You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > will the nhs ever be privatised?
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

will the nhs ever be privatised?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 22 May 17 7.04am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3171991]

Unless the NHS drags itself away from it's 1950/60's state run behemoth attitude, it is probably inevitable.

I worked directly for them for a year. The amount of "it's not my job, mate" I heard was unbelievable. I worked as 'foreman' for the newly set up Minor Works Team. The team consisted of me (a carpenter) and an electrician (I had 3 different ones as they wouldn't sign off the dodgy work they were asked to do and left). We had two secretaries, a line manager, a department manager, and a director of management. I had to have meetings with the above management at least three times weekly. I had to do all the surveying, risk assessment, method statement, ordering of materials, checking said orders, arranging when I could access wards/theatres/treatment areas/public areas, &etc. All this and much more without anyone who worked there helping me if I needed information. It was my job,"Find out yourself mate, I didn't know when I started, why should I tell you!", "But you know now", "Yeah, but I ain't telling you, I'm Maintenance"

I lasted a year. The place is incredibly backward.

There is also, sadly, a lot of truth in this. Speak to anyone that works in the NHS and they will be able to tell you about the inefficiency they see on a daily basis. Like any big company I guess

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 22 May 17 8.06am

Originally posted by Mapletree

You are missing the point.

We eat far too many carbs and in part it's because it's so much easier in all ways than eating better food.

No I am not. We eat too much full stop and yes that does include carbs. We eat more but physically less active than we were even 30 years ago.

There are many reasons why we are where we are but one of them is the demonising of various foods.

Fat carried the blame for the last generation and now it is sugar's turn. It solves nothing

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 17 9.21am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

No I am not. We eat too much full stop and yes that does include carbs. We eat more but physically less active than we were even 30 years ago.

There are many reasons why we are where we are but one of them is the demonising of various foods.

Fat carried the blame for the last generation and now it is sugar's turn. It solves nothing

The amount of natural sugars in 3 balanced meals is not going to make you facking massive and clinically obese. It doesn't because it isn't processed and there's only so much you can eat.

Processed shyte and sugary food will make you fat because it's already been broken down so the stomach doesn't have to work. So after that 2 rows of Cadbury's that were easy to chomp down, down goes another few rows, and another. If you've watched that series called 'Secret Eaters' you'll see how people try and claim they eat well but don't, because the good stuff is added to with cr&p.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 17 9.23am

Barnet hospital is an impressive place.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 17 9.26am

Originally posted by gbox82

Some really good points made on this thread on these lines, and I agree with the above.

The NHS is in crisis, and it's turned into some political pawn where people look at funding etc. But part of the reason is because us as a society have abused it. We just accept that obesity affects huge parts of society, and the cost to the NHS is enormous. Fully agree that sweets, sugary drinks etc should contribute towards the funding.

And then there's the number of gp appointments that get missed - the medium sized practice (6 partners) near where I live regularly has 25+ hours of appointments missed. How much does that cost?

People who miss appointments should be charged £10 or £15 or whatever it costs when they have their next one or they don't have that appointment.

 


COYP

Hansy Flag 22 May 17 9.27am

Just got to think how lucky we are even with a run down NHS. Look at our cousins across the Atlantic.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 17 9.30am

Somethings got to give.

What's it gonna be?

 


COYP

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 22 May 17 9.47am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The amount of natural sugars in 3 balanced meals is not going to make you facking massive and clinically obese. It doesn't because it isn't processed and there's only so much you can eat.

Processed shyte and sugary food will make you fat because it's already been broken down so the stomach doesn't have to work. So after that 2 rows of Cadbury's that were easy to chomp down, down goes another few rows, and another. If you've watched that series called 'Secret Eaters' you'll see how people try and claim they eat well but don't, because the good stuff is added to with cr&p.

I am not disputing eating s*** loads of chocolate isn't good for you, I am saying we eat too much. Yes in that I include lots of "nice" treats like biscuits, chocolates, crisps etc.

But to demonise one Macro-nutrient is a mistake. To try and tax foods (as my original post was a reply to) containing high sugar or high fat is not the way to do it. There is an argument that we have become so used to sugar in everything because of years of eating low fat food. Yes low in fat but high in sugar.

It seems a lot of people have forgotten, or have never learned how to cook. Everyone wants the easy option, even that curly haired squeaky voiced prat says eat more and exercise less. It's bulls***

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 17 10.03am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

I am not disputing eating s*** loads of chocolate isn't good for you, I am saying we eat too much. Yes in that I include lots of "nice" treats like biscuits, chocolates, crisps etc.

But to demonise one Macro-nutrient is a mistake. To try and tax foods (as my original post was a reply to) containing high sugar or high fat is not the way to do it. There is an argument that we have become so used to sugar in everything because of years of eating low fat food. Yes low in fat but high in sugar.

It seems a lot of people have forgotten, or have never learned how to cook. Everyone wants the easy option, even that curly haired squeaky voiced prat says eat more and exercise less. It's bulls***

If people cut out the biscuits, crisps, chocolate, chocolate mousses, pastries etc they wouldn't be either fat or as fat. You don't see many fat free of those items but they're all holding spoons of sugar.

Sure there are jars of sweet and sour sauce holding loads of sugar but you can bet your life if they're eating that they're eating loads of unnecessary cr&p during the day and after dinner without a care.

It's got worse since its been so cheap in multipacks at the supermarket rather than having to go to the sweet shop and seeing how much it costs. So maybe charging more at the supermarket is the answer.

 


COYP

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 22 May 17 11.22am

Originally posted by gbox82

There is also, sadly, a lot of truth in this. Speak to anyone that works in the NHS and they will be able to tell you about the inefficiency they see on a daily basis. Like any big company I guess


I've said this myself numerous times on here...I work alongside NHS staff and farrrk me is there a shyte load of wastage going on, meetings for meetings sake and then very little movement as something new comes along and then the project they've pumped oodles into is dropped like a stone..

It's definitely a clash of cultures between the front line staff are there for vocational reasons (i.e. wanting to help people no matter how its done) and those trying to stop the front line hemorrhaging money because all they want to do is deal with someones ailment at whatever cost to the system...

Working in social care i see this day in day out as well...staff do not record anything properly...having said that they're not helped by lack of training as well as systems that need updating...but nevertheless even with what they have getting it into their head that if they took care in what they recorded i'd be able to build better cases for them to receive more money for staff etc as i can prove the work being done, but they simply dont care, instead seeing me a s a bean counter, without realising its their beans i'm counting.

Data quality is a massive issue for the Health 'system' as a whole...no one can say hand on heart what they're dealing with day in day out other than anecdotally...and its the data that the government uses (whoever is in power) to make these decisions.


Edited by Lyons550 (22 May 2017 11.25am)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Painter Flag Croydon 22 May 17 2.50pm

Will it happen, I doubt it.

It wouldn't be such a bad thing, if it was run as a business, it would be far more cost effective. There are far to many people on inflated salaries doing nothing productive at all, just creating work to validate their job, this doesn't include medical staff, just the raft of pen pushers.
How any privatisation would affect tax is anyone's guess.

 

VeganPower Flag Chesham 22 May 17 3.04pm

Originally posted by Painter

Will it happen, I doubt it.

It wouldn't be such a bad thing, if it was run as a business, it would be far more cost effective. There are far to many people on inflated salaries doing nothing productive at all, just creating work to validate their job, this doesn't include medical staff, just the raft of pen pushers.
How any privatisation would affect tax is anyone's guess.

Our NHS is possibly the most efficient national health service in the developed world.

 


22 years eating a vegan diet. Perfectly happy and healthy on it.

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 22 May 17 3.13pm

Originally posted by VeganPower

Our NHS is possibly the most efficient national health service in the developed world.

That's not saying much about anyone else's tbh

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 22 May 17 3.16pm

Originally posted by nickyf

I have a feeling if the conservative win
it will happen.

It's what they've always wanted. Most tories would prefer a US style system where the poorest are excluded.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 May 17 3.19pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Somethings got to give.

What's it gonna be?

I'd say tax cuts. Everyone is poised to benefit from a well funded NHS, even if it costs us more in NI and Tax. A well organised, funded NHS would also save people in private health care, as well as companies that provide Private Health Care as a bonus.

Problem is, everyone wants to turn health care into a political issue, rather than a pragmatic one.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 22 May 17 3.21pm

Originally posted by sa_eagle

It's what they've always wanted. Most tories would prefer a US style system where the poorest are excluded.

Not sure how you come by that conclusion...

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 May 17 3.29pm

Originally posted by Painter

Will it happen, I doubt it.

It wouldn't be such a bad thing, if it was run as a business, it would be far more cost effective. There are far to many people on inflated salaries doing nothing productive at all, just creating work to validate their job, this doesn't include medical staff, just the raft of pen pushers.
How any privatisation would affect tax is anyone's guess.

If private health care had to provide the kind of coverage that the NHS does, it would be prohibitively expensive. There is no way private health care could afford to run things like A+E at the same level as the NHS, let alone with the same efficiency.

There will always be some room for privatisation in the NHS. Certain areas of care and treatment are better handled through private contractors (especially in areas of rare disease).

Its not a business, and not everything can be run as a business.

To me, provision of health care and assuring the national security of citizens are the primary concerns of any democratic western government, closely followed by education of its young (and adults).

We have long achieved national security of the United Kingdom, so much so, that we're politically more motivated towards securing British Interests as a priority now over citizens.

Its imperative that we don't end up like the US, in which paying taxes results in next to no return to the population.

Good health care for all, should be a cornerstone of any decent nation that is funded by its citizens. Assure their access to health, as well as military security.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 22 May 17 4.36pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

If private health care had to provide the kind of coverage that the NHS does, it would be prohibitively expensive. There is no way private health care could afford to run things like A+E at the same level as the NHS, let alone with the same efficiency.

There will always be some room for privatisation in the NHS. Certain areas of care and treatment are better handled through private contractors (especially in areas of rare disease).

Its not a business, and not everything can be run as a business.

To me, provision of health care and assuring the national security of citizens are the primary concerns of any democratic western government, closely followed by education of its young (and adults).

We have long achieved national security of the United Kingdom, so much so, that we're politically more motivated towards securing British Interests as a priority now over citizens.

Its imperative that we don't end up like the US, in which paying taxes results in next to no return to the population.

Good health care for all, should be a cornerstone of any decent nation that is funded by its citizens. Assure their access to health, as well as military security.

Agreed. The provision, or ability to effectively look after ones own people, should be at the very forefront of any elected governments guiding principles.

Privatisation of the NHS is the one thing the Torys are moving toward that I cannot agree with, and am Strongly opposed against.

Now if they were to streamline the NHS, and get rid of all the Civil servant posts created years ago that just bleed the NHS funds more than a car park full of Romanian Pikeys, then that would free up more money for the things we actually need in hospitals, like Dr's, Nurses and equipment, not to mention new real estate to put them in.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Painter Flag Croydon 22 May 17 7.30pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

If private health care had to provide the kind of coverage that the NHS does, it would be prohibitively expensive. There is no way private health care could afford to run things like A+E at the same level as the NHS, let alone with the same efficiency.

There will always be some room for privatisation in the NHS. Certain areas of care and treatment are better handled through private contractors (especially in areas of rare disease).

Its not a business, and not everything can be run as a business.

To me, provision of health care and assuring the national security of citizens are the primary concerns of any democratic western government, closely followed by education of its young (and adults).

We have long achieved national security of the United Kingdom, so much so, that we're politically more motivated towards securing British Interests as a priority now over citizens.

Its imperative that we don't end up like the US, in which paying taxes results in next to no return to the population.

Good health care for all, should be a cornerstone of any decent nation that is funded by its citizens. Assure their access to health, as well as military security.

I agree with all you points. The issue is its now too big and needs some sort of streamlining and more efficient if possible. You make an appointment and get on average 3 letters confirming it, months in advance, in the end I gave up and went private.
Some sort of control on access is needed, our NHS is for UK citizens, but it is being used by everybody worldwide costing the UK taxpayers £millions.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 23 May 17 8.59am

The NHS is changing...its focusing far more on preventative care, through increased working relationships with Social care and charities alike away from Hospitals.

This way it can 'triage' out in the communities rather than in a A&E and the benefits will pay for themselves in the coming years as we stay fitter and healthier for longer.

It's as much about changing peoples mindsets as it is the actual treatment. Too many people in the last 40years have automatically turned up at a GP or A&E for the most innocuous of issues. The more informed we all are the less stress on the system there will be....but it will take time...it's like turning an oil tanker.

Before too long it wont be a bus pass we get at 60...it'll be a gym membership

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > will the nhs ever be privatised?