This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Loaning players
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
coulsdoneagle London 11 Aug 17 2.53am |
|
|
And before we bought him back
|
Stirlingsays 11 Aug 17 6.59am |
|
|
Be nice if we could loan girlfriends.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
laddo london 11 Aug 17 7.22am |
|
|
The suggestion there is a 'lack of funds' is rubbish. Truth is we had a deal in place for chambers but fosu-mensah has meant we can explore our primary target again (you know who).
Plus we need a striker and they are priced at a premium. So actually, an 8m cb from Ajax with hopefully Sakho and a striker in place is great. That's where our efforts are going right now. We want a gk too but are not willing to break the bank there.
If the board secure their targets come August 31st we will be very happy fans.
laddo
"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist". David Brent.
|
Maine Eagle USA 11 Aug 17 8.19am |
|
|
Some good points here but the fact is that loanees are not something you can build anything around. When a new manager comes in he is looking to start a series of seasons where we build a team in his image, and a system and style of play. Loanees can certainly help instill a system but when some call it a win win, you could say it’s a lose lose. If they turn out to be Bamford it’s a total waste of time. If they turn out to be Sakho you get some short term gains then you are dealt a big blow when they abruptly disappear and you cannot fill that immense void – think about Sakho last year, sure it was down to an injury, but if a loan player turns out be a massive success then when they inevitably disappear you are weakened, not strengthened. I am past the point of wanting to lurch from one relegation scrap to the next hell bent on survival at all costs, its time for our team to grow and FDB to build something here. And we cannot say “thank god we only loaned Sanogo” as we never would have signed half of those guys permanently. I agree with loans if we actually have a chance at buying the player but I don’t think that’s the case with RLC or TFM.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.
|
slubglurge welling 11 Aug 17 8.34am |
|
|
I don't agree with it full stop. It holds back clubs young players. Chelsea see it as part of their business model. Loan 40 players out every season for fees and wages and it is costing them nothing to hoard these players while making a nice lot of money from the process. Virtually all of them will never make the 1st team and then they willbe sold off with their profiles higher to fetch a higher price
|
dreamwaverider London 11 Aug 17 9.06am |
|
|
Football at top leve nowl is totally ruthless short termism. That is why loaning works. There is no loyalty or love left. It's all about who is right today. Not yesterday or tomorrow. Fast fit agile big athletic skilful that's what cuts it now. So we have to accept that and run with it. So The likes of Ward whose done a great job for us is suddenly history. We got half a dozen who we have loved but who are now history. As a club we are embracing the new face of football which will take us to new levels. But it will have its casualties too. If we want it we have to toughen up and accept reality. Hang on to loyalty, love and history and we will fail. FdB has been brought in to deliver a new product. Tough but fact. Not easy for everyone to accept especially where we came from, but it is what it is. Here today gone tomorrow players know this. No loyalty. Follow the money. How long will it last? Who knows.
|
CrazyBadger Ware 11 Aug 17 9.13am |
|
|
Loans are useful as supplements to the squad, and should never replace actual signings in the same period. Afterall, all a loan is only a deferment of the problem - when the loan period has ended you are left with The same problem, although maybe with a slightly higher chance of signing the loaned player. They should be used when it allows you to fill a gap in the squad that your could not otherwise fill. Yes, it may block youngsters coming through, but due to the high penalties of failure in this league, it can be too risky to blood untested young players. (A squad should not include untested Youth Players as starters) If reports are to be believed that SA spunked all of The transfer budget in January - then a) it was completely justified and b) we should consider them as summer signings. The loaning of TFM and RLC has allowed us to sign Luka, Schlupp and PVA. and Boy! did we need them in January.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"
|
Casual Orpington 11 Aug 17 9.35am |
|
|
I like it. Means we can get in a couple of decent young players for a minimum of a year for a small amount of money. I'm not particularly bothered if we are bringing along players for the bigger clubs, if the loanees are helping us get 3 points on a regular basis. If RLCs loan means that Puncheon plays less then we will have a better first 11. Also we have a year to look for a long term replacement , possibly RLC.
|
Hudsoneagle 11 Aug 17 10.41am |
|
|
I think the mistake being made by many people on here moaning about loans is that a loan player is not a signing the club makes instead of a permanent signing...it is more often a signing we can make on top of permanent signings.
Let’s say the club spend 30m altogether this summer. 8m on Riedewald and another 20m let’s say.
Both RLC and TFM would cost us a minimum of 15m each...maybe even more.
Those two loans if permanent would have cost us our entire summer kitty.
FdB has come in and changed the system completely. He needs different players than the ones we had. There is only so much money to spend so the club have a choice...do you only spend money on permanent players and only solve half the problems at the club or do you mix it up with loans as well and plug all the gaps giving a whole year to make plans for more permanent solutions?
It’s a god damn no brainer to me but people will still complain.
Some people saying we should only loan players who we can buy at the end of the loan...what are you on about??? These two chaps are not for sale, because their clubs believe they can be 1st team players and are too good to be sold. Would you prefer we signed players that are not as good as them and who are not wanted by their parent clubs because they are not good enough???
|
Dan89 Se25 11 Aug 17 10.49am |
|
Originally posted by Hudsoneagle
I think the mistake being made by many people on here moaning about loans is that a loan player is not a signing the club makes instead of a permanent signing...it is more often a signing we can make on top of permanent signings.
Let’s say the club spend 30m altogether this summer. 8m on Riedewald and another 20m let’s say.
Both RLC and TFM would cost us a minimum of 15m each...maybe even more.
Those two loans if permanent would have cost us our entire summer kitty.
FdB has come in and changed the system completely. He needs different players than the ones we had. There is only so much money to spend so the club have a choice...do you only spend money on permanent players and only solve half the problems at the club or do you mix it up with loans as well and plug all the gaps giving a whole year to make plans for more permanent solutions?
It’s a god damn no brainer to me but people will still complain.
Some people saying we should only loan players who we can buy at the end of the loan...what are you on about??? These two chaps are not for sale, because their clubs believe they can be 1st team players and are too good to be sold. Would you prefer we signed players that are not as good as them and who are not wanted by their parent clubs because they are not good enough???
It's not long term solution, fast forward to next summer and we still have these holes in the team developing for Chelsea and Man Utd benefit. We should be looking for more long term.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
Midlands Eagle 11 Aug 17 11.00am |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
It's not long term solution, fast forward to next summer and we still have these holes in the team developing for Chelsea and Man Utd benefit. We should be looking for more long term.
It isn't a long term solutions but it could be part of a long term solution.
If using a pair of quality loan players enables us to move away from being perennial strugglers and relegation candidates to mid table it will be easier in the future to attract replacements.
|
Maine Eagle USA 11 Aug 17 11.01am |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
It's not long term solution, fast forward to next summer and we still have these holes in the team developing for Chelsea and Man Utd benefit. We should be looking for more long term.
Absolutely Dan89, loaning a player you have no chance of signing is the ultimate short term move. Fast forward 1 year and we wont have moved on at all in those positions, if they become first teamers.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.
|
Dan89 Se25 11 Aug 17 11.14am |
|
|
If we get a few of our younger players integrated then could be a plus like Lokilo or wan-bisakka . Then could be a positive, but think I'd rather get Chambers on loan with that fee already set and option to buy would be better than fosu-mensah. If both are successful and play a huge part in this season. Next summer we're having these problems to solve, let alone more that will arise. I do like the fact we are targeting young players, but I'd rather get them permanently. With Man City spending maybe we can nab maffeo or Patrick Roberts.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 11 Aug 17 11.33am |
|
|
It will purely depend on the parent club willing to sell. Ashley Cole was never going to be sold. Paul Stewart was,but Ron would not pay his wages. Sakho is for sale but supposedly we will not pay the fee or wages. Let's see how the new lads perform in the Red&Blue. Then worry about signing permanently. Shame we did not loan Mutch.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
Hudsoneagle 11 Aug 17 11.40am |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
It's not long term solution, fast forward to next summer and we still have these holes in the team developing for Chelsea and Man Utd benefit. We should be looking for more long term.
Are you an idiot?
If we don't have the money to buy permanent replacements and we don't have the right quality available in the youth setup then what would your alternative suggestion be? Because it sounds as if you don't have a solution and that you are just moaning for the sakes of it.
If you have enough money to buy 3 players but you need maybe 5 or 6 players if you are going to succeed then what is the solution?
|
Hudsoneagle 11 Aug 17 11.42am |
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Absolutely Dan89, loaning a player you have no chance of signing is the ultimate short term move. Fast forward 1 year and we wont have moved on at all in those positions, if they become first teamers.
Fast forward a year and we are another 100m richer for still being in the prem league which is a better solution than not having the required quality in the team and getting relegated.
|
Hudsoneagle 11 Aug 17 11.48am |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
If we get a few of our younger players integrated then could be a plus like Lokilo or wan-bisakka . Then could be a positive, but think I'd rather get Chambers on loan with that fee already set and option to buy would be better than fosu-mensah. If both are successful and play a huge part in this season. Next summer we're having these problems to solve, let alone more that will arise. I do like the fact we are targeting young players, but I'd rather get them permanently. With Man City spending maybe we can nab maffeo or Patrick Roberts.
So we shouldn't loan players but we should loan Chambers? lol
A player who was for sale at 7m last year and is now valued at 20m after Borough got relegated and would still cost 20-30m next summer if we loaned him and he played ok...you might as well class him as a player we couldn't sign.
I would avoid this player.
|
Dan89 Se25 11 Aug 17 11.49am |
|
Originally posted by Hudsoneagle
Are you an idiot?
If we don't have the money to buy permanent replacements and we don't have the right quality available in the youth setup then what would your alternative suggestion be? Because it sounds as if you don't have a solution and that you are just moaning for the sakes of it.
If you have enough money to buy 3 players but you need maybe 5 or 6 players if you are going to succeed then what is the solution?
Because have a different opinion, we sell some big earners such as dann, Cabaye to raise funds to strengthen the squad bringing in younger additions. You say we have 100m next summer but if we in trouble in January, the owners will put their hands in their pockets to bail us out. We will also have other areas where we need to strength next summer including Rcb and cm spots.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
Dan89 Se25 11 Aug 17 11.51am |
|
Originally posted by Hudsoneagle
So we shouldn't loan players but we should loan Chambers? lol
A player who was for sale at 7m last year and is now valued at 20m after Borough got relegated and would still cost 20-30m next summer if we loaned him and he played ok...you might as well class him as a player we couldn't sign.
I would avoid this player. Because there's an option to buy, clearly by response if not worth debating as you lead to insults rather than proper debate.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
Username Horsham 11 Aug 17 11.51am |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
It's not long term solution, fast forward to next summer and we still have these holes in the team developing for Chelsea and Man Utd benefit. We should be looking for more long term.
Yes, but if we bring in a couple more players on permanent deals, then next summer we have less holes to fill overall.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.
|