You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dementia Tax
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dementia Tax


Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 10.56am

Hmm who would have thought that a policy of cutting taxes and providing means of avoiding tax through specific exemption policy or programs would have any long term impact on society.

Of course by privatising elderly care we haven't exactly done ourselves any favours.

This is the society that generation wanted and voted for.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Jun 17 10.57am

Originally posted by Lyons550


I agree entirely with taxing the f*** out of the contributory factors for ill health; AS LONG AS it's ring fenced solely for the purposes of the Health System...which is where the problem lies...as its not.

It already is in many cases as this country would be in a far poorer economic state if it wasn't for the income so generously provided by smokers and drinkers

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 10.58am

Originally posted by npn

It all depends on how you define "can afford it". If someone has scrimped and saved over their entire working lives to ensure a comfortable retirement, is it right that they are now penalised because they "can afford it"? I had this when my parents retired - never owned a house (unluckily went down the private landlord rather than council route or they would probably have had a right to buy) and then suddenly everything they had saved was going on rent, as they watched their peers who had never put anything aside getting housing benefit instead, and were, quite understandably, asking themselves why they'd bothered being frugal when they would have ended up in exactly the same position, but having had less luxuries up to that point.

The point of tax relief on pensions is surely to encourage people to put money away for a retirement and not then be a burden on the state? Start making it not cost effective to save, and you get an even bigger increase in elderly people running out of cash and needing support.

The inheritance tax I totally get - the recipient has not earned the money and therefore there's a good argument that it should be increased and, as I will be getting no inheritance regardless, it doesn't really apply to me anyway, but pensions, nah!

I think it was entirely about winning votes, by providing a means that the slightly better off and higher in society, could effectively maximise their returns on their salary / dividends.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 13 Jun 17 11.02am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think it was entirely about winning votes, by providing a means that the slightly better off and higher in society, could effectively maximise their returns on their salary / dividends.

Yes, we can't have that, can't encourage people to behave responsibly. Give all the money of people who have it to those that don't, that will solve everything.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Jun 17 11.02am

Originally posted by npn

The point of tax relief on pensions is surely to encourage people to put money away for a retirement and not then be a burden on the state?

Surely the point of encouraging people to invest in a pension is to make life after retirement more comfortable as everyone is entitled to the state pension on reaching retirement age anyway

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 11.04am

Originally posted by Lyons550


I agree entirely with taxing the f*** out of the contributory factors for ill health; AS LONG AS it's ring fenced solely for the purposes of the Health System...which is where the problem lies...as its not.

But I bet you don't believe in reducing peoples taxes proportionally to the reduction in life expectancy.

The irony here is that you should likely be reducing the taxation on things like smoking, drinking, drugs etc which reduce life expectancy.

Sure, someone with cancer is a burden, but generally for a few years, and the intensity of treatment is sporadic. Similarly, diabetes, cheap to manage and a reduced life expectancy.

Where as old age care, really f**king expensive and intensive continual care provision. Chemo twice a week for five weeks is a damn site cheaper than long term dementia, which can last decades, of costs on a daily basis.

The problem really is all those people eating health, exercising regularly, not drinking, drugging and smoking who live into their 80s and 90s.

Live fast, die younger and leave less of a burden on the tax payer.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 11.05am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Surely the point of encouraging people to invest in a pension is to make life after retirement more comfortable as everyone is entitled to the state pension on reaching retirement age anyway

I thought it was to obtain investment capital by any means, by which companies could maximise profits whilst risk to the company (by laying off poor investments against their clients capital investments).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 13 Jun 17 11.07am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

But I bet you don't believe in reducing peoples taxes proportionally to the reduction in life expectancy.

The irony here is that you should likely be reducing the taxation on things like smoking, drinking, drugs etc which reduce life expectancy.

Sure, someone with cancer is a burden, but generally for a few years, and the intensity of treatment is sporadic. Similarly, diabetes, cheap to manage and a reduced life expectancy.

Where as old age care, really f**king expensive and intensive continual care provision. Chemo twice a week for five weeks is a damn site cheaper than long term dementia, which can last decades, of costs on a daily basis.

The problem really is all those people eating health, exercising regularly, not drinking, drugging and smoking who live into their 80s and 90s.

Live fast, die younger and leave less of a burden on the tax payer.

With opinions like this, it appears that dementia is affecting the younger generations too.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jun 17 11.10am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

But I bet you don't believe in reducing peoples taxes proportionally to the reduction in life expectancy.

The irony here is that you should likely be reducing the taxation on things like smoking, drinking, drugs etc which reduce life expectancy.

Sure, someone with cancer is a burden, but generally for a few years, and the intensity of treatment is sporadic. Similarly, diabetes, cheap to manage and a reduced life expectancy.

Where as old age care, really f**king expensive and intensive continual care provision. Chemo twice a week for five weeks is a damn site cheaper than long term dementia, which can last decades, of costs on a daily basis.

The problem really is all those people eating health, exercising regularly, not drinking, drugging and smoking who live into their 80s and 90s.

Live fast, die younger and leave less of a burden on the tax payer.


I guess it gets reduced in comparison to those that live longer...so that's a bit of a paradox/oxymoron.

What I would say is that those who life debilitating conditions are also more likely to utilise the system more and their treatment cost more than those who simply live a healthy normal (if there is such a thing) life until they pass away.

Also, the life expectancy for someone with Dementia isn't as long as you or others would think...it's around 5yrs on avg.

I work in Social services, I see how much Residential and nursing beds cost..its criminal and EXACTLY why there's a push for preventative care to stop people getting to this stage in the first place.

Swings and roundabouts I guess


Edited by Lyons550 (13 Jun 2017 11.13am)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

becky Flag over the moon 13 Jun 17 11.11am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

But I bet you don't believe in reducing peoples taxes proportionally to the reduction in life expectancy.

The irony here is that you should likely be reducing the taxation on things like smoking, drinking, drugs etc which reduce life expectancy.

Sure, someone with cancer is a burden, but generally for a few years, and the intensity of treatment is sporadic. Similarly, diabetes, cheap to manage and a reduced life expectancy.

Where as old age care, really f**king expensive and intensive continual care provision. Chemo twice a week for five weeks is a damn site cheaper than long term dementia, which can last decades, of costs on a daily basis.

The problem really is all those people eating health, exercising regularly, not drinking, drugging and smoking who live into their 80s and 90s.

Live fast, die younger and leave less of a burden on the tax payer.

There is also the factor that the younger generation expect to put their elderly parents with any form of dementia/senility/illness into subsidised care rather than look after them at home, as previous generations did - this has been a major factor in the increased cost of elderly care that is sadly overlooked by those complaining about it!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 13 Jun 17 11.17am

The problem with NIC or the stamp is most people did not understand what they were paying for. Most thought they were saving stamp for their own retirement when (originally) they were paying for current pensioners on a very short “just in time “window, a couple of weeks I think. Obviously, this money is now just subsumed within the general tax burden.

As such perhaps pensioners should pay NIC or get rid of NIC and add into an adjusted income tax, which would be my preference.

You could remove the triple lock, or means test the basic state pension, or even remove the state pension and replace it with the stakeholder scheme, but contributions would require increasing shifting the burden of pension provision entirely onto the private sector, there would be some form very basic state net for those who did not contribute, but not for those who opted out.

I think it is probably too late to solve this solely by taxing pensioners and probably requires general taxation over the short-term to medium term (60 years); typical of a mixed economy, whilst the falling rate of birth and added longevity stabilise.

You bring in young temporary workers who could contribute to the tax yield from the rest of the EU, but that has been kyboshed mainly due to racism.

Some good news is that demographic trends have shown a slight worsening in longevity which should be encouraged, laws and taxation against smoking, drinking should be relaxed to draw maximum tax return against mortality. Recreational drugs should be legalised and taxed.

The baby boomers have had the best gold-plated pensioners, free education, the best of the NHS, perhaps we should treat them like the under 30s who have loans to pay off for state services. Perhaps the elderly should have a loan account on which they can draw upon (not just for a Dementia Tax but increased income, for example, and offset against all assets. An IFA would perhaps call this an enhanced nationalised equity release scheme. I would envisage that inter-generational responsibility would be a must.

You could always take their house and savings.

For Becky – During employment NIC was taken on standard pension contributions but not salary sacrifice, a loop hole HMRC is ready to close.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jun 17 11.18am

Originally posted by becky

There is also the factor that the younger generation expect to put their elderly parents with any form of dementia/senility/illness into subsidised care rather than look after them at home, as previous generations did - this has been a major factor in the increased cost of elderly care that is sadly overlooked by those complaining about it!


That's certainly true and our figures show that cultures that retain a strong Family network would rather take the strain of caring for an elderly family member at home then to allow someone else to do so.

Also over the last couple of decades Social Services would have accepted to pay for a person to be admitted to a home with certain conditions that they wouldn't now. This is primarily driven by the cuts that we've seen, but it's also forced the system to look at different ways to support clients, as well as promoting their independence and preventing Deprivation Of liberty in the process.

Edited by Lyons550 (13 Jun 2017 11.20am)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 13 Jun 17 11.26am

Originally posted by europalace


Why do people have to 'buy' housing? Most of continental Europe lives very happily with a far higher quality of life simply renting their homes. In Germany, private rents can't go up by more than 10% in any 3 year period. If you think you're being overcharged you go to the town hall where you give a description and sqm of your apartment/house and they decide if you're being overcharged. If so, the landlord must pay back the difference plus interest. When I lived there, nobody talked about property. Renting also makes for a much more flexible workforce and for the individual, much easy to move city for work. A brilliant system overall.

Long term renter here. You make some very important sensible points. However the conservative government in its manifesto was banging the drum yet again of home ownership. Obvious reasons. If you fall on hard times you cannot claim housing benefit so it doesn't cost them anything. When you get old and possibly need care it's sold to fund it so again they don't have to pay anything or if they do it's massively reduced. And then the whole cycle repeats itself. There is no rent cap , longest tenancy you can get is a year so it's constant worry and uncertainty with it . Nigh on impossible to get a local authority property . Labour were the only party which addressed this issue in their manifesto. My rent for the house I live in is twice the mortgage. But I can't get a mortgage and I can't save the deposit so in effect trapped in this cycle. Quite what happens once I am old with no income and having to move all the time I don't know.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 11.33am

Originally posted by Lyons550


I guess it gets reduced in comparison to those that live longer...so that's a bit of a paradox/oxymoron.

What I would say is that those who life debilitating conditions are also more likely to utilise the system more and their treatment cost more than those who simply live a healthy normal (if there is such a thing) life until they pass away.

Also, the life expectancy for someone with Dementia isn't as long as you or others would think...it's around 5yrs on avg.

I work in Social services, I see how much Residential and nursing beds cost..its criminal and EXACTLY why there's a push for preventative care to stop people getting to this stage in the first place.

Swings and roundabouts I guess


Edited by Lyons550 (13 Jun 2017 11.13am)


Plenty of people end up in old age care without dementia due to less fatal conditions, such a frailty etc. The point is, that we have accepted the idea of 'taxing people' who live unhealthy life styles without actually thinking of those costs that healthy lifestyles entail.

We encourage the idea of living as 'long as possible' and then financially try to fund that by targeting people who won't.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Jun 17 11.33am

Originally posted by becky

There is also the factor that the younger generation expect to put their elderly parents with any form of dementia/senility/illness into subsidised care rather than look after them at home, as previous generations did - this has been a major factor in the increased cost of elderly care that is sadly overlooked by those complaining about it!

You are referring back to a time when most women didn't work so had the time to look after elderly parents.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 11.36am

Originally posted by hedgehog50

With opinions like this, it appears that dementia is affecting the younger generations too.

Not really, I saw my grandparents live into their later years, suffering dementia and physical frailty, requiring constant care etc. It was a horrible existence, s**ting yourself, having no dignity, being herded around, in a banal and sterile environment where you're more an object than a person.

Its not really worth the effort if you ask me. I'd rather go out a) on my own terms b) whilst I'm still me c) and enjoy the pleasures and vices of life.

A walk around an old peoples home is like an advert for not making the average life expectancy.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jun 17 11.42am

Originally posted by pefwin

The problem with NIC or the stamp is most people did not understand what they were paying for. Most thought they were saving stamp for their own retirement when (originally) they were paying for current pensioners on a very short “just in time “window, a couple of weeks I think. Obviously, this money is now just subsumed within the general tax burden.

As such perhaps pensioners should pay NIC or get rid of NIC and add into an adjusted income tax, which would be my preference.

You could remove the triple lock, or means test the basic state pension, or even remove the state pension and replace it with the stakeholder scheme, but contributions would require increasing shifting the burden of pension provision entirely onto the private sector, there would be some form very basic state net for those who did not contribute, but not for those who opted out.

I think it is probably too late to solve this solely by taxing pensioners and probably requires general taxation over the short-term to medium term (60 years); typical of a mixed economy, whilst the falling rate of birth and added longevity stabilise.

You bring in young temporary workers who could contribute to the tax yield from the rest of the EU, but that has been kyboshed mainly due to racism.

Some good news is that demographic trends have shown a slight worsening in longevity which should be encouraged, laws and taxation against smoking, drinking should be relaxed to draw maximum tax return against mortality. Recreational drugs should be legalised and taxed.

The baby boomers have had the best gold-plated pensioners, free education, the best of the NHS, perhaps we should treat them like the under 30s who have loans to pay off for state services. Perhaps the elderly should have a loan account on which they can draw upon (not just for a Dementia Tax but increased income, for example, and offset against all assets. An IFA would perhaps call this an enhanced nationalised equity release scheme. I would envisage that inter-generational responsibility would be a must.

You could always take their house and savings.

For Becky – During employment NIC was taken on standard pension contributions but not salary sacrifice, a loop hole HMRC is ready to close.

You cannot be serious.

Hold old are you Pefwin?

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 13 Jun 17 11.45am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You cannot be serious.

Hold old are you Pefwin?

Why not?

Your Political Correct world does not suit everyone.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

becky Flag over the moon 13 Jun 17 11.50am

Originally posted by pefwin

The problem with NIC or the stamp is most people did not understand what they were paying for. Most thought they were saving stamp for their own retirement when (originally) they were paying for current pensioners on a very short “just in time “window, a couple of weeks I think. Obviously, this money is now just subsumed within the general tax burden.

As such perhaps pensioners should pay NIC or get rid of NIC and add into an adjusted income tax, which would be my preference.

You could remove the triple lock, or means test the basic state pension, or even remove the state pension and replace it with the stakeholder scheme, but contributions would require increasing shifting the burden of pension provision entirely onto the private sector, there would be some form very basic state net for those who did not contribute, but not for those who opted out.

I think it is probably too late to solve this solely by taxing pensioners and probably requires general taxation over the short-term to medium term (60 years); typical of a mixed economy, whilst the falling rate of birth and added longevity stabilise.

You bring in young temporary workers who could contribute to the tax yield from the rest of the EU, but that has been kyboshed mainly due to racism.

Some good news is that demographic trends have shown a slight worsening in longevity which should be encouraged, laws and taxation against smoking, drinking should be relaxed to draw maximum tax return against mortality. Recreational drugs should be legalised and taxed.

The baby boomers have had the best gold-plated pensioners(1), free education (2), the best of the NHS (3), perhaps we should treat them like the under 30s who have loans to pay off for state services. Perhaps the elderly should have a loan account on which they can draw upon (not just for a Dementia Tax but increased income, for example, and offset against all assets. An IFA would perhaps call this an enhanced nationalised equity release scheme. I would envisage that inter-generational responsibility would be a must.

You could always take their house and savings.

For Becky (4)– During employment NIC was taken on standard pension contributions but not salary sacrifice, a loop hole HMRC is ready to close.


(1) Only some- especially those in the public sector, who are probably the biggest drain on public finances to this day. The rest of hard-working Joe-public just get by on what's available.

(2) Far, far fewer went to university in those days - it was a privilege reserved for the genuinely academic. Others went to a polytechnic and gained a 'useful' qualification that had a practical purpose in the workplace. Turning every poly into a university so any halfwit could get a degree in 'meeja
studies' increased the cost of those places immeasurably, so far less would have been spent on our generation, and probably to a greater level of usefulness and ultimate financial return from their future employment.

(3) For our generation the NHS was for sick people. Cosmetic surgery was not heard of, expensive stuff like premature baby units had not been developed, diagnostics were manually made assessments by the 'specialists' rather than millions of pounds worth of machinery, and hospitals were staffed by medical professionals rather than accountants and managers ( yeh, I'll allow that we did have the best there), so diagnostics and treatment was much pooer for us who had the 'best' of the service.....

(4) I have no idea what 'salary sacrifice' is - did not exist in my working time - you earned and you paid tax and National Insurance - the latter on your private pension annuity, whether you liked it or not!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jun 17 11.52am

Originally posted by pefwin

Why not?

Your Political Correct world does not suit everyone.

Not a question of correctness.

The system serves the people not the reverse. Encouraging people to a premature death is not what a society is about.
The real cause of our current problems is the short sighted, self serving nature of politicians and the greed of financial institutions. The public should not have to pay the cost with mass immigration, poor care in old age or being encouraged to slowly kill themselves.

 

Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dementia Tax