You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch at RWB
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Punch at RWB


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
TheBigToePunt Flag 25 Jul 17 1.31pm

Puncheon can't play RWB in a million years. He switches off defensively, isn't much of a tackler, doesn't have a great engine and is left footed. I can't think of a single attribute that is needed to play RWB that Puncheon possesses.

Unless we make signings, it is almost certain that we will use Ward at RWB. This is for a number of reasons:

1. Ward is fine. He's much better than some on here give him credit for. Nothing flash, and won't add a massive amount to the attack, but compare his generally tidy defending over the last few years to the huge gaps left behind and inside, last minute lunges and general scattiness of Souare on the other side. Ward is steady, and there is a lot to be said for that.

2. The other option is Kelly. Ward is better than Kelly, who has only come to life as a centre back, and even then only for a short while (so far). Otherwise he has been a disappointment and not able to keep Ward out under three managers so far.

3. We will need at least one more very good centre back if we are to play with three of them every week, as you would want to have five or six to see you through. We have Dann, Delaney, Tompkins and now Riedewald. Even if Kelly is counted as a centre back we are still short of numbers and quality, so the money we have will go on a centre back and not a new RWB, meaning the one we have (Ward) will play.

4. If we use Townsend at RWB we will need to find someone else to play in the front 3. Sako or any of the kids are nowhere near as good as Townsend in that role, so we'd need to sign a new attacker just to fill the gap left by moving Townsend to RWB. Attackers (good ones anyway) eat up the budget like no-one else, and given that we need at least one more centre back (Chambers I presume) we won't have the money left over for a new goalscoring, match-winning forward, so we'll have to use the ones we've got. We've only got one decent CF, so Benteke plays, and we've only got two decent wing forwards, so Zaha and Townsend play too. There is nobody else even close to the required standard to play up there.

I can imagine we would push Townsend out to RWB if we are chasing a game, or going balls-out for a win at home, and maybe use Wickham or someone up top, but generally its not going to be his position.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (25 Jul 2017 1.37pm)

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 1.35pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Puncheon can't play RWB in a million years. He switches off defensively, isn't much of a tackler, doesn't have a great engine and is left footed. I can't think of a single attribute that is needed to play there that Puncheon possesses.

Unless we make signings, it is almost certain that we will use Ward at RWB. This is for a number of reasons:

1. Ward is fine. He's much better than some on here give him credit for. Nothing flash, and won't add a massive amount to the attack, but compare his generally tidy defending over the last few years to the huge gaps left behind and inside, last minute lunges and general scattiness of Souare on the other side. Ward is steady, and there is a lot to be said for that.

2. The other option is Kelly. Ward is better than Kelly, who has only come to life as a centre back, and even then only for a short while (so far). Otherwise he has been a disappointment and not able to keep Ward out under three managers so far.

3. We will need at least one more very good centre back if we are to play with three of them every week, as you would want to have five or six to see you through. We have Dann, Delaney, Tompkins and now Riedewald. Even if Kelly is counted as a centre back we are still short of numbers and quality, so the money we have will go on a centre back and not a new RWB, meaning the one we have (Ward) will play.

4. If we use Townsend at RWB we will need to find someone else to play in the front 3. Sako or any of the kids are nowhere near as good as Townsend in that role, so we'd need to sign a new attacker just to fill the gap left by moving Townsend to RWB. Attackers (good ones anyway) eat up the budget like no-one else, and given that we need at least one more centre back (Chambers I presume) we won't have the money left over for a new goalscoring, match-winning forward, so we'll have to use the ones we've got. We've only got one decent CF, so Benteke plays, and we've only got two decent wing forwards, so Zaha and Townsend play too. There is nobody else even close to the required standard to play up there.

I can imagine we would push Townsend out to RWB if we are chasing a game, or going ball-out for a win at home, and maybe use Wickham or someone up top, but generally its not going to be his position.

If the 2 pre season games are anything to go by he clearly doesn't fancy ward or Kelly in that wingback role. He also choose to play Luka in the back 3, instead of Tomkins. They maybe 'good' defenders but they clearly not rated with the ball at their feet by de Boer.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

TheBigToePunt Flag 25 Jul 17 1.40pm

Originally posted by Dan89

If the 2 pre season games are anything to go by he clearly doesn't fancy ward or Kelly in that wingback role. He also choose to play Luka in the back 3, instead of Tomkins. They maybe 'good' defenders but they clearly not rated with the ball at their feet by de Boer.

Pre season is as much about getting minutes into legs as anything else, so we shouldn't read too much into who plays where. I can imagine that De Boer wants to look at different options at the back in case we can't sign anyone else to play there, but I doubt that all adds up to Townsend playing RWB for the reasons set out in my post.

 

Oliver Flag Bodega Bay 25 Jul 17 1.41pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

What about fans favourite, Julian Speroni? Train up to not reflexively use his hands and I reckon he'd be just as good up the right hand side as Joel Ward. Thoughts?

 


I have prepared one of my own time capsules. I have placed some rather large samples of dynamite, gunpowder and nitroglycerin. My time capsule is set to go off in the year 3000. It will show them what we are really like.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Jul 17 2.22pm

Ok having read all of the comments it looks like the general feeling is that Punch can't play wingback. On the basis he isn't going to take Cabaye or Milivojevic's spot on the park, the only player that can be left out is Townsend. If that is the case we lose a lot of our threat going forward and I just can't see Punch being a full time, every game, starter more particularly as we haven't even taken RLC into account in this equation. So, why has he been picked as captain? Surely your captain is the rock, the first person on the teamsheet and who you want on the field at all times unless injured?

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 25 Jul 17 2.28pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I've just posted this under 3-4-3 but thinking about it, it might deserve it's own topic. What do you think?

The only position I can see Punch getting into the team believe it or not is at right wing back. Before anyone dies laughing remember that Milner has successfully converted to this role and Punch to me is a better tackler than Townsend and better going forward than Ward, so if he could learn his trade in that position it answers the question of keeping the captain in the team without him taking up either Cabaye's or Luka's position.

Based on current staff the team for me would be:

Hennessey

Punch, Tomkins, Dann, Reidewald, PVA

Cabaye, Milivojevic

Townsend, Benteke, Zaha

Glad we got de boar


 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Jul 17 2.32pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Glad we got de boar


Do you actually read anything or just post sarcastic replies to the OP with poor spelling. Try and add something to the debate, it makes for far more interesting reading.

 

Username Flag Horsham 25 Jul 17 4.24pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Do you actually read anything or just post sarcastic replies to the OP with poor spelling. Try and add something to the debate, it makes for far more interesting reading.

I'm sure he was probably just thinking the same thing, why pick a slow, incredibly left-footed player who has a worrying knack for conceding stupid free kicks, but has shown recently to have a good influence in the centre of the pitch, at right wing back?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Petereagle Flag Brockley 25 Jul 17 4.32pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Ok having read all of the comments it looks like the general feeling is that Punch can't play wingback. On the basis he isn't going to take Cabaye or Milivojevic's spot on the park, the only player that can be left out is Townsend. If that is the case we lose a lot of our threat going forward and I just can't see Punch being a full time, every game, starter more particularly as we haven't even taken RLC into account in this equation. So, why has he been picked as captain? Surely your captain is the rock, the first person on the teamsheet and who you want on the field at all times unless injured?

FdB has appointed him captain after getting to know the squad so he must see things in punch that we don't. If FdB really does think that punch actually does have a role in the new system, that's good news all round. Nobody can doubt his loyalty and commitment to palace

 

Mad4palace Flag 25 Jul 17 4.37pm

I was impressed with Punch's performance against West Brom, he knows how to feint in the middle of the park, seems to have taken to de Boers new system so far.

 

Part Time James Flag 25 Jul 17 4.42pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

FdB has appointed him captain after getting to know the squad so he must see things in punch that we don't. If FdB really does think that punch actually does have a role in the new system, that's good news all round. Nobody can doubt his loyalty and commitment to palace

Not just FdB either, Allardyce gave him captaincy too. And we all through the sun shone out of his backside.

 




dreamwaverider Flag London 25 Jul 17 4.45pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Do you actually read anything or just post sarcastic replies to the OP with poor spelling. Try and add something to the debate, it makes for far more interesting reading.

No offence, didn't have time for a long response.

Harmless humour in my world sarcastic in yours.

So we are all different, but have one thing in common that keeps us all here.

PALACE. The red and blue.

C'est la vie.

 

cpj Flag Kent 25 Jul 17 5.00pm

How about playing him left back ...... inside the dressing room. Cannot for the life of me see what the managers see in him.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Jul 17 5.13pm

Originally posted by cpj

How about playing him left back ...... inside the dressing room. Cannot for the life of me see what the managers see in him.

As much as I love the fact he is local, Palace through and through and has played well for us in previous seasons, the fact remains that last year he posed no threat to goal and spurned many opportunities to slip crucial passes in. Yes, the management obviously like him and his attitude is probably fantastic however his performances on the pitch don't reflect that so I'm with you cpj. I am expecting RLC/Cabaye to be an upgrade at Punch's normal position.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Jul 17 5.14pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

No offence, didn't have time for a long response.

Harmless humour in my world sarcastic in yours.

So we are all different, but have one thing in common that keeps us all here.

PALACE. The red and blue.

C'est la vie.

No problem........Eeeeeeeeeagles

 

Mad4palace Flag 25 Jul 17 5.36pm

Originally posted by cpj

How about playing him left back ...... inside the dressing room. Cannot for the life of me see what the managers see in him.

Punch remains one of the most underrated players by most of our fans. If you watch him off the ball, watch his positional awareness and his communication then you'll see what he does for the team.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 25 Jul 17 5.36pm

He shouldn't be in the first team, he shouldn't be captain and he most definitely should not be played at rwb.
He should be on the runway at Gatwick directing aeroplanes.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 25 Jul 17 5.40pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Punch remains one of the most underrated players by most of our fans. If you watch him off the ball, watch his positional awareness and his communication then you'll see what he does for the team.

Gotta be a joke? He's got the worst positional awareness out of the whole squad.

 

Mad4palace Flag 25 Jul 17 6.38pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

Gotta be a joke? He's got the worst positional awareness out of the whole squad.

He covers a lot for other players, also you just said he shouldn't be captain which you are totally wrong about. When Dann was made captain I called that it would be a mistake (and not just because of the circumstances he was given it), I was proved right.

Who would you have as captain?

Puncheon is the most communicative player on the pitch, Cabaye barely speaks, neither does Ward, Delaney was a good captain but is in and out of the team, Milivojevic may be a good captain one day but he's not been at the club very long.

Last season the only one other than Puncheon that looked like a captain was Flamini in the couple of cameos that he had.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 25 Jul 17 7.16pm

Remind me again how one-footed Punch is, and what foot that is.....?

And there ends the discussion, IMO.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch at RWB