You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The FA Cup final- A year on
November 16 2026 9.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The FA Cup final- A year on


CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 17 May 17 1.42pm

Here's the team that started that day. The question is would the current side now of won the cup on that day .

Hennessy
Ward
Dann
Delaney
Soaure
Cabaye
Jedinak
mcarthur
Zaha
Bolasie
Wickham

Subs:- speroni, Gayle, adebayor, sako, Kelly, Mariappa , puncheon

What your feeling on this? (If it doesn't bring back bad memories)

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Mad4palace Flag 17 May 17 1.46pm

The key difference is the manager, Pardew deserves credit for getting us there but again we showed naivety in that game, especially after Man United went down to 10 men.

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 17 May 17 1.52pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

The key difference is the manager, Pardew deserves credit for getting us there but again we showed naivety in that game, especially after Man United went down to 10 men.

Actually your right. The game management from pardew or the lack of it cost us that day. If we had Benteke though might of given us that extra edge.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

chateauferret Flag 17 May 17 1.55pm

Yes, because Cl*****f**k wouldn't be reffing it.

 


============
The Ferret
============

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 17 May 17 1.58pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Yes, because Cl*****f**k wouldn't be reffing it.

The lack of play on decision costs us dearly. That said your 1-0 up with a 5 minutes to play. I'm sure big Sam side wouldn't of conceded.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

chateauferret Flag 17 May 17 2.08pm

No, he would not. He would've been making sure the team kept its shape and remained focused on keeping United away from our goal, instead of doing stupid dances and posing for the cameras.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Mad4palace Flag 17 May 17 2.11pm

Mariappa off the bench also sort of cost us, he had looked extremely poor that season when he did make an appearance, I think losing Dann and for Mariappa to come on did affect the players. If it were today and Dann or Kelly to come on for Sakho/Tomkins then it wouldn't have been such a blow.

Townsend vs Bolasie is an interesting one, Bolasie had a poor game that day but for me is still much better than Andros. BUT the Andros of today works so much harder for the team that it's feasible to say he would have played better in that final for us.

But are we also saying that Man United would have Ibrahimovic, Pogba, Mkhitaryan, Bailly etc?

 

Part Time James Flag 17 May 17 2.11pm

The bench is just as important as the XI there. We could put out a much stronger bench this year that could be utilised to steady the ship.

I assume we're talking about our current squad if there were no injuries though? Without the injuries of Tomkins and Sakho the centre back pairing we could put out now would be a lot better (also assuming Sakho was on a loan contract that allowed him to play).

 




Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 17 May 17 2.19pm

Horrible day moved my holiday back a day 14 family went out on the day and I'd booked a new flight on the Sunday
Was like 1990 all over again so close yet so far :'(
Punch should have started and Gayle for all of the 2nd half, dont even want to mention c***enberg ffs makes me puke!
Although I dont want to blame anyone but Jedi should have taken Rooney out he just ran and ran with the ball for what seemed like forever

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 17 May 17 3.06pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

The key difference is the manager, Pardew deserves credit for getting us there but again we showed naivety in that game, especially after Man United went down to 10 men.

In hindsight, we were witnessing not only Pardew's naivety, but also the lack of fitness that was creeping into the squad. We lost to 10 men in extra time, and never really looked like winning it with the man advantage.

Allardyce's team would've had the legs to dominate in extra time, not that they would've conceded after going 1-up in the first place.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 17 May 17 3.08pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

But are we also saying that Man United would have Ibrahimovic, Pogba, Mkhitaryan, Bailly etc?


Have you watched this year's team? Looked at the league table?

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

suttonEagle2010 Flag Shirley 17 May 17 3.46pm

I know we don't really have anything to play for but I think we may well get a good idea on Sunday.

 

chateauferret Flag 17 May 17 4.01pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Mariappa off the bench also sort of cost us, he had looked extremely poor that season when he did make an appearance, I think losing Dann and for Mariappa to come on did affect the players. If it were today and Dann or Kelly to come on for Sakho/Tomkins then it wouldn't have been such a blow.

Townsend vs Bolasie is an interesting one, Bolasie had a poor game that day but for me is still much better than Andros. BUT the Andros of today works so much harder for the team that it's feasible to say he would have played better in that final for us.

But are we also saying that Man United would have Ibrahimovic, Pogba, Mkhitaryan, Bailly etc?

Yes, I also think he might have intended to use Adebayor but lost his third substitution to Dann's injury.

If we were playing that lot today of course Ibrahimovic would be injured.

 


============
The Ferret
============

leejaneagles Flag 17 May 17 4.23pm

I feel like that was the perfect blend of everything going right with the wrong man in charge that year.

If you think about what Pep and Jose will bring to the Manchester squads this summer, plus Chelsea's strength already, plus Arsenal being in the final 3 of the last 4 and you wonder when a little clubs gonna get another chance.

Last year Chelsea were shocking, City not far behind them, Leicester upsetting everybody and Arsenal having a rare early exit from the cup was a great chance that might not be repeated.

Coupled with us 'only' having to beat Spurs as true top class opposition on the way to the final we really looked a gift horse in the mouth last year.

1-0 up against an unsettled Man Utd, LVG's last game no matter what and a red car...where's our Manager? Oh, doing the Macarana down the touch line.

If that's Big Sam he throws on another defender and sits everyone back. A fat Rooney can't penetrate our defense and starts to kick out and scream before eventually the final whistle.

So in answer to original question, our squad (and Manager) a year ago would have won the cup. I just don't see how we get this squad and Manager into a FA Cup final over the next few years unfortunately.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 17 May 17 5.00pm

I just remember the absolute tidal wave of emotions that afternoon when it was 1-1. That feeling of it being so close. One goal and it was ours. Crazy feelings.


When that first goal went in. The absolute euphoria. I was right at the back of the upper tier and complete strangers were hugging and kissing each other. For those few minutes the fa cup was ours and it was a magical feeling I will never forget

Edited by Michaelawt85 (17 May 2017 5.06pm)

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

suttonEagle2010 Flag Shirley 17 May 17 6.59pm

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

I just remember the absolute tidal wave of emotions that afternoon when it was 1-1. That feeling of it being so close. One goal and it was ours. Crazy feelings.


When that first goal went in. The absolute euphoria. I was right at the back of the upper tier and complete strangers were hugging and kissing each other. For those few minutes the fa cup was ours and it was a magical feeling I will never forget

Edited by Michaelawt85 (17 May 2017 5.06pm)

Yeah that would have been me. To be fair though I started doing that long before the goal went in, in fact probably before kick off!

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 17 May 17 7.46pm

Exactly as I was screaming from my seat the moment Puncheon scored his last goal for Palace. Organise, shape, tackle... then when won, celebrate.
If only we had the Kelly (of now), back then instead of Watford bound mariappa


Originally posted by chateauferret

No, he would not. He would've been making sure the team kept its shape and remained focused on keeping United away from our goal, instead of doing stupid dances and posing for the cameras.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 17 May 17 7.50pm

Why on earth was he on the bench, what did he ever do at Palace, what has he done since. The only time he tried in a match was the last match at Southampton.. Good riddance!! Upset the dressing room with high wages and no commitment!!


Originally posted by chateauferret

Yes, I also think he might have intended to use Adebayor but lost his third substitution to Dann's injury.

If we were playing that lot today of course Ibrahimovic would be injured.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 17 May 17 7.53pm

Yes I saw all the hype on TV prior to match about Bolasie plus he was "off". so was not longer committed!! Plus he was upset by the Addebadbuy high wages

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Mariappa off the bench also sort of cost us, he had looked extremely poor that season when he did make an appearance, I think losing Dann and for Mariappa to come on did affect the players. If it were today and Dann or Kelly to come on for Sakho/Tomkins then it wouldn't have been such a blow.

Townsend vs Bolasie is an interesting one, Bolasie had a poor game that day but for me is still much better than Andros. BUT the Andros of today works so much harder for the team that it's feasible to say he would have played better in that final for us.

But are we also saying that Man United would have Ibrahimovic, Pogba, Mkhitaryan, Bailly etc?

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The FA Cup final- A year on