policy on guesses on intentions....You build it on capacity. With the USSR we knew we had a rational opponent, whereas with North Korea we have guesswork. If Japan and South Korea wish to bend its knee then that's for them....though I wouldn't be so certain that this would carry much favour for long in Japan. They need to be building underground bunkers....Hell, it's a crime that this hasn't been invested in even here. I've said what I think should be done...I wouldn't be surprised if Trump's team has done this already. You provide your client states with as much anti missile capacity as possible. Notice that China object heavily to this...How surprising. Then you tell China and its barking dog that once you assess that they have advanced their strike capacity to a certain stage that they will lose Pyongyang. This is what happens when you continue to pass the buck down the line and let the problem continue to grow. It should be made very clear that we won't be paying any danegeld.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You are quite the modern day 'Chamberlain' Jamie. Again, I think this analysis is short sighted. Once you accept the danegeld with NK you show that blackmail works and you encourage this approach with other emerging states. For me personally I would never agree to this. Of course...I only represent an opinion as does any individual. Japan and South Korea can make their own minds up or course but I think it's a foolish path. The US needs to draw a line in the sand quickly before it loses all its options here. NK is essentially China's little barking dog and we are the scared tart standing on the chair. I'm afraid it's calculation like yours Jamie that has led us here. Destroying the capital Pyongyang has to be a real possibility. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 May 2017 12.18pm) If we can escape the rhetroric for a minute, of who is who, I'm not really suggesting that dane gold is anything more than negotiations - Something that happens with every country in the world. What do I think will happen, well the US line in the sand will be 'the face to the world' and in truth, they'll negotiate a solution behind the scenes with the Chinese. The US won't I think, do much more than rattle its sabres, the two sides will face off, and that'll be that for another few years. Both sides will them claim a great victory. Same as always happens. They're not going to give up their nuclear program, any more than Iran will, because ultimately, its their main means of political engagement with the outside world, and their leverage. Full scale military intervention? If I'm Chamberlin, then you're Jack Ripper (Dr Strangelove).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You can't be certain of NK's intentions and you don't build a defence policy on guesses on intentions....You build it on capacity. With the USSR we knew we had a rational opponent, whereas with North Korea we have guesswork. Of course they're rational, because irrational dictators tend to end up 'having accidents'. They seem irrational, but like anything, the 'Leader' isn't really the person in charge, they're the symbol of power. They're not, as a rule, raving mad men. And even if they are, they tend to be quickly replaced, because like any other system, the elite have their own interests at heart. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
If Japan and South Korea wish to bend its knee then that's for them....though I wouldn't be so certain that this would carry much favour for long in Japan. They need to be building underground bunkers....Hell, it's a crime that this hasn't been invested in even here. I think Japan might be more concerned that they'd carry the vast weight of the retaliation for the US foreign policy. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It should be made very clear that we won't be paying any danegeld. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 May 2017 12.31pm) We're not though, we're negotiating with them, because the consequence of an actual war with North Korea potentially means millions on dead in South Korea and Japan - Which isn't an acceptable price for preventing North Korean missile research.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
If we can escape the rhetroric for a minute, of who is who, I'm not really suggesting that dane gold is anything more than negotiations - Something that happens with every country in the world. What do I think will happen, well the US line in the sand will be 'the face to the world' and in truth, they'll negotiate a solution behind the scenes with the Chinese. The US won't I think, do much more than rattle its sabres, the two sides will face off, and that'll be that for another few years. Both sides will them claim a great victory. Same as always happens. They're not going to give up their nuclear program, any more than Iran will, because ultimately, its their main means of political engagement with the outside world, and their leverage. Full scale military intervention? If I'm Chamberlin, then you're Jack Ripper (Dr Strangelove).
Come on James...the rhetoric is half the fun. As for 'Jack the Ripper' well he got away with it. Chamberlain died a quite unpleasant death while we were still very much in peril. A noble but unfortunately duped actor on the world stage. You see these 'negotiations' with China will result in very little result without the real intent for actual military action on NK. The 'Obamas' of this world just don't cut it. A defensively minded and supplicant west is very much a desired state for China's regional ambitions. I hope you are right about the 'behind the scenes' negotiations with China. That's what should happen but I think it's fifty fifty myself......I don't see NK being easily talked out from a blackmail position myself. Real ball twisting is required.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
We're not though, we're negotiating with them, because the consequence of an actual war with North Korea potentially means millions on dead in South Korea and Japan - Which isn't an acceptable price for preventing North Korean missile research. I wish I could say I agreed with any of your analysis on this topic Jamie. Regardless we are pawns on the board and we will see where the Kings and Queens move us. Quite a while ago I started looking for what I should do for my family in the result of a nuclear attack....I'm probably fifty miles away from the most likely target.....third degree burns at worse, building would stand up and depending on the wind direction half an hour to get underground with provisions....Still, I swiftly discovered that there is no provision for the general public. You can't even easily get planning permission to start building an underground bunker. I think the general public need to start putting pressure on the government for more of a 'cold war' mentality. We need the options to create communal bunkers. Up s*** creek without a paddle. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 May 2017 1.16pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| .TUX. |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I wish I could say I agreed with any of your analysis on this topic Jamie. Regardless we are pawns on the board and we will see where the Kings and Queens move us. Quite a while ago I started looking for what I should do for my family in the result of a nuclear attack....I'm probably fifty miles away from the most likely target.....third degree burns at worse, building would stand up and depending on the wind direction half an hour to get underground with provisions....Still, I swiftly discovered that there is no provision for the general public. You can't even easily get planning permission to start building an underground bunker. I think the general public need to start putting pressure on the government for more of a 'cold war' mentality. We need the options to create communal bunkers. Up s*** creek without a paddle. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 May 2017 1.16pm) It's a tough call but ultimately the best bet may well be to move 50miles closer and get it over with.
Buy Litecoin. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The policy on North Korea is seemingly to wait until it is powerful enough to blackmail western and regional states for money and influence to avoid nuclear war. Leaders preferring to pass on the problem to the next administration. In history it's a bit like paying the danegeld to avoid the raiding Vikings....the softness of the rich and entitled west exposed on the world stage. Anyone have any thoughts on the issue? Trump and the new South Korean head chap have both said they'd be up for meeting him in the right circumstances. No one wants a war so engagement and conversation is the best route to bringing about a better way of N Korea working with the rest of the world. It might just be the olive branch they need to dig their backwards regime and poor people out of the dark ages.
|
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
Trump and the new South Korean head chap have both said they'd be up for meeting him in the right circumstances. No one wants a war so engagement and conversation is the best route to bringing about a better way of N Korea working with the rest of the world. It might just be the olive branch they need to dig their backwards regime and poor people out of the dark ages. Perhaps they could meet in Munich?
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
|
Originally posted by .TUX.
It's a tough call but ultimately the best bet may well be to move 50miles closer and get it over with. I think that's what a lot of people say....I don't think they actually mean it. Anyway when you have kids there survival becomes more important.....hence why I get irritated with the incompetent easy wittering away of the west's advantages over the last few decades. Inaction and buck passing became policy. Well, if the worse is realised the elites get the bunkers while the plebs get the radiation. I'm not interested in outrage and finger pointing after the fact. We must not be put into a situation where an enemy can blackmail us over nuclear war. Those who allow this situation to be realised must be held accountable for it....retrospectively if necessary.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Come on James...the rhetoric is half the fun. As for 'Jack the Ripper' well he got away with it. Chamberlain died a quite unpleasant death while we were still very much in peril. A noble but unfortunately duped actor on the world stage. You see these 'negotiations' with China will result in very little result without the real intent for actual military action on NK. The 'Obamas' of this world just don't cut it. A defensively minded and supplicant west is very much a desired state for China's regional ambitions. I hope you are right about the 'behind the scenes' negotiations with China. That's what should happen but I think it's fifty fifty myself......I don't see NK being easily talked out from a blackmail position myself. Real ball twisting is required. I was thinking Jack D. Ripper from Dr Stangelove. With N Korea, I'd imagine that the only real hope is a negotiated agreement and some shifty CIA work behind the scenes to get the 'right man' in place. The real thing to leverage N Korea with is food, but the problem is getting news to the public, that in return for ending the Nuke program the UN would provide food relief to eradicate the regular famines that wrack the nation and the people. N Korea is a bit like Israel, but with China as the USA in terms of protection of the client state. Without China, North Korea is f**ked - There is no one to trade with. A bit of 'blackmail' is acceptable. its how the world works with military leverage. The US isn't beyond backing up its 'political interests' with some military muscle. North Korea, will demand what they want, the US will demand what they want, and they'll meet somewhere in the middle around what they can live with. Likely as not, NK will settle for not developing ICBM technology and solid state fuel systems that they require, and likely the Chinese will provide the compromise the US wants, and in turn the North Koreans will compromise with China. North Korea will continue its Nuclear program, but restrict the number of warheads they build (mostly because they're massively expensive, and they can't afford to produce too many, or maintain too many).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I wish I could say I agreed with any of your analysis on this topic Jamie. Regardless we are pawns on the board and we will see where the Kings and Queens move us. Quite a while ago I started looking for what I should do for my family in the result of a nuclear attack....I'm probably fifty miles away from the most likely target.....third degree burns at worse, building would stand up and depending on the wind direction half an hour to get underground with provisions....Still, I swiftly discovered that there is no provision for the general public. You can't even easily get planning permission to start building an underground bunker. I think the general public need to start putting pressure on the government for more of a 'cold war' mentality. We need the options to create communal bunkers. Up s*** creek without a paddle. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 May 2017 1.16pm) Well it is kind of a cold war mentality with North Korea. They're sanctioned up the wazoo, with hardly any external trade, with both sides of the last parallel on a war in hours footing. Its a bit like China. Relations and trade in the cold war were non-existent, but over time, slowly but surely, things changed. To the point that the US and China are so economically entwined as to be co-dependent. All of which really started with Nixon of all people.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.