This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by MrCParrot
Its an excellent argument. Kone is clearly not better than Sakho but we still need a left back, so Kone & Jenkinson is better than Sakho in the greater scheme of things. So its down to available budget and working out what gives us the best value for the positions we need to fill. Kone is better than Damo. Parrot This is key, and let's be honest, none of us know how much we have to spend. We could have anything between £10m to £100m, to spend, maybe more.
|
|
|
He can be a foundation to support the development of our young players.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
It's certainly true that if they've stupidly decided they don't need money to acquire the players they'll need then they won't be coming in for McArthur. I don't see the need to sell him to replace with like, if his current form/fitness matters are likely to be resolved over the summer. And he isn't surplus to requirements. Of course the player may decide that he wants to leave but if that is the case why would he go to Seaweed of all places? The only certainty about that would be championship football in 2018/9. Surely he would get better offers than that. Edited by chateauferret (15 May 2017 10.42pm) Yeah I don't see it happening either (MacArthur going to Brighton) and good reasons you've mentioned
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by nairb75
everton's defense is rubbish. they have money and europe. could be tough to beat. could probably help MU as well but they won't think he's good enough. If they were not city rivals, it seems an obvious move Our best chance with Liverpool is that they take Schlupp or PVA in part exchange. They need a left back (or 2 with CL) and hopefully with Souare back we are well covered there. Of course, without showing his ability with us over just 8 matches, Liverpool would be struggling to regain their 18 million outlay on a player who hadn't played for a year and with a manager who would never use him again
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrCParrot
Its an excellent argument. Kone is clearly not better than Sakho but we still need a left back, so Kone & Jenkinson is better than Sakho in the greater scheme of things. So its down to available budget and working out what gives us the best value for the positions we need to fill. Kone is better than Damo. Parrot
In all seriousness: yes, a right back is definitely needed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by pssguy
If they were not city rivals, it seems an obvious move Our best chance with Liverpool is that they take Schlupp or PVA in part exchange. They need a left back (or 2 with CL) and hopefully with Souare back we are well covered there. Of course, without showing his ability with us over just 8 matches, Liverpool would be struggling to regain their 18 million outlay on a player who hadn't played for a year and with a manager who would never use him again You're right, but I think they'll sign Bertrand off of Southampton.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrCParrot
Its an excellent argument. Kone is clearly not better than Sakho but we still need a left back, so Kone & Jenkinson is better than Sakho in the greater scheme of things. So its down to available budget and working out what gives us the best value for the positions we need to fill. Kone is better than Damo. Parrot
|
|
|
Sahko and Kone as our two centre backs next season, what a beast of a pairing they'd be!
|
|
|
Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme
You're right, but I think they'll sign Bertrand off of Southampton. I think it's some sort of rule that they have to sign at least one Southampton player a year.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
[link]http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/mamadou-sakho-films-fans-chanting-13033234[/link] Probably reading into it far to much but his actions have shown to me that he wants to stay. After being flogged by PSG and mistreated at Liverpool he may be enjoying his time here being a bigger fish (tin hat) in a smaller pond and receiving the praise that goes with it. I don't think he'll go to a top club. Saints, West Ham, and Leicester could probably offer a better deal than us if they want him but he'd think before going to any of them after making such a good start here. Then I'm not sure if any other club in the league could make a more tempting offer. Edited by jeeagles (15 May 2017 11.02pm) Why would anyone want to go to West Ham. This season has been a terrible advert for them. Playing at that ground with the fans miles away and half of the seats empty can't be that much fun. I'd imagine it would be much more satisfying as a pro to play in front of a full ground, with fans singing and right on top of the pitch.
|
|
| bubble wrap |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Why would anyone want to go to West Ham. This season has been a terrible advert for them. Playing at that ground with the fans miles away and half of the seats empty can't be that much fun. I'd imagine it would be much more satisfying as a pro to play in front of a full ground, with fans singing and right on top of the pitch. Players will go to clubs willing to pay them the most money. Anyone who thinks that players go to a club because of their fanbase is deluded. West Ham have a lot more to offer than us. Very big crowds, new stadium, better facilities etc but as io said it is about money. The more they get the easier it is to sign them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydonlad
It seemed yesterday by Sakho's comments that he wants to play elsewhere And yet he was at the Hull game on crutches and joined the squad on the pitch when he could just have easily been back on Merseyside. That sounds like a man rushing to get away.
Cynic or realist? It's a fine line! |
|
|
Originally posted by sa_eagle
And yet he was at the Hull game on crutches and joined the squad on the pitch when he could just have easily been back on Merseyside. That sounds like a man rushing to get away. And again, he was sat on the Palace bench at Liverpool, celebrating when we won, that doesnt scream loyalty to Liverpool.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.