You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What we need to do
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What we need to do


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 13 Aug 17 4.31pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Unfortunately I don't believe that FDB knows any other system. The 'total football' philosophy of high pressing, possession football is embedded in him from Ajax and he's going to persist with it until it works.

I don't think anyone was confident going into yesterday's game as we all know it's going to take time for it work and we're going to have to accept that and be patient. The return of Cabaye will help as him and RLC are both technically good on the ball.

As it stands we certainly need a GK who can use his feet and comand his area, another CB who can use his feet (Riedewald was pathetic in my opinion) and a RWB. Expect more dross vs Liverpool and Swansea and after that if no improvements and new signings it's time to get nervous.

He had no business being on the pitch.

I suggest he was bought because he is an FdB 'yes man'.
You could almost hear him thinking 'where do I put this that will please the gaffer'?

Worse still, he'd did that for the entire first half, and probably in the second half too, but he was too far away for me to comment during the second half.


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 17 4.36pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

Perhaps you should head down to the training ground and tell FDB where he's going wrong and what he needs to do to evolve the team

May as well shut down the website if that's how you feel.

 


COYP

DalacetiliPie Flag Kettering 13 Aug 17 4.39pm

High folly to ditch the back4 system with Milo in front (and freed our forwards up) that stabilised last season's-end, ESPECIALLY as our early schedule avoids most Top6 clubs. Better to accumulate some points early on with a familiar system and work on FDB's back3 Plan B - or his "new, improved" Plan A - behind closed doors until players understand and comfortably embrace it, or until we have the required new players in place. How stubborn will FDB be?? I hope fervently to be proven wrong... My worst fear is that we'll be so far behind on points at Xmas, we'll need snookers...

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 17 4.44pm

Our start isn't that good apart from 4 easier teams. We've lost to one of them. Liverpool next then 3 easier games but not actually 'easy.' Then we have Chelsea ManC and Manscum. Great.

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 13 Aug 17 4.53pm

Originally posted by Harpo

He had no business being on the pitch.

I suggest he was bought because he is an FdB 'yes man'.
You could almost hear him thinking 'where do I put this that will please the gaffer'?

Worse still, he'd did that for the entire first half, and probably in the second half too, but he was too far away for me to comment during the second half.


Also was obvious to see that Hennessey ain't comfortable at all playing out from the back but has been instructed not to hoof the ball, I really can't see the problem we've got benteke up top get the ball up to him and try and hit Huddersfield on the break instead of playing about with the ball and letting them all get back.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 14 Aug 17 1.44am

Originally posted by srh

Two classy wingers, a world class target man and we play a system that plays against our strengths

but we have to win the passing!!!

(even though our pass completion stat was awful and this new system is as far from the Palace way as it gets and negates what makes us beat teams)

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 14 Aug 17 5.12am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Don't know about that. We had the better of the chances. Missed 4 absolute sitters. Not like we didn't create those chances.

Loftus Cheek agrees

[Link]

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 14 Aug 17 6.21am

Which was not really created. More like a lucky bounce.

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Wilf's open goal miss?

 

homes Flag New Eltham 14 Aug 17 6.29am

Study us under Freedman, Pulis and Alladyce.

Give up on the system and work with the players that you have, that is being a good manager.

Unfortunately I don't think we will change and we will get sparked by Liverpool next week. This could be a blessing in disguise

[Link]

 


IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 14 Aug 17 7.28am

Originally posted by rikz

His ego wont allow him to change anything but it's plainly obvious to anyone where our strength lays, pardew done the same, tried to change our system drastically over night and came unstuck. Berkamp had enough of him because he was sick of him being possessed by possession.

It won't happen over night and FDB has publicly said that. Rather than 'ego' i see a philosophy that has been proven to work. It will need moulding to the Prem. I don't mind a period of transition, which will include a few disaster games and turnover of players, if it means we evolve our style to take us up a couple of notches. You have to break a few eggs to make an omelette.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 14 Aug 17 7.39am

Originally posted by homes

Study us under Freedman, Pulis and Alladyce.

Give up on the system and work with the players that you have, that is being a good manager.

Unfortunately I don't think we will change and we will get sparked by Liverpool next week. This could be a blessing in disguise

[Link]


Now I really am worried, having read that CA interview

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

rikz Flag Croydon 14 Aug 17 8.03am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

It won't happen over night and FDB has publicly said that. Rather than 'ego' i see a philosophy that has been proven to work. It will need moulding to the Prem. I don't mind a period of transition, which will include a few disaster games and turnover of players, if it means we evolve our style to take us up a couple of notches. You have to break a few eggs to make an omelette.

Proven to work with Spain, Barcelona and Ajax with 3 of the greatest teams that have existed. I'm not convinced we have the players like someone else has said if the board want to back the manager and this philosophy then fine but we need to spend. The opposition only needs to be well drilled and organised and our players look lost, how do you break a team down when you have puncheon passing from left to right then back to dann. Pulis would have a field day playing against us.

Watch arsenal play, ozil, Sanchez and Ramsay do not stop moving, constantly finding and creating space then watch our midfielders. We just ain't good enough our movement off the ball is terrible. Townsend and zaha hitting teams with pace down the wing and getting the ball into benteke, that's what works so why stop ?

 

GreenwichEagle Flag Greenwich 14 Aug 17 8.37am

It's just so so so so so so simple. Everyone can see it literally everyone.
If FDB wants to see out this new style of play for us he simply cannot play some of the players we have...square pegs round holes right? We don't have the payers with the quick thinking, quick feet, technical ability required.
That cannot ever be our starting 11 again what he played on Saturday.
WARD - not good enough anymore (sorry to say) even at RB let alone being asked to now be more of an attacking outlet for us. All kinds of wrong. When have you EVER seen Ward bomb down the right and swing in any kind of end product? He is a right back end of. And not a very good one anymore either.
HENNESSEY - I mean come on? Why are we not even being linked with any new keepers? I thought him being absolutely dreadful had finally been recognised with Speroni playing a few games but then suddenly w*** Hennessey is back in. He installs 0% confidence in the defence/team and you can just see it. He cannot command a thing. He needs to be replaced and quickly. A new keeper would lift everything. Do it now.
PUNCHEON - can someone please tell me why this bloke walks into our team week in week out? I do not understand. Yes he is red and blue throughout but what does he ever actually do? He would get a 5/10 every game almost over the last 2 years! He doesn't create, he doesn't defend, he breaks down passages of play numerous times because he needs 11 touches and fannying around with it in a circle before he can release it. He is dead wood and a wast of someone else who could be playing. Keep him club captain but he is not good enough and we all know it. I don't understand what attributes he brings to our starting 11. Squad yes team hell no not anymore.

We desperately need a new GK and a striker too. What the hell happens if Benteke gets injured? I mean seriously? We have absolutely nobody it's pure madness. Hence why he strolls around most the time knowing that his pace is under no threat whatsoever.

Get Cabaye fit and back in the team. Start Townsend as he is one of the only players at the club who can run at players and attack teams at pace and actually have a proper end product, either having a crack at goal himself or a nice little dink for Benteke.

And sign Sakho. Now. For the love of god sign him. Even if he only has one leg.

My team with the squad as it is would be and if RDB insists on 3-4-3:
GK Speroni
LCB Reidewald
CB Dann
RCB Tomkins
LWB Van Aanholt
RWB Fosu-Mensah
CM Milivojevic
CM RLC
AM Townsend
AM Zaha
ST Benteke

And this is only the team if Cabaye is still crocked. He needs to fit in somewhere when he is back in RDB style team as he is our only decent passer of the ball.

THE END.

 

elky30 Flag Clapham 14 Aug 17 8.51am

Think if we had time to get used to the formation it could work.

But the Premier League is far too punishing for that and we just cant risk it at the time being.
Could take months for the formation to start working and at that point it could be too late.

It looks as though we dont have the right players to be using this formation. You need player who can pass out from the back, Dann is obviously trying but just is not good enough, gifted Huddersfield with a 1 on 1 after a misplaced pass, then Reidewald passes back to Hennessey every time he got the ball.

Seems silly to be trying to pass out from the back when we have Benteke who wins nearly every long ball.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 14 Aug 17 9.08am

If we lose our next 9 games then he has to go!

 

slubglurge Flag welling 14 Aug 17 9.48am

For gods sake sign Sakho. We need a leader at the back who will help Riedewalde no end. It was Danns responsibilty to talk to the youngsters either side of him but it was TFM at 19 who was more of a leader. Im afraid Scotty couldnt inspire a loaf to rise in the oven these days. Tomkins Sakho and Riedwalde at the back and with Sakho there Riedewalde will improve

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 14 Aug 17 2.41pm

Originally posted by rikz

Proven to work with Spain, Barcelona and Ajax with 3 of the greatest teams that have existed. I'm not convinced we have the players like someone else has said if the board want to back the manager and this philosophy then fine but we need to spend. The opposition only needs to be well drilled and organised and our players look lost, how do you break a team down when you have puncheon passing from left to right then back to dann. Pulis would have a field day playing against us.

Watch arsenal play, ozil, Sanchez and Ramsay do not stop moving, constantly finding and creating space then watch our midfielders. We just ain't good enough our movement off the ball is terrible. Townsend and zaha hitting teams with pace down the wing and getting the ball into benteke, that's what works so why stop ?

Agree with what you're saying about the need for signings however FDB will need time to assess which players can/can't play the new system. We may not be able to get in everyone we need this season hence a transitional period but I'd expect a couple more before deadline day and again in January and we're not far off. It's a longterm approach. No need to get all panicky after one game. Patience is needed. Not blind Pardew patience but realistic time for what is a fairly large change and everyone gettin their knickers in a twist already needs to think of the bigger picture of what FDB and Parish are trying to do, not about reverting to type because we lost to Huddersfield which will ensure we never evolve as a club to a higher Prem level

 

The Dolphin Flag 14 Aug 17 3.06pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Unfortunately I don't believe that FDB knows any other system. The 'total football' philosophy of high pressing, possession football is embedded in him from Ajax and he's going to persist with it until it works.

I don't think anyone was confident going into yesterday's game as we all know it's going to take time for it work and we're going to have to accept that and be patient. The return of Cabaye will help as him and RLC are both technically good on the ball.

As it stands we certainly need a GK who can use his feet and comand his area, another CB who can use his feet (Riedewald was pathetic in my opinion) and a RWB. Expect more dross vs Liverpool and Swansea and after that if no improvements and new signings it's time to get nervous.

It is too early to get really worried but he may persist and lose his job if it doesn't work.
I was unable to attend on Saturday but round pegs and squre holes spring to mind from what I have been told and read - and this was only against Huddersfield!
Time will tell but he won't get long in my opinion - Parish won't let this run fopr too long if it's going nowhere.
On the other hand the Players may adapt quickly but one would have hoped that they knew what to do before the start of the season - the Premier League is not the place for trial and error!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Aug 17 4.30pm

Originally posted by rikz

Also was obvious to see that Hennessey ain't comfortable at all playing out from the back but has been instructed not to hoof the ball, I really can't see the problem we've got benteke up top get the ball up to him and try and hit Huddersfield on the break instead of playing about with the ball and letting them all get back.

A major criticism of Benteke at Liverpool was they didn't get the ball to him early enough standing 20 yards out. Instead they passed and passed and passed, looking for the floor pass in the channel to someone else running through. Will be interesting to see what happens.

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 14 Aug 17 4.35pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

A major criticism of Benteke at Liverpool was they didn't get the ball to him early enough standing 20 yards out. Instead they passed and passed and passed, looking for the floor pass in the channel to someone else running through. Will be interesting to see what happens.

Maybe if he actually moved, he would get the ball more often....

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What we need to do