This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Part Time James
We didn't write him off after one game, we wrote him off before then. A lot of people thought we wouldn't have the personnel to suddenly change to a 3-4-3, based on past experience, not just a gut feeling. Then we watched the Huddersfield game and our minds weren't changed on the subject. If one of these things happen: then fine, I'll have no reason to bash FdB. I am prepared to accept one of those things could happen and that's where I'll reserve some judgement. Exactly. I wasn't a believer at 15.00 on Saturday and I don't think I could be expected to be come 16.45 ( actually make that 15.05 ! ) My perception is that FDB got the job based upon the brand of football he intended to introduce, and that brand is going to be introduced regardless of the strengths and weaknesses in the playing squad. If that doesn't work then we will see what else FDB has of offer. And in terms of investment in players, you could argue that we are paying the price for keeping Pardew in a job for too long. It would appear that the money spent in trying to avoid relegation in January has led to a lack of available funds in this window unless we see some movement before the window closes. I agree with those that say it's ridiculous to press the panic button after just one game, but come on...0-3...to Huddersfield....
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
I think the trepidation was widespread before the game. Talking to those around me on Saturday, most seemed to think we would get beaten before we'd even kicked off. Many very fearful of the passing out of defence tactics, especially given our lack of defensive passing prowess. It seemed the players shared this nervousness and there seemed a real lack of belief everywhere in the stadium. If we are to continue with this system we need a result or two quickly to calm players and supporters alike. Lets hope Anfield is the start. We may be less nervous collectively with lower expectations of a result. Originally posted by Willo
This is my way of thinking as well although I did approach the season with a sense of trepidation as I mentioned on HOL earlier in the day. My son-in-law asked me in midweek about how I felt we would do this season and I expressed certain concerns to him based on fact and instinct. Only 1 game - let's not over-react but I can understand some of the arguments on here.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Part Time James
We didn't write him off after one game, we wrote him off before then. A lot of people thought we wouldn't have the personnel to suddenly change to a 3-4-3, based on past experience, not just a gut feeling. Then we watched the Huddersfield game and our minds weren't changed on the subject. If one of these things happen: then fine, I'll have no reason to bash FdB. I am prepared to accept one of those things could happen and that's where I'll reserve some judgement. Which is more ridiculous. You're admitting right now you haven't been prepared to give him a chance. Was Saturday good? No, the first half was a shambles. We got ourselves into a hole with some silly goals, and (as has been the case for the last few years) looked a bit undercooked in terms of tempo and aggression for the first game. However there were positives, RLC in particular. In the second half we created some good opportunities. Had one of those gone in I think we'd have been back in business, and we probably wouldn't have been picked off late on. If the last few years (including our promotion year) have proven anything, it's that judgement should always be reserved until after 3-4 games, and after the transfer window has closed.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
Which is more ridiculous. You're admitting right now you haven't been prepared to give him a chance. Was Saturday good? No, the first half was a shambles. We got ourselves into a hole with some silly goals, and (as has been the case for the last few years) looked a bit undercooked in terms of tempo and aggression for the first game. However there were positives, RLC in particular. In the second half we created some good opportunities. Had one of those gone in I think we'd have been back in business, and we probably wouldn't have been picked off late on. If the last few years (including our promotion year) have proven anything, it's that judgement should always be reserved until after 3-4 games, and after the transfer window has closed. I don't think you understood a word I said. I had a system written off that this general team of players has attempted and failed at several times and that I was worried FdB might try to play. And he did. Edited by Part Time James (14 Aug 2017 10.01am)
|
|
|
I don't recall Pardew having a Plan B..
|
|
|
Originally posted by Bangell
Either the players will adapt to the system, or we'll buy reinforcements, or the system will change, but our squad is good enough to stay well clear of relegation trouble. One of these will have to happen and can.
COYP |
|
|
Who said that? I was worried about him coming. I am worried about managers prioritizing a system over the players they have in squad, I am worried about "Dutch possession and control attitude" (and believe me I know all about it) and I am worried about him underestimating the PL.
Originally posted by spartakev2
And we're writing him off after one game. ..
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
We have a manager who won 4 successive Eredivisie titles with Ajax. So are you saying he is/cant be a good manager?
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
Who said that? I was worried about him coming. I am worried about managers prioritizing a system over the players they have in squad, I am worried about "Dutch possession and control attitude" (and believe me I know all about it) and I am worried about him underestimating the PL. It seemed pretty clear to me that he had underestimated the PL and the opposition. Perhaps he was using it as an opportunity to experiment, in which case one hopes he will not do so against the bin dippers. But if he was serious about this is the way he wants to play from right now - three at the back, wing backs without the required pace and skill, centre backs without the required experience and composure, midfielders out of position and forwards isolated - then he is Pardew in disguise. He may be able to play that kind of game at Palace one day, maybe even later this season, but right now it is suicide.
============ |
|
|
The next game will show us how good FDB is, and how much he understands premier league footy.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Dale Holmes
We show astonishing naivety at times. A new manager comes in, working with a group of players he barely knows and declares that he is going to play 3-4-3, a system that half his team are not used to. A tactically aware opposition manager sees this, drills his team to press high and nullify any attempts to build from the back. Why telegraph it? Why give them a chance to prepare (which they clearly did - very well). And having done all this, where was plan B? Allardyce, Pulis and even Pardew always had a plan B. But FdB stuck doggedly to a system that wasn't working. That for me was the biggest concern - a failure to react to what is in front of him. I really want FdB to be a success but I have to agree. Surely you have to assess your squad before deciding on the tactics. Most managers would want their team to play like Barcelona but most realise quite quickly that their players are just not good enough. British defenders are not overly comfortable with the ball (e.g Dann) so why play a system where he is being asked to play with it a lot more? Palace have 2 international wingers so why not play both? Why play a wing back (a pivotal role in this system)who has barely featured in any of the pre season games and is clearly not equipped for the role? FdB was told that money would be tight so he must have known the additions would be limited so surely assessing the squad was his main priority. I think he has used the loan system really well, but that is a sign that Parish is trying to limit the spending so there will be no Sakho signings etc. Chelsea went out and bought Alonso and Luiz so the manager could play his preferred formation and also converted Moses. Frank will need to get the best out of Townsend and make a quick decision on Punch (who is not up to standard), and work out where best to play Loftus Road if this formation is to have a chance of success. I would love to see Palace play more football but too often I've seen us try and play possession football, struggle with any penetration and then finally hoof it forward anyway. Unfortunately I can see the same happening here
|
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
The next game will show us how good FDB is, and how much he understands premier league footy. Agreed. I won't whinge if we lose it (I mean we'll be the underdogs anyway) provided we show signs that lessons were learnt from the first game. Maybe not ALL the lessons, just that something has hit home.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
On reflection the result Saturday, could be a blessing in disguise. If we had won, due to Huddersfield being poor, we would of carried on playing in this fashion. That crossed my mind for the second time in recent months. The last time was Sunderland, and I think we'd all agree Sunderland was a wake up call. So I hope you are right and this is just this year's "Sunderland" game come nice and early and with the window fortunately still open.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.